http://stupid.domain.name/ietf/

One document matched: draft-ietf-avt-rtp-new-12.ps
%!PS-Adobe-2.0
%%Creator: dvips(k) 5.86d Copyright 1999 Radical Eye Software
%%Title: rtp-draft.dvi
%%Pages: 84
%%PageOrder: Ascend
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 612 792
%%DocumentFonts: CMR10 CMBX12 CMBX10 CMTI10 CMSY10 CMCSC10 CMTT10 CMMI10
%%+ CMMI8 CMSY8 CMR6 CMR8 CMMI6
%%EndComments
%DVIPSWebPage: (www.radicaleye.com)
%DVIPSCommandLine: dvips -o rtp-draft.ps rtp-draft
%DVIPSParameters: dpi=600, compressed
%DVIPSSource:  TeX output 2003.03.03:1726
%%BeginProcSet: texc.pro
%!
/TeXDict 300 dict def TeXDict begin/N{def}def/B{bind def}N/S{exch}N/X{S
N}B/A{dup}B/TR{translate}N/isls false N/vsize 11 72 mul N/hsize 8.5 72
mul N/landplus90{false}def/@rigin{isls{[0 landplus90{1 -1}{-1 1}ifelse 0
0 0]concat}if 72 Resolution div 72 VResolution div neg scale isls{
landplus90{VResolution 72 div vsize mul 0 exch}{Resolution -72 div hsize
mul 0}ifelse TR}if Resolution VResolution vsize -72 div 1 add mul TR[
matrix currentmatrix{A A round sub abs 0.00001 lt{round}if}forall round
exch round exch]setmatrix}N/@landscape{/isls true N}B/@manualfeed{
statusdict/manualfeed true put}B/@copies{/#copies X}B/FMat[1 0 0 -1 0 0]
N/FBB[0 0 0 0]N/nn 0 N/IEn 0 N/ctr 0 N/df-tail{/nn 8 dict N nn begin
/FontType 3 N/FontMatrix fntrx N/FontBBox FBB N string/base X array
/BitMaps X/BuildChar{CharBuilder}N/Encoding IEn N end A{/foo setfont}2
array copy cvx N load 0 nn put/ctr 0 N[}B/sf 0 N/df{/sf 1 N/fntrx FMat N
df-tail}B/dfs{div/sf X/fntrx[sf 0 0 sf neg 0 0]N df-tail}B/E{pop nn A
definefont setfont}B/Cw{Cd A length 5 sub get}B/Ch{Cd A length 4 sub get
}B/Cx{128 Cd A length 3 sub get sub}B/Cy{Cd A length 2 sub get 127 sub}
B/Cdx{Cd A length 1 sub get}B/Ci{Cd A type/stringtype ne{ctr get/ctr ctr
1 add N}if}B/id 0 N/rw 0 N/rc 0 N/gp 0 N/cp 0 N/G 0 N/CharBuilder{save 3
1 roll S A/base get 2 index get S/BitMaps get S get/Cd X pop/ctr 0 N Cdx
0 Cx Cy Ch sub Cx Cw add Cy setcachedevice Cw Ch true[1 0 0 -1 -.1 Cx
sub Cy .1 sub]/id Ci N/rw Cw 7 add 8 idiv string N/rc 0 N/gp 0 N/cp 0 N{
rc 0 ne{rc 1 sub/rc X rw}{G}ifelse}imagemask restore}B/G{{id gp get/gp
gp 1 add N A 18 mod S 18 idiv pl S get exec}loop}B/adv{cp add/cp X}B
/chg{rw cp id gp 4 index getinterval putinterval A gp add/gp X adv}B/nd{
/cp 0 N rw exit}B/lsh{rw cp 2 copy get A 0 eq{pop 1}{A 255 eq{pop 254}{
A A add 255 and S 1 and or}ifelse}ifelse put 1 adv}B/rsh{rw cp 2 copy
get A 0 eq{pop 128}{A 255 eq{pop 127}{A 2 idiv S 128 and or}ifelse}
ifelse put 1 adv}B/clr{rw cp 2 index string putinterval adv}B/set{rw cp
fillstr 0 4 index getinterval putinterval adv}B/fillstr 18 string 0 1 17
{2 copy 255 put pop}for N/pl[{adv 1 chg}{adv 1 chg nd}{1 add chg}{1 add
chg nd}{adv lsh}{adv lsh nd}{adv rsh}{adv rsh nd}{1 add adv}{/rc X nd}{
1 add set}{1 add clr}{adv 2 chg}{adv 2 chg nd}{pop nd}]A{bind pop}
forall N/D{/cc X A type/stringtype ne{]}if nn/base get cc ctr put nn
/BitMaps get S ctr S sf 1 ne{A A length 1 sub A 2 index S get sf div put
}if put/ctr ctr 1 add N}B/I{cc 1 add D}B/bop{userdict/bop-hook known{
bop-hook}if/SI save N @rigin 0 0 moveto/V matrix currentmatrix A 1 get A
mul exch 0 get A mul add .99 lt{/QV}{/RV}ifelse load def pop pop}N/eop{
SI restore userdict/eop-hook known{eop-hook}if showpage}N/@start{
userdict/start-hook known{start-hook}if pop/VResolution X/Resolution X
1000 div/DVImag X/IEn 256 array N 2 string 0 1 255{IEn S A 360 add 36 4
index cvrs cvn put}for pop 65781.76 div/vsize X 65781.76 div/hsize X}N
/p{show}N/RMat[1 0 0 -1 0 0]N/BDot 260 string N/Rx 0 N/Ry 0 N/V{}B/RV/v{
/Ry X/Rx X V}B statusdict begin/product where{pop false[(Display)(NeXT)
(LaserWriter 16/600)]{A length product length le{A length product exch 0
exch getinterval eq{pop true exit}if}{pop}ifelse}forall}{false}ifelse
end{{gsave TR -.1 .1 TR 1 1 scale Rx Ry false RMat{BDot}imagemask
grestore}}{{gsave TR -.1 .1 TR Rx Ry scale 1 1 false RMat{BDot}
imagemask grestore}}ifelse B/QV{gsave newpath transform round exch round
exch itransform moveto Rx 0 rlineto 0 Ry neg rlineto Rx neg 0 rlineto
fill grestore}B/a{moveto}B/delta 0 N/tail{A/delta X 0 rmoveto}B/M{S p
delta add tail}B/b{S p tail}B/c{-4 M}B/d{-3 M}B/e{-2 M}B/f{-1 M}B/g{0 M}
B/h{1 M}B/i{2 M}B/j{3 M}B/k{4 M}B/w{0 rmoveto}B/l{p -4 w}B/m{p -3 w}B/n{
p -2 w}B/o{p -1 w}B/q{p 1 w}B/r{p 2 w}B/s{p 3 w}B/t{p 4 w}B/x{0 S
rmoveto}B/y{3 2 roll p a}B/bos{/SS save N}B/eos{SS restore}B end

%%EndProcSet
%%BeginProcSet: texps.pro
%!
TeXDict begin/rf{findfont dup length 1 add dict begin{1 index/FID ne 2
index/UniqueID ne and{def}{pop pop}ifelse}forall[1 index 0 6 -1 roll
exec 0 exch 5 -1 roll VResolution Resolution div mul neg 0 0]/Metrics
exch def dict begin Encoding{exch dup type/integertype ne{pop pop 1 sub
dup 0 le{pop}{[}ifelse}{FontMatrix 0 get div Metrics 0 get div def}
ifelse}forall Metrics/Metrics currentdict end def[2 index currentdict
end definefont 3 -1 roll makefont/setfont cvx]cvx def}def/ObliqueSlant{
dup sin S cos div neg}B/SlantFont{4 index mul add}def/ExtendFont{3 -1
roll mul exch}def/ReEncodeFont{CharStrings rcheck{/Encoding false def
dup[exch{dup CharStrings exch known not{pop/.notdef/Encoding true def}
if}forall Encoding{]exch pop}{cleartomark}ifelse}if/Encoding exch def}
def end

%%EndProcSet
%%BeginProcSet: special.pro
%!
TeXDict begin/SDict 200 dict N SDict begin/@SpecialDefaults{/hs 612 N
/vs 792 N/ho 0 N/vo 0 N/hsc 1 N/vsc 1 N/ang 0 N/CLIP 0 N/rwiSeen false N
/rhiSeen false N/letter{}N/note{}N/a4{}N/legal{}N}B/@scaleunit 100 N
/@hscale{@scaleunit div/hsc X}B/@vscale{@scaleunit div/vsc X}B/@hsize{
/hs X/CLIP 1 N}B/@vsize{/vs X/CLIP 1 N}B/@clip{/CLIP 2 N}B/@hoffset{/ho
X}B/@voffset{/vo X}B/@angle{/ang X}B/@rwi{10 div/rwi X/rwiSeen true N}B
/@rhi{10 div/rhi X/rhiSeen true N}B/@llx{/llx X}B/@lly{/lly X}B/@urx{
/urx X}B/@ury{/ury X}B/magscale true def end/@MacSetUp{userdict/md known
{userdict/md get type/dicttype eq{userdict begin md length 10 add md
maxlength ge{/md md dup length 20 add dict copy def}if end md begin
/letter{}N/note{}N/legal{}N/od{txpose 1 0 mtx defaultmatrix dtransform S
atan/pa X newpath clippath mark{transform{itransform moveto}}{transform{
itransform lineto}}{6 -2 roll transform 6 -2 roll transform 6 -2 roll
transform{itransform 6 2 roll itransform 6 2 roll itransform 6 2 roll
curveto}}{{closepath}}pathforall newpath counttomark array astore/gc xdf
pop ct 39 0 put 10 fz 0 fs 2 F/|______Courier fnt invertflag{PaintBlack}
if}N/txpose{pxs pys scale ppr aload pop por{noflips{pop S neg S TR pop 1
-1 scale}if xflip yflip and{pop S neg S TR 180 rotate 1 -1 scale ppr 3
get ppr 1 get neg sub neg ppr 2 get ppr 0 get neg sub neg TR}if xflip
yflip not and{pop S neg S TR pop 180 rotate ppr 3 get ppr 1 get neg sub
neg 0 TR}if yflip xflip not and{ppr 1 get neg ppr 0 get neg TR}if}{
noflips{TR pop pop 270 rotate 1 -1 scale}if xflip yflip and{TR pop pop
90 rotate 1 -1 scale ppr 3 get ppr 1 get neg sub neg ppr 2 get ppr 0 get
neg sub neg TR}if xflip yflip not and{TR pop pop 90 rotate ppr 3 get ppr
1 get neg sub neg 0 TR}if yflip xflip not and{TR pop pop 270 rotate ppr
2 get ppr 0 get neg sub neg 0 S TR}if}ifelse scaleby96{ppr aload pop 4
-1 roll add 2 div 3 1 roll add 2 div 2 copy TR .96 dup scale neg S neg S
TR}if}N/cp{pop pop showpage pm restore}N end}if}if}N/normalscale{
Resolution 72 div VResolution 72 div neg scale magscale{DVImag dup scale
}if 0 setgray}N/psfts{S 65781.76 div N}N/startTexFig{/psf$SavedState
save N userdict maxlength dict begin/magscale true def normalscale
currentpoint TR/psf$ury psfts/psf$urx psfts/psf$lly psfts/psf$llx psfts
/psf$y psfts/psf$x psfts currentpoint/psf$cy X/psf$cx X/psf$sx psf$x
psf$urx psf$llx sub div N/psf$sy psf$y psf$ury psf$lly sub div N psf$sx
psf$sy scale psf$cx psf$sx div psf$llx sub psf$cy psf$sy div psf$ury sub
TR/showpage{}N/erasepage{}N/copypage{}N/p 3 def @MacSetUp}N/doclip{
psf$llx psf$lly psf$urx psf$ury currentpoint 6 2 roll newpath 4 copy 4 2
roll moveto 6 -1 roll S lineto S lineto S lineto closepath clip newpath
moveto}N/endTexFig{end psf$SavedState restore}N/@beginspecial{SDict
begin/SpecialSave save N gsave normalscale currentpoint TR
@SpecialDefaults count/ocount X/dcount countdictstack N}N/@setspecial{
CLIP 1 eq{newpath 0 0 moveto hs 0 rlineto 0 vs rlineto hs neg 0 rlineto
closepath clip}if ho vo TR hsc vsc scale ang rotate rwiSeen{rwi urx llx
sub div rhiSeen{rhi ury lly sub div}{dup}ifelse scale llx neg lly neg TR
}{rhiSeen{rhi ury lly sub div dup scale llx neg lly neg TR}if}ifelse
CLIP 2 eq{newpath llx lly moveto urx lly lineto urx ury lineto llx ury
lineto closepath clip}if/showpage{}N/erasepage{}N/copypage{}N newpath}N
/@endspecial{count ocount sub{pop}repeat countdictstack dcount sub{end}
repeat grestore SpecialSave restore end}N/@defspecial{SDict begin}N
/@fedspecial{end}B/li{lineto}B/rl{rlineto}B/rc{rcurveto}B/np{/SaveX
currentpoint/SaveY X N 1 setlinecap newpath}N/st{stroke SaveX SaveY
moveto}N/fil{fill SaveX SaveY moveto}N/ellipse{/endangle X/startangle X
/yrad X/xrad X/savematrix matrix currentmatrix N TR xrad yrad scale 0 0
1 startangle endangle arc savematrix setmatrix}N end

%%EndProcSet
%%BeginFont: CMMI6
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMMI6 1.100
%%CreationDate: 1996 Jul 23 07:53:52

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.100) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMMI6) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.04 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMMI6 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 76 /L put
readonly def
/FontBBox{11 -250 1241 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5087381 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMR8
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMR8 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 20 16:39:40

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMR8) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMR8 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 50 /two put
dup 52 /four put
dup 55 /seven put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-36 -250 1070 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000791 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMR6
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMR6 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 20 16:39:02

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMR6) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMR6 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 43 /plus put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-20 -250 1193 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000789 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMSY8
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMSY8 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 15 07:22:10

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMSY8) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.035 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMSY8 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 0 /minus put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-30 -955 1185 779}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000818 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec
9b9c1569015f2c1d2bf560f4c0d52257bac8ced9b09a275ab231194ecf829352
05826f4e975dcecec72b2cf3a18899ccde1fd935d09d813b096cc6b83cdf4f23
b9a60db41f9976ac333263c908dcefcdbd4c8402ed00a36e7487634d089fd45a
f4a38a56a4412c3b0baffaeb717bf0de9ffb7a8460bf475a6718b0c73c571145
d026957276530530a2fbefc6c8f059084178f5ab59e11b66566ca5ba42b1911a
5d7f1bf343015eece988b7a93bce0c7aa61344d48aed9c92c8698d4b7c9951c8
7d103f2414b39e1437f9d2e50c4ee5f218f2e6716926a79ea978f13b1f855345
191dd7d31d8f82c2e3343c7a5894d95bdc492c28226834efcb5c12fea36ac5cc
430e0aa604961e34888adf6c1f3954cbc2498e225d953cf5685852162346f474
5a2a7087d5d7ad486de16d2ca8e15cee26e012671ba3bdc7d95cc8c98bb774f5
08625e968aee27ff7d1a06e63bcfb5aa4876c3f8f13b30ccccee73c3caf4e70d
98e6ed2f422dbb4950bf789680e064150995941a9f4dd68a575949847a7d012b
b910bf03a7a227d51386469ec9ef415f3bb849d30411890d9c6f5b9ee172e351
8cba2ea47be683900e1c23554cfb193067c35d0813c4bc68f817ef9f0206f08d
1d8be63236cb2d08f42c4a0b73a147cc7baf1a212637a7b9c3243332a162b8d4
955e17a50b678c6a322c4eccd28fd709ccef5f4a0c7f542c5ee8fec88895af93
48d3cc99e31f083e3f3d6be883803f7d3f4c4519360fc6d925a31d854e764f79
403b30ae39e581fb941615aa3c86287f7cf79b84e95db76ec8f15c8b43029a6c
e93ae76e0320d0daece8c62f7f4d189fefdbb7bbdb43cb87
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMMI8
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMMI8 1.100
%%CreationDate: 1996 Jul 23 07:53:54

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.100) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMMI8) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.04 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMMI8 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 61 /slash put
dup 76 /L put
dup 78 /N put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-24 -250 1110 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5087383 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMTT10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMTT10 1.00B
%%CreationDate: 1992 Apr 26 10:42:42

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.00B) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMTT10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch true def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMTT10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 33 /exclam put
dup 34 /quotedbl put
dup 35 /numbersign put
dup 38 /ampersand put
dup 39 /quoteright put
dup 40 /parenleft put
dup 41 /parenright put
dup 42 /asterisk put
dup 43 /plus put
dup 44 /comma put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 47 /slash put
dup 48 /zero put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
dup 51 /three put
dup 52 /four put
dup 53 /five put
dup 54 /six put
dup 55 /seven put
dup 56 /eight put
dup 57 /nine put
dup 58 /colon put
dup 59 /semicolon put
dup 60 /less put
dup 61 /equal put
dup 62 /greater put
dup 64 /at put
dup 65 /A put
dup 66 /B put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 72 /H put
dup 73 /I put
dup 75 /K put
dup 76 /L put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 81 /Q put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 85 /U put
dup 86 /V put
dup 87 /W put
dup 88 /X put
dup 89 /Y put
dup 91 /bracketleft put
dup 93 /bracketright put
dup 94 /asciicircum put
dup 95 /underscore put
dup 96 /quoteleft put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 113 /q put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
dup 122 /z put
dup 123 /braceleft put
dup 124 /bar put
dup 125 /braceright put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-4 -235 731 800}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000832 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMMI10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMMI10 1.100
%%CreationDate: 1996 Jul 23 07:53:57

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.100) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMMI10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.04 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMMI10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 58 /period put
dup 59 /comma put
dup 61 /slash put
dup 62 /greater put
dup 65 /A put
dup 68 /D put
dup 74 /J put
dup 76 /L put
dup 78 /N put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 101 /e put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-32 -250 1048 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5087385 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMCSC10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMCSC10 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 18 17:46:49

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMCSC10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMCSC10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 97 /a put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 113 /q put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 121 /y put
readonly def
/FontBBox{14 -250 1077 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000772 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMSY10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMSY10 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 15 07:20:57

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMSY10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.035 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMSY10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 0 /minus put
dup 1 /periodcentered put
dup 15 /bullet put
dup 106 /bar put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-29 -960 1116 775}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000820 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMTI10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMTI10 1.00B
%%CreationDate: 1992 Feb 19 19:56:16

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.00B) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMTI10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle -14.04 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMTI10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 12 /fi put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 47 /slash put
dup 49 /one put
dup 54 /six put
dup 65 /A put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 73 /I put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-163 -250 1146 969}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000828 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMBX10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMBX10 1.00B
%%CreationDate: 1992 Feb 19 19:54:06

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.00B) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMBX10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Bold) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMBX10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 12 /fi put
dup 39 /quoteright put
dup 40 /parenleft put
dup 41 /parenright put
dup 44 /comma put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 47 /slash put
dup 48 /zero put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
dup 51 /three put
dup 52 /four put
dup 53 /five put
dup 54 /six put
dup 55 /seven put
dup 56 /eight put
dup 57 /nine put
dup 58 /colon put
dup 65 /A put
dup 66 /B put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 72 /H put
dup 73 /I put
dup 76 /L put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 85 /U put
dup 86 /V put
dup 88 /X put
dup 89 /Y put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 113 /q put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
dup 122 /z put
dup 123 /endash put
dup 124 /emdash put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-301 -250 1164 946}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000768 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
cleartomark

%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMR10
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMR10 1.00B
%%CreationDate: 1992 Feb 19 19:54:52

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.00B) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMR10) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Medium) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMR10 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 11 /ff put
dup 12 /fi put
dup 13 /fl put
dup 14 /ffi put
dup 34 /quotedblright put
dup 37 /percent put
dup 38 /ampersand put
dup 39 /quoteright put
dup 40 /parenleft put
dup 41 /parenright put
dup 42 /asterisk put
dup 43 /plus put
dup 44 /comma put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 47 /slash put
dup 48 /zero put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
dup 51 /three put
dup 52 /four put
dup 53 /five put
dup 54 /six put
dup 55 /seven put
dup 56 /eight put
dup 57 /nine put
dup 58 /colon put
dup 59 /semicolon put
dup 61 /equal put
dup 64 /at put
dup 65 /A put
dup 66 /B put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 72 /H put
dup 73 /I put
dup 74 /J put
dup 75 /K put
dup 76 /L put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 81 /Q put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 85 /U put
dup 86 /V put
dup 87 /W put
dup 88 /X put
dup 89 /Y put
dup 90 /Z put
dup 91 /bracketleft put
dup 92 /quotedblleft put
dup 93 /bracketright put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 106 /j put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 113 /q put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
dup 122 /z put
dup 123 /endash put
dup 124 /emdash put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-251 -250 1009 969}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000793 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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%%EndFont 
%%BeginFont: CMBX12
%!PS-AdobeFont-1.1: CMBX12 1.0
%%CreationDate: 1991 Aug 20 16:34:54

% Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society.  All Rights Reserved.

11 dict begin
/FontInfo 7 dict dup begin
/version (1.0) readonly def
/Notice (Copyright (C) 1997 American Mathematical Society. All Rights Reserved) readonly def
/FullName (CMBX12) readonly def
/FamilyName (Computer Modern) readonly def
/Weight (Bold) readonly def
/ItalicAngle 0 def
/isFixedPitch false def
end readonly def
/FontName /CMBX12 def
/PaintType 0 def
/FontType 1 def
/FontMatrix [0.001 0 0 0.001 0 0] readonly def
/Encoding 256 array
0 1 255 {1 index exch /.notdef put} for
dup 12 /fi put
dup 44 /comma put
dup 45 /hyphen put
dup 46 /period put
dup 48 /zero put
dup 49 /one put
dup 50 /two put
dup 51 /three put
dup 52 /four put
dup 53 /five put
dup 54 /six put
dup 55 /seven put
dup 56 /eight put
dup 57 /nine put
dup 58 /colon put
dup 65 /A put
dup 66 /B put
dup 67 /C put
dup 68 /D put
dup 69 /E put
dup 70 /F put
dup 71 /G put
dup 72 /H put
dup 73 /I put
dup 74 /J put
dup 76 /L put
dup 77 /M put
dup 78 /N put
dup 79 /O put
dup 80 /P put
dup 82 /R put
dup 83 /S put
dup 84 /T put
dup 85 /U put
dup 86 /V put
dup 89 /Y put
dup 97 /a put
dup 98 /b put
dup 99 /c put
dup 100 /d put
dup 101 /e put
dup 102 /f put
dup 103 /g put
dup 104 /h put
dup 105 /i put
dup 107 /k put
dup 108 /l put
dup 109 /m put
dup 110 /n put
dup 111 /o put
dup 112 /p put
dup 114 /r put
dup 115 /s put
dup 116 /t put
dup 117 /u put
dup 118 /v put
dup 119 /w put
dup 120 /x put
dup 121 /y put
dup 124 /emdash put
readonly def
/FontBBox{-53 -251 1139 750}readonly def
/UniqueXX 5000769 def
currentdict end
currentfile eexec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%%EndFont 
TeXDict begin 40258431 52099146 1000 600 600 (rtp-draft.dvi)
@start /Fa 179[42 76[{}1 49.8132 /CMMI6 rf /Fb 200[35
2[35 1[35 50[{}3 66.4176 /CMR8 rf /Fc 205[30 30 5[47
43[{}3 49.8132 /CMR6 rf /Fd 255[55{}1 66.4176 /CMSY8
rf /Fe 149[29 24 26[56 1[48 14[35 61[{}5 66.4176 /CMMI8
rf /Ff 131[44 2[44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44
44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 1[44 5[44 2[44 1[44
44 44 1[44 44 44 44 44 2[44 44 2[44 44 44 44 44 3[44
2[44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 44 1[44
44 44 39[{}64 83.022 /CMTT10 rf /Fg 149[37 31 3[42 17[56
69 3[73 1[62 1[50 5[75 2[68 2[71 45 1[25 25 58[{}14 90.9091
/CMMI10 rf /Fh 130[48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48
48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48
48 48 48 1[48 1[48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48
48 48 1[48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 1[48 48 48 48 48
48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48 48
48 48 2[48 48 48 33[{}87 90.9091 /CMTT10 rf /Fi 134[56
3[56 54 42 55 58 51 58 56 68 47 2[27 56 2[51 57 54 1[56
97[{}17 90.9091 /CMCSC10 rf /Fj 149[25 90[45 13[25 71{}4
90.9091 /CMSY10 rf /Fk 134[44 42 60 42 49 30 37 38 1[46
46 51 74 23 42 1[28 46 42 28 42 46 42 42 46 12[65 51
66 1[62 70 68 82 3[35 1[70 59 62 69 65 1[68 10[46 4[46
1[46 28 33 32[51 12[{}43 90.9091 /CMTI10 rf /Fl 131[105
52 46 55 55 76 55 58 41 41 43 55 58 52 58 87 29 55 32
29 58 52 32 48 58 46 58 51 7[79 79 1[79 80 73 58 78 1[71
79 82 99 63 2[40 82 82 66 69 80 76 74 79 6[29 52 52 52
52 52 52 52 52 52 52 52 29 35 29 2[41 41 29 26[58 12[{}68
90.9091 /CMBX10 rf /Fm 133[37 44 44 60 44 46 32 33 33
44 46 42 46 69 23 44 25 23 46 42 25 37 46 37 46 42 12[60
1[61 1[57 2[76 6[54 2[60 9[42 42 6[42 2[23 28 23 2[32
32 27[46 12[{}41 83.022 /CMR10 rf /Fn 139[37 38 39 14[42
53 46 31[72 65[{}7 83.022 /CMBX10 rf /Fo 134[59 59 81
59 62 44 44 46 1[62 56 62 93 31 59 1[31 62 56 34 51 62
50 62 54 7[85 2[85 86 78 62 84 1[77 1[88 106 67 1[58
42 88 88 70 74 86 81 80 85 6[31 56 56 56 56 56 56 56
56 56 2[31 37 32[62 12[{}56 99.6264 /CMBX12 rf /Fp 131[134
2[71 71 97 71 75 52 53 55 1[75 67 75 112 37 71 1[37 75
67 41 61 75 60 1[65 11[103 94 75 100 1[92 101 105 128
3[50 105 106 85 88 103 97 96 102 6[37 67 67 67 67 67
67 67 67 67 67 2[45 37 31[75 12[{}54 119.552 /CMBX12
rf /Fq 131[91 45 40 48 48 66 48 51 35 36 36 48 51 45
51 76 25 48 28 25 51 45 28 40 51 40 51 45 3[25 45 25
56 68 68 93 68 68 66 51 67 71 62 71 68 83 57 71 47 33
68 71 59 62 69 66 64 68 71 2[71 1[25 25 45 45 45 45 45
45 45 45 45 45 45 25 30 25 71 45 35 35 25 71 76 2[45
19[76 51 51 53 11[{}87 90.9091 /CMR10 rf end
%%EndProlog
%%BeginSetup
%%Feature: *Resolution 600dpi
TeXDict begin

%%EndSetup
%%Page: 1 1
1 0 bop 141 87 a Fq(In)m(ternet)31 b(Engineering)f(T)-8
b(ask)31 b(F)-8 b(orce)1030 b(Audio/Video)31 b(T)-8 b(ransp)s(ort)29
b(W)-8 b(orking)32 b(Group)141 200 y(INTERNET-DRAFT)1459
b(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)141
313 y(draft-ietf-a)m(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)655 b(Colum)m(bia)30
b(U./P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)k(Design/Blue)f(Coat/P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)h(Design)3475
426 y(Marc)m(h)d(2,)g(2003)3046 539 y(Expires:)41 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)29
b(2003)310 739 y Fp(R)-11 b(TP:)45 b(A)f(T)-11 b(ransp)t(ort)44
b(Proto)t(col)i(for)f(Real-Time)h(Applications)0 982
y Fo(Status)38 b(of)f(this)h(Memo)0 1154 y Fq(This)30
b(do)s(cumen)m(t)g(is)g(an)g(In)m(ternet-Draft)i(and)e(is)g(sub)5
b(ject)30 b(to)i(all)f(pro)m(visions)f(of)h(Section)g(10)g(of)g(RF)m(C)
g(2026.)141 1267 y(In)m(ternet-Drafts)24 b(are)f(w)m(orking)g(do)s
(cumen)m(ts)f(of)h(the)g(In)m(ternet)g(Engineering)g(T)-8
b(ask)23 b(F)-8 b(orce)24 b(\(IETF\),)f(its)g(areas,)0
1380 y(and)h(its)h(w)m(orking)g(groups.)38 b(Note)26
b(that)f(other)g(groups)f(ma)m(y)h(also)g(distribute)f(w)m(orking)h(do)
s(cumen)m(ts)f(as)h(In)m(ternet-)0 1493 y(Drafts.)141
1606 y(In)m(ternet-Drafts)34 b(are)e(draft)g(do)s(cumen)m(ts)g(v)-5
b(alid)33 b(for)f(a)h(maxim)m(um)f(of)g(six)h(mon)m(ths)f(and)f(ma)m(y)
i(b)s(e)f(up)s(dated,)0 1719 y(replaced,)i(or)f(obsoleted)h(b)m(y)e
(other)h(do)s(cumen)m(ts)g(at)g(an)m(y)g(time.)49 b(It)33
b(is)f(inappropriate)h(to)g(use)g(In)m(ternet-Drafts)0
1831 y(as)e(reference)f(material)i(or)f(to)g(cite)g(them)g(other)f
(than)h(as)f(\\w)m(ork)h(in)f(progress.")141 1944 y(The)g(list)h(of)g
(curren)m(t)f(In)m(ternet-Drafts)h(can)g(b)s(e)f(accessed)h(at)g(h)m
(ttp://www.ietf.org/1id-abstracts.txt)141 2044 y(The)20
b(list)h(of)f(In)m(ternet-Draft)i(Shado)m(w)e(Directories)i(can)e(b)s
(e)g(accessed)i(at)f(h)m(ttp://www.ietf.org/shado)m(w.h)m(tml)1767
2318 y Fn(Abstract)352 2445 y Fm(This)30 b(memorandum)g(describ)r(es)g
(R)-7 b(TP)g(,)30 b(the)h(real-time)e(transp)r(ort)g(proto)r(col.)44
b(R)-7 b(TP)31 b(pro)n(vides)d(end-to-)227 2544 y(end)k(net)n(w)n(ork)e
(transp)r(ort)h(functions)g(suitable)h(for)f(applications)f
(transmitting)i(real-time)e(data,)i(suc)n(h)f(as)227
2644 y(audio,)41 b(video)e(or)f(sim)n(ulation)g(data,)j(o)n(v)n(er)c(m)
n(ulticast)i(or)f(unicast)g(net)n(w)n(ork)g(services.)69
b(R)-7 b(TP)38 b(do)r(es)h(not)227 2743 y(address)e(resource)f(reserv)
-5 b(ation)37 b(and)h(do)r(es)f(not)h(guaran)n(tee)f(qualit)n
(y-of-service)e(for)j(real-time)f(services.)227 2843
y(The)25 b(data)g(transp)r(ort)f(is)h(augmen)n(ted)f(b)n(y)h(a)f(con)n
(trol)g(proto)r(col)g(\(R)-7 b(TCP\))25 b(to)g(allo)n(w)f(monitoring)g
(of)h(the)g(data)227 2943 y(deliv)n(ery)k(in)g(a)g(manner)g(scalable)f
(to)h(large)f(m)n(ulticast)i(net)n(w)n(orks,)e(and)h(to)g(pro)n(vide)f
(minimal)i(con)n(trol)e(and)227 3042 y(iden)n(ti\014cation)i
(functionalit)n(y)-7 b(.)44 b(R)-7 b(TP)29 b(and)h(R)-7
b(TCP)29 b(are)g(designed)h(to)f(b)r(e)i(indep)r(enden)n(t)f(of)g(the)g
(underlying)227 3142 y(transp)r(ort)40 b(and)g(net)n(w)n(ork)f(la)n(y)n
(ers.)73 b(The)41 b(proto)r(col)e(supp)r(orts)h(the)h(use)f(of)g(R)-7
b(TP-lev)n(el)40 b(translators)e(and)227 3242 y(mixers.)352
3341 y(Most)24 b(of)g(the)g(text)h(in)f(this)g(memorandum)g(is)g(iden)n
(tical)g(to)g(RF)n(C)g(1889)e(whic)n(h)i(it)h(obsoletes.)34
b(There)24 b(are)227 3441 y(no)e(c)n(hanges)e(in)h(the)h(pac)n(k)n(et)f
(formats)g(on)g(the)h(wire,)g(only)f(c)n(hanges)f(to)i(the)g(rules)f
(and)g(algorithms)f(go)n(v)n(erning)227 3540 y(ho)n(w)j(the)i(proto)r
(col)d(is)i(used.)36 b(The)24 b(biggest)f(c)n(hange)f(is)i(an)g
(enhancemen)n(t)f(to)h(the)g(scalable)f(timer)h(algorithm)227
3640 y(for)30 b(calculating)e(when)i(to)g(send)g(R)-7
b(TCP)29 b(pac)n(k)n(ets)g(in)h(order)e(to)i(minimize)g(transmission)f
(in)h(excess)f(of)g(the)227 3740 y(in)n(tended)f(rate)f(when)h(man)n(y)
f(participan)n(ts)g(join)g(a)g(session)g(sim)n(ultaneously)-7
b(.)p eop
%%Page: 2 2
2 1 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fp(Con)l(ten)l(ts)0 602 y Fl(1)84 b(In)m(tro)s(duction)3136
b(4)136 715 y Fq(1.1)94 b(T)-8 b(erminology)32 b(.)46
b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)131 b(5)0 919 y Fl(2)84 b(R)-9 b(TP)36
b(Use)g(Scenarios)2832 b(5)136 1032 y Fq(2.1)94 b(Simple)30
b(Multicast)j(Audio)d(Conference)i(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)131 b(5)136 1145 y(2.2)94 b(Audio)31 b(and)e(Video)j
(Conference)88 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
131 b(6)136 1258 y(2.3)94 b(Mixers)31 b(and)f(T)-8 b(ranslators)26
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)131 b(6)136 1371 y(2.4)94 b(La)m(y)m(ered)32 b(Enco)s(dings)57
b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)131 b(7)0 1575 y Fl(3)84 b(De\014nitions)3218
b(7)0 1778 y(4)84 b(Byte)35 b(Order,)g(Alignmen)m(t,)g(and)g(Time)g(F)
-9 b(ormat)1724 b(10)0 1982 y(5)84 b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Data)e(T)-9
b(ransfer)35 b(Proto)s(col)2349 b(11)136 2095 y Fq(5.1)94
b(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(Fixed)f(Header)h(Fields)74 b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(11)136 2208
y(5.2)94 b(Multiplexing)32 b(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(Sessions)90
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(13)136 2321 y(5.3)94 b(Pro\014le-Sp)s(eci\014c)31 b(Mo)s
(di\014cations)g(to)g(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(Header)59
b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(14)345 2434 y(5.3.1)106 b(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(Header)f(Extension)92 b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)f(.)85 b(15)0 2638 y Fl(6)f(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Con)m(trol)f(Proto)s(col)
h(|)f(R)-9 b(TCP)2173 b(16)136 2751 y Fq(6.1)94 b(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)j(F)-8 b(ormat)85 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(17)136
2863 y(6.2)94 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(T)-8 b(ransmission)30
b(In)m(terv)-5 b(al)25 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(19)345 2976 y(6.2.1)106 b(Main)m(taining)32
b(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(session)f(mem)m(b)s(ers)35
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)85 b(22)136 3089 y(6.3)94 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)j
(Send)d(and)f(Receiv)m(e)k(Rules)62 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)85 b(22)345 3202 y(6.3.1)106 b(Computing)30 b(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(transmission)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)52 b(.)45
b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)85 b(23)345 3315 y(6.3.2)106 b(Initialization)84 b(.)45
b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
85 b(24)345 3428 y(6.3.3)106 b(Receiving)32 b(an)f(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(or)g(non-BYE)h(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)56
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)85 b(24)345 3541 y(6.3.4)106 b(Receiving)32 b(an)f(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(BYE)i(pac)m(k)m(et)66 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(24)345 3654 y(6.3.5)106 b(Timing)31 b(Out)e(an)i(SSR)m(C)78
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(25)345 3767 y(6.3.6)106 b(Expiration)31 b(of)f(transmission)g(timer)
70 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(25)345 3880 y(6.3.7)106
b(T)-8 b(ransmitting)31 b(a)g(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)51 b(.)46
b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(25)345 3993
y(6.3.8)106 b(Up)s(dating)30 b(w)m(e)p 1148 3993 28 4
v 34 w(sen)m(t)g(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(26)345 4105 y(6.3.9)106 b(Allo)s(cation)33
b(of)d(source)h(description)f(bandwidth)78 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(26)136 4218 y(6.4)94 b(Sender)30 b(and)f(Receiv)m(er)k(Rep)s(orts)79
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(27)345 4331 y(6.4.1)106 b(SR:)30 b(Sender)g(rep)s(ort)f(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)83 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(28)345 4444 y(6.4.2)106 b(RR:)31 b(Receiv)m(er)h(rep)s(ort)e(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)71 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(33)345 4557 y(6.4.3)106 b(Extending)30 b(the)h(sender)f(and)f(receiv)
m(er)j(rep)s(orts)49 b(.)d(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(33)345 4670 y(6.4.4)106
b(Analyzing)32 b(sender)d(and)h(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(orts)73
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(34)136 4783 y(6.5)94 b(SDES:)30
b(Source)h(description)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)74
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(35)345 4896 y(6.5.1)106
b(CNAME:)31 b(Canonical)g(end-p)s(oin)m(t)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(SDES)f
(item)87 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(36)345 5009 y(6.5.2)106 b(NAME:)31 b(User)g(name)f(SDES)g(item)67
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(38)345 5122
y(6.5.3)106 b(EMAIL:)31 b(Electronic)h(mail)f(address)e(SDES)h(item)36
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)85 b(38)345 5235 y(6.5.4)106 b(PHONE:)31 b(Phone)f(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)f(SDES)g(item)73 b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(38)345
5347 y(6.5.5)106 b(LOC:)30 b(Geographic)i(user)d(lo)s(cation)j(SDES)e
(item)84 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(39)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518
b([P)m(age)32 b(2])p eop
%%Page: 3 3
3 2 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)345 399
y(6.5.6)106 b(TOOL:)30 b(Application)h(or)g(to)s(ol)g(name)f(SDES)g
(item)72 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(39)345 511 y(6.5.7)106 b(NOTE:)30
b(Notice/status)k(SDES)29 b(item)36 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(39)345 624 y(6.5.8)106 b(PRIV:)31 b(Priv)-5 b(ate)31
b(extensions)g(SDES)e(item)g(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(40)136 737 y(6.6)94 b(BYE:)31 b(Go)s(o)s(db)m(y)m(e)g(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)65 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(41)136 850 y(6.7)94 b(APP:)31 b(Application-de\014ned)
f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)68 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(42)0 1054 y Fl(7)f(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(T)-9 b(ranslators)35
b(and)g(Mixers)2344 b(42)136 1167 y Fq(7.1)94 b(General)32
b(Description)87 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(43)136 1280 y(7.2)94 b(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(Pro)s(cessing)h(in)f(T)-8 b(ranslators)88
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(45)136
1393 y(7.3)94 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(Pro)s(cessing)h(in)f(Mixers)56
b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(46)136 1506 y(7.4)94 b(Cascaded)31 b(Mixers)65 b(.)46
b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)85 b(47)0 1709 y Fl(8)f(SSR)m(C)35 b(Iden)m(ti\014er)g(Allo)s
(cation)g(and)g(Use)2027 b(47)136 1822 y Fq(8.1)94 b(Probabilit)m(y)32
b(of)e(Collision)d(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(47)136 1935 y(8.2)94 b(Collision)32
b(Resolution)f(and)f(Lo)s(op)g(Detection)43 b(.)j(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)85 b(48)136 2048 y(8.3)94 b(Use)31 b(with)f(La)m(y)m(ered)i(Enco)s
(dings)d(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(51)0 2252 y Fl(9)f(Securit)m(y)3284 b(51)136 2365 y
Fq(9.1)94 b(Con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)81 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(52)136 2478 y(9.2)94 b(Authen)m(tication)33 b(and)c(Message)k(In)m
(tegrit)m(y)84 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(53)0 2682 y Fl(10)32 b(Congestion)k(Con)m(trol)2768
b(54)0 2885 y(11)32 b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(o)m(v)m(er)g(Net)m(w)m(ork)e(and)h
(T)-9 b(ransp)s(ort)35 b(Proto)s(cols)1636 b(54)0 3089
y(12)32 b(Summary)k(of)f(Proto)s(col)h(Constan)m(ts)2184
b(55)136 3202 y Fq(12.1)49 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s
(es)d(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(55)136 3315 y(12.2)49 b(SDES)30 b(t)m(yp)s(es)53
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(56)0 3519 y Fl(13)32
b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Pro\014les)g(and)f(P)m(a)m(yload)h(F)-9
b(ormat)34 b(Sp)s(eci\014cations)1450 b(56)0 3723 y(A)57
b(Algorithms)3148 b(58)136 3836 y Fq(A.1)71 b(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(Data)h(Header)e(V)-8 b(alidit)m(y)33 b(Chec)m(ks)69
b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(61)136
3949 y(A.2)71 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(Header)h(V)-8 b(alidit)m(y)33
b(Chec)m(ks)88 b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(65)136 4061 y(A.3)71 b(Determining)32 b(Num)m(b)s(er)d(of)h(P)m(ac)m
(k)m(ets)k(Exp)s(ected)c(and)g(Lost)92 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f
(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(65)136
4174 y(A.4)71 b(Generating)32 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(SDES)f(P)m(ac)m(k)m
(ets)62 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85
b(66)136 4287 y(A.5)71 b(P)m(arsing)31 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30
b(SDES)g(P)m(ac)m(k)m(ets)62 b(.)46 b(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g
(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)
f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(67)136 4400 y(A.6)71 b(Generating)32
b(a)f(Random)f(32-bit)h(Iden)m(ti\014er)54 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)
g(.)f(.)85 b(68)136 4513 y(A.7)71 b(Computing)30 b(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(T)-8 b(ransmission)29 b(In)m(terv)-5 b(al)30
b(.)46 b(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(70)136 4626 y(A.8)71 b(Estimating)32
b(the)e(In)m(terarriv)-5 b(al)31 b(Jitter)56 b(.)45 b(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h
(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)g(.)f(.)
h(.)g(.)f(.)h(.)g(.)f(.)85 b(76)0 4830 y Fl(B)62 b(Changes)35
b(from)g(RF)m(C)g(1889)2531 b(76)0 5034 y(C)60 b(Securit)m(y)36
b(Considerations)2571 b(80)0 5237 y(D)56 b(IANA)35 b(Considerations)
2667 b(80)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518
b([P)m(age)32 b(3])p eop
%%Page: 4 4
4 3 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(E)67 b(References)3169 b(81)0 602 y(F)70 b(Ac)m(kno)m(wledgmen)m
(ts)2840 b(83)0 806 y(G)54 b(Addresses)36 b(of)f(Authors)2675
b(83)0 1010 y(H)54 b(In)m(tellectual)35 b(Prop)s(ert)m(y)g(Righ)m(ts)h
(Statemen)m(t)1861 b(84)0 1214 y(I)96 b(F)-9 b(ull)35
b(Cop)m(yrigh)m(t)h(Statemen)m(t)2487 b(84)0 1500 y Fp(1)135
b(In)l(tro)t(duction)0 1703 y Fq([Note)30 b(to)g(the)f(RF)m(C)g
(Editor:)40 b(This)28 b(paragraph)g(is)h(to)h(b)s(e)e(deleted)i(when)d
(this)i(draft)g(is)g(published)e(as)i(an)f(RF)m(C.)0
1816 y(All)i(RF)m(C)h(XXXX)f(should)f(b)s(e)g(\014lled)h(in)g(with)f
(the)h(RF)m(C)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)30
b(Pro\014le)g(for)f(Audio)h(and)f(Video)0 1929 y(Conferences)i(as)h(it)
g(is)f(submitted)g(for)g(Draft)g(Standard)g(status.)43
b(RF)m(C)32 b(2373)h(is)e(men)m(tioned)h(in)f(Section)h(6.5.1)0
2042 y(and)40 b(included)f(as)i(a)g(reference;)46 b(please)41
b(up)s(date)f(b)s(oth)g(if)g(the)h(Draft)g(Standard)e(revision)h(of)h
(RF)m(C)g(2373)h(is)0 2155 y(published)34 b(b)s(efore)i(this)g(do)s
(cumen)m(t.)58 b(Similarly)-8 b(,)39 b(please)e(up)s(date)e(the)i
(reference)f(to)h(the)g(\\Secure)f(Real-time)0 2268 y(T)-8
b(ransp)s(ort)33 b(Proto)s(col")j(In)m(ternet-Draft)f(if)f(it)g(is)g
(published)e(as)j(an)e(RF)m(C)i(in)e(time.)52 b(Readers)35
b(are)f(directed)g(to)0 2381 y(App)s(endix)i(B,)k(Changes)d(from)g(RF)m
(C)h(1889,)k(for)37 b(a)h(listing)g(of)g(the)g(c)m(hanges)g(that)h(ha)m
(v)m(e)f(b)s(een)f(made)h(in)f(this)0 2494 y(draft.])141
2606 y(This)k(memorandum)e(sp)s(eci\014es)i(the)h(real-time)h(transp)s
(ort)d(proto)s(col)i(\(R)-8 b(TP\),)42 b(whic)m(h)f(pro)m(vides)g
(end-to-)0 2719 y(end)35 b(deliv)m(ery)i(services)g(for)f(data)g(with)g
(real-time)i(c)m(haracteristics,)i(suc)m(h)c(as)g(in)m(teractiv)m(e)j
(audio)d(and)f(video.)0 2832 y(Those)26 b(services)g(include)g(pa)m
(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)f(iden)m(ti\014cation,)j(sequence)d(n)m(um)m(b)s
(ering,)g(timestamping)h(and)e(deliv)m(ery)0 2945 y(monitoring.)57
b(Applications)36 b(t)m(ypically)h(run)e(R)-8 b(TP)35
b(on)g(top)h(of)g(UDP)g(to)g(mak)m(e)g(use)g(of)f(its)h(m)m
(ultiplexing)h(and)0 3058 y(c)m(hec)m(ksum)23 b(services;)j(b)s(oth)21
b(proto)s(cols)i(con)m(tribute)g(parts)f(of)g(the)g(transp)s(ort)g
(proto)s(col)h(functionalit)m(y)-8 b(.)40 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)0
3171 y(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(used)g(with)g(other)g(suitable)h
(underlying)f(net)m(w)m(ork)h(or)f(transp)s(ort)g(proto)s(cols)h(\(see)
g(Section)g(11\).)0 3284 y(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(supp)s(orts)d(data)k
(transfer)e(to)i(m)m(ultiple)f(destinations)g(using)g(m)m(ulticast)h
(distribution)e(if)h(pro)m(vided)f(b)m(y)h(the)0 3397
y(underlying)i(net)m(w)m(ork.)141 3510 y(Note)43 b(that)f(R)-8
b(TP)41 b(itself)h(do)s(es)f(not)h(pro)m(vide)g(an)m(y)f(mec)m(hanism)h
(to)g(ensure)f(timely)h(deliv)m(ery)g(or)g(pro)m(vide)0
3623 y(other)25 b(qualit)m(y-of-service)j(guaran)m(tees,)g(but)d
(relies)g(on)g(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)k(services)d(to)f(do)g(so.)40
b(It)25 b(do)s(es)g Fk(not)g Fq(guaran)m(tee)0 3736 y(deliv)m(ery)j(or)
f(prev)m(en)m(t)h(out-of-order)g(deliv)m(ery)-8 b(,)29
b(nor)e(do)s(es)g(it)g(assume)g(that)h(the)g(underlying)e(net)m(w)m
(ork)i(is)f(reliable)0 3848 y(and)38 b(deliv)m(ers)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(in)d(sequence.)66 b(The)38 b(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)e(included)h
(in)g(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(allo)m(w)i(the)f(receiv)m(er)h(to)0
3961 y(reconstruct)34 b(the)g(sender's)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(sequence,)g
(but)d(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f(migh)m(t)h(also)h(b)s(e)e(used)g
(to)i(determine)0 4074 y(the)24 b(prop)s(er)e(lo)s(cation)i(of)g(a)g
(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(for)c(example)h(in)f(video)h(deco)s(ding,)h(without)e
(necessarily)i(deco)s(ding)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 4187 y(in)30
b(sequence.)141 4300 y(While)45 b(R)-8 b(TP)44 b(is)g(primarily)g
(designed)g(to)g(satisfy)h(the)f(needs)g(of)g(m)m(ulti-participan)m(t)i
(m)m(ultimedia)f(con-)0 4413 y(ferences,)40 b(it)e(is)g(not)g(limited)g
(to)g(that)g(particular)g(application.)64 b(Storage)39
b(of)e(con)m(tin)m(uous)i(data,)h(in)m(teractiv)m(e)0
4526 y(distributed)25 b(sim)m(ulation,)j(activ)m(e)h(badge,)e(and)e
(con)m(trol)j(and)d(measuremen)m(t)i(applications)g(ma)m(y)g(also)g
(\014nd)d(R)-8 b(TP)0 4639 y(applicable.)141 4752 y(This)30
b(do)s(cumen)m(t)g(de\014nes)f(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)31 b(consisting)g(of)g(t)m
(w)m(o)h(closely-link)m(ed)g(parts:)136 4964 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(the)31 b(real-time)h(transp)s(ort)d(proto)s(col)j(\(R)-8
b(TP\),)31 b(to)g(carry)f(data)h(that)g(has)g(real-time)h(prop)s
(erties.)136 5152 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(the)23 b(R)-8 b(TP)23
b(con)m(trol)h(proto)s(col)g(\(R)-8 b(TCP\),)23 b(to)g(monitor)g(the)g
(qualit)m(y)h(of)f(service)h(and)e(to)h(con)m(v)m(ey)i(information)227
5265 y(ab)s(out)f(the)g(participan)m(ts)g(in)f(an)h(on-going)h
(session.)39 b(The)23 b(latter)i(asp)s(ect)f(of)g(R)-8
b(TCP)23 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(su\016cien)m(t)h(for)227
5378 y(\\lo)s(osely)35 b(con)m(trolled")g(sessions,)f(i.e.,)h(where)e
(there)g(is)g(no)g(explicit)h(mem)m(b)s(ership)e(con)m(trol)i(and)f
(set-up,)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)
519 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518 b([P)m(age)32
b(4])p eop
%%Page: 5 5
5 4 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(but)37 b(it)h(is)g(not)g(necessarily)g(in)m(tended)g(to)g(supp)s(ort)
e(all)i(of)g(an)f(application's)i(con)m(trol)g(comm)m(unication)227
511 y(requiremen)m(ts.)62 b(This)37 b(functionalit)m(y)i(ma)m(y)f(b)s
(e)f(fully)g(or)g(partially)i(subsumed)c(b)m(y)j(a)f(separate)i
(session)227 624 y(con)m(trol)32 b(proto)s(col,)g(whic)m(h)e(is)g(b)s
(ey)m(ond)g(the)g(scop)s(e)h(of)f(this)h(do)s(cumen)m(t.)141
837 y(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(represen)m(ts)g(a)g(new)f(st)m(yle)i(of)f(proto)s
(col)h(follo)m(wing)h(the)e(principles)f(of)h(application)h(lev)m(el)h
(framing)e(and)0 950 y(in)m(tegrated)40 b(la)m(y)m(er)g(pro)s(cessing)f
(prop)s(osed)e(b)m(y)i(Clark)f(and)g(T)-8 b(ennenhouse)38
b([10)q(].)66 b(That)38 b(is,)j(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(is)h(in)m(tended)0
1063 y(to)44 b(b)s(e)f(malleable)i(to)f(pro)m(vide)f(the)h(information)
f(required)g(b)m(y)g(a)h(particular)f(application)i(and)e(will)h(often)
0 1176 y(b)s(e)35 b(in)m(tegrated)i(in)m(to)f(the)g(application)h(pro)s
(cessing)e(rather)g(than)g(b)s(eing)g(implemen)m(ted)h(as)g(a)g
(separate)g(la)m(y)m(er.)0 1289 y(R)-8 b(TP)41 b(is)g(a)h(proto)s(col)g
(framew)m(ork)f(that)h(is)f(delib)s(erately)h(not)f(complete.)74
b(This)41 b(do)s(cumen)m(t)g(sp)s(eci\014es)f(those)0
1401 y(functions)29 b(exp)s(ected)g(to)h(b)s(e)f(common)g(across)h(all)
g(the)f(applications)h(for)f(whic)m(h)g(R)-8 b(TP)29
b(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)g(appropriate.)0 1514 y(Unlik)m(e)39
b(con)m(v)m(en)m(tional)i(proto)s(cols)e(in)f(whic)m(h)g(additional)h
(functions)f(migh)m(t)h(b)s(e)e(accommo)s(dated)j(b)m(y)e(making)0
1627 y(the)33 b(proto)s(col)i(more)e(general)h(or)f(b)m(y)g(adding)g
(an)g(option)h(mec)m(hanism)f(that)h(w)m(ould)f(require)g(parsing,)h(R)
-8 b(TP)33 b(is)0 1740 y(in)m(tended)25 b(to)g(b)s(e)f(tailored)i
(through)e(mo)s(di\014cations)h(and/or)g(additions)g(to)g(the)g
(headers)f(as)h(needed.)39 b(Examples)0 1853 y(are)31
b(giv)m(en)g(in)f(Sections)h(5.3)h(and)d(6.4.3.)141 1966
y(Therefore,)f(in)g(addition)g(to)g(this)g(do)s(cumen)m(t,)g(a)g
(complete)h(sp)s(eci\014cation)g(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(for)h(a)g
(particular)g(appli-)0 2079 y(cation)k(will)e(require)h(one)f(or)h
(more)f(companion)h(do)s(cumen)m(ts)f(\(see)h(Section)g(13\):)136
2291 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(a)28 b Fk(pr)-5 b(o\014le)29 b
Fq(sp)s(eci\014cation)f(do)s(cumen)m(t,)f(whic)m(h)g(de\014nes)g(a)g
(set)h(of)f(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)g(co)s(des)f(and)f(their)i(mapping)
227 2404 y(to)h(pa)m(yload)h(formats)e(\(e.g.,)j(media)d(enco)s
(dings\).)41 b(A)28 b(pro\014le)g(ma)m(y)h(also)g(de\014ne)f
(extensions)h(or)f(mo)s(di\014ca-)227 2517 y(tions)33
b(to)f(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(that)h(are)f(sp)s(eci\014c)g(to)g(a)h(particular)
f(class)h(of)f(applications.)47 b(T)m(ypically)33 b(an)f(application)
227 2630 y(will)h(op)s(erate)g(under)f(only)g(one)h(pro\014le.)47
b(A)33 b(pro\014le)f(for)h(audio)f(and)g(video)i(data)f(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)
f(found)f(in)i(the)227 2743 y(companion)e(RF)m(C)g(XXXX)g([1].)136
2931 y Fj(\017)46 b Fk(p)-5 b(aylo)g(ad)42 b(format)c
Fq(sp)s(eci\014cation)f(do)s(cumen)m(ts,)g(whic)m(h)f(de\014ne)g(ho)m
(w)g(a)h(particular)g(pa)m(yload,)i(suc)m(h)d(as)g(an)227
3044 y(audio)31 b(or)f(video)h(enco)s(ding,)g(is)f(to)h(b)s(e)f
(carried)g(in)g(R)-8 b(TP.)141 3256 y(A)24 b(discussion)f(of)h
(real-time)i(services)e(and)g(algorithms)g(for)g(their)g(implemen)m
(tation)h(as)f(w)m(ell)h(as)f(bac)m(kground)0 3369 y(discussion)30
b(on)g(some)h(of)f(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(design)g(decisions)h(can)g(b)s
(e)f(found)f(in)h([11)q(].)0 3612 y Fo(1.1)112 b(T)-9
b(erminology)0 3784 y Fq(The)29 b(k)m(ey)h(w)m(ords)g(\\)p
Fi(must)p Fq(",)f(\\)p Fi(must)k(not)p Fq(",)d(\\)p Fi(required)p
Fq(",)g(\\)p Fi(shall)p Fq(",)f(\\)p Fi(shall)j(not)p
Fq(",)e(\\)p Fi(should)p Fq(",)f(\\)p Fi(should)0 3897
y(not)p Fq(",)35 b(\\)p Fi(recommended)p Fq(",)e(\\)p
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)r Fq(",)35 b(and)e(\\)p Fi(optional)p Fq(")g(in)h(this)f
(do)s(cumen)m(t)h(are)g(to)h(b)s(e)e(in)m(terpreted)h(as)g(de-)0
4010 y(scrib)s(ed)29 b(in)h(RF)m(C)h(2119)h([2)q(])f(and)e(indicate)j
(requiremen)m(t)e(lev)m(els)i(for)e(complian)m(t)i(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(implemen)m(tations.)0 4296 y Fp(2)135 b(R)-11
b(TP)44 b(Use)i(Scenarios)0 4499 y Fq(The)39 b(follo)m(wing)j(sections)
e(describ)s(e)g(some)g(asp)s(ects)g(of)g(the)g(use)f(of)h(R)-8
b(TP.)69 b(The)39 b(examples)i(w)m(ere)f(c)m(hosen)g(to)0
4612 y(illustrate)34 b(the)g(basic)g(op)s(eration)f(of)h(applications)g
(using)f(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)33 b(not)h(to)g(limit)g(what)f(R)-8
b(TP)33 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(used)h(for.)0 4725 y(In)e(these)i(examples,)
g(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(is)g(carried)g(on)g(top)g(of)g(IP)g(and)f(UDP)-8
b(,)33 b(and)e(follo)m(ws)i(the)g(con)m(v)m(en)m(tions)h(established)0
4838 y(b)m(y)c(the)h(pro\014le)f(for)g(audio)g(and)g(video)h(sp)s
(eci\014ed)f(in)g(the)g(companion)h(RF)m(C)g(XXXX.)0
5081 y Fo(2.1)112 b(Simple)39 b(Multicast)f(Audio)g(Conference)0
5253 y Fq(A)g(w)m(orking)g(group)f(of)h(the)g(IETF)f(meets)h(to)h
(discuss)e(the)h(latest)h(proto)s(col)g(draft,)g(using)e(the)h(IP)f(m)m
(ulticast)0 5366 y(services)25 b(of)g(the)f(In)m(ternet)h(for)f(v)m
(oice)i(comm)m(unications.)40 b(Through)23 b(some)i(allo)s(cation)h
(mec)m(hanism)f(the)g(w)m(orking)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518
b([P)m(age)32 b(5])p eop
%%Page: 6 6
6 5 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(group)g(c)m(hair)i(obtains)f(a)g(m)m(ulticast)h(group)e(address)g
(and)g(pair)h(of)g(p)s(orts.)44 b(One)31 b(p)s(ort)g(is)h(used)f(for)g
(audio)h(data,)0 511 y(and)26 b(the)h(other)g(is)g(used)f(for)g(con)m
(trol)i(\(R)-8 b(TCP\))27 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)41 b(This)26
b(address)g(and)g(p)s(ort)g(information)h(is)g(distributed)0
624 y(to)32 b(the)f(in)m(tended)f(participan)m(ts.)43
b(If)31 b(priv)-5 b(acy)30 b(is)h(desired,)g(the)g(data)h(and)e(con)m
(trol)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(ma)m(y)e(b)s(e)f(encrypted)0
737 y(as)d(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(in)g(Section)i(9.1,)h(in)d(whic)m(h)g(case)
i(an)f(encryption)f(k)m(ey)i(m)m(ust)e(also)i(b)s(e)e(generated)i(and)e
(distributed.)0 850 y(The)k(exact)i(details)f(of)g(these)g(allo)s
(cation)h(and)e(distribution)g(mec)m(hanisms)g(are)h(b)s(ey)m(ond)f
(the)g(scop)s(e)h(of)f(R)-8 b(TP.)141 963 y(The)39 b(audio)h
(conferencing)g(application)h(used)e(b)m(y)g(eac)m(h)i(conference)f
(participan)m(t)h(sends)d(audio)i(data)g(in)0 1076 y(small)d(c)m(h)m
(unks)e(of,)j(sa)m(y)-8 b(,)39 b(20)e(ms)f(duration.)58
b(Eac)m(h)37 b(c)m(h)m(unk)e(of)i(audio)f(data)h(is)f(preceded)g(b)m(y)
g(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)36 b(header;)0 1189 y(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(header)h(and)f
(data)i(are)f(in)f(turn)g(con)m(tained)i(in)e(a)h(UDP)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)
41 b(The)26 b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(header)h(indicates)g(what)g(t)m(yp)s(e)0
1302 y(of)h(audio)h(enco)s(ding)f(\(suc)m(h)g(as)g(PCM,)h(ADPCM)f(or)g
(LPC\))g(is)g(con)m(tained)i(in)e(eac)m(h)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(so)f(that)f
(senders)g(can)0 1415 y(c)m(hange)34 b(the)f(enco)s(ding)g(during)f(a)h
(conference,)i(for)e(example,)h(to)g(accommo)s(date)h(a)e(new)f
(participan)m(t)i(that)g(is)0 1528 y(connected)d(through)f(a)h(lo)m
(w-bandwidth)e(link)i(or)f(react)i(to)f(indications)g(of)f(net)m(w)m
(ork)i(congestion.)141 1641 y(The)21 b(In)m(ternet,)i(lik)m(e)g(other)e
(pac)m(k)m(et)i(net)m(w)m(orks,)h(o)s(ccasionally)f(loses)f(and)e
(reorders)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(and)d(dela)m(ys)i(them)0
1753 y(b)m(y)37 b(v)-5 b(ariable)38 b(amoun)m(ts)f(of)g(time.)61
b(T)-8 b(o)37 b(cop)s(e)h(with)e(these)i(impairmen)m(ts,)h(the)e(R)-8
b(TP)37 b(header)f(con)m(tains)i(timing)0 1866 y(information)28
b(and)f(a)i(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(that)j(allo)m(w)g(the)f
(receiv)m(ers)i(to)e(reconstruct)g(the)g(timing)h(pro)s(duced)d(b)m(y)0
1979 y(the)k(source,)h(so)f(that)h(in)f(this)g(example,)h(c)m(h)m(unks)
f(of)g(audio)h(are)f(con)m(tiguously)i(pla)m(y)m(ed)f(out)f(the)h(sp)s
(eak)m(er)f(ev)m(ery)0 2092 y(20)k(ms.)50 b(This)33 b(timing)h
(reconstruction)g(is)g(p)s(erformed)e(separately)i(for)g(eac)m(h)g
(source)g(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(in)d(the)0
2205 y(conference.)46 b(The)32 b(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(can)h
(also)h(b)s(e)f(used)f(b)m(y)h(the)g(receiv)m(er)h(to)g(estimate)h(ho)m
(w)e(man)m(y)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 2318 y(are)f(b)s(eing)f(lost.)141
2431 y(Since)i(mem)m(b)s(ers)f(of)h(the)f(w)m(orking)h(group)g(join)f
(and)g(lea)m(v)m(e)j(during)d(the)h(conference,)h(it)f(is)g(useful)f
(to)h(kno)m(w)0 2544 y(who)40 b(is)g(participating)i(at)f(an)m(y)f
(momen)m(t)h(and)f(ho)m(w)g(w)m(ell)h(they)g(are)f(receiving)i(the)e
(audio)g(data.)71 b(F)-8 b(or)41 b(that)0 2657 y(purp)s(ose,)24
b(eac)m(h)i(instance)g(of)e(the)h(audio)g(application)h(in)f(the)f
(conference)i(p)s(erio)s(dically)f(m)m(ulticasts)h(a)f(reception)0
2770 y(rep)s(ort)32 b(plus)f(the)i(name)f(of)h(its)g(user)f(on)g(the)h
(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(\(con)m(trol\))i(p)s(ort.)46 b(The)32
b(reception)i(rep)s(ort)e(indicates)h(ho)m(w)0 2883 y(w)m(ell)43
b(the)g(curren)m(t)f(sp)s(eak)m(er)h(is)f(b)s(eing)g(receiv)m(ed)i(and)
e(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(used)f(to)i(con)m(trol)h(adaptiv)m(e)g(enco)s
(dings.)77 b(In)0 2995 y(addition)35 b(to)g(the)g(user)f(name,)i(other)
f(iden)m(tifying)h(information)f(ma)m(y)g(also)h(b)s(e)e(included)g
(sub)5 b(ject)34 b(to)h(con)m(trol)0 3108 y(bandwidth)27
b(limits.)41 b(A)29 b(site)h(sends)e(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)29
b(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(\(Section)f(6.6\))h(when)d(it)h(lea)m(v)m(es)j
(the)d(conference.)0 3352 y Fo(2.2)112 b(Audio)38 b(and)g(Video)g
(Conference)0 3523 y Fq(If)h(b)s(oth)f(audio)i(and)e(video)i(media)g
(are)g(used)e(in)h(a)h(conference,)i(they)e(are)g(transmitted)f(as)h
(separate)g Fk(R)-7 b(TP)0 3636 y(sessions.)59 b Fq(That)36
b(is,)i(separate)f(R)-8 b(TP)36 b(and)g(R)-8 b(TCP)36
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(are)e(transmitted)h(for)f(eac)m(h)h(medium)f(using)g
(t)m(w)m(o)0 3749 y(di\013eren)m(t)30 b(UDP)g(p)s(ort)f(pairs)g(and/or)
h(m)m(ulticast)h(addresses.)40 b(There)29 b(is)g(no)h(direct)g
(coupling)g(at)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(lev)m(el)0 3862
y(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)i(the)g(audio)g(and)f(video)h(sessions,)g(except)h
(that)f(a)g(user)f(participating)i(in)f(b)s(oth)f(sessions)h(should)e
(use)0 3975 y(the)g(same)g(distinguished)e(\(canonical\))k(name)e(in)f
(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(for)f(b)s(oth)e(so)i(that)g(the)
g(sessions)g(can)g(b)s(e)0 4088 y(asso)s(ciated.)141
4201 y(One)23 b(motiv)-5 b(ation)26 b(for)e(this)f(separation)i(is)f
(to)g(allo)m(w)i(some)e(participan)m(ts)g(in)g(the)g(conference)h(to)f
(receiv)m(e)i(only)0 4314 y(one)36 b(medium)f(if)h(they)g(c)m(ho)s
(ose.)57 b(F)-8 b(urther)36 b(explanation)h(is)e(giv)m(en)i(in)f
(Section)g(5.2.)58 b(Despite)37 b(the)f(separation,)0
4427 y(sync)m(hronized)42 b(pla)m(ybac)m(k)h(of)g(a)f(source's)g(audio)
h(and)e(video)i(can)f(b)s(e)g(ac)m(hiev)m(ed)h(using)f(timing)h
(information)0 4540 y(carried)31 b(in)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(for)e(b)s(oth)g(sessions.)0 4783 y
Fo(2.3)112 b(Mixers)38 b(and)h(T)-9 b(ranslators)0 4955
y Fq(So)25 b(far,)h(w)m(e)f(ha)m(v)m(e)i(assumed)d(that)h(all)h(sites)g
(w)m(an)m(t)g(to)f(receiv)m(e)i(media)f(data)f(in)g(the)g(same)g
(format.)40 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)28 b(this)0 5068 y(ma)m(y)37
b(not)f(alw)m(a)m(ys)h(b)s(e)f(appropriate.)58 b(Consider)35
b(the)h(case)h(where)f(participan)m(ts)h(in)e(one)i(area)g(are)f
(connected)0 5180 y(through)30 b(a)h(lo)m(w-sp)s(eed)f(link)h(to)g(the)
f(ma)5 b(jorit)m(y)32 b(of)f(the)f(conference)i(participan)m(ts)f(who)f
(enjo)m(y)h(high-sp)s(eed)e(net-)0 5293 y(w)m(ork)d(access.)40
b(Instead)25 b(of)h(forcing)f(ev)m(ery)m(one)j(to)e(use)f(a)h(lo)m(w)m
(er-bandwidth,)g(reduced-qualit)m(y)g(audio)g(enco)s(ding,)0
5406 y(an)32 b(R)-8 b(TP-lev)m(el)33 b(rela)m(y)g(called)g(a)f
Fk(mixer)g Fq(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(placed)h(near)g(the)g(lo)m(w-bandwidth)f
(area.)45 b(This)31 b(mixer)g(resyn-)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518 b([P)m(age)32 b(6])p eop
%%Page: 7 7
7 6 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(c)m(hronizes)22 b(incoming)h(audio)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(to)e
(reconstruct)g(the)g(constan)m(t)h(20)f(ms)f(spacing)h(generated)h(b)m
(y)f(the)f(sender,)0 511 y(mixes)35 b(these)h(reconstructed)f(audio)h
(streams)f(in)m(to)h(a)g(single)g(stream,)h(translates)f(the)f(audio)h
(enco)s(ding)f(to)h(a)0 624 y(lo)m(w)m(er-bandwidth)e(one)h(and)g(forw)
m(ards)f(the)g(lo)m(w)m(er-bandwidth)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(stream)e(across)g
(the)g(lo)m(w-sp)s(eed)g(link.)0 737 y(These)29 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(migh)
m(t)g(b)s(e)e(unicast)h(to)h(a)f(single)h(recipien)m(t)g(or)f(m)m
(ulticast)h(on)f(a)g(di\013eren)m(t)h(address)e(to)h(m)m(ultiple)0
850 y(recipien)m(ts.)53 b(The)33 b(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(header)g(includes)g
(a)g(means)g(for)g(mixers)g(to)h(iden)m(tify)g(the)f(sources)g(that)h
(con)m(tributed)0 963 y(to)c(a)g(mixed)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i(so)f(that)g
(correct)h(talk)m(er)f(indication)h(can)e(b)s(e)g(pro)m(vided)g(at)h
(the)g(receiv)m(ers.)141 1076 y(Some)j(of)g(the)g(in)m(tended)g
(participan)m(ts)g(in)g(the)g(audio)g(conference)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e
(connected)i(with)e(high)h(band-)0 1189 y(width)40 b(links)g(but)g
(migh)m(t)h(not)f(b)s(e)g(directly)h(reac)m(hable)h(via)f(IP)f(m)m
(ulticast.)73 b(F)-8 b(or)41 b(example,)j(they)c(migh)m(t)i(b)s(e)0
1302 y(b)s(ehind)33 b(an)h(application-lev)m(el)k(\014rew)m(all)d(that)
h(will)f(not)f(let)i(an)m(y)f(IP)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(pass.)53
b(F)-8 b(or)35 b(these)g(sites,)i(mixing)0 1415 y(ma)m(y)h(not)f(b)s(e)
g(necessary)-8 b(,)40 b(in)d(whic)m(h)g(case)i(another)e(t)m(yp)s(e)h
(of)f(R)-8 b(TP-lev)m(el)39 b(rela)m(y)g(called)f(a)g
Fk(tr)-5 b(anslator)41 b Fq(ma)m(y)d(b)s(e)0 1528 y(used.)g(Tw)m(o)25
b(translators)g(are)f(installed,)j(one)e(on)f(either)h(side)f(of)h(the)
f(\014rew)m(all,)j(with)d(the)g(outside)h(one)g(funneling)0
1641 y(all)i(m)m(ulticast)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)f(receiv)m(ed)g(through)e(a)h
(secure)f(connection)i(to)f(the)g(translator)g(inside)g(the)f(\014rew)m
(all.)40 b(The)0 1753 y(translator)30 b(inside)f(the)h(\014rew)m(all)f
(sends)g(them)g(again)h(as)g(m)m(ulticast)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(to)f(a)g(m)
m(ulticast)h(group)d(restricted)0 1866 y(to)j(the)g(site's)g(in)m
(ternal)g(net)m(w)m(ork.)141 1979 y(Mixers)e(and)e(translators)i(ma)m
(y)g(b)s(e)f(designed)g(for)g(a)h(v)-5 b(ariet)m(y)30
b(of)e(purp)s(oses.)38 b(An)28 b(example)h(is)f(a)h(video)g(mixer)0
2092 y(that)e(scales)h(the)f(images)h(of)f(individual)f(p)s(eople)h(in)
f(separate)i(video)f(streams)g(and)g(comp)s(osites)g(them)g(in)m(to)h
(one)0 2205 y(video)i(stream)g(to)h(sim)m(ulate)g(a)f(group)f(scene.)41
b(Other)29 b(examples)h(of)g(translation)h(include)e(the)h(connection)h
(of)f(a)0 2318 y(group)23 b(of)h(hosts)f(sp)s(eaking)h(only)f(IP/UDP)i
(to)f(a)g(group)f(of)h(hosts)f(that)h(understand)e(only)i(ST-I)s(I,)e
(or)i(the)g(pac)m(k)m(et-)0 2431 y(b)m(y-pac)m(k)m(et)30
b(enco)s(ding)e(translation)h(of)f(video)h(streams)f(from)g(individual)
f(sources)h(without)g(resync)m(hronization)0 2544 y(or)i(mixing.)41
b(Details)33 b(of)d(the)h(op)s(eration)f(of)h(mixers)f(and)g
(translators)h(are)g(giv)m(en)g(in)f(Section)h(7.)0 2787
y Fo(2.4)112 b(La)m(y)m(ered)39 b(Enco)s(dings)0 2959
y Fq(Multimedia)d(applications)h(should)d(b)s(e)h(able)h(to)g(adjust)f
(the)h(transmission)f(rate)h(to)g(matc)m(h)h(the)e(capacit)m(y)j(of)0
3072 y(the)33 b(receiv)m(er)g(or)g(to)g(adapt)g(to)g(net)m(w)m(ork)g
(congestion.)48 b(Man)m(y)34 b(implemen)m(tations)f(place)h(the)e(resp)
s(onsibilit)m(y)h(of)0 3185 y(rate-adaptivit)m(y)h(at)e(the)g(source.)
44 b(This)30 b(do)s(es)h(not)h(w)m(ork)f(w)m(ell)i(with)e(m)m(ulticast)
i(transmission)e(b)s(ecause)g(of)h(the)0 3298 y(con\015icting)e
(bandwidth)d(requiremen)m(ts)i(of)h(heterogeneous)g(receiv)m(ers.)42
b(The)28 b(result)h(is)g(often)h(a)f(least-common)0 3410
y(denominator)d(scenario,)h(where)f(the)f(smallest)i(pip)s(e)e(in)g
(the)h(net)m(w)m(ork)g(mesh)g(dictates)h(the)e(qualit)m(y)i(and)e
(\014delit)m(y)0 3523 y(of)31 b(the)f(o)m(v)m(erall)j(liv)m(e)e(m)m
(ultimedia)h(\\broadcast".)141 3636 y(Instead,)27 b(resp)s(onsibilit)m
(y)e(for)g(rate-adaptation)j(can)e(b)s(e)f(placed)h(at)g(the)g(receiv)m
(ers)g(b)m(y)g(com)m(bining)g(a)f(la)m(y)m(ered)0 3749
y(enco)s(ding)30 b(with)g(a)h(la)m(y)m(ered)h(transmission)e(system.)41
b(In)30 b(the)g(con)m(text)i(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(o)m(v)m(er)i(IP)e(m)m
(ulticast,)i(the)f(source)0 3862 y(can)d(strip)s(e)g(the)g(progressiv)m
(e)h(la)m(y)m(ers)g(of)g(a)f(hierarc)m(hically)i(represen)m(ted)e
(signal)h(across)f(m)m(ultiple)h(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(sessions)0
3975 y(eac)m(h)35 b(carried)g(on)f(its)h(o)m(wn)f(m)m(ulticast)i
(group.)52 b(Receiv)m(ers)36 b(can)e(then)g(adapt)h(to)g(net)m(w)m(ork)
g(heterogeneit)m(y)i(and)0 4088 y(con)m(trol)32 b(their)e(reception)h
(bandwidth)e(b)m(y)h(joining)h(only)f(the)h(appropriate)f(subset)g(of)h
(the)f(m)m(ulticast)i(groups.)141 4201 y(Details)g(of)f(the)g(use)f(of)
g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(with)g(la)m(y)m(ered)i(enco)s(dings)e(are)h(giv)m(en)h
(in)e(Sections)h(6.3.9,)h(8.3)g(and)d(11.)0 4487 y Fp(3)135
b(De\014nitions)0 4690 y Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(pa)m(yload:)46
b Fq(The)38 b(data)i(transp)s(orted)e(b)m(y)i(R)-8 b(TP)38
b(in)h(a)h(pac)m(k)m(et,)k(for)39 b(example)g(audio)h(samples)f(or)g
(com-)227 4803 y(pressed)i(video)i(data.)76 b(The)42
b(pa)m(yload)h(format)f(and)f(in)m(terpretation)j(are)e(b)s(ey)m(ond)g
(the)g(scop)s(e)g(of)g(this)227 4916 y(do)s(cumen)m(t.)0
5104 y Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et:)46 b Fq(A)23 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m
(et)h(consisting)f(of)g(the)f(\014xed)g(R)-8 b(TP)23
b(header,)h(a)g(p)s(ossibly)e(empt)m(y)i(list)g(of)f(con)m(tribut-)227
5217 y(ing)38 b(sources)f(\(see)h(b)s(elo)m(w\),)i(and)d(the)h(pa)m
(yload)g(data.)62 b(Some)38 b(underlying)e(proto)s(cols)i(ma)m(y)g
(require)f(an)227 5330 y(encapsulation)c(of)f(the)h(R)-8
b(TP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(to)f(b)s(e)e(de\014ned.)45 b(T)m(ypically)33
b(one)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(of)d(the)g(underlying)f(pro-)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518 b([P)m(age)32
b(7])p eop
%%Page: 8 8
8 7 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(to)s(col)i(con)m(tains)g(a)f(single)g(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(but)d(sev)m(eral)h(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)32 b Fq(b)s(e)f(con)m(tained)i(if)e(p)s(ermitted)227
511 y(b)m(y)g(the)f(encapsulation)h(metho)s(d)f(\(see)h(Section)h
(11\).)0 699 y Fl(R)-9 b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et:)46 b
Fq(A)38 b(con)m(trol)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(consisting)f(of)f(a)g(\014xed)f
(header)h(part)f(similar)i(to)f(that)h(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)37
b(data)227 812 y(pac)m(k)m(ets,)h(follo)m(w)m(ed)d(b)m(y)f(structured)g
(elemen)m(ts)h(that)g(v)-5 b(ary)34 b(dep)s(ending)f(up)s(on)f(the)j(R)
-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(t)m(yp)s(e.)227 925 y(The)30
b(formats)g(are)g(de\014ned)e(in)i(Section)h(6.)41 b(T)m(ypically)-8
b(,)31 b(m)m(ultiple)g(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(are)e(sen)m(t)g
(together)i(as)227 1038 y(a)k(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)34
b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(in)e(a)h(single)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(of)e(the)h
(underlying)e(proto)s(col;)39 b(this)c(is)g(enabled)g(b)m(y)227
1151 y(the)c(length)g(\014eld)f(in)g(the)g(\014xed)g(header)g(of)h(eac)
m(h)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)0 1338 y Fl(P)m(ort:)46
b Fq(The)37 b(\\abstraction)h(that)g(transp)s(ort)f(proto)s(cols)g(use)
g(to)h(distinguish)f(among)g(m)m(ultiple)h(destinations)227
1451 y(within)24 b(a)g(giv)m(en)h(host)f(computer.)39
b(TCP/IP)23 b(proto)s(cols)i(iden)m(tify)g(p)s(orts)e(using)g(small)i
(p)s(ositiv)m(e)g(in)m(tegers.")227 1564 y([12)q(])30
b(The)f(transp)s(ort)g(selectors)i(\(TSEL\))e(used)g(b)m(y)g(the)h(OSI)
e(transp)s(ort)h(la)m(y)m(er)i(are)f(equiv)-5 b(alen)m(t)31
b(to)f(p)s(orts.)227 1677 y(R)-8 b(TP)41 b(dep)s(ends)f(up)s(on)f(the)j
(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)i(proto)s(col)e(to)g(pro)m(vide)f(some)h(mec)m
(hanism)f(suc)m(h)g(as)h(p)s(orts)e(to)227 1790 y(m)m(ultiplex)31
b(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(and)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(of)e(a)h
(session.)0 1978 y Fl(T)-9 b(ransp)s(ort)35 b(address:)46
b Fq(The)31 b(com)m(bination)h(of)f(a)h(net)m(w)m(ork)g(address)e(and)g
(p)s(ort)h(that)g(iden)m(ti\014es)h(a)f(transp)s(ort-)227
2090 y(lev)m(el)j(endp)s(oin)m(t,)f(for)f(example)h(an)g(IP)f(address)f
(and)h(a)h(UDP)g(p)s(ort.)46 b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(ets)35 b(are)e(transmitted)
g(from)f(a)227 2203 y(source)f(transp)s(ort)e(address)h(to)h(a)g
(destination)g(transp)s(ort)e(address.)0 2391 y Fl(R)-9
b(TP)36 b(media)f(t)m(yp)s(e:)45 b Fq(An)35 b(R)-8 b(TP)36
b(media)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(is)g(the)g(collection)i(of)e(pa)m(yload)h(t)m
(yp)s(es)f(whic)m(h)f(can)i(b)s(e)e(carried)227 2504
y(within)k(a)i(single)f(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(session.)69 b(The)40
b(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(Pro\014le)h(assigns)g(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(media)h(t)m(yp)s
(es)g(to)g(R)-8 b(TP)40 b(pa)m(yload)227 2617 y(t)m(yp)s(es.)0
2804 y Fl(Multimedia)35 b(session:)46 b Fq(A)32 b(set)g(of)f(concurren)
m(t)g(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(sessions)h(among)f(a)h(common)g(group)e(of)i
(participan)m(ts.)227 2917 y(F)-8 b(or)35 b(example,)g(a)g(video)s
(conference)f(\(whic)m(h)g(is)g(a)g(m)m(ultimedia)h(session\))f(ma)m(y)
g(con)m(tain)i(an)d(audio)h(R)-8 b(TP)227 3030 y(session)31
b(and)f(a)g(video)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(session.)0 3218 y
Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(session:)46 b Fq(An)21 b(asso)s(ciation)i(among)f(a)g
(set)g(of)g(participan)m(ts)g(comm)m(unicating)h(with)e(R)-8
b(TP.)37 b(A)22 b(participan)m(t)227 3331 y(ma)m(y)36
b(b)s(e)e(in)m(v)m(olv)m(ed)j(in)d(m)m(ultiple)i(R)-8
b(TP)34 b(sessions)h(at)h(the)f(same)g(time.)55 b(In)34
b(a)i(m)m(ultimedia)f(session,)i(eac)m(h)227 3444 y(medium)i(is)h(t)m
(ypically)i(carried)e(in)g(a)g(separate)h(R)-8 b(TP)40
b(session)g(with)g(its)g(o)m(wn)g(R)-8 b(TCP)40 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(unless)227 3557 y(the)35 b(the)g(enco)s(ding)g(itself)g(m)m
(ultiplexes)h(m)m(ultiple)f(media)g(in)m(to)h(a)f(single)g(data)g
(stream.)54 b(A)35 b(participan)m(t)227 3670 y(distinguishes)c(m)m
(ultiple)i(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(sessions)h(b)m(y)g(reception)g(of)g
(di\013eren)m(t)g(sessions)g(using)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(pairs)g(of)227
3782 y(destination)j(transp)s(ort)f(addresses,)h(where)e(a)i(pair)f(of)
g(transp)s(ort)g(addresses)f(comprises)i(one)f(net)m(w)m(ork)227
3895 y(address)j(plus)g(a)h(pair)g(of)g(p)s(orts)f(for)h(R)-8
b(TP)37 b(and)h(R)-8 b(TCP.)62 b(All)39 b(participan)m(ts)f(in)g(an)g
(R)-8 b(TP)37 b(session)h(ma)m(y)227 4008 y(share)24
b(a)h(common)g(destination)g(transp)s(ort)f(address)f(pair,)j(as)f(in)f
(the)h(case)g(of)g(IP)f(m)m(ulticast,)j(or)e(the)f(pairs)227
4121 y(ma)m(y)33 b(b)s(e)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(for)f(eac)m(h)i(participan)
m(t,)g(as)f(in)f(the)h(case)g(of)g(individual)f(unicast)g(net)m(w)m
(ork)i(addresses)227 4234 y(and)e(p)s(ort)g(pairs.)48
b(In)32 b(the)h(unicast)g(case,)h(a)f(participan)m(t)h(ma)m(y)f(receiv)
m(e)i(from)d(all)i(other)f(participan)m(ts)g(in)227 4347
y(the)e(session)f(using)g(the)h(same)g(pair)f(of)g(p)s(orts,)g(or)g(ma)
m(y)h(use)f(a)h(distinct)g(pair)f(of)h(p)s(orts)e(for)h(eac)m(h.)227
4497 y(The)h(distinguishing)f(feature)h(of)g(an)g(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(session)h(is)g(that)g(eac)m(h)h(main)m(tains)g(a)f(full,)g
(separate)g(space)h(of)227 4610 y(SSR)m(C)c(iden)m(ti\014ers)g
(\(de\014ned)g(next\).)41 b(The)28 b(set)h(of)f(participan)m(ts)i
(included)e(in)g(one)h(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(session)g(consists)227
4723 y(of)f(those)h(that)f(can)h(receiv)m(e)h(an)d(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(transmitted)f(b)m(y)g(an)m(y)g(one)g(of)g(the)h(participan)
m(ts)f(either)227 4836 y(in)33 b(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(as)g(the)h(SSR)m(C)e
(or)h(a)g(CSR)m(C)g(\(also)h(de\014ned)e(b)s(elo)m(w\))i(or)f(in)f(R)-8
b(TCP.)49 b(F)-8 b(or)34 b(example,)h(consider)e(a)227
4949 y(three-part)m(y)e(conference)f(implemen)m(ted)g(using)f(unicast)h
(UDP)f(with)h(eac)m(h)g(participan)m(t)h(receiving)f(from)227
5062 y(the)35 b(other)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(on)e(separate)h(p)s(ort)f(pairs.)53
b(If)34 b(eac)m(h)i(participan)m(t)f(sends)f(R)-8 b(TCP)34
b(feedbac)m(k)h(ab)s(out)f(data)227 5175 y(receiv)m(ed)44
b(from)e(one)g(other)h(participan)m(t)g(only)g(bac)m(k)g(to)g(that)g
(participan)m(t,)j(then)c(the)h(conference)g(is)227 5288
y(comp)s(osed)31 b(of)h(three)f(separate)h(p)s(oin)m(t-to-p)s(oin)m(t)h
(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(sessions.)44 b(If)30 b(eac)m(h)j(participan)m(t)f(pro)m
(vides)f(R)-8 b(TCP)227 5401 y(feedbac)m(k)33 b(ab)s(out)e(its)h
(reception)g(of)g(one)g(other)f(participan)m(t)i(to)f(b)s(oth)f(of)h
(the)f(other)h(participan)m(ts,)h(then)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518 b([P)m(age)32 b(8])p eop
%%Page: 9 9
9 8 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(the)38 b(conference)h(is)e(comp)s(osed)h(of)g(one)g(m)m(ulti-part)m
(y)h(R)-8 b(TP)37 b(session.)63 b(The)37 b(latter)i(case)g(sim)m
(ulates)g(the)227 511 y(b)s(eha)m(vior)31 b(that)g(w)m(ould)f(o)s(ccur)
g(with)g(IP)g(m)m(ulticast)i(comm)m(unication)g(among)f(the)f(three)h
(participan)m(ts.)227 662 y(The)i(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(framew)m(ork)g(allo)m
(ws)h(the)f(v)-5 b(ariations)35 b(de\014ned)c(here,)j(but)f(a)g
(particular)g(con)m(trol)i(proto)s(col)f(or)227 775 y(application)e
(design)e(will)h(usually)f(imp)s(ose)g(constrain)m(ts)i(on)e(these)h(v)
-5 b(ariations.)0 962 y Fl(Sync)m(hronization)37 b(source)e(\(SSR)m
(C\):)45 b Fq(The)25 b(source)h(of)f(a)g(stream)h(of)f(R)-8
b(TP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(ets,)k(iden)m(ti\014ed)c(b)m(y)g(a)h(32-bit)227
1075 y(n)m(umeric)21 b(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)g(carried)h(in)g(the)g
(R)-8 b(TP)20 b(header)h(so)g(as)g(not)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(dep)s(enden)m(t)g
(up)s(on)f(the)i(net)m(w)m(ork)227 1188 y(address.)38
b(All)24 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)d(a)h(sync)m(hronization)g(source)g
(form)f(part)h(of)g(the)f(same)h(timing)h(and)e(sequence)227
1301 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(space,)j(so)f(a)g(receiv)m(er)h(groups)d(pac)m
(k)m(ets)j(b)m(y)f(sync)m(hronization)g(source)f(for)g(pla)m(ybac)m(k.)
41 b(Examples)227 1414 y(of)e(sync)m(hronization)g(sources)f(include)g
(the)g(sender)g(of)g(a)h(stream)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(deriv)m(ed)e
(from)g(a)g(signal)227 1527 y(source)33 b(suc)m(h)g(as)g(a)h
(microphone)e(or)h(a)h(camera,)h(or)d(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)33
b(mixer)g(\(see)h(b)s(elo)m(w\).)49 b(A)33 b(sync)m(hronization)227
1640 y(source)i(ma)m(y)g(c)m(hange)g(its)g(data)g(format,)h(e.g.,)h
(audio)e(enco)s(ding,)h(o)m(v)m(er)f(time.)54 b(The)34
b(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)i(is)227 1753 y(a)h(randomly)f(c)m(hosen)h
(v)-5 b(alue)36 b(mean)m(t)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(globally)i(unique)e(within)g
(a)g(particular)h(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(session)h(\(see)227
1866 y(Section)k(8\).)66 b(A)39 b(participan)m(t)g(need)g(not)f(use)h
(the)g(same)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(for)f(all)i(the)f(R)-8
b(TP)38 b(sessions)227 1978 y(in)32 b(a)g(m)m(ultimedia)h(session;)g
(the)f(binding)e(of)i(the)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014ers)h(is)g(pro)m
(vided)g(through)f(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(\(see)227 2091 y(Section)36
b(6.5.1\).)55 b(If)34 b(a)h(participan)m(t)g(generates)h(m)m(ultiple)f
(streams)g(in)f(one)h(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(session,)i(for)e(example)227
2204 y(from)c(separate)i(video)e(cameras,)i(eac)m(h)f
Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)f(iden)m(ti\014ed)i(as)g(a)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(SSR)m
(C.)0 2392 y Fl(Con)m(tributing)k(source)h(\(CSR)m(C\):)44
b Fq(A)38 b(source)g(of)h(a)f(stream)g(of)h(R)-8 b(TP)38
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(that)g(has)f(con)m(tributed)g(to)227
2505 y(the)30 b(com)m(bined)g(stream)g(pro)s(duced)e(b)m(y)i(an)f(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(mixer)f(\(see)i(b)s(elo)m(w\).)41 b(The)29
b(mixer)h(inserts)f(a)i(list)f(of)g(the)227 2618 y(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014ers)i(of)f(the)h(sources)f(that)h(con)m(tributed)f(to)h(the)g
(generation)g(of)g(a)f(particular)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(in)m(to)227
2731 y(the)37 b(R)-8 b(TP)36 b(header)g(of)g(that)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)60
b(This)36 b(list)g(is)h(called)g(the)g(CSR)m(C)e(list.)59
b(An)36 b(example)h(application)227 2844 y(is)d(audio)f(conferencing)h
(where)f(a)h(mixer)f(indicates)i(all)f(the)f(talk)m(ers)i(whose)e(sp)s
(eec)m(h)h(w)m(as)g(com)m(bined)f(to)227 2956 y(pro)s(duce)25
b(the)h(outgoing)h(pac)m(k)m(et,)i(allo)m(wing)f(the)e(receiv)m(er)i
(to)e(indicate)h(the)f(curren)m(t)g(talk)m(er,)j(ev)m(en)d(though)227
3069 y(all)32 b(the)e(audio)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(con)m(tain)f(the)g(same)g
(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(\(that)g(of)g(the)f(mixer\).)0
3257 y Fl(End)35 b(system:)46 b Fq(An)34 b(application)i(that)g
(generates)g(the)f(con)m(ten)m(t)i(to)e(b)s(e)f(sen)m(t)i(in)e(R)-8
b(TP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(and/or)d(con-)227 3370 y(sumes)c(the)h(con)m
(ten)m(t)i(of)e(receiv)m(ed)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)44
b(An)30 b(end)g(system)h(can)g(act)h(as)f(one)g(or)g(more)g(sync)m
(hro-)227 3483 y(nization)h(sources)e(in)g(a)h(particular)g(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(session,)h(but)e(t)m(ypically)j(only)f(one.)0
3670 y Fl(Mixer:)46 b Fq(An)40 b(in)m(termediate)i(system)f(that)g
(receiv)m(es)h(R)-8 b(TP)40 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(from)d(one)g(or)h(more)g
(sources,)i(p)s(ossibly)227 3783 y(c)m(hanges)26 b(the)f(data)g
(format,)i(com)m(bines)e(the)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)d(some)h(manner)f
(and)g(then)h(forw)m(ards)f(a)h(new)f(R)-8 b(TP)227 3896
y(pac)m(k)m(et.)61 b(Since)37 b(the)f(timing)h(among)g(m)m(ultiple)g
(input)f(sources)g(will)h(not)f(generally)i(b)s(e)e(sync)m(hronized,)
227 4009 y(the)c(mixer)f(will)h(mak)m(e)h(timing)f(adjustmen)m(ts)f
(among)h(the)f(streams)h(and)f(generate)i(its)f(o)m(wn)f(timing)h(for)
227 4122 y(the)k(com)m(bined)g(stream.)57 b(Th)m(us,)36
b(all)h(data)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(originating)f(from)e(a)h(mixer)g(will)g
(b)s(e)f(iden)m(ti\014ed)h(as)227 4235 y(ha)m(ving)31
b(the)g(mixer)f(as)h(their)f(sync)m(hronization)h(source.)0
4423 y Fl(T)-9 b(ranslator:)46 b Fq(An)24 b(in)m(termediate)i(system)f
(that)h(forw)m(ards)e(R)-8 b(TP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(with)d(their)h
(sync)m(hronization)h(source)227 4535 y(iden)m(ti\014er)44
b(in)m(tact.)81 b(Examples)43 b(of)h(translators)g(include)f(devices)h
(that)g(con)m(v)m(ert)h(enco)s(dings)e(without)227 4648
y(mixing,)31 b(replicators)g(from)f(m)m(ulticast)i(to)f(unicast,)g(and)
f(application-lev)m(el)k(\014lters)c(in)g(\014rew)m(alls.)0
4836 y Fl(Monitor:)46 b Fq(An)32 b(application)i(that)f(receiv)m(es)h
(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(sen)m(t)f(b)m(y)g(participan)m(ts)g
(in)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(session,)h(in)227 4949 y(particular)e(the)h
(reception)f(rep)s(orts,)g(and)f(estimates)i(the)g(curren)m(t)e(qualit)
m(y)i(of)f(service)h(for)f(distribution)227 5062 y(monitoring,)c(fault)
e(diagnosis)g(and)f(long-term)i(statistics.)41 b(The)24
b(monitor)h(function)g(is)f(lik)m(ely)j(to)e(b)s(e)f(built)227
5175 y(in)m(to)38 b(the)f(application\(s\))h(participating)g(in)f(the)f
(session,)j(but)d(ma)m(y)h(also)h(b)s(e)e(a)h(separate)h(application)
227 5288 y(that)28 b(do)s(es)f(not)h(otherwise)f(participate)i(and)e
(do)s(es)g(not)g(send)g(or)g(receiv)m(e)i(the)f(R)-8
b(TP)27 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(\(since)227 5401 y(they)e(are)g(on)g
(a)g(separate)h(p)s(ort\).)39 b(These)27 b(are)g(called)h
Fk(thir)-5 b(d-p)g(arty)30 b Fq(monitors.)40 b(It)27
b(is)f(also)i(acceptable)h(for)e(a)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)
-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)519 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)518
b([P)m(age)32 b(9])p eop
%%Page: 10 10
10 9 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(third-part)m(y)25 b(monitor)g(to)h(receiv)m(e)g(the)f(R)-8
b(TP)25 b(data)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(but)d(not)h(send)f(R)-8
b(TCP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(or)e(otherwise)227 511 y(b)s(e)30
b(coun)m(ted)h(in)f(the)h(session.)0 699 y Fl(Non-R)-9
b(TP)36 b(means:)45 b Fq(Proto)s(cols)29 b(and)e(mec)m(hanisms)g(that)h
(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(needed)h(in)g(addition)h(to)g(R)-8
b(TP)27 b(to)h(pro)m(vide)227 812 y(a)i(usable)f(service.)42
b(In)28 b(particular,)i(for)g(m)m(ultimedia)g(conferences,)g(a)g(con)m
(trol)h(proto)s(col)f(ma)m(y)g(distribute)227 925 y(m)m(ulticast)k
(addresses)e(and)g(k)m(eys)i(for)e(encryption,)h(negotiate)i(the)e
(encryption)g(algorithm)g(to)h(b)s(e)d(used,)227 1038
y(and)39 b(de\014ne)f(dynamic)h(mappings)f(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)h(R)-8
b(TP)39 b(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)f(v)-5 b(alues)39 b(and)g(the)g(pa)m
(yload)h(formats)227 1151 y(they)k(represen)m(t)g(for)f(formats)h(that)
g(do)g(not)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h(a)f(prede\014ned)d(pa)m(yload)k(t)m(yp)s(e)f
(v)-5 b(alue.)81 b(Examples)227 1264 y(of)36 b(suc)m(h)g(proto)s(cols)g
(include)g(the)g(Session)f(Initiation)i(Proto)s(col)g(\(SIP\))f(\(RF)m
(C)g(3261)i([13)q(]\),)g(H.323)g([14)q(])227 1377 y(and)g(applications)
i(using)e(SDP)g(\(RF)m(C)h(2327)h([15)q(]\),)h(suc)m(h)e(as)f(R)-8
b(TSP)38 b(\(RF)m(C)h(2326)h([16)q(]\).)66 b(F)-8 b(or)39
b(simple)227 1489 y(applications,)32 b(electronic)g(mail)f(or)f(a)h
(conference)g(database)g(ma)m(y)g(also)g(b)s(e)e(used.)40
b(The)30 b(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(of)227 1602 y(suc)m(h)f(proto)s(cols)h
(and)f(mec)m(hanisms)h(is)f(outside)h(the)f(scop)s(e)h(of)f(this)h(do)s
(cumen)m(t.)0 1889 y Fp(4)135 b(Byte)45 b(Order,)g(Alignmen)l(t,)h(and)
f(Time)g(F)-11 b(ormat)0 2092 y Fq(All)29 b(in)m(teger)h(\014elds)e
(are)h(carried)g(in)f(net)m(w)m(ork)i(b)m(yte)f(order,)g(that)g(is,)g
(most)g(signi\014can)m(t)g(b)m(yte)h(\(o)s(ctet\))g(\014rst.)40
b(This)0 2205 y(b)m(yte)34 b(order)e(is)i(commonly)f(kno)m(wn)g(as)g
(big-endian.)49 b(The)33 b(transmission)f(order)h(is)g(describ)s(ed)f
(in)h(detail)h(in)f([3)q(,)0 2318 y(App)s(endix)c(A].)i(Unless)f
(otherwise)h(noted,)g(n)m(umeric)f(constan)m(ts)h(are)g(in)f(decimal)h
(\(base)g(10\).)141 2430 y(All)38 b(header)f(data)g(is)g(aligned)h(to)g
(its)f(natural)g(length,)i(i.e.,)h(16-bit)f(\014elds)d(are)h(aligned)h
(on)f(ev)m(en)h(o\013sets,)0 2543 y(32-bit)i(\014elds)d(are)i(aligned)g
(at)h(o\013sets)f(divisible)f(b)m(y)h(four,)h(etc.)66
b(Octets)39 b(designated)g(as)g(padding)e(ha)m(v)m(e)j(the)0
2656 y(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(zero.)141 2769 y(W)-8 b(allclo)s(c)m(k)44
b(time)e(\(absolute)g(date)g(and)81 b(time\))43 b(is)e(represen)m(ted)g
(using)f(the)h(timestamp)h(format)g(of)f(the)0 2882 y(Net)m(w)m(ork)29
b(Time)e(Proto)s(col)i(\(NTP\),)e(whic)m(h)g(is)h(in)f(seconds)g
(relativ)m(e)i(to)f(0h)f(UTC)g(on)g(1)h(Jan)m(uary)f(1900)i([4)q(].)39
b(The)0 2995 y(full)f(resolution)h(NTP)f(timestamp)h(is)f(a)h(64-bit)g
(unsigned)e(\014xed-p)s(oin)m(t)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(with)h(the)g(in)m
(teger)i(part)e(in)0 3108 y(the)c(\014rst)g(32)g(bits)g(and)g(the)g
(fractional)i(part)e(in)f(the)i(last)g(32)f(bits.)52
b(In)33 b(some)i(\014elds)e(where)h(a)g(more)h(compact)0
3221 y(represen)m(tation)42 b(is)g(appropriate,)i(only)e(the)g(middle)f
(32)h(bits)f(are)h(used;)k(that)c(is,)j(the)c(lo)m(w)i(16)f(bits)f(of)h
(the)0 3334 y(in)m(teger)33 b(part)f(and)f(the)h(high)f(16)i(bits)e(of)
h(the)g(fractional)h(part.)45 b(The)31 b(high)g(16)i(bits)f(of)f(the)h
(in)m(teger)h(part)f(m)m(ust)0 3447 y(b)s(e)e(determined)g(indep)s
(enden)m(tly)-8 b(.)141 3560 y(An)38 b(implemen)m(tation)j(is)d(not)h
(required)f(to)h(run)e(the)i(Net)m(w)m(ork)h(Time)f(Proto)s(col)h(in)e
(order)g(to)i(use)e(R)-8 b(TP.)0 3672 y(Other)27 b(time)i(sources,)g
(or)f(none)g(at)g(all,)i(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)e(used)g(\(see)i(the)f
(description)g(of)g(the)g(NTP)g(timestamp)h(\014eld)e(in)0
3785 y(Section)33 b(6.4.1\).)50 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)35
b(running)c(NTP)h(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(useful)g(for)g(sync)m(hronizing)h
(streams)g(transmitted)f(from)0 3898 y(separate)f(hosts.)141
4011 y(The)22 b(NTP)f(timestamp)i(will)f(wrap)f(around)g(to)h(zero)h
(some)f(time)h(in)f(the)g(y)m(ear)g(2036,)k(but)21 b(for)h(R)-8
b(TP)22 b(purp)s(oses,)0 4124 y(only)36 b(di\013erences)h(b)s(et)m(w)m
(een)g(pairs)f(of)g(NTP)g(timestamps)h(are)g(used.)57
b(So)36 b(long)h(as)g(the)f(pairs)g(of)g(timestamps)0
4237 y(can)30 b(b)s(e)g(assumed)f(to)i(b)s(e)f(within)f(68)i(y)m(ears)g
(of)g(eac)m(h)g(other,)g(using)e(mo)s(dulo)h(arithmetic)h(for)f
(subtractions)h(and)0 4350 y(comparisons)f(mak)m(es)i(the)e(wraparound)
f(irrelev)-5 b(an)m(t.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)d(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(10])p eop
%%Page: 11 11
11 10 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fp(5)135 b(R)-11 b(TP)44 b(Data)i(T)-11 b(ransfer)45
b(Proto)t(col)0 605 y Fo(5.1)112 b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Fixed)j(Header)f
(Fields)0 776 y Fq(The)30 b(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(header)g(has)g(the)h(follo)m
(wing)h(format:)382 952 y Fh(0)906 b(1)h(2)f(3)382 1065
y(0)47 b(1)h(2)f(3)h(4)f(5)h(6)f(7)g(8)h(9)f(0)h(1)f(2)h(3)f(4)h(5)f(6)
h(7)f(8)g(9)h(0)f(1)h(2)f(3)h(4)f(5)h(6)f(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)h(1)334
1178 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)o
(-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)334 1291 y(|V=2|P|X|)93
b(CC)143 b(|M|)238 b(PT)285 b(|)334 b(sequence)46 b(number)428
b(|)334 1404 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o
(-+-+)o(-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)334 1517
y(|)1288 b(timestamp)f(|)334 1629 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o
(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)o(-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)334
1742 y(|)525 b(synchronization)43 b(source)k(\(SSRC\))f(identifier)570
b(|)334 1855 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+)o(=+=)o(+=+=)o(+=+=)o(+=+)o
(=+=+)o(=+=+)o(=+=)o(+=+=)o(+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+=+)334 1968
y(|)j(contributing)44 b(source)i(\(CSRC\))g(identifiers)618
b(|)334 2081 y(|)1384 b(....)1431 b(|)334 2194 y
(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)o(-+-+)o
(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)141 2398 y Fq(The)36
b(\014rst)f(t)m(w)m(elv)m(e)k(o)s(ctets)e(are)g(presen)m(t)f(in)g(ev)m
(ery)h(R)-8 b(TP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et,)k(while)c(the)g(list)h(of)f(CSR)m
(C)g(iden)m(ti\014ers)g(is)0 2511 y(presen)m(t)30 b(only)h(when)e
(inserted)h(b)m(y)h(a)f(mixer.)41 b(The)30 b(\014elds)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h
(the)g(follo)m(wing)h(meaning:)0 2686 y Fl(v)m(ersion)k(\(V\):)45
b Fq(2)30 b(bits)227 2799 y(This)i(\014eld)f(iden)m(ti\014es)i(the)f(v)
m(ersion)h(of)f(R)-8 b(TP.)46 b(The)31 b(v)m(ersion)i(de\014ned)e(b)m
(y)h(this)g(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(is)f(t)m(w)m(o)i(\(2\).)227
2912 y(\(The)29 b(v)-5 b(alue)29 b(1)g(is)f(used)g(b)m(y)h(the)f
(\014rst)g(draft)g(v)m(ersion)h(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(and)f(the)g(v)-5
b(alue)29 b(0)g(is)g(used)f(b)m(y)g(the)h(proto)s(col)227
3025 y(initially)j(implemen)m(ted)f(in)f(the)h(\\v)-5
b(at")32 b(audio)e(to)s(ol.\))0 3208 y Fl(padding)35
b(\(P\):)46 b Fq(1)30 b(bit)227 3321 y(If)36 b(the)g(padding)f(bit)h
(is)g(set,)j(the)d(pac)m(k)m(et)i(con)m(tains)f(one)f(or)g(more)h
(additional)g(padding)e(o)s(ctets)i(at)g(the)227 3434
y(end)h(whic)m(h)f(are)i(not)f(part)f(of)i(the)f(pa)m(yload.)64
b(The)37 b(last)i(o)s(ctet)h(of)e(the)g(padding)f(con)m(tains)i(a)f
(coun)m(t)h(of)227 3547 y(ho)m(w)d(man)m(y)f(padding)g(o)s(ctets)i
(should)d(b)s(e)h(ignored,)i(including)f(itself.)112
b(P)m(adding)36 b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(needed)g(b)m(y)227
3660 y(some)h(encryption)g(algorithms)g(with)f(\014xed)g(blo)s(c)m(k)h
(sizes)g(or)g(for)f(carrying)h(sev)m(eral)h(R)-8 b(TP)35
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)f(a)227 3773 y(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)e(proto)s
(col)d(data)g(unit.)0 3955 y Fl(extension)k(\(X\):)45
b Fq(1)31 b(bit)227 4068 y(If)26 b(the)g(extension)h(bit)f(is)h(set,)g
(the)g(\014xed)e(header)h Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)h(follo)m(w)m(ed)i(b)m(y)e
(exactly)i(one)e(header)g(extension,)227 4181 y(with)k(a)h(format)g
(de\014ned)e(in)h(Section)h(5.3.1.)0 4364 y Fl(CSR)m(C)j(coun)m(t)i
(\(CC\):)44 b Fq(4)31 b(bits)227 4477 y(The)f(CSR)m(C)g(coun)m(t)h(con)
m(tains)g(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(CSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014ers)g
(that)h(follo)m(w)h(the)e(\014xed)g(header.)0 4660 y
Fl(mark)m(er)35 b(\(M\):)45 b Fq(1)31 b(bit)227 4773
y(The)37 b(in)m(terpretation)h(of)f(the)g(mark)m(er)g(is)g(de\014ned)e
(b)m(y)i(a)g(pro\014le.)60 b(It)37 b(is)g(in)m(tended)f(to)i(allo)m(w)g
(signi\014can)m(t)227 4886 y(ev)m(en)m(ts)g(suc)m(h)f(as)g(frame)f(b)s
(oundaries)f(to)j(b)s(e)e(mark)m(ed)h(in)f(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i
(stream.)60 b(A)37 b(pro\014le)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)38 b Fq(de\014ne)227
4999 y(additional)32 b(mark)m(er)e(bits)h(or)f(sp)s(ecify)h(that)g
(there)f(is)h(no)f(mark)m(er)h(bit)g(b)m(y)f(c)m(hanging)h(the)g(n)m
(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(bits)227 5111 y(in)f(the)h(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)
g(\014eld)f(\(see)h(Section)g(5.3\).)0 5294 y Fl(pa)m(yload)k(t)m(yp)s
(e)g(\(PT\):)45 b Fq(7)31 b(bits)227 5407 y(This)h(\014eld)f(iden)m
(ti\014es)i(the)f(format)g(of)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(pa)m(yload)i(and)f
(determines)g(its)g(in)m(terpretation)i(b)m(y)e(the)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(11])p eop
%%Page: 12 12
12 11 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(application.)41 b(A)26 b(pro\014le)g Fi(ma)-6 b(y)27
b Fq(sp)s(ecify)52 b(a)27 b(default)f(static)i(mapping)e(of)g(pa)m
(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)g(co)s(des)f(to)h(pa)m(yload)227
511 y(formats.)39 b(Additional)24 b(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(co)s(des)
f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)25 b Fq(b)s(e)d(de\014ned)g(dynamically)i(through)f
(non-R)-8 b(TP)23 b(means)227 624 y(\(see)32 b(Section)g(3\).)44
b(A)31 b(set)h(of)f(default)g(mappings)g(for)g(audio)g(and)f(video)i
(is)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)g(in)f(the)i(companion)227 737 y(RF)m(C)27
b(XXXX)g([1)q(].)39 b(An)26 b(R)-8 b(TP)26 b(source)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)27 b Fq(c)m(hange)h(the)e(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)e
(during)f(a)i(session,)g(but)f(this)g(\014eld)227 850
y Fi(should)33 b(not)d Fq(b)s(e)f(used)60 b(for)30 b(m)m(ultiplexing)i
(separate)f(media)g(streams)f(\(see)h(Section)h(5.2\).)227
1000 y(A)f(receiv)m(er)h Fi(must)d Fq(ignore)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(with)e
(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(es)e(that)h(it)g(do)s(es)f(not)g(understand.)0
1188 y Fl(sequence)36 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er:)46 b Fq(16)31
b(bits)227 1301 y(The)36 b(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(incremen)m(ts)h
(b)m(y)g(one)g(for)f(eac)m(h)j(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(et)h
(sen)m(t,)g(and)d(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)g(used)227 1414 y(b)m(y)31
b(the)h(receiv)m(er)h(to)f(detect)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(loss)f(and)f(to)h
(restore)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(sequence.)43 b(The)31 b(initial)i(v)-5
b(alue)31 b(of)h(the)227 1527 y(sequence)40 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e
Fi(should)g Fq(b)s(e)h(random)g(\(unpredictable\))h(to)g(mak)m(e)g(kno)
m(wn-plain)m(text)h(attac)m(ks)h(on)227 1640 y(encryption)31
b(more)h(di\016cult,)g(ev)m(en)g(if)f(the)g(source)h(itself)g(do)s(es)f
(not)h(encrypt)f(according)h(to)g(the)f(metho)s(d)227
1753 y(in)f(Section)g(9.1,)62 b(b)s(ecause)29 b(the)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(ma)m(y)f(\015o)m(w)e(through)h(a)g(translator)g(that)h(do)s(es.)40
b(T)-8 b(ec)m(hniques)30 b(for)227 1866 y(c)m(ho)s(osing)h
(unpredictable)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f(are)i(discussed)f(in)g([17)q(].)0
2053 y Fl(timestamp:)45 b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 2166 y(The)h(timestamp)i
(re\015ects)f(the)g(sampling)f(instan)m(t)h(of)g(the)g(\014rst)f(o)s
(ctet)i(in)e(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(data)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)49
b(The)227 2279 y(sampling)35 b(instan)m(t)h Fi(must)e
Fq(b)s(e)g(deriv)m(ed)h(from)f(a)i(clo)s(c)m(k)g(that)g(incremen)m(ts)f
(monotonically)i(and)d(linearly)227 2392 y(in)j(time)h(to)g(allo)m(w)g
(sync)m(hronization)g(and)f(jitter)h(calculations)h(\(see)f(Section)g
(6.4.1\).)63 b(The)36 b(resolution)227 2505 y(of)g(the)h(clo)s(c)m(k)g
Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)h(su\016cien)m(t)g(for)g(the)g(desired)g(sync)m
(hronization)h(accuracy)g(and)e(for)h(measuring)227 2618
y(pac)m(k)m(et)30 b(arriv)-5 b(al)28 b(jitter)g(\(one)g(tic)m(k)h(p)s
(er)e(video)h(frame)g(is)f(t)m(ypically)j(not)e(su\016cien)m(t\).)40
b(The)27 b(clo)s(c)m(k)i(frequency)227 2731 y(is)f(dep)s(enden)m(t)f
(on)h(the)g(format)h(of)f(data)h(carried)f(as)g(pa)m(yload)h(and)e(is)i
(sp)s(eci\014ed)e(statically)j(in)e(the)g(pro\014le)227
2844 y(or)j(pa)m(yload)i(format)e(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(that)g
(de\014nes)e(the)h(format,)h(or)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)32 b Fq(b)s(e)f(sp)s
(eci\014ed)f(dynamically)i(for)227 2956 y(pa)m(yload)c(formats)f
(de\014ned)f(through)g(non-R)-8 b(TP)26 b(means.)39 b(If)27
b(R)-8 b(TP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(are)e(generated)h(p)s(erio)s(dically)
-8 b(,)227 3069 y(the)40 b(nominal)g(sampling)f(instan)m(t)h(as)g
(determined)f(from)g(the)h(sampling)f(clo)s(c)m(k)i(is)f(to)g(b)s(e)f
(used,)i(not)f(a)227 3182 y(reading)32 b(of)f(the)h(system)f(clo)s(c)m
(k.)45 b(As)32 b(an)f(example,)h(for)g(\014xed-rate)f(audio)h(the)f
(timestamp)h(clo)s(c)m(k)h(w)m(ould)227 3295 y(lik)m(ely)24
b(incremen)m(t)g(b)m(y)e(one)h(for)g(eac)m(h)h(sampling)e(p)s(erio)s
(d.)37 b(If)22 b(an)h(audio)g(application)h(reads)e(blo)s(c)m(ks)h(co)m
(v)m(ering)227 3408 y(160)39 b(sampling)e(p)s(erio)s(ds)f(from)g(the)i
(input)e(device,)k(the)d(timestamp)h(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)f(increased)i(b)m
(y)f(160)h(for)227 3521 y(eac)m(h)i(suc)m(h)e(blo)s(c)m(k,)k
(regardless)d(of)f(whether)g(the)h(blo)s(c)m(k)g(is)g(transmitted)g(in)
f(a)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(or)d(dropp)s(ed)f(as)227 3634 y(silen)m(t.)227
3784 y(The)29 b(initial)i(v)-5 b(alue)30 b(of)g(the)f(timestamp)h
Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)58 b(random,)29 b(as)h(for)f(the)h(sequence)g(n)m
(um)m(b)s(er.)39 b(Sev)m(eral)227 3897 y(consecutiv)m(e)27
b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(will)50 b(ha)m(v)m(e)26
b(equal)g(timestamps)f(if)g(they)g(are)g(\(logically\))k(generated)c
(at)h(once,)227 4010 y(e.g.,)i(b)s(elong)e(to)g(the)g(same)g(video)g
(frame.)39 b(Consecutiv)m(e)27 b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)26 b Fq(con)m(tain)h(timestamps)f(that)227
4123 y(are)33 b(not)g(monotonic)g(if)g(the)f(data)h(is)g(not)f
(transmitted)h(in)f(the)h(order)f(it)h(w)m(as)g(sampled,)f(as)h(in)f
(the)h(case)227 4236 y(of)i(MPEG)g(in)m(terp)s(olated)h(video)f
(frames.)53 b(\(The)34 b(sequence)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)d(of)h(the)h(pac)m
(k)m(ets)i(as)e(transmitted)227 4349 y(will)c(still)g(b)s(e)f
(monotonic.\))227 4499 y(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(timestamps)g(from)f(di\013eren)
m(t)h(media)g(streams)g(ma)m(y)h(adv)-5 b(ance)39 b(at)h(di\013eren)m
(t)f(rates)g(and)f(usually)227 4612 y(ha)m(v)m(e)k(indep)s(enden)m(t,)g
(random)e(o\013sets.)73 b(Therefore,)43 b(although)e(these)g
(timestamps)g(are)g(su\016cien)m(t)g(to)227 4725 y(reconstruct)29
b(the)f(timing)h(of)f(a)h(single)g(stream,)g(directly)g(comparing)f(R)
-8 b(TP)28 b(timestamps)h(from)e(di\013eren)m(t)227 4838
y(media)41 b(is)f(not)h(e\013ectiv)m(e)i(for)d(sync)m(hronization.)72
b(Instead,)43 b(for)d(eac)m(h)h(medium)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)40
b(timestamp)227 4951 y(is)j(related)h(to)g(the)f(sampling)g(instan)m(t)
h(b)m(y)f(pairing)g(it)g(with)g(a)g(timestamp)h(from)f(a)g(reference)h
(clo)s(c)m(k)227 5064 y(\(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k\))31 b(that)d(represen)m
(ts)f(the)g(time)h(when)e(the)i(data)g(corresp)s(onding)e(to)i(the)g(R)
-8 b(TP)27 b(timestamp)h(w)m(as)227 5176 y(sampled.)70
b(The)40 b(reference)g(clo)s(c)m(k)i(is)e(shared)g(b)m(y)g(all)h(media)
f(to)h(b)s(e)f(sync)m(hronized.)70 b(The)39 b(timestamp)227
5289 y(pairs)34 b(are)g(not)g(transmitted)g(in)g(ev)m(ery)g(data)h(pac)
m(k)m(et,)i(but)c(at)h(a)g(lo)m(w)m(er)i(rate)e(in)g(R)-8
b(TCP)33 b(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(as)227 5402 y(describ)s(ed)30
b(in)g(Section)h(6.4.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(12])p eop
%%Page: 13 13
13 12 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(The)d(sampling)h(instan)m(t)g(is)g(c)m(hosen)g(as)g(the)f(p)s(oin)m
(t)h(of)g(reference)g(for)f(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(timestamp)h(b)s
(ecause)g(it)g(is)227 511 y(kno)m(wn)g(to)h(the)g(transmitting)g(endp)s
(oin)m(t)e(and)h(has)g(a)h(common)g(de\014nition)f(for)g(all)h(media,)g
(indep)s(enden)m(t)227 624 y(of)g(enco)s(ding)g(dela)m(ys)h(or)f(other)
g(pro)s(cessing.)40 b(The)29 b(purp)s(ose)f(is)i(to)h(allo)m(w)g(sync)m
(hronized)f(presen)m(tation)h(of)227 737 y(all)h(media)e(sampled)g(at)h
(the)g(same)g(time.)227 883 y(Applications)j(transmitting)f(stored)f
(data)i(rather)e(than)g(data)h(sampled)g(in)f(real)h(time)g(t)m
(ypically)h(use)f(a)227 996 y(virtual)g(presen)m(tation)g(timeline)g
(deriv)m(ed)g(from)e(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)k(time)e(to)g(determine)f(when)
f(the)i(next)f(frame)227 1108 y(or)g(other)g(unit)f(of)h(eac)m(h)h
(medium)e(in)g(the)h(stored)g(data)g(should)f(b)s(e)g(presen)m(ted.)44
b(In)31 b(this)h(case,)h(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)227 1221 y(timestamp)28
b(w)m(ould)f(re\015ect)g(the)g(presen)m(tation)h(time)g(for)f(eac)m(h)h
(unit.)39 b(That)27 b(is,)h(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(timestamp)g(for)227
1334 y(eac)m(h)36 b(unit)f(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(related)i(to)f(the)g(w)m
(allclo)s(c)m(k)j(time)d(at)h(whic)m(h)e(the)h(unit)f(b)s(ecomes)i
(curren)m(t)e(on)h(the)227 1447 y(virtual)g(presen)m(tation)g
(timeline.)53 b(Actual)36 b(presen)m(tation)f(o)s(ccurs)f(some)h(time)g
(later)g(as)f(determined)g(b)m(y)227 1560 y(the)d(receiv)m(er.)227
1705 y(An)36 b(example)g(describing)f(liv)m(e)i(audio)f(narration)g(of)
f(prerecorded)g(video)h(illustrates)h(the)f(signi\014cance)227
1818 y(of)j(c)m(ho)s(osing)g(the)g(sampling)g(instan)m(t)g(as)g(the)g
(reference)g(p)s(oin)m(t.)65 b(In)38 b(this)g(scenario,)k(the)d(video)g
(w)m(ould)227 1931 y(b)s(e)29 b(presen)m(ted)h(lo)s(cally)h(for)f(the)g
(narrator)g(to)g(view)g(and)f(w)m(ould)h(b)s(e)f(sim)m(ultaneously)h
(transmitted)g(using)227 2044 y(R)-8 b(TP)g(.)33 b(The)f(\\sampling)g
(instan)m(t")i(of)e(a)h(video)f(frame)h(transmitted)f(in)g(R)-8
b(TP)32 b(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)g(established)g(b)m(y)227
2157 y(referencing)g(its)h(timestamp)f(to)h(the)f(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)i
(time)f(when)e(that)h(video)g(frame)g(w)m(as)g(presen)m(ted)g(to)h(the)
227 2270 y(narrator.)50 b(The)33 b(sampling)g(instan)m(t)h(for)f(the)h
(audio)g(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(con)m(taining)g(the)e
(narrator's)h(sp)s(eec)m(h)227 2383 y(w)m(ould)j(b)s(e)f(established)h
(b)m(y)g(referencing)g(the)g(same)g(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)j(time)d(when)f
(the)h(audio)g(w)m(as)g(sampled.)227 2496 y(The)g(audio)f(and)h(video)g
(ma)m(y)g(ev)m(en)h(b)s(e)e(transmitted)h(b)m(y)g(di\013eren)m(t)g
(hosts)g(if)g(the)g(reference)g(clo)s(c)m(ks)h(on)227
2609 y(the)28 b(t)m(w)m(o)h(hosts)f(are)g(sync)m(hronized)f(b)m(y)h
(some)g(means)f(suc)m(h)h(as)g(NTP)-8 b(.)27 b(A)h(receiv)m(er)h(can)f
(then)g(sync)m(hronize)227 2722 y(presen)m(tation)44
b(of)g(the)f(audio)g(and)f(video)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(b)m(y)e(relating)h
(their)f(R)-8 b(TP)43 b(timestamps)g(using)g(the)227
2835 y(timestamp)31 b(pairs)f(in)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets.)
0 3012 y Fl(SSR)m(C:)46 b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 3125 y(The)43
b(SSR)m(C)e(\014eld)i(iden)m(ti\014es)g(the)g(sync)m(hronization)h
(source.)78 b(This)42 b(iden)m(ti\014er)h Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)85 b(c)m(hosen)227 3238 y(randomly)-8 b(,)31
b(with)g(the)g(in)m(ten)m(t)h(that)g(no)e(t)m(w)m(o)j(sync)m
(hronization)e(sources)g(within)g(the)g(same)g(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(session)227 3351 y(will)d(ha)m(v)m(e)h(the)f(same)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er.)40 b(An)27 b(example)h(algorithm)h(for)e(generating)i(a)f
(random)f(iden)m(ti\014er)227 3464 y(is)e(presen)m(ted)f(in)g(App)s
(endix)f(A.6.)39 b(Although)25 b(the)g(probabilit)m(y)g(of)f(m)m
(ultiple)h(sources)g(c)m(ho)s(osing)g(the)g(same)227
3577 y(iden)m(ti\014er)32 b(is)f(lo)m(w,)i(all)g(R)-8
b(TP)31 b(implemen)m(tations)i(m)m(ust)e(b)s(e)g(prepared)f(to)j
(detect)f(and)f(resolv)m(e)i(collisions.)227 3690 y(Section)27
b(8)g(describ)s(es)f(the)h(probabilit)m(y)f(of)h(collision)h(along)g
(with)e(a)g(mec)m(hanism)h(for)f(resolving)h(collisions)227
3803 y(and)j(detecting)h(R)-8 b(TP-lev)m(el)32 b(forw)m(arding)d(lo)s
(ops)h(based)g(on)g(the)g(uniqueness)f(of)h(the)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er.)40 b(If)227 3916 y(a)34 b(source)g(c)m(hanges)h(its)f
(source)g(transp)s(ort)f(address,)h(it)g(m)m(ust)g(also)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)
h(a)f(new)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(to)227 4029 y(a)m(v)m(oid)e(b)s
(eing)e(in)m(terpreted)h(as)f(a)h(lo)s(op)s(ed)f(source)h(\(see)g
(Section)g(8.2\).)0 4206 y Fl(CSR)m(C)j(list:)46 b Fq(0)31
b(to)g(15)g(items,)g(32)g(bits)g(eac)m(h)227 4319 y(The)36
b(CSR)m(C)g(list)h(iden)m(ti\014es)f(the)h(con)m(tributing)g(sources)f
(for)g(the)h(pa)m(yload)g(con)m(tained)g(in)f(this)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)227
4432 y(The)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(iden)m(ti\014ers)g(is)h(giv)m(en)g
(b)m(y)f(the)g(CC)g(\014eld.)57 b(If)36 b(there)h(are)f(more)g(than)g
(15)h(con)m(tributing)227 4545 y(sources,)31 b(only)g(15)h(can)f(b)s(e)
f(iden)m(ti\014ed.)42 b(CSR)m(C)30 b(iden)m(ti\014ers)g(are)h(inserted)
g(b)m(y)g(mixers)f(\(see)i(Section)f(7.1\),)227 4658
y(using)e(the)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014ers)i(of)f(con)m(tributing)h
(sources.)41 b(F)-8 b(or)30 b(example,)g(for)g(audio)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(the)f(SSR)m(C)227 4771 y(iden)m(ti\014ers)23 b(of)g(all)g(sources)g
(that)g(w)m(ere)g(mixed)g(together)h(to)f(create)i(a)e(pac)m(k)m(et)h
(are)f(listed,)i(allo)m(wing)g(correct)227 4884 y(talk)m(er)32
b(indication)f(at)g(the)g(receiv)m(er.)0 5123 y Fo(5.2)112
b(Multiplexing)39 b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Sessions)0 5294 y
Fq(F)-8 b(or)37 b(e\016cien)m(t)h(proto)s(col)g(pro)s(cessing,)g(the)e
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(m)m(ultiplexing)g(p)s(oin)m(ts)g(should)e(b)s
(e)h(minimized,)i(as)f(de-)0 5407 y(scrib)s(ed)d(in)g(the)i(in)m
(tegrated)g(la)m(y)m(er)h(pro)s(cessing)d(design)h(principle)g([10)q
(].)54 b(In)34 b(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)36 b(m)m(ultiplexing)f(is)g(pro)m(vided)
0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(13])p eop
%%Page: 14 14
14 13 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(b)m(y)42 b(the)g(destination)h(transp)s(ort)e(address)g(\(net)m(w)m
(ork)j(address)d(and)g(p)s(ort)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er\))f(whic)m(h)h(is)g
(di\013eren)m(t)g(for)0 511 y(eac)m(h)35 b(R)-8 b(TP)34
b(session.)52 b(F)-8 b(or)35 b(example,)h(in)e(a)g(teleconference)i
(comp)s(osed)e(of)h(audio)f(and)f(video)i(media)f(enco)s(ded)0
624 y(separately)-8 b(,)41 b(eac)m(h)e(medium)e Fi(should)f
Fq(b)s(e)h(carried)h(in)f(a)h(separate)h(R)-8 b(TP)37
b(session)h(with)f(its)h(o)m(wn)g(destination)0 737 y(transp)s(ort)30
b(address.)141 850 y(Separate)g(audio)g(and)e(video)i(streams)g
Fi(should)h(not)58 b Fq(b)s(e)29 b(carried)h(in)f(a)g(single)h(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(session)f(and)g(dem)m(ul-)0 963 y(tiplexed)h(based)g(on)g
(the)g(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(or)g(SSR)m(C)f(\014elds.)40
b(In)m(terlea)m(ving)32 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)f(with)f(di\013eren)m(t)g(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(media)0 1076 y(t)m(yp)s(es)g(but)g(using)g(the)h(same)f(SSR)m
(C)g(w)m(ould)g(in)m(tro)s(duce)g(sev)m(eral)i(problems:)111
1264 y(1.)46 b(If,)34 b(sa)m(y)-8 b(,)35 b(t)m(w)m(o)f(audio)f(streams)
g(shared)f(the)h(same)h(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(session)h(and)g(the)g(same)g
(SSR)m(C)f(v)-5 b(alue,)34 b(and)f(one)227 1377 y(w)m(ere)e(to)h(c)m
(hange)g(enco)s(dings)e(and)g(th)m(us)g(acquire)h(a)g(di\013eren)m(t)h
(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e,)f(there)g(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g
(no)227 1489 y(general)i(w)m(a)m(y)f(of)g(iden)m(tifying)g(whic)m(h)f
(stream)g(had)g(c)m(hanged)h(enco)s(dings.)111 1677 y(2.)46
b(An)41 b(SSR)m(C)g(is)g(de\014ned)g(to)h(iden)m(tify)g(a)g(single)g
(timing)g(and)e(sequence)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(space.)75
b(In)m(terlea)m(ving)227 1790 y(m)m(ultiple)37 b(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s
(es)g(w)m(ould)f(require)g(di\013eren)m(t)g(timing)h(spaces)g(if)f(the)
g(media)h(clo)s(c)m(k)g(rates)g(di\013er)227 1903 y(and)24
b(w)m(ould)f(require)h(di\013eren)m(t)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f
(spaces)h(to)h(tell)g(whic)m(h)f(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)f(su\013ered)f
(pac)m(k)m(et)227 2016 y(loss.)111 2203 y(3.)46 b(The)37
b(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(sender)f(and)h(receiv)m(er)h(rep)s(orts)f(\(see)h
(Section)g(6.4\))h(can)e(only)h(describ)s(e)e(one)i(timing)g(and)227
2316 y(sequence)31 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(space)i(p)s(er)e(SSR)m(C)h(and)g
(do)g(not)g(carry)h(a)f(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)e(\014eld.)111
2504 y(4.)46 b(An)29 b(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(mixer)g(w)m(ould)g(not)g(b)s(e)f
(able)i(to)g(com)m(bine)f(in)m(terlea)m(v)m(ed)j(streams)d(of)h
(incompatible)g(media)f(in)m(to)227 2617 y(one)i(stream.)111
2804 y(5.)46 b(Carrying)29 b(m)m(ultiple)i(media)f(in)f(one)h(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(session)g(precludes:)40 b(the)29 b(use)h(of)g(di\013eren)m(t)
g(net)m(w)m(ork)h(paths)e(or)227 2917 y(net)m(w)m(ork)j(resource)g
(allo)s(cations)h(if)f(appropriate;)g(reception)g(of)f(a)h(subset)f(of)
g(the)h(media)g(if)f(desired,)g(for)227 3030 y(example)g(just)f(audio)g
(if)g(video)h(w)m(ould)f(exceed)h(the)f(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable)33
b(bandwidth;)28 b(and)i(receiv)m(er)i(implemen)m(ta-)227
3143 y(tions)26 b(that)f(use)g(separate)h(pro)s(cesses)f(for)g(the)g
(di\013eren)m(t)h(media,)h(whereas)d(using)h(separate)h(R)-8
b(TP)25 b(sessions)227 3256 y(p)s(ermits)30 b(either)h(single-)g(or)f
(m)m(ultiple-pro)s(cess)h(implemen)m(tations.)141 3444
y(Using)25 b(a)g(di\013eren)m(t)g(SSR)m(C)e(for)h(eac)m(h)i(medium)e
(but)f(sending)h(them)h(in)f(the)g(same)h(R)-8 b(TP)25
b(session)f(w)m(ould)g(a)m(v)m(oid)0 3557 y(the)31 b(\014rst)e(three)i
(problems)e(but)h(not)h(the)f(last)h(t)m(w)m(o.)141 3670
y(On)20 b(the)i(other)f(hand,)h(m)m(ultiplexing)g(m)m(ultiple)g
(related)g(sources)g(of)f(the)g Fk(same)h Fq(medium)f(in)f(one)i(R)-8
b(TP)21 b(session)0 3782 y(using)36 b(di\013eren)m(t)h(SSR)m(C)e(v)-5
b(alues)36 b(is)h(the)f(norm)g(for)g(m)m(ulticast)i(sessions.)58
b(The)36 b(problems)g(listed)g(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)i(don't)0
3895 y(apply:)i(an)29 b(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(mixer)g(can)h(com)m(bine)g(m)m
(ultiple)g(audio)g(sources,)f(for)g(example,)i(and)e(the)g(same)h
(treatmen)m(t)h(is)0 4008 y(applicable)36 b(for)f(all)h(of)f(them.)55
b(It)36 b(ma)m(y)g(also)g(b)s(e)e(appropriate)h(to)h(m)m(ultiplex)g
(streams)g(of)f(the)g(same)h(medium)0 4121 y(using)30
b(di\013eren)m(t)h(SSR)m(C)e(v)-5 b(alues)31 b(in)f(other)g(scenarios)i
(where)d(the)i(last)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(problems)e(do)g(not)g(apply)-8
b(.)0 4365 y Fo(5.3)112 b(Pro\014le-Sp)s(eci\014c)39
b(Mo)s(di\014cations)g(to)e(the)g(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Header)0
4536 y Fq(The)d(existing)i(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(et)h(header)
d(is)h(b)s(eliev)m(ed)g(to)h(b)s(e)e(complete)i(for)e(the)h(set)h(of)e
(functions)h(required)0 4649 y(in)g(common)h(across)h(all)f(the)g
(application)h(classes)g(that)f(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(migh)m(t)g(supp)s(ort.)
52 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)38 b(in)d(k)m(eeping)g(with)0
4762 y(the)f(ALF)g(design)g(principle,)h(the)f(header)g
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(b)s(e)e(tailored)j(through)d(mo)s(di\014cations)h
(or)g(additions)g(de\014ned)0 4875 y(in)d(a)h(pro\014le)g(sp)s
(eci\014cation)g(while)g(still)h(allo)m(wing)g(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)
m(t)e(monitoring)h(and)f(recording)h(to)s(ols)g(to)0
4988 y(function.)136 5176 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)22 b(mark)m(er)g(bit)g
(and)f(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\014eld)e(carry)h(pro\014le-sp)s
(eci\014c)g(information,)i(but)d(they)i(are)f(allo)s(cated)227
5288 y(in)32 b(the)g(\014xed)g(header)g(since)g(man)m(y)g(applications)
i(are)e(exp)s(ected)h(to)f(need)g(them)g(and)g(migh)m(t)h(otherwise)227
5401 y(ha)m(v)m(e)d(to)f(add)f(another)h(32-bit)g(w)m(ord)f(just)g(to)h
(hold)f(them.)40 b(The)28 b(o)s(ctet)i(con)m(taining)g(these)f
(\014elds)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)30 b Fq(b)s(e)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(14])p eop
%%Page: 15 15
15 14 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(rede\014ned)26 b(b)m(y)i(a)g(pro\014le)f(to)h(suit)f(di\013eren)m(t)h
(requiremen)m(ts,)h(for)e(example)h(with)f(a)h(more)g(or)f(few)m(er)h
(mark)m(er)227 511 y(bits.)51 b(If)33 b(there)h(are)g(an)m(y)g(mark)m
(er)f(bits,)i(one)f Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)h(lo)s(cated)i(in)e(the)h
(most)g(signi\014can)m(t)g(bit)g(of)g(the)227 624 y(o)s(ctet)29
b(since)f(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)m(t)e(monitors)h(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f
(able)g(to)i(observ)m(e)e(a)h(correlation)h(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f(pac)m(k)
m(et)227 737 y(loss)j(patterns)f(and)g(the)h(mark)m(er)f(bit.)136
925 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Additional)f(information)g(that)g(is)g(required)f
(for)g(a)h(particular)f(pa)m(yload)i(format,)j(suc)m(h)44
b(as)h(a)f(video)227 1038 y(enco)s(ding,)29 b Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)h(carried)h(in)f(the)h(pa)m(yload)h(section)f(of)g(the)g(pac)m
(k)m(et.)42 b(This)28 b(migh)m(t)h(b)s(e)f(in)g(a)h(header)227
1151 y(that)f(is)g(alw)m(a)m(ys)g(presen)m(t)g(at)g(the)f(start)h(of)g
(the)f(pa)m(yload)i(section,)g(or)e(migh)m(t)h(b)s(e)f(indicated)h(b)m
(y)f(a)h(reserv)m(ed)227 1264 y(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(in)f(the)h(data)g
(pattern.)136 1451 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(If)27 b(a)g(particular)g(class)h
(of)f(applications)h(needs)e(additional)i(functionalit)m(y)g(indep)s
(enden)m(t)e(of)h(pa)m(yload)h(for-)227 1564 y(mat,)i(the)f(pro\014le)f
(under)f(whic)m(h)i(those)g(applications)h(op)s(erate)f
Fi(should)e Fq(de\014ne)h(additional)h(\014xed)f(\014elds)227
1677 y(to)23 b(follo)m(w)h(immediately)f(after)g(the)g(SSR)m(C)e
(\014eld)h(of)g(the)g(existing)i(\014xed)d(header.)38
b(Those)22 b(applications)i(will)227 1790 y(b)s(e)i(able)i(to)f(quic)m
(kly)h(and)e(directly)i(access)g(the)f(additional)h(\014elds)e(while)h
(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)m(t)f(monitors)227 1903 y(or)31
b(recorders)f(can)g(still)i(pro)s(cess)e(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)30
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(b)m(y)d(in)m(terpreting)h(only)f(the)h(\014rst)f(t)m
(w)m(elv)m(e)i(o)s(ctets.)141 2090 y(If)d(it)g(turns)f(out)i(that)f
(additional)h(functionalit)m(y)h(is)e(needed)g(in)g(common)g(across)h
(all)g(pro\014les,)f(then)g(a)g(new)0 2203 y(v)m(ersion)i(of)f(R)-8
b(TP)31 b(should)e(b)s(e)h(de\014ned)f(to)i(mak)m(e)g(a)g(p)s(ermanen)m
(t)f(c)m(hange)h(to)g(the)g(\014xed)f(header.)0 2444
y Fl(5.3.1)105 b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Header)f(Extension)0
2615 y Fq(An)c(extension)h(mec)m(hanism)f(is)h(pro)m(vided)f(to)h(allo)
m(w)h(individual)d(implemen)m(tations)j(to)f(exp)s(erimen)m(t)f(with)g
(new)0 2728 y(pa)m(yload-format-indep)s(enden)m(t)26
b(functions)f(that)h(require)g(additional)g(information)g(to)g(b)s(e)f
(carried)g(in)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)0 2841 y(data)34 b(pac)m(k)m(et)g
(header.)49 b(This)32 b(mec)m(hanism)h(is)g(designed)f(so)i(that)f(the)
g(header)g(extension)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(ignored)h(b)m(y)0
2954 y(other)e(in)m(terop)s(erating)g(implemen)m(tations)h(that)f(ha)m
(v)m(e)g(not)g(b)s(een)f(extended.)141 3067 y(Note)38
b(that)g(this)f(header)f(extension)i(is)f(in)m(tended)f(only)h(for)g
(limited)h(use.)59 b(Most)38 b(p)s(oten)m(tial)h(uses)d(of)h(this)0
3180 y(mec)m(hanism)26 b(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(b)s(etter)h(done)f(another)
h(w)m(a)m(y)-8 b(,)28 b(using)d(the)h(metho)s(ds)f(describ)s(ed)f(in)i
(the)f(previous)h(section.)0 3293 y(F)-8 b(or)26 b(example,)h(a)f
(pro\014le-sp)s(eci\014c)f(extension)g(to)h(the)g(\014xed)e(header)h
(is)g(less)h(exp)s(ensiv)m(e)f(to)h(pro)s(cess)f(b)s(ecause)g(it)h(is)0
3406 y(not)h(conditional)i(nor)d(in)h(a)g(v)-5 b(ariable)28
b(lo)s(cation.)41 b(Additional)28 b(information)f(required)f(for)h(a)h
(particular)f(pa)m(yload)0 3518 y(format)36 b Fi(should)j(not)c
Fq(use)h(this)g(header)g(extension,)i(but)e Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)h(carried)i(in)e(the)h(pa)m(yload)i(section)f(of)0
3631 y(the)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)382 3819 y Fh(0)906 b(1)h(2)f(3)382
3932 y(0)47 b(1)h(2)f(3)h(4)f(5)h(6)f(7)g(8)h(9)f(0)h(1)f(2)h(3)f(4)h
(5)f(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)h(0)f(1)h(2)f(3)h(4)f(5)h(6)f(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)h(1)334
4045 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)o
(-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)334 4158 y(|)286
b(defined)46 b(by)h(profile)332 b(|)525 b(length)667
b(|)334 4271 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o
(-+-+)o(-+-+)o(-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+-+)334 4384
y(|)1145 b(header)46 b(extension)1096 b(|)334 4496 y(|)1384
b(....)1431 b(|)141 4700 y Fq(If)26 b(the)h(X)f(bit)h(in)f(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)27 b(header)f(is)g(one,)i(a)f(v)-5 b(ariable-length)28
b(header)e(extension)h Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)53 b(app)s(ended)24
b(to)0 4813 y(the)29 b(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(header,)g(follo)m(wing)h(the)g
(CSR)m(C)e(list)h(if)g(presen)m(t.)40 b(The)29 b(header)f(extension)i
(con)m(tains)g(a)f(16-bit)i(length)0 4926 y(\014eld)j(that)i(coun)m(ts)
f(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(32-bit)h(w)m(ords)e(in)g(the)h
(extension,)i(excluding)e(the)g(four-o)s(ctet)g(extension)0
5039 y(header)25 b(\(therefore)h(zero)g(is)g(a)f(v)-5
b(alid)26 b(length\).)40 b(Only)25 b(a)g(single)h(extension)g(can)51
b(b)s(e)25 b(app)s(ended)f(to)i(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(data)0
5152 y(header.)45 b(T)-8 b(o)32 b(allo)m(w)h(m)m(ultiple)g(in)m(terop)s
(erating)g(implemen)m(tations)g(to)g(eac)m(h)g(exp)s(erimen)m(t)e
(indep)s(enden)m(tly)g(with)0 5265 y(di\013eren)m(t)f(header)e
(extensions,)i(or)f(to)h(allo)m(w)h(a)e(particular)h(implemen)m(tation)
g(to)g(exp)s(erimen)m(t)f(with)g(more)g(than)0 5378 y(one)24
b(t)m(yp)s(e)g(of)f(header)h(extension,)i(the)d(\014rst)g(16)h(bits)g
(of)g(the)f(header)h(extension)g(are)g(left)g(op)s(en)f(for)g
(distinguishing)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(15])p eop
%%Page: 16 16
16 15 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(iden)m(ti\014ers)j(or)f(parameters.)51 b(The)34 b(format)g(of)f
(these)i(16)f(bits)g(is)f(to)i(b)s(e)e(de\014ned)f(b)m(y)i(the)g
(pro\014le)f(sp)s(eci\014cation)0 511 y(under)24 b(whic)m(h)h(the)h
(implemen)m(tations)h(are)f(op)s(erating.)39 b(This)25
b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(sp)s(eci\014cation)i(do)s(es)e(not)h(de\014ne)e(an)m
(y)i(header)0 624 y(extensions)31 b(itself.)0 911 y Fp(6)135
b(R)-11 b(TP)44 b(Con)l(trol)i(Proto)t(col)g(|)f(R)-11
b(TCP)0 1114 y Fq(The)42 b(R)-8 b(TP)42 b(con)m(trol)h(proto)s(col)h
(\(R)-8 b(TCP\))42 b(is)g(based)g(on)g(the)h(p)s(erio)s(dic)e
(transmission)h(of)g(con)m(trol)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(to)0
1227 y(all)38 b(participan)m(ts)g(in)f(the)g(session,)i(using)e(the)g
(same)h(distribution)e(mec)m(hanism)h(as)h(the)f(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets.)
62 b(The)0 1340 y(underlying)29 b(proto)s(col)i Fi(must)e
Fq(pro)m(vide)h(m)m(ultiplexing)g(of)h(the)f(data)g(and)g(con)m(trol)h
(pac)m(k)m(ets,)h(for)e(example)g(using)0 1452 y(separate)h(p)s(ort)f
(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f(with)h(UDP.)41 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(p)s(erforms)f
(four)h(functions:)111 1665 y(1.)46 b(The)38 b(primary)f(function)h(is)
g(to)g(pro)m(vide)h(feedbac)m(k)f(on)g(the)g(qualit)m(y)i(of)e(the)g
(data)h(distribution.)63 b(This)227 1778 y(is)36 b(an)f(in)m(tegral)i
(part)e(of)h(the)f(R)-8 b(TP's)36 b(role)g(as)f(a)h(transp)s(ort)f
(proto)s(col)h(and)f(is)g(related)h(to)h(the)e(\015o)m(w)h(and)227
1891 y(congestion)d(con)m(trol)g(functions)f(of)f(other)h(transp)s(ort)
f(proto)s(cols)h(\(see)h(Section)f(10)h(on)e(the)h(requiremen)m(t)227
2004 y(for)22 b(congestion)i(con)m(trol\).)78 b(The)21
b(feedbac)m(k)i(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(directly)h(useful)e(for)h(con)m(trol)i
(of)f(adaptiv)m(e)g(enco)s(dings)227 2117 y([18)q(,)f(19],)i(but)c(exp)
s(erimen)m(ts)h(with)f(IP)h(m)m(ulticasting)i(ha)m(v)m(e)f(sho)m(wn)e
(that)h(it)h(is)f(also)h(critical)g(to)g(get)g(feedbac)m(k)227
2230 y(from)31 b(the)h(receiv)m(ers)h(to)f(diagnose)h(faults)e(in)h
(the)g(distribution.)43 b(Sending)31 b(reception)h(feedbac)m(k)h(rep)s
(orts)227 2342 y(to)e(all)h(participan)m(ts)f(allo)m(ws)h(one)f(who)f
(is)g(observing)h(problems)e(to)j(ev)-5 b(aluate)32 b(whether)e(those)h
(problems)227 2455 y(are)36 b(lo)s(cal)h(or)e(global.)58
b(With)36 b(a)g(distribution)f(mec)m(hanism)g(lik)m(e)i(IP)e(m)m
(ulticast,)k(it)d(is)g(also)g(p)s(ossible)f(for)227 2568
y(an)41 b(en)m(tit)m(y)h(suc)m(h)f(as)g(a)g(net)m(w)m(ork)g(service)h
(pro)m(vider)e(who)g(is)h(not)g(otherwise)g(in)m(v)m(olv)m(ed)i(in)d
(the)h(session)227 2681 y(to)f(receiv)m(e)i(the)d(feedbac)m(k)h
(information)g(and)f(act)h(as)g(a)g(third-part)m(y)f(monitor)h(to)g
(diagnose)g(net)m(w)m(ork)227 2794 y(problems.)66 b(This)38
b(feedbac)m(k)i(function)f(is)g(p)s(erformed)e(b)m(y)i(the)g(R)-8
b(TCP)38 b(sender)h(and)f(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(orts,)227
2907 y(describ)s(ed)30 b(b)s(elo)m(w)g(in)g(Section)h(6.4.)111
3095 y(2.)46 b(R)-8 b(TCP)43 b(carries)g(a)g(p)s(ersisten)m(t)g(transp)
s(ort-lev)m(el)i(iden)m(ti\014er)e(for)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)43
b(source)g(called)h(the)f Fk(c)-5 b(anoni-)227 3208 y(c)g(al)41
b(name)e Fq(or)f(CNAME,)g(Section)h(6.5.1.)66 b(Since)38
b(the)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)h(ma)m(y)h(c)m(hange)g(if)f(a)h
(con\015ict)g(is)227 3320 y(disco)m(v)m(ered)j(or)e(a)h(program)g(is)f
(restarted,)k(receiv)m(ers)e(require)e(the)g(CNAME)h(to)g(k)m(eep)g
(trac)m(k)h(of)f(eac)m(h)227 3433 y(participan)m(t.)g(Receiv)m(ers)30
b(ma)m(y)f(also)g(require)e(the)i(CNAME)f(to)h(asso)s(ciate)h(m)m
(ultiple)e(data)h(streams)f(from)227 3546 y(a)37 b(giv)m(en)h
(participan)m(t)f(in)f(a)h(set)g(of)g(related)g(R)-8
b(TP)36 b(sessions,)j(for)d(example)h(to)g(sync)m(hronize)g(audio)g
(and)227 3659 y(video.)48 b(In)m(ter-media)34 b(sync)m(hronization)f
(also)h(requires)e(the)h(NTP)f(and)g(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(timestamps)h
(included)f(in)227 3772 y(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(b)m(y)f(data)
g(senders.)111 3960 y(3.)46 b(The)35 b(\014rst)g(t)m(w)m(o)i(functions)
f(require)f(that)h(all)h(participan)m(ts)f(send)f(R)-8
b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(ets,)k(therefore)d(the)g(rate)227
4073 y(m)m(ust)28 b(b)s(e)f(con)m(trolled)i(in)e(order)g(for)g(R)-8
b(TP)28 b(to)g(scale)h(up)d(to)i(a)g(large)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(of)i
(participan)m(ts.)41 b(By)27 b(ha)m(ving)227 4186 y(eac)m(h)g
(participan)m(t)g(send)e(its)h(con)m(trol)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)f(to)g(all)f
(the)g(others,)h(eac)m(h)g(can)g(indep)s(enden)m(tly)d(observ)m(e)j
(the)227 4298 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)33 b(of)h(participan)m(ts.)52
b(This)32 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(is)h(used)f(to)h(calculate)i(the)e(rate)h
(at)f(whic)m(h)g(the)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(are)227 4411 y(sen)m(t,)31
b(as)g(explained)g(in)f(Section)h(6.2.)111 4599 y(4.)46
b(A)34 b(fourth,)g Fi(optional)e Fq(function)h(is)g(to)i(con)m(v)m(ey)g
(minimal)f(session)f(con)m(trol)i(information,)g(for)e(example)227
4712 y(participan)m(t)27 b(iden)m(ti\014cation)h(to)f(b)s(e)f(displa)m
(y)m(ed)g(in)g(the)g(user)g(in)m(terface.)41 b(This)25
b(is)h(most)h(lik)m(ely)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(useful)227 4825
y(in)21 b(\\lo)s(osely)i(con)m(trolled")g(sessions)e(where)f
(participan)m(ts)i(en)m(ter)g(and)e(lea)m(v)m(e)k(without)d(mem)m(b)s
(ership)e(con)m(trol)227 4938 y(or)28 b(parameter)h(negotiation.)42
b(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(serv)m(es)i(as)f(a)g(con)m(v)m(enien)m(t)i(c)m
(hannel)f(to)f(reac)m(h)h(all)g(the)f(participan)m(ts,)227
5051 y(but)33 b(it)i(is)f(not)g(necessarily)h(exp)s(ected)f(to)g(supp)s
(ort)e(all)j(the)f(con)m(trol)i(comm)m(unication)f(requiremen)m(ts)f
(of)227 5164 y(an)40 b(application.)72 b(A)41 b(higher-lev)m(el)h
(session)e(con)m(trol)i(proto)s(col,)i(whic)m(h)c(is)g(b)s(ey)m(ond)g
(the)g(scop)s(e)h(of)f(this)227 5276 y(do)s(cumen)m(t,)31
b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(needed.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(16])p eop
%%Page: 17 17
17 16 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(F)-8 b(unctions)40 b(1-3)h Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)h(used)g(in)h(all)h
(en)m(vironmen)m(ts,)h(but)d(particularly)i(in)e(the)h(IP)f(m)m
(ulticast)j(en-)0 511 y(vironmen)m(t.)60 b(R)-8 b(TP)37
b(application)h(designers)f Fi(should)e Fq(a)m(v)m(oid)j(mec)m(hanisms)
f(that)g(can)g(only)g(w)m(ork)g(in)g(unicast)0 624 y(mo)s(de)d(and)g
(will)h(not)g(scale)g(to)h(larger)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers.)52
b(T)-8 b(ransmission)33 b(of)i(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b Fi(ma)-6
b(y)36 b Fq(b)s(e)e(con)m(trolled)i(separately)0 737
y(for)d(senders)g(and)g(receiv)m(ers,)k(as)d(describ)s(ed)e(in)i
(Section)g(6.2,)i(for)e(cases)g(suc)m(h)g(as)g(unidirectional)g(links)f
(where)0 850 y(feedbac)m(k)e(from)f(receiv)m(ers)i(is)e(not)h(p)s
(ossible.)364 1015 y(Non-normativ)m(e)h(note:)41 b(In)29
b(the)i(m)m(ulticast)h(routing)e(approac)m(h)h(called)g(Source-Sp)s
(eci\014c)f(Mul-)227 1127 y(ticast)35 b(\(SSM\),)f(there)g(is)f(only)h
(one)f(sender)g(p)s(er)f(\\c)m(hannel")j(\(a)f(source)g(address,)g
(group)f(address)227 1240 y(pair\),)i(and)d(receiv)m(ers)j(\(except)g
(for)e(the)g(c)m(hannel)h(source\))g(cannot)f(use)g(m)m(ulticast)i(to)f
(comm)m(uni-)227 1353 y(cate)39 b(directly)f(with)f(other)h(c)m(hannel)
g(mem)m(b)s(ers.)61 b(The)37 b(recommendations)h(here)f(accommo)s(date)
227 1466 y(SSM)32 b(only)g(through)f(Section)i(6.2's)h(option)e(of)h
(turning)e(o\013)i(receiv)m(ers')g(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(en)m(tirely)-8
b(.)48 b(F)-8 b(uture)227 1579 y(w)m(ork)33 b(will)f(sp)s(ecify)g
(adaptation)i(of)e(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(for)g(SSM)f(so)i(that)f(feedbac)m(k)
h(from)f(receiv)m(ers)i(can)e(b)s(e)227 1692 y(main)m(tained.)0
1931 y Fo(6.1)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)h(F)-9
b(ormat)0 2103 y Fq(This)30 b(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(de\014nes)e(sev)m
(eral)j(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(es)f(to)g(carry)f(a)h
(v)-5 b(ariet)m(y)32 b(of)e(con)m(trol)i(information:)0
2267 y Fl(SR:)46 b Fq(Sender)f(rep)s(ort,)k(for)c(transmission)h(and)f
(reception)i(statistics)g(from)e(participan)m(ts)i(that)g(are)f(activ)m
(e)227 2380 y(senders)0 2558 y Fl(RR:)g Fq(Receiv)m(er)34
b(rep)s(ort,)f(for)f(reception)h(statistics)h(from)e(participan)m(ts)h
(that)g(are)g(not)g(activ)m(e)h(senders)e(and)f(in)227
2671 y(com)m(bination)h(with)e(SR)g(for)g(activ)m(e)j(senders)c(rep)s
(orting)h(on)g(more)h(than)f(31)h(sources)0 2850 y Fl(SDES:)46
b Fq(Source)30 b(description)g(items,)h(including)f(CNAME)0
3028 y Fl(BYE:)46 b Fq(Indicates)30 b(end)g(of)h(participation)0
3206 y Fl(APP:)46 b Fq(Application)32 b(sp)s(eci\014c)e(functions)141
3371 y(Eac)m(h)35 b(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(b)s(egins)d(with)g
(a)i(\014xed)e(part)g(similar)i(to)f(that)h(of)f(R)-8
b(TP)33 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(ets,)i(follo)m(w)m(ed)e(b)m(y)0
3484 y(structured)23 b(elemen)m(ts)i(that)g Fi(ma)-6
b(y)24 b Fq(b)s(e)g(of)g(v)-5 b(ariable)24 b(length)h(according)f(to)h
(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(e)e(but)f Fi(must)47 b
Fq(end)23 b(on)h(a)0 3597 y(32-bit)29 b(b)s(oundary)-8
b(.)39 b(The)27 b(alignmen)m(t)j(requiremen)m(t)e(and)f(a)i(length)f
(\014eld)g(in)g(the)g(\014xed)f(part)h(of)g(eac)m(h)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g
(are)0 3709 y(included)23 b(to)i(mak)m(e)f(R)-8 b(TCP)24
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(\\stac)m(k)-5 b(able".)42 b(Multiple)24
b(R)-8 b(TCP)23 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(can)48 b(b)s(e)23 b(concatenated)j
(without)0 3822 y(an)m(y)31 b(in)m(terv)m(ening)h(separators)f(to)h
(form)e(a)h Fk(c)-5 b(omp)g(ound)36 b(R)-7 b(TCP)33 b(p)-5
b(acket)31 b Fq(that)h(is)f(sen)m(t)g(in)f(a)i(single)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i
(of)e(the)0 3935 y(lo)m(w)m(er)j(la)m(y)m(er)g(proto)s(col,)h(for)d
(example)h(UDP.)48 b(There)32 b(is)h(no)g(explicit)h(coun)m(t)f(of)g
(individual)f(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)0 4048
y(the)g(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j(since)f(the)g(lo)m(w)m(er)g(la)m
(y)m(er)h(proto)s(cols)g(are)f(exp)s(ected)f(to)i(pro)m(vide)e(an)h(o)m
(v)m(erall)h(length)f(to)0 4161 y(determine)c(the)h(end)f(of)g(the)h
(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et.)141 4274 y(Eac)m(h)d(individual)e(R)-8
b(TCP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(in)d(the)i(comp)s(ound)d(pac)m(k)m(et)k(ma)m
(y)e(b)s(e)f(pro)s(cessed)h(indep)s(enden)m(tly)f(with)g(no)0
4387 y(requiremen)m(ts)i(up)s(on)e(the)h(order)g(or)h(com)m(bination)h
(of)e(pac)m(k)m(ets.)41 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)29 b(in)c(order)g(to)i(p)s
(erform)d(the)h(functions)0 4500 y(of)31 b(the)f(proto)s(col,)i(the)e
(follo)m(wing)i(constrain)m(ts)f(are)g(imp)s(osed:)136
4664 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Reception)26 b(statistics)h(\(in)e(SR)f(or)h
(RR\))g(should)f(b)s(e)g(sen)m(t)i(as)f(often)g(as)g(bandwidth)e
(constrain)m(ts)j(will)f(allo)m(w)227 4777 y(to)g(maximize)f(the)g
(resolution)g(of)g(the)g(statistics,)j(therefore)d(eac)m(h)h(p)s(erio)s
(dically)e(transmitted)h(comp)s(ound)227 4890 y(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i Fi(must)60 b Fq(include)30
b(a)h(rep)s(ort)f(pac)m(k)m(et.)136 5068 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(New)37 b(receiv)m(ers)i(need)e(to)g(receiv)m(e)i(the)e(CNAME)g
(for)g(a)h(source)f(as)g(so)s(on)g(as)g(p)s(ossible)g(to)g(iden)m(tify)
h(the)227 5181 y(source)25 b(and)g(to)g(b)s(egin)g(asso)s(ciating)i
(media)e(for)g(purp)s(oses)e(suc)m(h)h(as)h(lip-sync,)i(so)e(eac)m(h)h
(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)227 5294 y(pac)m(k)m(et)37
b Fi(must)69 b Fq(also)36 b(include)f(the)g(SDES)f(CNAME)i(except)g
(when)e(the)h(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)227
5407 y(split)31 b(for)f(partial)h(encryption)f(as)h(describ)s(ed)e(in)h
(Section)i(9.1.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(17])p eop
%%Page: 18 18
18 17 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)136 399
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)22 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m
(yp)s(es)d(that)h(ma)m(y)g(app)s(ear)e(\014rst)h(in)g(the)g(comp)s
(ound)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(needs)e(to)46 b(b)s(e)21 b(limited)227
511 y(to)35 b(increase)f(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(constan)m(t)h
(bits)f(in)f(the)h(\014rst)f(w)m(ord)g(and)g(the)h(probabilit)m(y)g(of)
g(successfully)227 624 y(v)-5 b(alidating)29 b(R)-8 b(TCP)27
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(against)f(misaddressed)f(R)-8 b(TP)27
b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(or)e(other)h(unrelated)f(pac)m(k)m(ets.)141
805 y(Th)m(us,)h(all)g(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h
Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)g(sen)m(t)h(in)g(a)g(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k
(of)e(at)g(least)i(t)m(w)m(o)f(individual)e(pac)m(k)m(ets,)0
918 y(with)j(the)h(follo)m(wing)g(format:)0 1099 y Fl(Encryption)k
(pre\014x:)46 b Fq(If)f(and)f(only)h(if)g(the)g(comp)s(ound)f(pac)m(k)m
(et)j(is)e(to)g(b)s(e)g(encrypted)f(according)i(to)g(the)227
1212 y(metho)s(d)33 b(in)f(Section)i(9.1,)h(it)f Fi(must)e
Fq(b)s(e)65 b(pre\014xed)32 b(b)m(y)h(a)g(random)g(32-bit)h(quan)m(tit)
m(y)g(redra)m(wn)e(for)h(ev)m(ery)227 1325 y(comp)s(ound)g(pac)m(k)m
(et)i(transmitted.)52 b(If)33 b(padding)g(is)h(required)f(for)h(the)g
(encryption,)g(it)h Fi(must)d Fq(b)s(e)i(added)227 1438
y(to)d(the)g(last)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(of)d(the)h(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m
(et.)0 1623 y Fl(SR)35 b(or)h(RR:)46 b Fq(The)33 b(\014rst)h(R)-8
b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(in)c(the)i(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j
Fi(must)d Fq(alw)m(a)m(ys)i(b)s(e)f(a)h(rep)s(ort)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j(to)
227 1736 y(facilitate)j(header)d(v)-5 b(alidation)37
b(as)f(describ)s(ed)f(in)g(App)s(endix)g(A.2.)58 b(This)35
b(is)h(true)f(ev)m(en)i(if)f(no)g(data)g(has)227 1849
y(b)s(een)30 b(sen)m(t)i(or)e(receiv)m(ed,)j(in)d(whic)m(h)h(case)g(an)
g(empt)m(y)g(RR)g Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)61 b(sen)m(t,)32
b(and)e(ev)m(en)h(if)g(the)g(only)g(other)227 1962 y(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(in)f(the)f(comp)s(ound)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)f
(a)g(BYE.)0 2146 y Fl(Additional)k(RRs:)47 b Fq(If)19
b(the)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(sources)h(for)f(whic)m(h)g(reception)h
(statistics)h(are)f(b)s(eing)e(rep)s(orted)h(exceeds)227
2259 y(31,)34 b(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(that)i(will)g(\014t)f(in)m(to)h
(one)g(SR)e(or)i(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(then)d(additional)h(RR)f(pac)m(k)
m(ets)j Fi(should)227 2372 y Fq(follo)m(w)d(the)e(initial)i(rep)s(ort)e
(pac)m(k)m(et.)0 2557 y Fl(SDES:)46 b Fq(An)31 b(SDES)g(pac)m(k)m(et)j
(con)m(taining)f(a)g(CNAME)f(item)g Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)g(included)g(in)
h(eac)m(h)h(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)227 2670 y(pac)m(k)m(et,)44
b(except)c(as)f(noted)g(in)g(Section)g(9.1.)68 b(Other)38
b(source)i(description)f(items)g Fi(ma)-6 b(y)40 b Fq(optionally)h(b)s
(e)227 2783 y(included)35 b(if)h(required)e(b)m(y)i(a)g(particular)g
(application,)i(sub)5 b(ject)35 b(to)i(bandwidth)c(constrain)m(ts)k
(\(see)f(Sec-)227 2896 y(tion)31 b(6.3.9\).)0 3081 y
Fl(BYE)k(or)g(APP:)47 b Fq(Other)33 b(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)
m(yp)s(es,)f(including)f(those)g(y)m(et)h(to)g(b)s(e)e(de\014ned,)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(follo)m(w)g(in)f(an)m(y)227 3194
y(order,)h(except)g(that)f(BYE)h Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)h(the)h(last)h
(pac)m(k)m(et)h(sen)m(t)e(with)g(a)g(giv)m(en)h(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C.)50
b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)227 3307 y(t)m(yp)s(es)31 b Fi(ma)-6
b(y)31 b Fq(app)s(ear)f(more)g(than)h(once.)141 3488
y(An)44 b(individual)f(R)-8 b(TP)44 b(participan)m(t)i
Fi(should)c Fq(send)h(only)i(one)f(comp)s(ound)f(R)-8
b(TCP)43 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(p)s(er)e(rep)s(ort)0 3601 y(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)22 b(in)f(order)g(for)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)21 b(bandwidth)e(p)s(er)h
(participan)m(t)j(to)f(b)s(e)f(estimated)h(correctly)h(\(see)f(Section)
g(6.2\),)0 3714 y(except)28 b(when)e(the)i(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8
b(TCP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)f(split)f(for)g(partial)h(encryption)f(as)
h(describ)s(ed)e(in)h(Section)h(9.1.)0 3826 y(If)g(there)i(are)f(to)s
(o)g(man)m(y)g(sources)g(to)h(\014t)f(all)g(the)g(necessary)h(RR)e(pac)
m(k)m(ets)j(in)m(to)f(one)f(comp)s(ound)f(R)-8 b(TCP)28
b(pac)m(k)m(et)0 3939 y(without)42 b(exceeding)h(the)g(maxim)m(um)f
(transmission)g(unit)f(\(MTU\))i(of)f(the)h(net)m(w)m(ork)g(path,)i
(then)d(only)g(the)0 4052 y(subset)35 b(that)h(will)g(\014t)f(in)m(to)h
(one)g(MTU)g Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)g(included)h(in)g(eac)m(h)i(in)m
(terv)-5 b(al.)57 b(The)35 b(subsets)g Fi(should)f Fq(b)s(e)0
4165 y(selected)e(round-robin)c(across)j(m)m(ultiple)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(als)32 b(so)e(that)h(all)h(sources)e(are)h(rep)s(orted.)141
4278 y(It)i(is)h Fi(recommended)c Fq(that)k(translators)g(and)e(mixers)
66 b(com)m(bine)34 b(individual)f(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(from)
e(the)0 4391 y(m)m(ultiple)46 b(sources)f(they)h(are)g(forw)m(arding)f
(in)m(to)h(one)g(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j(whenev)m(er)e(feasible)h
(in)f(order)g(to)0 4504 y(amortize)37 b(the)e(pac)m(k)m(et)i(o)m(v)m
(erhead)f(\(see)g(Section)g(7\).)56 b(An)34 b(example)i(R)-8
b(TCP)35 b(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(as)f(migh)m(t)g(b)s(e)0
4617 y(pro)s(duced)30 b(b)m(y)i(a)g(mixer)g(is)g(sho)m(wn)f(in)g(Fig.)i
(1.)46 b(If)31 b(the)h(o)m(v)m(erall)i(length)e(of)g(a)g(comp)s(ound)f
(pac)m(k)m(et)i(w)m(ould)f(exceed)0 4730 y(the)h(MTU)g(of)g(the)g(net)m
(w)m(ork)h(path,)f(it)h Fi(should)64 b Fq(b)s(e)32 b(segmen)m(ted)i(in)
m(to)g(m)m(ultiple)f(shorter)g(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)0
4843 y(to)h(b)s(e)e(transmitted)h(in)f(separate)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(of)e
(the)g(underlying)e(proto)s(col.)43 b(This)30 b(do)s(es)h(not)g(impair)
f(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)0 4956 y(bandwidth)31 b(estimation)j(b)s(ecause)e
(eac)m(h)i(comp)s(ound)d(pac)m(k)m(et)j(represen)m(ts)e(at)h(least)h
(one)f(distinct)g(participan)m(t.)0 5068 y(Note)f(that)f(eac)m(h)g(of)g
(the)f(comp)s(ound)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(egin)g(with)g(an)
g(SR)g(or)g(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)141 5181 y(An)37 b(implemen)m(tation)h
Fi(should)72 b Fq(ignore)37 b(incoming)h(R)-8 b(TCP)36
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(with)d(t)m(yp)s(es)h(unkno)m(wn)f(to)h(it.)61
b(Ad-)0 5294 y(ditional)44 b(R)-8 b(TCP)42 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s
(es)d(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)e(registered)i(with)e(the)h(In)m(ternet)g
(Assigned)g(Num)m(b)s(ers)e(Authorit)m(y)0 5407 y(\(IANA\))31
b(as)g(describ)s(ed)e(in)h(App)s(endix)f(D.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(18])p eop
%%Page: 19 19
19 18 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 1249
y
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 0.84326 0.84326 scale neg exch
neg exch translate
 0 1249 a @beginspecial 0 @llx 0 @lly 555 @urx 134 @ury
5550 @rwi @setspecial
%%BeginDocument: rtcp_packet.ps
%!PS-Adobe-2.0 EPSF-2.0
%%Title: rtcp_packet.fig
%%Creator: fig2dev Version 3.1 Patchlevel 1
%%CreationDate: Thu Nov  9 14:11:56 1995
%%For: hgs@lupus (Henning Schulzrinne)
%%Orientation: Portrait
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 555 134
%%Pages: 0
%%BeginSetup
%%IncludeFeature: *PageSize Letter
%%EndSetup
%%EndComments
/$F2psDict 200 dict def
$F2psDict begin
$F2psDict /mtrx matrix put
/col-1 {} def
/col0 {0.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col1 {0.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col2 {0.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col3 {0.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col4 {1.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col5 {1.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col6 {1.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col7 {1.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col8 {0.000 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col9 {0.000 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col10 {0.000 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col11 {0.530 0.810 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col12 {0.000 0.560 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col13 {0.000 0.690 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col14 {0.000 0.820 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col15 {0.000 0.560 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col16 {0.000 0.690 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col17 {0.000 0.820 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col18 {0.560 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col19 {0.690 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col20 {0.820 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col21 {0.560 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col22 {0.690 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col23 {0.820 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col24 {0.500 0.190 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col25 {0.630 0.250 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col26 {0.750 0.380 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col27 {1.000 0.500 0.500 srgb} bind def
/col28 {1.000 0.630 0.630 srgb} bind def
/col29 {1.000 0.750 0.750 srgb} bind def
/col30 {1.000 0.880 0.880 srgb} bind def
/col31 {1.000 0.840 0.000 srgb} bind def

end
save
-13.0 232.0 translate
1 -1 scale

/clp {closepath} bind def
/ef {eofill} bind def
/gr {grestore} bind def
/gs {gsave} bind def
/l {lineto} bind def
/m {moveto} bind def
/n {newpath} bind def
/s {stroke} bind def
/slc {setlinecap} bind def
/slj {setlinejoin} bind def
/slw {setlinewidth} bind def
/srgb {setrgbcolor} bind def
/rot {rotate} bind def
/sc {scale} bind def
/tr {translate} bind def
/tnt {dup dup currentrgbcolor
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add srgb}
  bind def
/shd {dup dup currentrgbcolor 4 -2 roll mul 4 -2 roll mul
  4 -2 roll mul srgb} bind def
/$F2psBegin {$F2psDict begin /$F2psEnteredState save def} def
/$F2psEnd {$F2psEnteredState restore end} def
%%EndProlog

$F2psBegin
10 setmiterlimit
 0.06299 0.06299 sc
7.500 slw
% Polyline
n 330 2700 m 225 2700 225 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 225 3150 570 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 675 3150 675 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 675 2700 330 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs 0.80 setgray ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 7755 2700 m 7650 2700 7650 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 7650 3150 8895 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 9000 3150 9000 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 9000 2700 7755 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 225 2700 m 225 3150 l  9000 3150 l  9000 2700 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 780 2700 m 675 2700 675 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 675 3150 3720 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3825 3150 3825 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3825 2700 780 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3930 2700 m 3825 2700 3825 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3825 3150 7545 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 7650 3150 7650 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 7650 2700 3930 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3930 2700 m 3825 2700 3825 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3825 3150 4170 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 4275 3150 4275 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 4275 2700 3930 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 7755 2700 m 7650 2700 7650 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 7650 3150 7995 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 8100 3150 8100 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 8100 2700 7755 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 780 2700 m 675 2700 675 3045 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 675 3150 1020 3150 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1125 3150 1125 2805 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1125 2700 780 2700 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 225 3375 m 3915 3375 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 345.00 3405.00 m 225.00 3375.00 l 345.00 3345.00 l  345.50 3375.50 l 345.00 3405.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 5310 3375 m 9000 3375 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 8880.00 3345.00 m 9000.00 3375.00 l 8880.00 3405.00 l  8880.50 3375.50 l 8880.00 3345.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 5850 2700 m 5850 3150 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3825 2025 m 5400 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 3945.00 2055.00 m 3825.00 2025.00 l 3945.00 1995.00 l  3945.50 2025.50 l 3945.00 2055.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 3825 1935 m 3825 2070 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 6075 2025 m 7650 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 7530.00 1995.00 m 7650.00 2025.00 l 7530.00 2055.00 l  7530.50 2025.50 l 7530.00 1995.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 450 1755 m 450 2970 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 480.00 2850.00 m 450.00 2970.00 l 420.00 2850.00 l  450.50 2850.50 l 480.00 2850.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 675 2025 m 1980 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 795.00 2055.00 m 675.00 2025.00 l 795.00 1995.00 l  795.50 2025.50 l 795.00 2055.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 3825 2025 m 2610 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 3705.00 1995.00 m 3825.00 2025.00 l 3705.00 2055.00 l  3705.50 2025.50 l 3705.00 1995.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 675 1935 m 675 2115 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 7650 1935 m 7650 2070 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2025 2700 m 2025 3150 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2880 2700 m 2880 3150 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 7650 2025 m 8055 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 7770.00 2055.00 m 7650.00 2025.00 l 7770.00 1995.00 l  7770.50 2025.50 l 7770.00 2055.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 8595 2025 m 9000 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 8880.00 1995.00 m 9000.00 2025.00 l 8880.00 2055.00 l  8880.50 2025.50 l 8880.00 1995.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 9000 1935 m 9000 2070 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 225 3600 m 4050 3600 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 345.00 3630.00 m 225.00 3600.00 l 345.00 3570.00 l  345.50 3600.50 l 345.00 3630.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 5175 3600 m 9000 3600 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
n 8880.00 3570.00 m 9000.00 3600.00 l 8880.00 3630.00 l  8880.50 3600.50 l 8880.00 3570.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
7875 3015 m
gs 1 -1 sc (BYE) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
900 3015 m
gs 1 -1 sc (SR) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4050 3015 m
gs 1 -1 sc (SDES) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
4455 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
4500 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (CNAME) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
5175 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (PHONE) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
7020 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (LOC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
6300 2655 m
gs 1 -1 sc (item) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
4635 2655 m
gs 1 -1 sc (item) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
5310 2655 m
gs 1 -1 sc (item) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4860 2430 m
gs 1 -1 sc (chunk) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
6795 2430 m
gs 1 -1 sc (chunk) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
6975 2655 m
gs 1 -1 sc (item) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5760 2070 m
gs 1 -1 sc (packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
8325 2070 m
gs 1 -1 sc (packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
225 1710 m
gs 1 -1 sc (if encrypted: random 32-bit integer) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
2295 2070 m
gs 1 -1 sc (packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
8280 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
8460 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
8550 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (reason) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
6030 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
6120 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (CNAME) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
1485 2925 m
gs 1 -1 sc (sender) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
1485 3060 m
gs 1 -1 sc (report) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
1305 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
2205 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
2385 2655 m
gs 1 -1 sc (receiver reports) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
3060 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
3240 2970 m
gs 1 -1 sc (site 2) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
2340 2970 m
gs 1 -1 sc (site 1) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4635 3420 m
gs 1 -1 sc (compound packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4590 3645 m
gs 1 -1 sc (UDP packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
$F2psEnd
restore

%%EndDocument
 @endspecial 0 1249 a
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1 0.84326 div 1 0.84326 div scale
neg exch neg exch translate
 0 1249 a 957 1445 a Fq(Figure)g(1:)41
b(Example)31 b(of)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(comp)s(ound)f(pac)m(k)m(et)0
1720 y Fo(6.2)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(T)-9 b(ransmission)39
b(In)m(terv)-6 b(al)0 1891 y Fq(R)e(TP)36 b(is)g(designed)g(to)h(allo)m
(w)h(an)e(application)h(to)g(scale)h(automatically)h(o)m(v)m(er)e
(session)g(sizes)f(ranging)h(from)f(a)0 2004 y(few)f(participan)m(ts)g
(to)h(thousands.)53 b(F)-8 b(or)35 b(example,)i(in)e(an)g(audio)f
(conference)i(the)f(data)h(tra\016c)f(is)g(inheren)m(tly)0
2117 y(self-limiting)29 b(b)s(ecause)e(only)g(one)h(or)f(t)m(w)m(o)h(p)
s(eople)g(will)f(sp)s(eak)g(at)h(a)f(time,)i(so)f(with)e(m)m(ulticast)j
(distribution)e(the)0 2230 y(data)j(rate)f(on)g(an)m(y)h(giv)m(en)g
(link)f(remains)f(relativ)m(ely)k(constan)m(t)e(indep)s(enden)m(t)e(of)
h(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(participan)m(ts.)0 2343
y(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)i(the)e(con)m(trol)h(tra\016c)f(is)g(not)g
(self-limiting.)42 b(If)28 b(the)h(reception)g(rep)s(orts)f(from)g(eac)
m(h)i(participan)m(t)f(w)m(ere)0 2456 y(sen)m(t)38 b(at)h(a)f(constan)m
(t)h(rate,)h(the)e(con)m(trol)h(tra\016c)f(w)m(ould)g(gro)m(w)g
(linearly)g(with)g(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(participan)m(ts.)0
2569 y(Therefore,)g(the)e(rate)h(m)m(ust)f(b)s(e)g(scaled)h(do)m(wn)e
(b)m(y)i(dynamically)f(calculating)j(the)d(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)38 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)e(R)-8 b(TCP)0 2682 y(pac)m(k)m(et)32
b(transmissions.)141 2795 y(F)-8 b(or)34 b(eac)m(h)g(session,)f(it)g
(is)g(assumed)f(that)i(the)f(data)g(tra\016c)g(is)g(sub)5
b(ject)32 b(to)i(an)f(aggregate)i(limit)f(called)g(the)0
2908 y(\\session)41 b(bandwidth")e(to)i(b)s(e)f(divided)g(among)h(the)g
(participan)m(ts.)71 b(This)40 b(bandwidth)f(migh)m(t)i(b)s(e)f(reserv)
m(ed)0 3021 y(and)32 b(the)h(limit)h(enforced)f(b)m(y)f(the)h(net)m(w)m
(ork.)49 b(If)33 b(there)g(is)g(no)f(reserv)-5 b(ation,)35
b(there)e(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(other)g(constrain)m(ts,)0
3133 y(dep)s(ending)22 b(on)i(the)f(en)m(vironmen)m(t,)j(that)f
(establish)f(the)f(\\reasonable")j(maxim)m(um)d(for)h(the)f(session)h
(to)h(use,)g(and)0 3246 y(that)g(w)m(ould)e(b)s(e)h(the)g(session)g
(bandwidth.)75 b(The)23 b(session)i(bandwidth)d(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)g(c)m
(hosen)g(based)g(on)g(some)g(cost)h(or)0 3359 y Fk(a)30
b(priori)f Fq(kno)m(wledge)g(of)e(the)h(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable)30
b(net)m(w)m(ork)e(bandwidth)e(for)h(the)g(session.)40
b(It)28 b(is)f(somewhat)h(indep)s(enden)m(t)0 3472 y(of)23
b(the)f(media)h(enco)s(ding,)i(but)d(the)g(enco)s(ding)h(c)m(hoice)h
(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)f(limited)i(b)m(y)e(the)h(session)f(bandwidth.)37
b(Often,)24 b(the)0 3585 y(session)h(bandwidth)e(is)i(the)g(sum)f(of)h
(the)g(nominal)g(bandwidths)e(of)i(the)g(senders)f(exp)s(ected)i(to)f
(b)s(e)g(concurren)m(tly)0 3698 y(activ)m(e.)76 b(F)-8
b(or)42 b(teleconference)i(audio,)h(this)c(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(w)m(ould)h
(t)m(ypically)j(b)s(e)d(one)g(sender's)g(bandwidth.)72
b(F)-8 b(or)0 3811 y(la)m(y)m(ered)27 b(enco)s(dings,)g(eac)m(h)f(la)m
(y)m(er)h(is)f(a)g(separate)g(R)-8 b(TP)26 b(session)f(with)h(its)g(o)m
(wn)f(session)h(bandwidth)d(parameter.)141 3924 y(The)28
b(session)g(bandwidth)e(parameter)j(is)f(exp)s(ected)h(to)g(b)s(e)e
(supplied)g(b)m(y)h(a)h(session)f(managemen)m(t)i(applica-)0
4037 y(tion)k(when)f(it)i(in)m(v)m(ok)m(es)g(a)f(media)g(application,)j
(but)c(media)h(applications)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(set)f(a)h(default)f
(based)f(on)h(the)0 4150 y(single-sender)f(data)h(bandwidth)d(for)i
(the)h(enco)s(ding)f(selected)h(for)f(the)h(session.)49
b(The)32 b(application)j Fi(ma)-6 b(y)34 b Fq(also)0
4263 y(enforce)i(bandwidth)d(limits)j(based)f(on)g(m)m(ulticast)i(scop)
s(e)e(rules)g(or)g(other)h(criteria.)56 b(All)36 b(participan)m(ts)g
Fi(must)0 4375 y Fq(use)30 b(the)h(same)f(v)-5 b(alue)31
b(for)f(the)h(session)f(bandwidth)f(so)i(that)g(the)f(same)h(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)31 b(will)g(b)s(e)f(calculated.)141
4488 y(Bandwidth)j(calculations)j(for)d(con)m(trol)j(and)d(data)h
(tra\016c)g(include)g(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)j(transp)s(ort)c(and)g
(net)m(w)m(ork)0 4601 y(proto)s(cols)40 b(\(e.g.,)k(UDP)c(and)f(IP\))h
(since)g(that)g(is)g(what)g(the)f(resource)h(reserv)-5
b(ation)41 b(system)e(w)m(ould)h(need)f(to)0 4714 y(kno)m(w.)h(The)26
b(application)i(can)f(also)h(b)s(e)e(exp)s(ected)h(to)h(kno)m(w)f(whic)
m(h)f(of)h(these)g(proto)s(cols)h(are)f(in)g(use.)39
b(Link)26 b(lev)m(el)0 4827 y(headers)h(are)h(not)g(included)e(in)h
(the)h(calculation)i(since)d(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(will)f(b)s(e)f
(encapsulated)h(with)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(link)0 4940 y(lev)m(el)k
(headers)e(as)h(it)g(tra)m(v)m(els.)141 5053 y(The)i(con)m(trol)i
(tra\016c)f(should)f(b)s(e)g(limited)h(to)h(a)f(small)g(and)f(kno)m(wn)
g(fraction)h(of)g(the)g(session)g(bandwidth:)0 5166 y(small)25
b(so)f(that)h(the)f(primary)f(function)h(of)g(the)g(transp)s(ort)g
(proto)s(col)h(to)g(carry)f(data)g(is)h(not)f(impaired;)i(kno)m(wn)e
(so)0 5279 y(that)f(the)f(con)m(trol)i(tra\016c)e(can)h(b)s(e)e
(included)h(in)g(the)g(bandwidth)e(sp)s(eci\014cation)j(giv)m(en)g(to)g
(a)g(resource)f(reserv)-5 b(ation)0 5392 y(proto)s(col,)40
b(and)c(so)i(that)f(eac)m(h)h(participan)m(t)h(can)e(indep)s(enden)m
(tly)f(calculate)j(its)f(share.)60 b(The)37 b(con)m(trol)h(tra\016c)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(19])p eop
%%Page: 20 20
20 19 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(bandwidth)22 b(is)i(in)f(addition)h(to)h(the)f(session)g(bandwidth)e
(for)i(the)g(data)g(tra\016c.)39 b(It)24 b(is)g Fi(recommended)d
Fq(that)k(the)0 511 y(fraction)33 b(of)f(the)g(session)f(bandwidth)f
(added)i(for)f(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(b)s(e)h(\014xed)f(at)h(5\045.)46
b(It)32 b(is)f(also)i Fi(recommended)c Fq(that)0 624
y(1/4)i(of)e(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(bandwidth)e(b)s(e)i(dedicated)h(to)g
(participan)m(ts)h(that)f(are)f(sending)g(data)h(so)g(that)g(in)f
(sessions)0 737 y(with)38 b(a)h(large)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(of)i(receiv)m
(ers)h(but)e(a)h(small)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(senders,)h(newly)e
(joining)h(participan)m(ts)h(will)0 850 y(more)30 b(quic)m(kly)h
(receiv)m(e)h(the)f(CNAME)f(for)g(the)g(sending)g(sites.)41
b(When)30 b(the)h(prop)s(ortion)e(of)h(senders)f(is)i(greater)0
963 y(than)d(1/4)h(of)g(the)f(participan)m(ts,)i(the)e(senders)f(get)j
(their)e(prop)s(ortion)f(of)h(the)h(full)f(R)-8 b(TCP)27
b(bandwidth.)78 b(While)0 1076 y(the)32 b(v)-5 b(alues)33
b(of)f(these)h(and)e(other)i(constan)m(ts)g(in)f(the)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)34 b(calculation)g(are)f(not)f(critical,)j(all)e(participan)m(ts)0
1189 y(in)g(the)g(session)h Fi(must)e Fq(use)h(the)g(same)h(v)-5
b(alues)33 b(so)h(the)f(same)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)34 b(will)g(b)s(e)e
(calculated.)52 b(Therefore,)33 b(these)0 1302 y(constan)m(ts)f
Fi(should)c Fq(b)s(e)i(\014xed)g(for)g(a)h(particular)f(pro\014le.)141
1415 y(A)36 b(pro\014le)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)37 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)e(that)h(the)
g(con)m(trol)h(tra\016c)f(bandwidth)e(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)f(a)h(separate)h
(parameter)f(of)g(the)0 1528 y(session)25 b(rather)g(than)g(a)h(strict)
g(p)s(ercen)m(tage)h(of)e(the)g(session)h(bandwidth.)37
b(Using)25 b(a)h(separate)g(parameter)g(allo)m(ws)0 1641
y(rate-adaptiv)m(e)32 b(applications)g(to)f(set)f(an)g(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(bandwidth)e(consisten)m(t)j(with)f(a)g(\\t)m(ypical")j(data)
e(bandwidth)0 1753 y(that)g(is)f(lo)m(w)m(er)i(than)e(the)h(maxim)m(um)
f(bandwidth)e(sp)s(eci\014ed)i(b)m(y)g(the)h(session)f(bandwidth)f
(parameter.)141 1866 y(The)40 b(pro\014le)g Fi(ma)-6
b(y)41 b Fq(further)e(sp)s(ecify)h(that)g(the)h(con)m(trol)g(tra\016c)g
(bandwidth)e(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)g(divided)f(in)m(to)j(t)m(w)m(o)0
1979 y(separate)35 b(session)f(parameters)g(for)f(those)i(participan)m
(ts)f(whic)m(h)g(are)g(activ)m(e)i(data)f(senders)e(and)g(those)h(whic)
m(h)0 2092 y(are)k(not.)63 b(F)-8 b(ollo)m(wing)40 b(the)e
(recommendation)h(that)f(1/4)h(of)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37
b(bandwidth)f(b)s(e)h(dedicated)i(to)f(data)0 2205 y(senders,)d(the)g
Fi(recommended)d Fq(default)j(v)-5 b(alues)35 b(for)g(these)g(t)m(w)m
(o)h(parameters)f(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)f(1.25\045)i(and)e(3.75\045,)0
2318 y(resp)s(ectiv)m(ely)-8 b(.)55 b(When)34 b(the)h(prop)s(ortion)e
(of)i(senders)e(is)i(greater)g(than)g(1/4)g(of)g(the)g(participan)m
(ts,)h(the)f(senders)0 2431 y(get)29 b(their)f(prop)s(ortion)f(of)h
(the)h(sum)e(of)h(these)g(parameters.)41 b(Using)28 b(t)m(w)m(o)h
(parameters)f(allo)m(ws)i(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(reception)0
2544 y(rep)s(orts)32 b(to)h(b)s(e)f(turned)f(o\013)i(en)m(tirely)h(for)
e(a)h(particular)g(session)g(b)m(y)f(setting)i(the)e(R)-8
b(TCP)32 b(bandwidth)f(for)h(non-)0 2657 y(data-senders)g(to)g(zero)g
(while)f(k)m(eeping)i(the)e(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(bandwidth)e(for)j(data)g
(senders)e(non-zero)i(so)g(that)g(sender)0 2770 y(rep)s(orts)k(can)h
(still)h(b)s(e)e(sen)m(t)h(for)g(in)m(ter-media)h(sync)m(hronization.)
61 b(T)-8 b(urning)36 b(o\013)h(R)-8 b(TCP)36 b(reception)i(rep)s(orts)
e(is)0 2883 y Fi(not)30 b(recommended)23 b Fq(b)s(ecause)k(they)g(are)f
(needed)h(for)f(the)h(functions)f(listed)h(at)g(the)g(b)s(eginning)e
(of)i(Section)g(6,)0 2995 y(particularly)34 b(reception)g(qualit)m(y)h
(feedbac)m(k)f(and)f(congestion)i(con)m(trol.)52 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)36
b(doing)e(so)f(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(appro-)0 3108 y(priate)h(for)f(systems)
h(op)s(erating)f(on)h(unidirectional)g(links)f(or)h(for)f(sessions)g
(that)h(don't)g(require)f(feedbac)m(k)h(on)0 3221 y(the)d(qualit)m(y)g
(of)g(reception)g(or)f(liv)m(eness)i(of)e(receiv)m(ers)i(and)e(that)g
(ha)m(v)m(e)i(other)f(means)f(to)h(a)m(v)m(oid)h(congestion.)141
3334 y(The)27 b(calculated)j(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)29 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f
(transmissions)g(of)g(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j
Fi(should)c Fq(also)j(ha)m(v)m(e)g(a)0 3447 y(lo)m(w)m(er)k(b)s(ound)c
(to)j(a)m(v)m(oid)h(ha)m(ving)f(bursts)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(exceed)g
(the)f(allo)m(w)m(ed)h(bandwidth)c(when)i(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)0
3560 y(participan)m(ts)j(is)g(small)g(and)e(the)i(tra\016c)g(isn't)g
(smo)s(othed)f(according)h(to)g(the)g(la)m(w)g(of)g(large)g(n)m(um)m(b)
s(ers.)45 b(It)33 b(also)0 3673 y(k)m(eeps)27 b(the)f(rep)s(ort)g(in)m
(terv)-5 b(al)27 b(from)f(b)s(ecoming)g(to)s(o)h(small)g(during)e
(transien)m(t)i(outages)g(lik)m(e)h(a)e(net)m(w)m(ork)h(partition)0
3786 y(suc)m(h)k(that)g(adaptation)i(is)e(dela)m(y)m(ed)h(when)e(the)i
(partition)f(heals.)43 b(A)m(t)32 b(application)h(startup,)e(a)g(dela)m
(y)j Fi(should)0 3899 y Fq(b)s(e)k(imp)s(osed)g(b)s(efore)g(the)h
(\014rst)f(comp)s(ound)g(R)-8 b(TCP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)d(sen)m(t)i
(to)f(allo)m(w)h(time)g(for)e(R)-8 b(TCP)39 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(to)0
4012 y(b)s(e)33 b(receiv)m(ed)j(from)d(other)h(participan)m(ts)h(so)f
(the)g(rep)s(ort)f(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)35 b(will)g(con)m(v)m(erge)h(to)e
(the)g(correct)h(v)-5 b(alue)35 b(more)0 4125 y(quic)m(kly)-8
b(.)42 b(This)29 b(dela)m(y)k Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(b)s(e)f(set)g(to)h
(half)f(the)h(minim)m(um)e(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)31 b(to)g(allo)m(w)h(quic)
m(k)m(er)f(noti\014cation)h(that)f(the)0 4237 y(new)f(participan)m(t)h
(is)g(presen)m(t.)40 b(The)30 b Fi(recommended)e Fq(v)-5
b(alue)31 b(for)f(a)h(\014xed)f(minim)m(um)f(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)32 b(is)e(5)h(seconds.)141 4350 y(An)c(implemen)m(tation)i
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)28 b Fq(scale)g(the)f(minim)m(um)g(R)-8
b(TCP)26 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)28 b(to)g(a)g(smaller)f(v)-5
b(alue)28 b(in)m(v)m(ersely)g(prop)s(or-)0 4463 y(tional)k(to)f(the)f
(session)h(bandwidth)d(parameter)j(with)f(the)h(follo)m(wing)h
(limitations:)136 4676 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(F)-8 b(or)45
b(m)m(ulticast)h(sessions,)i(only)c(activ)m(e)j(data)e(senders)e
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)45 b Fq(use)f(the)h(reduced)e(minim)m(um)g(v)-5
b(alue)45 b(to)227 4789 y(calculate)33 b(the)e(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)31 b(for)f(transmission)g(of)h(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)136 4976 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(F)-8
b(or)31 b(unicast)f(sessions,)g(the)f(reduced)g(v)-5
b(alue)30 b Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(b)s(e)e(used)g(b)m(y)h(participan)m
(ts)g(that)g(are)g(not)g(activ)m(e)i(data)227 5089 y(senders)24
b(as)h(w)m(ell,)i(and)d(the)g(dela)m(y)i(b)s(efore)e(sending)g(the)h
(initial)h(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)26 b Fq(b)s(e)e(zero.)136 5277 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(F)-8 b(or)26 b(all)g(sessions,)h(the)f(\014xed)e(minim)m(um)h
Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)i(used)f(when)h(calculating)i(the)f(participan)m
(t)g(timeout)227 5390 y(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)36 b(\(see)f(Section)g
(6.3.5\))h(so)f(that)f(implemen)m(tations)i(whic)m(h)e(do)g(not)h(use)f
(the)g(reduced)f(v)-5 b(alue)35 b(for)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(20])p eop
%%Page: 21 21
21 20 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(transmitting)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(are)f(not)g(timed)f
(out)h(b)m(y)f(other)h(participan)m(ts)g(prematurely)-8
b(.)136 584 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)29 b Fi(recommended)e
Fq(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(for)e(the)h(reduced)f(minim)m(um)g(in)g(seconds)h
(is)f(360)i(divided)e(b)m(y)h(the)g(session)227 697 y(bandwidth)20
b(in)i(kilobits/second.)39 b(This)21 b(minim)m(um)g(is)h(smaller)g
(than)g(5)g(seconds)f(for)h(bandwidths)e(greater)227
810 y(than)30 b(72)i(kb/s.)141 1017 y(The)41 b(algorithm)h(describ)s
(ed)e(in)h(Section)g(6.3)i(and)81 b(App)s(endix)39 b(A.7)j(w)m(as)g
(designed)f(to)g(meet)h(the)g(goals)0 1130 y(outlined)c(in)h(this)f
(section.)66 b(It)38 b(calculates)j(the)d(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)40 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f(sending)e(comp)s(ound)g(R)-8
b(TCP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(to)0 1243 y(divide)d(the)g(allo)m(w)m(ed)i
(con)m(trol)g(tra\016c)f(bandwidth)d(among)j(the)f(participan)m(ts.)62
b(This)36 b(allo)m(ws)j(an)e(application)0 1355 y(to)e(pro)m(vide)g
(fast)g(resp)s(onse)e(for)i(small)g(sessions)f(where,)h(for)g(example,)
h(iden)m(ti\014cation)g(of)f(all)g(participan)m(ts)h(is)0
1468 y(imp)s(ortan)m(t,)43 b(y)m(et)e(automatically)i(adapt)d(to)h
(large)g(sessions.)70 b(The)40 b(algorithm)h(incorp)s(orates)f(the)g
(follo)m(wing)0 1581 y(c)m(haracteristics:)136 1788 y
Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)25 b(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)27
b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f(R)-8 b(TCP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(scales)f(linearly)
g(with)g(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(mem)m(b)s(ers)e(in)227
1901 y(the)32 b(group.)44 b(It)31 b(is)h(this)f(linear)h(factor)g(whic)
m(h)g(allo)m(ws)g(for)g(a)g(constan)m(t)g(amoun)m(t)g(of)g(con)m(trol)h
(tra\016c)f(when)227 2014 y(summed)d(across)i(all)h(mem)m(b)s(ers.)136
2200 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)40 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)41
b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)g(R)-8 b(TCP)40 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(is)e(v)-5
b(aried)40 b(randomly)g(o)m(v)m(er)h(the)f(range)h([0.5,1.5])i(times)e
(the)227 2312 y(calculated)j(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)44 b(to)f(a)m(v)m(oid)h
(unin)m(tended)d(sync)m(hronization)i(of)g(all)g(participan)m(ts)g([20)
q(].)77 b(The)42 b(\014rst)227 2425 y(R)-8 b(TCP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j
(sen)m(t)e(after)g(joining)f(a)h(session)g(is)g(also)g(dela)m(y)m(ed)h
(b)m(y)e(a)h(random)f(v)-5 b(ariation)38 b(of)e(half)h(the)227
2538 y(minim)m(um)30 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al.)136
2724 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(A)e(dynamic)g(estimate)i(of)e(the)g(a)m(v)m
(erage)i(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)43 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(size)f(is)f
(calculated,)49 b(including)227 2837 y(all)d(those)f(receiv)m(ed)i(and)
d(sen)m(t,)49 b(to)d(automatically)h(adapt)e(to)h(c)m(hanges)g(in)e
(the)h(amoun)m(t)g(of)g(con)m(trol)227 2950 y(information)31
b(carried.)136 3135 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Since)33 b(the)f(calculated)j(in)
m(terv)-5 b(al)34 b(is)e(dep)s(enden)m(t)g(on)g(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e
(of)i(observ)m(ed)f(group)g(mem)m(b)s(ers,)h(there)227
3248 y(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(undesirable)g(startup)h(e\013ects)h(when)e(a)i
(new)e(user)g(joins)h(an)g(existing)h(session,)g(or)f(man)m(y)g(users)
227 3361 y(sim)m(ultaneously)h(join)g(a)g(new)f(session.)46
b(These)33 b(new)f(users)f(will)i(initially)h(ha)m(v)m(e)f(incorrect)h
(estimates)g(of)227 3474 y(the)j(group)e(mem)m(b)s(ership,)i(and)e(th)m
(us)h(their)h(R)-8 b(TCP)35 b(transmission)h(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)38 b(will)e(b)s(e)g(to)s(o)h(short.)58 b(This)227
3587 y(problem)33 b(can)h(b)s(e)f(signi\014can)m(t)i(if)e(man)m(y)h
(users)f(join)g(the)h(session)g(sim)m(ultaneously)-8
b(.)51 b(T)-8 b(o)34 b(deal)g(with)g(this,)227 3700 y(an)25
b(algorithm)i(called)f(\\timer)g(reconsideration")h(is)e(emplo)m(y)m
(ed.)40 b(This)24 b(algorithm)j(implemen)m(ts)e(a)h(simple)227
3813 y(bac)m(k-o\013)33 b(mec)m(hanism)e(whic)m(h)g(causes)g(users)g
(to)g(hold)g(bac)m(k)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(transmission)c
(if)h(the)g(group)227 3926 y(sizes)g(are)g(increasing.)136
4111 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(When)22 b(users)e(lea)m(v)m(e)k(a)e(session,)i
(either)e(with)f(a)h(BYE)g(or)g(b)m(y)f(timeout,)k(the)d(group)f(mem)m
(b)s(ership)f(decreases,)227 4224 y(and)38 b(th)m(us)f(the)h
(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)39 b(should)e(decrease.)64
b(A)38 b(\\rev)m(erse)h(reconsideration")g(algorithm)g(is)227
4337 y(used)22 b(to)h(allo)m(w)h(mem)m(b)s(ers)e(to)h(more)g(quic)m
(kly)g(reduce)f(their)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(als)23 b(in)g(resp)s(onse)e(to)i
(group)f(mem)m(b)s(ership)227 4450 y(decreases.)136 4636
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(BYE)38 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(are)f(giv)m(en)g(di\013eren)
m(t)g(treatmen)m(t)h(than)e(other)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)63
b(When)37 b(a)h(user)f(lea)m(v)m(es)227 4749 y(a)h(group,)i(and)d
(wishes)g(to)h(send)f(a)i(BYE)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(it)e(ma)m(y)f(do)g(so)g
(b)s(efore)f(its)h(next)g(sc)m(heduled)f(R)-8 b(TCP)227
4862 y(pac)m(k)m(et.)57 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)39 b(transmission)c(of)g
(BYEs)g(follo)m(ws)h(a)g(bac)m(k-o\013)g(algorithm)h(whic)m(h)d(a)m(v)m
(oids)j(\015o)s(o)s(ds)d(of)227 4975 y(BYE)d(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(should)e
(a)g(large)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(of)h(mem)m(b)s(ers)g(sim)m(ultaneously)h
(lea)m(v)m(e)i(the)e(session.)141 5181 y(This)g(algorithm)i(ma)m(y)g(b)
s(e)e(used)g(for)h(sessions)g(in)g(whic)m(h)g(all)g(participan)m(ts)h
(are)g(allo)m(w)m(ed)h(to)e(send.)45 b(In)31 b(that)0
5294 y(case,)36 b(the)f(session)f(bandwidth)e(parameter)j(is)f(the)g
(pro)s(duct)f(of)h(the)g(individual)g(sender's)f(bandwidth)f(times)0
5407 y(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(participan)m(ts,)i(and)d(the)i(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(bandwidth)e(is)j(5\045)f(of)h(that.)0 5656
y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(21])p eop
%%Page: 22 22
22 21 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(Details)k(of)f(the)f(algorithm's)h(op)s(eration)g(are)f(giv)m(en)i
(in)d(the)i(sections)g(that)g(follo)m(w.)50 b(App)s(endix)32
b(A.7)i(giv)m(es)0 511 y(an)c(example)h(implemen)m(tation.)0
752 y Fl(6.2.1)105 b(Main)m(taining)36 b(the)e(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(of)g
(session)h(mem)m(b)s(ers)0 923 y Fq(Calculation)e(of)e(the)g(R)-8
b(TCP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)33 b(dep)s(ends)d(up)s(on)h
(an)h(estimate)i(of)e(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(sites)h(partic-)0
1036 y(ipating)k(in)g(the)g(session.)60 b(New)37 b(sites)g(are)g(added)
f(to)i(the)e(coun)m(t)i(when)d(they)i(are)g(heard,)h(and)f(an)f(en)m
(try)h(for)0 1149 y(eac)m(h)g Fi(should)c Fq(b)s(e)i(created)i(in)e(a)h
(table)g(indexed)f(b)m(y)h(the)f(SSR)m(C)g(or)g(CSR)m(C)g(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(\(see)g(Section)g(8.2\))h(to)0 1262 y(k)m(eep)e(trac)m(k)g
(of)f(them.)52 b(New)34 b(en)m(tries)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35
b Fq(b)s(e)f(considered)g(not)g(v)-5 b(alid)34 b(un)m(til)h(m)m
(ultiple)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(carrying)g(the)0 1375 y(new)g(SSR)m(C)g(ha)m
(v)m(e)h(b)s(een)f(receiv)m(ed)i(\(see)g(App)s(endix)d(A.1\),)k(or)e
(un)m(til)f(an)h(SDES)f(R)-8 b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(con)m(taining)h
(a)0 1488 y(CNAME)28 b(for)f(that)h(SSR)m(C)e(has)h(b)s(een)g(receiv)m
(ed.)81 b(En)m(tries)27 b Fi(ma)-6 b(y)29 b Fq(b)s(e)e(deleted)h(from)f
(the)g(table)i(when)d(an)h(R)-8 b(TCP)0 1601 y(BYE)36
b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(with)d(the)h(corresp)s(onding)f(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(is)g(receiv)m(ed,)j(except)d(that)h(some)f(straggler)h
(data)0 1714 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)28 b(migh)m(t)e(arriv)m(e)g(after)h(the)f
(BYE)g(and)f(cause)h(the)g(en)m(try)g(to)g(b)s(e)g(recreated.)40
b(Instead,)27 b(the)e(en)m(try)j Fi(should)0 1826 y Fq(b)s(e)i(mark)m
(ed)g(as)h(ha)m(ving)g(receiv)m(ed)h(a)e(BYE)h(and)f(then)g(deleted)h
(after)g(an)f(appropriate)h(dela)m(y)-8 b(.)141 1939
y(A)30 b(participan)m(t)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(mark)f(another)g(site)g
(inactiv)m(e,)j(or)c(delete)j(it)e(if)g(not)g(y)m(et)h(v)-5
b(alid,)30 b(if)g(no)g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(or)f(R)-8 b(TCP)0
2052 y(pac)m(k)m(et)31 b(has)d(b)s(een)g(receiv)m(ed)i(for)e(a)h(small)
g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(als)30 b(\(5)f(is)g Fi(recommended)p Fq(\).)38 b(This)0
2165 y(pro)m(vides)27 b(some)g(robustness)f(against)i(pac)m(k)m(et)h
(loss.)40 b(All)28 b(sites)f(m)m(ust)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h(the)f(same)g(v)-5
b(alue)28 b(for)f(this)f(m)m(ultiplier)0 2278 y(and)31
b(m)m(ust)g(calculate)j(roughly)d(the)h(same)g(v)-5 b(alue)32
b(for)f(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)32 b(in)f(order)g(for)h(this)f(timeout)0 2391 y(to)g(w)m(ork)g
(prop)s(erly)-8 b(.)40 b(Therefore,)30 b(this)g(m)m(ultiplier)h
Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)g(\014xed)h(for)g(a)h(particular)g(pro\014le.)141
2504 y(F)-8 b(or)42 b(sessions)g(with)f(a)g(v)m(ery)h(large)h(n)m(um)m
(b)s(er)d(of)h(participan)m(ts,)46 b(it)41 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f
(impractical)i(to)f(main)m(tain)h(a)0 2617 y(table)34
b(to)f(store)g(the)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(and)f(state)i
(information)f(for)f(all)i(of)f(them.)47 b(An)32 b(implemen)m(tation)j
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)0 2730 y Fq(use)33 b(SSR)m(C)f(sampling,)i(as)f(describ)s
(ed)f(in)g([21)r(],)i(to)f(reduce)g(the)g(storage)i(requiremen)m(ts.)49
b(An)32 b(implemen)m(tation)0 2843 y Fi(ma)-6 b(y)34
b Fq(use)e(an)m(y)i(other)f(algorithm)h(with)e(similar)h(p)s
(erformance.)48 b(A)33 b(k)m(ey)g(requiremen)m(t)g(is)g(that)h(an)m(y)f
(algorithm)0 2956 y(considered)27 b Fi(should)j(not)d
Fq(substan)m(tially)i(underestimate)f(the)f(group)g(size,)j(although)e
(it)g Fi(ma)-6 b(y)29 b Fq(o)m(v)m(erestimate.)0 3199
y Fo(6.3)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)h(Send)h(and)h(Receiv)m
(e)e(Rules)0 3371 y Fq(The)30 b(rules)h(for)g(ho)m(w)g(to)g(send,)g
(and)f(what)h(to)h(do)e(when)g(receiving)j(an)d(R)-8
b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(are)e(outlined)g(here.)42 b(An)0
3484 y(implemen)m(tation)32 b(that)g(allo)m(ws)g(op)s(eration)f(in)f(a)
h(m)m(ulticast)h(en)m(vironmen)m(t)g(or)e(a)h(m)m(ultip)s(oin)m(t)h
(unicast)f(en)m(viron-)0 3596 y(men)m(t)g Fi(must)e Fq(meet)i(the)f
(requiremen)m(ts)g(in)g(Section)h(6.2.)41 b(Suc)m(h)30
b(an)g(implemen)m(tation)i Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(use)f(the)g(algorithm)0
3709 y(de\014ned)h(in)g(this)h(section)h(to)g(meet)g(those)f
(requiremen)m(ts,)h(or)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)33 b Fq(use)f(some)g(other)g
(algorithm)h(so)g(long)f(as)g(it)0 3822 y(pro)m(vides)h(equiv)-5
b(alen)m(t)35 b(or)f(b)s(etter)f(p)s(erformance.)50 b(An)33
b(implemen)m(tation)i(whic)m(h)e(is)h(constrained)g(to)g(t)m(w)m
(o-part)m(y)0 3935 y(unicast)e(op)s(eration)g Fi(should)e
Fq(still)j(use)f(randomization)g(of)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)31
b(transmission)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)33 b(to)f(a)m(v)m(oid)i(un-)0
4048 y(in)m(tended)e(sync)m(hronization)i(of)f(m)m(ultiple)g(instances)
g(op)s(erating)g(in)g(the)f(same)h(en)m(vironmen)m(t,)i(but)c
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)34 b Fq(omit)0 4161 y(the)i(\\timer)g(reconsideration")h
(and)e(\\rev)m(erse)h(reconsideration")h(algorithms)f(in)f(Sections)i
(6.3.3,)h(6.3.6)g(and)0 4274 y(6.3.7.)141 4387 y(T)-8
b(o)31 b(execute)h(these)f(rules,)f(a)h(session)f(participan)m(t)h(m)m
(ust)g(main)m(tain)g(sev)m(eral)h(pieces)f(of)f(state:)0
4599 y Fl(tp:)45 b Fq(the)31 b(last)g(time)g(an)f(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(w)m(as)d(transmitted;)0 4787
y Fl(tc:)46 b Fq(the)30 b(curren)m(t)g(time;)0 4975 y
Fl(tn:)45 b Fq(the)31 b(next)f(sc)m(heduled)g(transmission)g(time)i(of)
e(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et;)0 5162 y Fl(pmem)m(b)s(ers:)46
b Fq(the)31 b(estimated)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(session)f(mem)m(b)s
(ers)g(at)h(the)g(time)g(tn)f(w)m(as)h(last)g(recomputed;)0
5350 y Fl(mem)m(b)s(ers:)46 b Fq(the)31 b(most)f(curren)m(t)g(estimate)
j(for)d(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(session)f(mem)m(b)s(ers;)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(22])p eop
%%Page: 23 23
23 22 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(senders:)46 b Fq(the)31 b(most)f(curren)m(t)g(estimate)j(for)d
(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(senders)e(in)h(the)h(session;)0
586 y Fl(rtcp)p 194 586 32 4 v 38 w(b)m(w:)45 b Fq(The)d(target)i(R)-8
b(TCP)41 b(bandwidth,)j(i.e.,)i(the)d(total)h(bandwidth)c(that)j(will)f
(b)s(e)g(used)f(for)h(R)-8 b(TCP)227 699 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)32
b(b)m(y)e(all)i(mem)m(b)s(ers)d(of)h(this)h(session,)f(in)g(o)s(ctets)i
(p)s(er)d(second.)40 b(This)30 b(will)g(b)s(e)g(a)h(sp)s(eci\014ed)e
(fraction)227 812 y(of)i(the)f(\\session)h(bandwidth")e(parameter)i
(supplied)e(to)i(the)g(application)h(at)f(startup.)0
1000 y Fl(w)m(e)p 127 1000 V 37 w(sen)m(t:)46 b Fq(Flag)37
b(that)f(is)g(true)g(if)f(the)h(application)h(has)f(sen)m(t)g(data)h
(since)f(the)g(2nd)f(previous)g(R)-8 b(TCP)36 b(rep)s(ort)227
1112 y(w)m(as)31 b(transmitted.)0 1300 y Fl(a)m(vg)p
161 1300 V 38 w(rtcp)p 387 1300 V 38 w(size:)46 b Fq(The)33
b(a)m(v)m(erage)j(comp)s(ound)c(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(size,)f
(in)f(o)s(ctets,)i(o)m(v)m(er)f(all)f(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(sen)m(t)227 1413 y(and)23 b(receiv)m(ed)i(b)m(y)f(this)f(participan)m
(t.)40 b(The)23 b(size)i(includes)e(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)k(transp)s
(ort)22 b(and)i(net)m(w)m(ork)g(proto)s(col)227 1526
y(headers)30 b(\(e.g.,)j(UDP)d(and)g(IP\))h(as)f(explained)h(in)f
(Section)h(6.2.)0 1714 y Fl(initial:)45 b Fq(Flag)32
b(that)f(is)f(true)h(if)f(the)g(application)i(has)e(not)h(y)m(et)g(sen)
m(t)g(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)141 1926 y(Man)m(y)k(of)g
(these)g(rules)g(mak)m(e)g(use)g(of)f(the)h(\\calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5
b(al")35 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)e(pac)m(k)m(et)i(transmissions.)47
b(This)0 2039 y(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)32 b(is)e(describ)s(ed)f(in)h(the)h
(follo)m(wing)h(section.)0 2279 y Fl(6.3.1)105 b(Computing)35
b(the)g(R)-9 b(TCP)35 b(transmission)h(in)m(terv)-6 b(al)0
2451 y Fq(T)e(o)25 b(main)m(tain)g(scalabilit)m(y)-8
b(,)28 b(the)d(a)m(v)m(erage)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)26 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)
f(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(from)d(a)i(session)f(participan)m(t)h(should)f(scale)
0 2564 y(with)37 b(the)h(group)g(size.)63 b(This)37 b(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)39 b(is)f(called)h(the)f(calculated)h(in)m(terv)-5
b(al.)64 b(It)38 b(is)g(obtained)g(b)m(y)f(com)m(bining)0
2677 y(a)d(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(the)h(pieces)g(of)f(state)i(describ)s
(ed)d(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e.)51 b(The)33 b(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)34 b(T)f(is)h(then)f(determined)g(as)0 2789 y(follo)m(ws:)111
3002 y(1.)46 b(If)32 b(there)g(are)h(an)m(y)g(senders)e(\(senders)h
Fg(>)f Fq(0\))i(in)f(the)h(session,)g(but)e(the)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)
h(senders)f(is)i(less)f(than)227 3115 y(25\045)43 b(of)f(the)g(mem)m(b)
s(ership)e(\(mem)m(b)s(ers\),)45 b(the)d(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)43 b(dep)s(ends)d(on)i(whether)f(the)h(participan)m(t)h(is)f(a)227
3228 y(sender)33 b(or)h(not)g(\(based)g(on)f(the)h(v)-5
b(alue)34 b(of)g(w)m(e)p 1828 3228 28 4 v 33 w(sen)m(t\).)52
b(If)33 b(the)h(participan)m(t)h(is)f(a)g(sender)f(\(w)m(e)p
3456 3228 V 33 w(sen)m(t)i(true\),)227 3341 y(the)c(constan)m(t)h(C)f
(is)f(set)i(to)f(the)g(a)m(v)m(erage)i(R)-8 b(TCP)31
b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(size)g(\(a)m(vg)p 2593 3341 V 34 w(rtcp)p
2789 3341 V 33 w(size\))g(divided)e(b)m(y)h(25\045)g(of)g(the)227
3454 y(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(bandwidth)e(\(rtcp)p 1172 3454
V 33 w(b)m(w\),)i(and)f(the)i(constan)m(t)g(n)e(is)h(set)g(to)h(the)f
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(senders.)48 b(If)32 b(w)m(e)p
3712 3454 V 33 w(sen)m(t)227 3567 y(is)38 b(not)h(true,)h(the)e
(constan)m(t)i(C)e(is)g(set)g(to)h(the)g(a)m(v)m(erage)h(R)-8
b(TCP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(size)f(divided)f(b)m(y)g(75\045)g(of)h(the)
227 3679 y(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(bandwidth.)39 b(The)29 b(constan)m(t)i(n)e
(is)g(set)h(to)h(the)e(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(of)g(receiv)m(ers)i(\(mem)m(b)
s(ers)e Fj(\000)h Fq(senders\).)39 b(If)227 3792 y(the)34
b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(senders)f(is)h(greater)i(than)e(25\045,)i
(senders)d(and)g(receiv)m(ers)j(are)f(treated)g(together.)50
b(The)227 3905 y(constan)m(t)28 b(C)e(is)h(set)g(to)g(the)g(a)m(v)m
(erage)i(R)-8 b(TCP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(size)g(divided)d(b)m(y)i(the)g
(total)h(R)-8 b(TCP)26 b(bandwidth)f(and)227 4018 y(n)30
b(is)g(set)h(to)h(the)e(total)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(of)i(mem)m(b)s(ers.)
111 4206 y(2.)46 b(If)28 b(the)g(participan)m(t)i(has)e(not)g(y)m(et)h
(sen)m(t)g(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(\(the)f(v)-5
b(ariable)29 b(initial)g(is)f(true\),)h(the)g(constan)m(t)227
4319 y(Tmin)h(is)g(set)h(to)g(2.5)h(seconds,)e(else)h(it)g(is)g(set)g
(to)g(5)g(seconds.)111 4506 y(3.)46 b(The)30 b(deterministic)h
(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)31 b(Td)f(is)g(set)h(to)g(max\(Tmin,)f
(n*C\).)111 4694 y(4.)46 b(The)28 b(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)30 b(T)d(is)i(set)f(to)h(a)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(uniformly)g
(distributed)g(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)i(0.5)g(and)f(1.5)h(times)227
4807 y(the)i(deterministic)g(calculated)h(in)m(terv)-5
b(al.)111 4995 y(5.)46 b(The)38 b(resulting)h(v)-5 b(alue)39
b(of)g(T)f(is)h(divided)f(b)m(y)g Fg(e)26 b Fj(\000)g
Fq(3)p Fg(=)p Fq(2)40 b(=)f(1)p Fg(:)p Fq(21828)i(to)e(comp)s(ensate)h
(for)e(the)h(fact)g(that)227 5107 y(the)32 b(timer)g(reconsideration)h
(algorithm)f(con)m(v)m(erges)i(to)e(a)g(v)-5 b(alue)32
b(of)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(bandwidth)f(b)s(elo)m(w)i(the)227
5220 y(in)m(tended)e(a)m(v)m(erage.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(23])p eop
%%Page: 24 24
24 23 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(This)25 b(pro)s(cedure)f(results)i(in)f(an)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(al)27 b(whic)m(h)e(is)h(random,)g(but)f(whic)m(h,)h(on)g(a)m(v)m
(erage,)j(giv)m(es)e(at)g(least)f(25\045)0 511 y(of)33
b(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(bandwidth)f(to)j(senders)e(and)g(the)h(rest)g
(to)g(receiv)m(ers.)50 b(If)32 b(the)h(senders)f(constitute)i(more)f
(than)0 624 y(one)26 b(quarter)f(of)g(the)h(mem)m(b)s(ership,)f(this)h
(pro)s(cedure)e(splits)h(the)h(bandwidth)d(equally)k(among)e(all)i
(participan)m(ts,)0 737 y(on)j(a)m(v)m(erage.)0 976 y
Fl(6.3.2)105 b(Initialization)0 1148 y Fq(Up)s(on)32
b(joining)h(the)g(session,)h(the)f(participan)m(t)h(initializes)h(tp)d
(to)i(0,)g(tc)g(to)f(0,)h(senders)e(to)i(0,)g(pmem)m(b)s(ers)e(to)h(1,)
0 1261 y(mem)m(b)s(ers)g(to)i(1,)g(w)m(e)p 716 1261 28
4 v 33 w(sen)m(t)g(to)f(false,)i(rtcp)p 1454 1261 V 33
w(b)m(w)d(to)i(the)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(fraction)h(of)g(the)h(session)f
(bandwidth,)f(initial)0 1374 y(to)i(true,)g(and)f(a)m(vg)p
658 1374 V 34 w(rtcp)p 854 1374 V 33 w(size)h(to)g(the)g(probable)f
(size)h(of)f(the)h(\014rst)e(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(that)f(the)
g(application)h(will)0 1487 y(later)e(construct.)50 b(The)33
b(calculated)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)35 b(T)d(is)i(then)f(computed,)h(and)f
(the)g(\014rst)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)e(sc)m(heduled)g(for)0
1599 y(time)g(tn)g(=)f(T.)48 b(This)32 b(means)g(that)i(a)f
(transmission)f(timer)h(is)g(set)g(whic)m(h)g(expires)f(at)i(time)f(T.)
48 b(Note)34 b(that)f(an)0 1712 y(application)f Fi(ma)-6
b(y)31 b Fq(use)f(an)m(y)h(desired)f(approac)m(h)g(for)h(implemen)m
(ting)g(this)f(timer.)141 1825 y(The)g(participan)m(t)h(adds)f(its)h(o)
m(wn)f(SSR)m(C)g(to)h(the)f(mem)m(b)s(er)g(table.)0 2064
y Fl(6.3.3)105 b(Receiving)37 b(an)d(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(or)f(non-BYE)g(R)-9
b(TCP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et)0 2236 y Fq(When)d(an)g(R)-8
b(TP)33 b(or)h(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(is)d(receiv)m(ed)i(from)e
(a)g(participan)m(t)i(whose)e(SSR)m(C)f(is)h(not)h(in)f(the)h(mem)m(b)s
(er)0 2349 y(table,)e(the)f(SSR)m(C)f(is)h(added)g(to)g(the)g(table,)i
(and)d(the)h(v)-5 b(alue)32 b(for)e(mem)m(b)s(ers)g(is)h(up)s(dated)f
(once)i(the)f(participan)m(t)0 2462 y(has)h(b)s(een)g(v)-5
b(alidated)33 b(as)g(describ)s(ed)e(in)h(Section)h(6.2.1.)49
b(The)31 b(same)i(pro)s(cessing)f(o)s(ccurs)g(for)g(eac)m(h)i(CSR)m(C)e
(in)g(a)0 2575 y(v)-5 b(alidated)31 b(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)141
2688 y(When)d(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)e(receiv)m(ed)i
(from)d(a)h(participan)m(t)h(whose)f(SSR)m(C)f(is)h(not)g(in)g(the)g
(sender)f(table,)j(the)0 2800 y(SSR)m(C)f(is)i(added)e(to)j(the)e
(table,)i(and)d(the)i(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(for)f(senders)f(is)i(up)s
(dated.)141 2913 y(F)-8 b(or)31 b(eac)m(h)h(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(receiv)m(ed,)g(the)e(v)-5 b(alue)31
b(of)g(a)m(vg)p 2528 2913 V 34 w(rtcp)p 2724 2913 V 33
w(size)g(is)f(up)s(dated:)732 3095 y(a)m(vg)p 872 3095
V 34 w(rtcp)p 1068 3095 V 33 w(size)h(=)f(\(1/16\))j(*)e(pac)m(k)m(et)p
1986 3095 V 34 w(size)h(+)e(\(15/16\))j(*)e(a)m(vg)p
2833 3095 V 34 w(rtcp)p 3029 3095 V 32 w(size)0 3277
y(where)f(pac)m(k)m(et)p 521 3277 V 35 w(size)h(is)f(the)h(size)g(of)g
(the)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(just)e(receiv)m(ed.)0
3516 y Fl(6.3.4)105 b(Receiving)37 b(an)d(R)-9 b(TCP)36
b(BYE)f(pac)m(k)m(et)0 3687 y Fq(Except)d(as)g(describ)s(ed)e(in)i
(Section)g(6.3.7)h(for)f(the)f(case)i(when)e(an)g(R)-8
b(TCP)31 b(BYE)h(is)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(transmitted,)h(if)g(the)0
3800 y(receiv)m(ed)25 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(is)e(an)g(R)-8
b(TCP)24 b(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et,)k(the)c(SSR)m(C)f(is)h(c)m(hec)m(k)m(ed)
i(against)f(the)f(mem)m(b)s(er)g(table.)39 b(If)24 b(presen)m(t,)0
3913 y(the)38 b(en)m(try)g(is)f(remo)m(v)m(ed)i(from)e(the)g(table,)k
(and)c(the)h(v)-5 b(alue)38 b(for)f(mem)m(b)s(ers)g(is)g(up)s(dated.)61
b(The)37 b(SSR)m(C)g(is)g(then)0 4026 y(c)m(hec)m(k)m(ed)30
b(against)g(the)f(sender)f(table.)41 b(If)28 b(presen)m(t,)h(the)f(en)m
(try)h(is)g(remo)m(v)m(ed)g(from)f(the)h(table,)h(and)e(the)g(v)-5
b(alue)29 b(for)0 4139 y(senders)g(is)i(up)s(dated.)141
4252 y(F)-8 b(urthermore,)25 b(to)f(mak)m(e)g(the)g(transmission)f
(rate)h(of)f(R)-8 b(TCP)23 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(more)f(adaptiv)m(e)g(to)g
(c)m(hanges)g(in)f(group)0 4365 y(mem)m(b)s(ership,)32
b(the)i(follo)m(wing)g(\\rev)m(erse)g(reconsideration")h(algorithm)f
Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)h(executed)i(when)e(a)i(BYE)0 4478
y(pac)m(k)m(et)e(is)f(receiv)m(ed)h(that)e(reduces)g(mem)m(b)s(ers)g
(to)h(a)g(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(less)f(than)h(pmem)m(b)s(ers:)136
4683 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(for)f(tn)g(is)h(up)s
(dated)e(according)i(to)g(the)g(follo)m(wing)h(form)m(ula:)1199
4924 y(tn)e(=)g(tc)h(+)f(\(mem)m(b)s(ers/pmem)m(b)s(ers\))g(*)h(\(tn)f
(-)h(tc\))136 5166 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(v)-5 b(alue)31
b(for)f(tp)g(is)h(up)s(dated)e(according)i(the)g(follo)m(wing)h(form)m
(ula:)1207 5407 y(tp)e(=)g(tc)h(-)g(\(mem)m(b)s(ers/pmem)m(b)s(ers\))e
(*)i(\(tc)g(-)g(tp\).)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(24])p eop
%%Page: 25 25
25 24 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)136 399
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(next)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)e
(resc)m(heduled)g(for)h(transmission)f(at)h(time)g(tn,)f(whic)m(h)g(is)
h(no)m(w)f(earlier.)136 586 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30
b(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(of)g(pmem)m(b)s(ers)e(is)h(set)h(equal)g(to)g(mem)m
(b)s(ers.)141 796 y(This)h(algorithm)h(do)s(es)g(not)f(prev)m(en)m(t)h
(the)g(group)f(size)h(estimate)i(from)d(incorrectly)h(dropping)f(to)h
(zero)g(for)0 909 y(a)38 b(short)f(time)h(due)e(to)i(premature)f
(timeouts)h(when)e(most)i(participan)m(ts)g(of)f(a)h(large)g(session)g
(lea)m(v)m(e)h(at)f(once)0 1022 y(but)29 b(some)h(remain.)41
b(The)29 b(algorithm)i(do)s(es)f(mak)m(e)g(the)g(estimate)i(return)d
(to)h(the)g(correct)h(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(more)f(rapidly)-8
b(.)0 1135 y(This)30 b(situation)i(is)g(un)m(usual)e(enough)h(and)f
(the)i(consequences)f(are)h(su\016cien)m(tly)g(harmless)f(that)g(this)h
(problem)0 1248 y(is)e(deemed)h(only)f(a)h(secondary)f(concern.)0
1488 y Fl(6.3.5)105 b(Timing)36 b(Out)e(an)g(SSR)m(C)0
1659 y Fq(A)m(t)40 b(o)s(ccasional)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(als,)43
b(the)c(participan)m(t)i Fi(must)d Fq(c)m(hec)m(k)j(to)f(see)g(if)f(an)
m(y)h(of)g(the)f(other)h(participan)m(ts)g(time)0 1772
y(out.)65 b(T)-8 b(o)38 b(do)g(this,)j(the)d(participan)m(t)h(computes)
g(the)f(deterministic)h(\(without)g(the)f(randomization)i(factor\))0
1885 y(calculated)28 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)27 b(Td)d(for)i(a)g(receiv)m
(er,)i(that)f(is,)g(with)e(w)m(e)p 2067 1885 28 4 v 33
w(sen)m(t)h(false.)40 b(An)m(y)26 b(other)g(session)g(mem)m(b)s(er)f
(who)g(has)0 1998 y(not)32 b(sen)m(t)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TP)32
b(or)h(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(since)f(time)g(tc)g(-)f(MTd)g
(\(M)h(is)f(the)h(timeout)g(m)m(ultiplier,)g(and)f(defaults)0
2111 y(to)j(5\))h(is)f(timed)g(out.)54 b(This)34 b(means)g(that)i(its)f
(SSR)m(C)e(is)i(remo)m(v)m(ed)h(from)e(the)h(mem)m(b)s(er)f(list,)j
(and)d(mem)m(b)s(ers)g(is)0 2224 y(up)s(dated.)40 b(A)30
b(similar)h(c)m(hec)m(k)h(is)e(p)s(erformed)f(on)i(the)f(sender)g
(list.)41 b(An)m(y)31 b(mem)m(b)s(er)f(on)g(the)h(sender)e(list)i(who)f
(has)0 2337 y(not)g(sen)m(t)g(an)f(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(since)
f(time)g(tc)g(-)g(2T)f(\(within)h(the)f(last)h(t)m(w)m(o)h(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(als\))31 b(is)e(remo)m(v)m(ed)0
2450 y(from)h(the)g(sender)g(list,)h(and)f(senders)g(is)g(up)s(dated.)
141 2563 y(If)46 b(an)m(y)h(mem)m(b)s(ers)f(time)h(out,)k(the)46
b(rev)m(erse)h(reconsideration)h(algorithm)f(describ)s(ed)f(in)g
(Section)h(6.3.4)0 2675 y Fi(should)29 b Fq(b)s(e)g(p)s(erformed.)141
2788 y(The)h(participan)m(t)h Fi(must)f Fq(p)s(erform)f(this)h(c)m(hec)
m(k)i(at)f(least)h(once)f(p)s(er)e(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(transmission)g(in)m
(terv)-5 b(al.)0 3028 y Fl(6.3.6)105 b(Expiration)35
b(of)g(transmission)h(timer)0 3200 y Fq(When)30 b(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h
(transmission)e(timer)h(expires,)f(the)h(participan)m(t)g(p)s(erforms)e
(the)i(follo)m(wing)h(op)s(erations:)136 3386 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(The)27 b(transmission)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)28 b(T)f(is)g(computed)g
(as)h(describ)s(ed)e(in)g(Section)i(6.3.1,)i(including)d(the)g(random-)
227 3499 y(ization)32 b(factor.)136 3686 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(If)35 b(tp)g(+)g(T)g(is)h(less)g(than)f(or)g(equal)h(to)g(tc,)i
(an)d(R)-8 b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)f(transmitted.)56
b(tp)35 b(is)h(set)f(to)i(tc,)g(then)227 3799 y(another)45
b(v)-5 b(alue)44 b(for)g(T)g(is)g(calculated)i(as)e(in)g(the)g
(previous)g(step)g(and)f(tn)h(is)g(set)h(to)g(tc)f(+)g(T.)81
b(The)227 3912 y(transmission)30 b(timer)h(is)f(set)h(to)g(expire)f
(again)i(at)f(time)g(tn.)40 b(If)30 b(tp)g(+)g(T)g(is)g(greater)i(than)
e(tc,)h(tn)f(is)g(set)h(to)227 4025 y(tp)f(+)f(T.)40
b(No)30 b(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)e(transmitted.)41
b(The)29 b(transmission)g(timer)h(is)g(set)g(to)g(expire)g(at)h(time)f
(tn.)136 4212 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(pmem)m(b)s(ers)29 b(is)i(set)g(to)g
(mem)m(b)s(ers.)141 4398 y(If)f(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)
e(transmitted,)g(the)g(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(of)f(initial)h(is)f(set)g(to)h
(F)-10 b(ALSE.)40 b(F)-8 b(urthermore,)30 b(the)g(v)-5
b(alue)0 4511 y(of)31 b(a)m(vg)p 244 4511 V 34 w(rtcp)p
440 4511 V 32 w(size)g(is)g(up)s(dated:)732 4697 y(a)m(vg)p
872 4697 V 34 w(rtcp)p 1068 4697 V 33 w(size)g(=)f(\(1/16\))j(*)e(pac)m
(k)m(et)p 1986 4697 V 34 w(size)h(+)e(\(15/16\))j(*)e(a)m(vg)p
2833 4697 V 34 w(rtcp)p 3029 4697 V 32 w(size)0 4883
y(where)f(pac)m(k)m(et)p 521 4883 V 35 w(size)h(is)f(the)h(size)g(of)g
(the)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(just)e(transmitted.)0
5123 y Fl(6.3.7)105 b(T)-9 b(ransmitting)35 b(a)g(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)0
5294 y Fq(When)j(a)h(participan)m(t)h(wishes)e(to)h(lea)m(v)m(e)i(a)e
(session,)i(a)e(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(is)f(transmitted)g(to)g(inform)f
(the)h(other)0 5407 y(participan)m(ts)33 b(of)e(the)h(ev)m(en)m(t.)47
b(In)31 b(order)g(to)h(a)m(v)m(oid)h(a)f(\015o)s(o)s(d)f(of)h(BYE)g
(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(when)e(man)m(y)h(participan)m(ts)h(lea)m(v)m(e)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(25])p eop
%%Page: 26 26
26 25 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(the)f(system,)h(a)f(participan)m(t)h Fi(must)e Fq(execute)j(the)e
(follo)m(wing)i(algorithm)f(if)f(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(mem)m(b)s
(ers)g(is)g(more)0 511 y(than)43 b(50)i(when)e(the)h(participan)m(t)g
(c)m(ho)s(oses)h(to)g(lea)m(v)m(e.)83 b(This)43 b(algorithm)h(usurps)e
(the)i(normal)f(role)i(of)f(the)0 624 y(mem)m(b)s(ers)30
b(v)-5 b(ariable)31 b(to)g(coun)m(t)g(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(instead:)
136 836 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(When)25 b(the)h(participan)m(t)h(decides)e
(to)h(lea)m(v)m(e)i(the)e(system,)g(tp)g(is)f(reset)h(to)g(tc,)i(the)d
(curren)m(t)g(time,)j(mem)m(b)s(ers)227 949 y(and)k(pmem)m(b)s(ers)f
(are)h(initialized)i(to)f(1,)g(initial)h(is)e(set)h(to)g(1,)g(w)m(e)p
2459 949 28 4 v 33 w(sen)m(t)g(is)f(set)h(to)g(false,)g(senders)e(is)h
(set)h(to)227 1062 y(0,)g(and)e(a)m(vg)p 648 1062 V 34
w(rtcp)p 844 1062 V 33 w(size)h(is)g(set)h(to)f(the)g(size)h(of)f(the)g
(comp)s(ound)e(BYE)i(pac)m(k)m(et.)47 b(The)31 b(calculated)j(in)m
(terv)-5 b(al)227 1175 y(T)30 b(is)h(computed.)40 b(The)30
b(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(is)f(then)f(sc)m(heduled)g(for)g(time)h(tn)f(=)g
(tc)h(+)f(T.)136 1362 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Ev)m(ery)f(time)h(a)f(BYE)h
(pac)m(k)m(et)h(from)d(another)h(participan)m(t)h(is)f(receiv)m(ed,)50
b(mem)m(b)s(ers)44 b(is)h(incremen)m(ted)227 1475 y(b)m(y)c(1)g
(regardless)h(of)f(whether)f(that)i(participan)m(t)g(exists)f(in)g(the)
g(mem)m(b)s(er)g(table)g(or)g(not,)k(and)40 b(when)227
1588 y(SSR)m(C)32 b(sampling)g(is)g(in)g(use,)h(regardless)f(of)h
(whether)e(or)h(not)h(the)f(BYE)h(SSR)m(C)e(w)m(ould)h(b)s(e)g
(included)f(in)227 1701 y(the)38 b(sample.)61 b(mem)m(b)s(ers)37
b(is)g(NOT)g(incremen)m(ted)h(when)e(other)h(R)-8 b(TCP)37
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(or)e(R)-8 b(TP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(are)227
1814 y(receiv)m(ed,)28 b(but)d(only)h(for)f(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(ets.)41
b(Similarly)-8 b(,)28 b(a)m(vg)p 2204 1814 V 34 w(rtcp)p
2400 1814 V 32 w(size)f(is)e(up)s(dated)g(only)g(for)h(receiv)m(ed)h
(BYE)227 1927 y(pac)m(k)m(ets.)43 b(senders)29 b(is)i(NOT)f(up)s(dated)
f(when)g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(arriv)m(e;)g(it)f(remains)f(0.)
136 2114 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(ransmission)43 b(of)h(the)g(BYE)f
(pac)m(k)m(et)j(then)d(follo)m(ws)i(the)e(rules)g(for)h(transmitting)g
(a)g(regular)f(R)-8 b(TCP)227 2227 y(pac)m(k)m(et,)33
b(as)d(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e.)141 2439 y(This)c(allo)m(ws)h(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m
(ets)h(to)f(b)s(e)f(sen)m(t)h(righ)m(t)g(a)m(w)m(a)m(y)-8
b(,)30 b(y)m(et)d(con)m(trols)h(their)e(total)j(bandwidth)24
b(usage.)40 b(In)26 b(the)0 2552 y(w)m(orst)j(case,)h(this)f(could)f
(cause)h(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(con)m(trol)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(to)e(use)f(t)m
(wice)i(the)f(bandwidth)e(as)i(normal)f(\(10\045\))i(|)0
2664 y(5\045)h(for)f(non)f(BYE)i(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(and)e
(5\045)g(for)h(BYE.)141 2777 y(A)j(participan)m(t)h(that)f(do)s(es)f
(not)h(w)m(an)m(t)h(to)f(w)m(ait)h(for)f(the)g(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)h(mec)m
(hanism)f(to)g(allo)m(w)h(transmission)f(of)g(a)0 2890
y(BYE)f(pac)m(k)m(et)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)34 b Fq(lea)m(v)m(e)g(the)f(group)f
(without)g(sending)g(a)h(BYE)g(at)g(all.)47 b(That)33
b(participan)m(t)g(will)g(ev)m(en)m(tually)0 3003 y(b)s(e)d(timed)g
(out)h(b)m(y)f(the)h(other)f(group)g(mem)m(b)s(ers.)141
3116 y(If)35 b(the)g(group)g(size)h(estimate)h(mem)m(b)s(ers)d(is)h
(less)h(than)f(50)h(when)e(the)h(participan)m(t)h(decides)g(to)g(lea)m
(v)m(e,)j(the)0 3229 y(participan)m(t)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)40
b Fq(send)e(a)h(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(immediately)-8 b(.)68
b(Alternativ)m(ely)-8 b(,)44 b(the)39 b(participan)m(t)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)40 b Fq(c)m(ho)s(ose)g(to)0 3342 y(execute)32
b(the)e(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)i(BYE)f(bac)m(k)m(o\013)h(algorithm.)141
3455 y(In)d(either)g(case,)i(a)f(participan)m(t)g(whic)m(h)f(nev)m(er)h
(sen)m(t)g(an)f(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(or)h(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k
Fi(must)g(not)c Fq(send)h(a)h(BYE)0 3568 y(pac)m(k)m(et)i(when)e(they)g
(lea)m(v)m(e)j(the)e(group.)0 3808 y Fl(6.3.8)105 b(Up)s(dating)36
b(w)m(e)p 912 3808 32 4 v 37 w(sen)m(t)0 3979 y Fq(The)30
b(v)-5 b(ariable)32 b(w)m(e)p 637 3979 28 4 v 33 w(sen)m(t)f(con)m
(tains)h(true)f(if)f(the)h(participan)m(t)h(has)e(sen)m(t)h(an)g(R)-8
b(TP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(recen)m(tly)-8 b(,)33 b(false)e(other-)0
4092 y(wise.)43 b(This)30 b(determination)i(is)f(made)h(b)m(y)f(using)f
(the)h(same)h(mec)m(hanisms)f(as)h(for)f(managing)g(the)h(set)f(of)h
(other)0 4205 y(participan)m(ts)37 b(listed)g(in)e(the)i(senders)e
(table.)59 b(If)35 b(the)i(participan)m(t)g(sends)e(an)h(R)-8
b(TP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(when)d(w)m(e)p 3615 4205 V 33
w(sen)m(t)i(is)0 4318 y(false,)d(it)e(adds)g(itself)h(to)g(the)f
(sender)f(table)i(and)f(sets)h(w)m(e)p 2014 4318 V 33
w(sen)m(t)g(to)f(true.)46 b(The)32 b(rev)m(erse)h(reconsideration)g
(algo-)0 4431 y(rithm)c(describ)s(ed)f(in)h(Section)h(6.3.4)i
Fi(should)27 b Fq(b)s(e)i(p)s(erformed)f(to)i(p)s(ossibly)e(reduce)i
(the)f(dela)m(y)i(b)s(efore)e(sending)0 4544 y(an)k(SR)f(pac)m(k)m(et.)
51 b(Ev)m(ery)34 b(time)g(another)f(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)e
(sen)m(t,)i(the)e(time)h(of)f(transmission)g(of)g(that)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h
(is)0 4657 y(main)m(tained)f(in)f(the)h(table.)51 b(The)33
b(normal)g(sender)g(timeout)i(algorithm)f(is)g(then)f(applied)g(to)h
(the)g(participan)m(t)0 4770 y(|)j(if)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)37
b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(has)f(not)g(b)s(een)f(transmitted)h(since)g(time)h(tc)
f(-)g(2T,)g(the)g(participan)m(t)h(remo)m(v)m(es)g(itself)0
4883 y(from)30 b(the)g(sender)g(table,)i(decremen)m(ts)f(the)f(sender)g
(coun)m(t,)h(and)f(sets)h(w)m(e)p 2559 4883 V 33 w(sen)m(t)g(to)g
(false.)0 5123 y Fl(6.3.9)105 b(Allo)s(cation)36 b(of)f(source)h
(description)g(bandwidth)0 5294 y Fq(This)h(sp)s(eci\014cation)i
(de\014nes)e(sev)m(eral)j(source)e(description)g(\(SDES\))g(items)h(in)
f(addition)g(to)h(the)f(mandatory)0 5407 y(CNAME)g(item,)i(suc)m(h)d
(as)h(NAME)g(\(p)s(ersonal)g(name\))g(and)f(EMAIL)h(\(email)h
(address\).)62 b(It)37 b(also)i(pro)m(vides)f(a)0 5656
y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(26])p eop
%%Page: 27 27
27 26 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(means)e(to)h(de\014ne)e(new)g(application-sp)s(eci\014c)j(R)-8
b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s(es.)40 b(Applications)30
b(should)e(exercise)i(caution)0 511 y(in)c(allo)s(cating)j(con)m(trol)f
(bandwidth)d(to)i(this)g(additional)g(information)g(b)s(ecause)g(it)g
(will)g(slo)m(w)g(do)m(wn)f(the)h(rate)g(at)0 624 y(whic)m(h)j
(reception)i(rep)s(orts)e(and)g(CNAME)h(are)g(sen)m(t,)h(th)m(us)e
(impairing)h(the)g(p)s(erformance)f(of)h(the)g(proto)s(col.)43
b(It)0 737 y(is)26 b Fi(recommended)d Fq(that)k(no)f(more)g(than)g
(20\045)g(of)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)25 b(bandwidth)f(allo)s(cated)k(to)f(a)
f(single)h(participan)m(t)0 850 y(b)s(e)32 b(used)h(to)g(carry)g(the)h
(additional)g(information.)49 b(F)-8 b(urthermore,)33
b(it)h(is)f Fk(not)h Fq(in)m(tended)f(that)g(all)h(SDES)e(items)0
963 y(will)68 b(b)s(e)34 b(included)f(in)h(ev)m(ery)h(application.)53
b(Those)33 b(that)i(are)f(included)g Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)h(assigned)i
(a)f(fraction)h(of)0 1076 y(the)h(bandwidth)e(according)j(to)g(their)f
(utilit)m(y)-8 b(.)59 b(Rather)36 b(than)g(estimate)i(these)e
(fractions)h(dynamically)-8 b(,)38 b(it)f(is)0 1189 y(recommended)26
b(that)i(the)f(p)s(ercen)m(tages)h(b)s(e)e(translated)i(statically)h
(in)m(to)f(rep)s(ort)e(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)28 b(coun)m(ts)g(based)e(on)h
(the)0 1302 y(t)m(ypical)32 b(length)f(of)f(an)h(item.)141
1415 y(F)-8 b(or)23 b(example,)i(an)d(application)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e
(designed)h(to)h(send)e(only)i(CNAME,)f(NAME)h(and)e(EMAIL)h(and)g(not)
0 1528 y(an)m(y)k(others.)39 b(NAME)26 b(migh)m(t)g(b)s(e)f(giv)m(en)h
(m)m(uc)m(h)f(higher)g(priorit)m(y)h(than)f(EMAIL)h(b)s(ecause)f(the)h
(NAME)f(w)m(ould)h(b)s(e)0 1641 y(displa)m(y)m(ed)i(con)m(tin)m(uously)
g(in)f(the)g(application's)i(user)d(in)m(terface,)k(whereas)d(EMAIL)g
(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)f(displa)m(y)m(ed)i(only)0 1753 y(when)34
b(requested.)53 b(A)m(t)36 b(ev)m(ery)f(R)-8 b(TCP)34
b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al,)38 b(an)c(RR)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(and)e(an)h(SDES)f
(pac)m(k)m(et)j(with)d(the)h(CNAME)0 1866 y(item)c(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)f
(sen)m(t.)41 b(F)-8 b(or)31 b(a)g(small)f(session)h(op)s(erating)f(at)h
(the)g(minim)m(um)e(in)m(terv)-5 b(al,)31 b(that)g(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g
(ev)m(ery)h(5)0 1979 y(seconds)d(on)g(the)h(a)m(v)m(erage.)43
b(Ev)m(ery)28 b(third)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)29 b(\(15)h(seconds\),)f(one)
f(extra)h(item)g(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)e(included)h(in)g(the)0
2092 y(SDES)34 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)55 b(Sev)m(en)35 b(out)f(of)h(eigh)m(t)h
(times)f(this)f(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)g(the)h(NAME)g(item,)h(and)e(ev)m(ery)
i(eigh)m(th)f(time)g(\(2)0 2205 y(min)m(utes\))c(it)g(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)
g(the)g(EMAIL)g(item.)141 2318 y(When)h(m)m(ultiple)h(applications)h
(op)s(erate)f(in)f(concert)h(using)f(cross-application)i(binding)e
(through)f(a)i(com-)0 2431 y(mon)i(CNAME)g(for)g(eac)m(h)h(participan)m
(t,)i(for)d(example)g(in)g(a)h(m)m(ultimedia)g(conference)g(comp)s
(osed)f(of)g(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)0 2544 y(session)31 b(for)g(eac)m(h)h
(medium,)e(the)h(additional)h(SDES)e(information)h Fi(ma)-6
b(y)63 b Fq(b)s(e)31 b(sen)m(t)g(in)g(only)g(one)g(R)-8
b(TP)31 b(session.)0 2657 y(The)39 b(other)h(sessions)g(w)m(ould)g
(carry)g(only)g(the)g(CNAME)g(item.)70 b(In)39 b(particular,)k(this)d
(approac)m(h)g(should)f(b)s(e)0 2770 y(applied)30 b(to)h(the)g(m)m
(ultiple)g(sessions)f(of)h(a)g(la)m(y)m(ered)g(enco)s(ding)g(sc)m(heme)
g(\(see)g(Section)g(2.4\).)0 3013 y Fo(6.4)112 b(Sender)39
b(and)f(Receiv)m(er)f(Rep)s(orts)0 3185 y Fq(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(receiv)m(ers)h(pro)m(vide)g(reception)g(qualit)m(y)g(feedbac)m(k)g
(using)f(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(rep)s(ort)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(whic)m(h)e(ma)m(y)
h(tak)m(e)h(one)0 3298 y(of)40 b(t)m(w)m(o)g(forms)f(dep)s(ending)f(up)
s(on)g(whether)h(or)h(not)f(the)h(receiv)m(er)h(is)e(also)i(a)f
(sender.)67 b(The)39 b(only)g(di\013erence)0 3410 y(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)c
(the)g(sender)e(rep)s(ort)h(\(SR\))h(and)f(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(ort)d
(\(RR\))i(forms,)g(b)s(esides)f(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(t)m(yp)s(e)f(co)s
(de,)h(is)0 3523 y(that)28 b(the)g(sender)f(rep)s(ort)h(includes)f(a)h
(20-b)m(yte)i(sender)d(information)h(section)h(for)e(use)h(b)m(y)f
(activ)m(e)j(senders.)39 b(The)0 3636 y(SR)31 b(is)i(issued)e(if)h(a)h
(site)g(has)e(sen)m(t)i(an)m(y)g(data)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(during)d(the)i
(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)33 b(since)f(issuing)g(the)g(last)h(rep)s(ort)f(or)0
3749 y(the)f(previous)e(one,)i(otherwise)g(the)g(RR)f(is)g(issued.)141
3862 y(Both)36 b(the)f(SR)g(and)f(RR)h(forms)f(include)h(zero)h(or)f
(more)h(reception)g(rep)s(ort)e(blo)s(c)m(ks,)j(one)e(for)g(eac)m(h)h
(of)g(the)0 3975 y(sync)m(hronization)44 b(sources)g(from)f(whic)m(h)g
(this)g(receiv)m(er)i(has)e(receiv)m(ed)i(R)-8 b(TP)43
b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(since)d(the)h(last)0 4088 y(rep)s(ort.)62
b(Rep)s(orts)38 b(are)g(not)g(issued)f(for)g(con)m(tributing)i(sources)
f(listed)g(in)f(the)h(CSR)m(C)f(list.)64 b(Eac)m(h)38
b(reception)0 4201 y(rep)s(ort)25 b(blo)s(c)m(k)h(pro)m(vides)g
(statistics)i(ab)s(out)d(the)h(data)h(receiv)m(ed)g(from)e(the)h
(particular)h(source)e(indicated)i(in)e(that)0 4314 y(blo)s(c)m(k.)39
b(Since)25 b(a)g(maxim)m(um)f(of)h(31)g(reception)h(rep)s(ort)d(blo)s
(c)m(ks)i(will)g(\014t)g(in)f(an)g(SR)g(or)h(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)k
(additional)d(RR)0 4427 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)35 b Fi(should)65
b Fq(b)s(e)32 b(stac)m(k)m(ed)k(after)d(the)h(initial)g(SR)f(or)g(RR)g
(pac)m(k)m(et)j(as)d(needed)g(to)h(con)m(tain)h(the)e(reception)0
4540 y(rep)s(orts)27 b(for)g(all)i(sources)e(heard)g(during)f(the)i(in)
m(terv)-5 b(al)29 b(since)f(the)g(last)g(rep)s(ort.)39
b(If)27 b(there)h(are)g(to)s(o)g(man)m(y)g(sources)0
4653 y(to)k(\014t)g(all)g(the)g(necessary)g(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)m
(to)g(one)e(comp)s(ound)f(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(without)d
(exceeding)i(the)f(MTU)0 4765 y(of)g(the)f(net)m(w)m(ork)h(path,)g
(then)f(only)h(the)f(subset)g(that)h(will)g(\014t)f(in)m(to)h(one)g
(MTU)g Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)i(included)g(in)g(eac)m(h)0
4878 y(in)m(terv)-5 b(al.)46 b(The)31 b(subsets)g Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)i(selected)j(round-robin)29 b(across)j(m)m(ultiple)h(in)m
(terv)-5 b(als)32 b(so)g(that)g(all)h(sources)0 4991
y(are)e(rep)s(orted.)141 5104 y(The)c(next)g(sections)i(de\014ne)d(the)
i(formats)f(of)g(the)h(t)m(w)m(o)h(rep)s(orts,)e(ho)m(w)g(they)h(ma)m
(y)f(b)s(e)g(extended)g(in)g(a)h(pro\014le-)0 5217 y(sp)s(eci\014c)39
b(manner)g(if)g(an)h(application)h(requires)e(additional)h(feedbac)m(k)
g(information,)j(and)c(ho)m(w)g(the)h(rep)s(orts)0 5330
y(ma)m(y)31 b(b)s(e)f(used.)40 b(Details)32 b(of)e(reception)i(rep)s
(orting)e(b)m(y)g(translators)h(and)f(mixers)g(is)g(giv)m(en)i(in)e
(Section)h(7.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(27])p eop
%%Page: 28 28
28 27 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(6.4.1)105 b(SR:)36 b(Sender)f(rep)s(ort)g(R)-9 b(TCP)35
b(pac)m(k)m(et)349 557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 656
y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)
h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)0
856 y(header)e(|V=2|P|)172 b(RC)129 b(|)i(PT=SR=200)c(|)566
b(length)521 b(|)305 955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1055 y(|)1089 b(SSRC)42 b(of)h(sender)1044
b(|)305 1155 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o
(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0
1254 y(sender)41 b(|)610 b(NTP)42 b(timestamp,)e(most)i(significant)d
(word)565 b(|)0 1354 y(info)129 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1453 y(|)566 b(NTP)43 b(timestamp,)c(least)j
(significant)d(word)565 b(|)305 1553 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1653 y(|)1089 b(RTP)43
b(timestamp)1086 b(|)305 1752 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)
o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)
o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1852 y(|)915 b(sender's)40 b(packet)h(count)914
b(|)305 1952 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
305 2051 y(|)959 b(sender's)40 b(octet)h(count)914 b(|)305
2151 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0
2250 y(report)41 b(|)741 b(SSRC_1)41 b(\(SSRC)g(of)i(first)f(source\))
738 b(|)0 2350 y(block)85 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)87 2450 y(1)174 b(|)43 b(fraction)e(lost)g(|)305
b(cumulative)40 b(number)h(of)h(packets)f(lost)304 b(|)305
2549 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
2649 y(|)479 b(extended)40 b(highest)h(sequence)f(number)h(received)477
b(|)305 2749 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
305 2848 y(|)959 b(interarrival)38 b(jitter)957 b(|)305
2948 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
3048 y(|)1089 b(last)42 b(SR)h(\(LSR\))1088 b(|)305 3147
y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
3247 y(|)828 b(delay)41 b(since)h(last)g(SR)h(\(DLSR\))782
b(|)305 3346 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o
(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0
3446 y(report)41 b(|)741 b(SSRC_2)41 b(\(SSRC)g(of)i(second)e(source\))
695 b(|)0 3546 y(block)85 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)87 3645 y(2)174 b(:)1351 b(...)1263 b(:)305
3745 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)305
3845 y(|)784 b(profile-specific)37 b(extensions)781 b(|)305
3944 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
4140 y Fq(The)26 b(sender)g(rep)s(ort)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(consists)f(of)g
(three)f(sections,)j(p)s(ossibly)c(follo)m(w)m(ed)j(b)m(y)f(a)g(fourth)
e(pro\014le-sp)s(eci\014c)0 4253 y(extension)39 b(section)h(if)e
(de\014ned.)63 b(The)38 b(\014rst)g(section,)j(the)e(header,)h(is)f(8)g
(o)s(ctets)g(long.)65 b(The)38 b(\014elds)g(ha)m(v)m(e)i(the)0
4366 y(follo)m(wing)32 b(meaning:)0 4551 y Fl(v)m(ersion)k(\(V\):)45
b Fq(2)30 b(bits)227 4664 y(Iden)m(ti\014es)35 b(the)h(v)m(ersion)f(of)
g(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)36 b(whic)m(h)f(is)g(the)g(same)h(in)f(R)-8
b(TCP)34 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(as)e(in)g(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m
(ets.)227 4777 y(The)30 b(v)m(ersion)h(de\014ned)e(b)m(y)h(this)h(sp)s
(eci\014cation)g(is)f(t)m(w)m(o)i(\(2\).)0 4956 y Fl(padding)j(\(P\):)
46 b Fq(1)30 b(bit)227 5068 y(If)23 b(the)h(padding)f(bit)h(is)f(set,)j
(this)e(individual)f(R)-8 b(TCP)23 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(con)m(tains)g(some)
f(additional)h(padding)e(o)s(ctets)227 5181 y(at)31 b(the)f(end)f(whic)
m(h)g(are)h(not)g(part)g(of)g(the)g(con)m(trol)h(information)f(but)f
(are)h(included)g(in)f(the)h(length)g(\014eld.)227 5294
y(The)41 b(last)h(o)s(ctet)h(of)e(the)g(padding)g(is)g(a)g(coun)m(t)h
(of)g(ho)m(w)f(man)m(y)g(padding)f(o)s(ctets)j(should)d(b)s(e)h
(ignored,)227 5407 y(including)35 b(itself)h(\(it)h(will)e(b)s(e)g(a)h
(m)m(ultiple)g(of)f(four\).)55 b(P)m(adding)36 b(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)g
(needed)g(b)m(y)g(some)h(encryption)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(28])p eop
%%Page: 29 29
29 28 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(algorithms)g(with)f(\014xed)f(blo)s(c)m(k)i(sizes.)41
b(In)30 b(a)g(comp)s(ound)f(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(padding)e
(is)g(only)g(required)f(on)227 511 y(one)c(individual)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j
(b)s(ecause)d(the)h(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(is)d(encrypted)h(as)f
(a)h(whole)g(for)f(the)h(metho)s(d)f(in)227 624 y(Section)29
b(9.1.)42 b(Th)m(us,)27 b(padding)i Fi(must)e Fq(only)i(b)s(e)f(added)f
(to)i(the)g(last)g(individual)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(and)d(if)g(padding)227
737 y(is)34 b(added)f(to)h(that)g(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(the)d(padding)e(bit)i
Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)h(set)h(only)g(on)g(that)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)52
b(This)33 b(con)m(v)m(en)m(tion)227 850 y(aids)38 b(the)g(header)g(v)-5
b(alidit)m(y)40 b(c)m(hec)m(ks)f(describ)s(ed)e(in)h(App)s(endix)e(A.2)
j(and)e(allo)m(ws)i(detection)h(of)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)227
963 y(from)31 b(some)h(early)h(implemen)m(tations)g(that)f(incorrectly)
g(set)h(the)e(padding)g(bit)h(on)f(the)h(\014rst)f(individual)227
1076 y(pac)m(k)m(et)i(and)c(add)h(padding)g(to)h(the)f(last)i
(individual)d(pac)m(k)m(et.)0 1264 y Fl(reception)35
b(rep)s(ort)g(coun)m(t)h(\(R)m(C\):)44 b Fq(5)31 b(bits)227
1377 y(The)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(blo)s(c)m
(ks)g(con)m(tained)i(in)e(this)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)43 b(A)31
b(v)-5 b(alue)30 b(of)h(zero)g(is)g(v)-5 b(alid.)0 1564
y Fl(pac)m(k)m(et)35 b(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\(PT\):)45 b Fq(8)31
b(bits)227 1677 y(Con)m(tains)g(the)g(constan)m(t)g(200)h(to)f(iden)m
(tify)g(this)f(as)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)0
1865 y Fl(length:)46 b Fq(16)31 b(bits)227 1978 y(The)37
b(length)h(of)g(this)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(in)f(32-bit)g(w)m
(ords)f(min)m(us)g(one,)j(including)d(the)h(header)g(and)f(an)m(y)227
2090 y(padding.)51 b(\(The)34 b(o\013set)g(of)h(one)f(mak)m(es)h(zero)f
(a)h(v)-5 b(alid)34 b(length)g(and)f(a)m(v)m(oids)j(a)e(p)s(ossible)g
(in\014nite)f(lo)s(op)h(in)227 2203 y(scanning)e(a)h(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8
b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et,)k(while)d(coun)m(ting)h(32-bit)h(w)m(ords)e(a)
m(v)m(oids)h(a)g(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)33 b(c)m(hec)m(k)h(for)227
2316 y(a)d(m)m(ultiple)g(of)g(4.\))0 2504 y Fl(SSR)m(C:)46
b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 2617 y(The)f(sync)m(hronization)h(source)g(iden)m
(ti\014er)g(for)f(the)g(originator)i(of)e(this)h(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et.)141
2829 y(The)39 b(second)g(section,)j(the)d(sender)f(information,)k(is)d
(20)h(o)s(ctets)g(long)f(and)g(is)f(presen)m(t)h(in)g(ev)m(ery)h
(sender)0 2942 y(rep)s(ort)25 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)41 b(It)25
b(summarizes)g(the)h(data)g(transmissions)f(from)g(this)g(sender.)39
b(The)24 b(\014elds)h(ha)m(v)m(e)i(the)e(follo)m(wing)0
3055 y(meaning:)0 3268 y Fl(NTP)35 b(timestamp:)45 b
Fq(64)31 b(bits)227 3381 y(Indicates)d(the)f(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)i(time)
f(\(see)g(Section)g(4\))54 b(when)26 b(this)h(rep)s(ort)g(w)m(as)g(sen)
m(t)g(so)h(that)f(it)h(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)g(used)227 3494
y(in)c(com)m(bination)i(with)f(timestamps)f(returned)g(in)g(reception)h
(rep)s(orts)f(from)g(other)h(receiv)m(ers)h(to)f(measure)227
3606 y(round-trip)j(propagation)h(to)h(those)f(receiv)m(ers.)41
b(Receiv)m(ers)29 b(should)e(exp)s(ect)h(that)h(the)f(measuremen)m(t)g
(ac-)227 3719 y(curacy)d(of)g(the)f(timestamp)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f
(limited)i(to)f(far)f(less)h(than)f(the)h(resolution)g(of)f(the)h(NTP)f
(timestamp.)227 3832 y(The)k(measuremen)m(t)g(uncertain)m(t)m(y)h(of)f
(the)g(timestamp)g(is)g(not)g(indicated)g(as)g(it)h(ma)m(y)f(not)g(b)s
(e)f(kno)m(wn.)40 b(On)227 3945 y(a)31 b(system)f(that)h(has)f(no)g
(notion)g(of)h(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)h(time)f(but)f(do)s(es)f(ha)m(v)m(e)j
(some)e(system-sp)s(eci\014c)h(clo)s(c)m(k)g(suc)m(h)227
4058 y(as)38 b(\\system)g(uptime",)i(a)e(sender)e Fi(ma)-6
b(y)39 b Fq(use)e(that)h(clo)s(c)m(k)h(as)f(a)g(reference)g(to)g
(calculate)i(relativ)m(e)f(NTP)227 4171 y(timestamps.)h(It)26
b(is)g(imp)s(ortan)m(t)g(to)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)h(a)f(commonly)g(used)f(clo)
s(c)m(k)j(so)e(that)g(if)g(separate)h(implemen)m(ta-)227
4284 y(tions)g(are)g(used)f(to)i(pro)s(duce)d(the)i(individual)f
(streams)h(of)g(a)g(m)m(ultimedia)h(session,)g(all)f(implemen)m
(tations)227 4397 y(will)33 b(use)g(the)g(same)g(clo)s(c)m(k.)50
b(Un)m(til)34 b(the)f(y)m(ear)h(2036,)h(relativ)m(e)g(and)d(absolute)i
(timestamps)f(will)h(di\013er)e(in)227 4510 y(the)f(high)g(bit)f(so)h
(\(in)m(v)-5 b(alid\))32 b(comparisons)f(will)g(sho)m(w)g(a)g(large)g
(di\013erence;)h(b)m(y)f(then)f(one)h(hop)s(es)f(relativ)m(e)227
4623 y(timestamps)35 b(will)f(no)g(longer)g(b)s(e)g(needed.)102
b(A)34 b(sender)f(that)h(has)g(no)g(notion)g(of)g(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)j
(or)d(elapsed)227 4736 y(time)d Fi(ma)-6 b(y)32 b Fq(set)f(the)f(NTP)g
(timestamp)h(to)g(zero.)0 4923 y Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(timestamp:)45
b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 5036 y(Corresp)s(onds)36 b(to)j(the)f(same)h
(time)f(as)h(the)f(NTP)g(timestamp)g(\(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e\),)k(but)c(in)f
(the)i(same)f(units)g(and)227 5149 y(with)c(the)g(same)h(random)e
(o\013set)i(as)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(timestamps)g(in)g(data)h(pac)m(k)
m(ets.)53 b(This)33 b(corresp)s(ondence)227 5262 y(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)e
(used)g(for)g(in)m(tra-)i(and)e(in)m(ter-media)i(sync)m(hronization)f
(for)g(sources)g(whose)f(NTP)g(timestamps)227 5375 y(are)g(sync)m
(hronized,)f(and)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(used)f(b)m(y)h(media-indep)s(enden)
m(t)g(receiv)m(ers)h(to)g(estimate)h(the)e(nominal)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(29])p eop
%%Page: 30 30
30 29 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(clo)s(c)m(k)i(frequency)-8 b(.)46 b(Note)34
b(that)f(in)f(most)g(cases)h(this)f(timestamp)h(will)g(not)f(b)s(e)g
(equal)h(to)g(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)227 511 y(timestamp)22
b(in)e(an)m(y)h(adjacen)m(t)i(data)e(pac)m(k)m(et.)40
b(Rather,)23 b(it)e Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)41 b(calculated)23
b(from)d(the)h(corresp)s(onding)227 624 y(NTP)27 b(timestamp)i(using)e
(the)h(relationship)f(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)i(the)e(R)-8 b(TP)28
b(timestamp)g(coun)m(ter)g(and)f(real)h(time)h(as)227
737 y(main)m(tained)i(b)m(y)g(p)s(erio)s(dically)f(c)m(hec)m(king)j
(the)d(w)m(allclo)s(c)m(k)j(time)e(at)g(a)g(sampling)f(instan)m(t.)0
918 y Fl(sender's)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(coun)m(t:)46 b
Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 1030 y(The)d(total)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(R)-8
b(TP)28 b(data)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(transmitted)e(b)m(y)g(the)g(sender)f
(since)i(starting)f(transmission)227 1143 y(up)34 b(un)m(til)h(the)g
(time)g(this)g(SR)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i(w)m(as)f(generated.)55
b(The)34 b(coun)m(t)h Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)69 b(reset)35
b(if)g(the)g(sender)227 1256 y(c)m(hanges)d(its)e(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m
(ti\014er.)0 1437 y Fl(sender's)35 b(o)s(ctet)g(coun)m(t:)46
b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 1549 y(The)38 b(total)j(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)c(of)h
(pa)m(yload)i(o)s(ctets)g(\(i.e.,)i(not)d(including)f(header)g(or)g
(padding\))g(transmitted)h(in)227 1662 y(R)-8 b(TP)29
b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(b)m(y)e(the)h(sender)e(since)i(starting)g
(transmission)e(up)h(un)m(til)g(the)g(time)h(this)f(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(et)
227 1775 y(w)m(as)34 b(generated.)50 b(The)32 b(coun)m(t)i
Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)65 b(reset)34 b(if)f(the)g(sender)g(c)m(hanges)h
(its)f(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er.)49 b(This)227 1888
y(\014eld)30 b(can)h(b)s(e)f(used)f(to)i(estimate)h(the)f(a)m(v)m
(erage)i(pa)m(yload)e(data)h(rate.)141 2079 y(The)k(third)f(section)j
(con)m(tains)g(zero)f(or)f(more)g(reception)i(rep)s(ort)d(blo)s(c)m(ks)
i(dep)s(ending)e(on)h(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)0 2192
y(other)44 b(sources)f(heard)f(b)m(y)i(this)f(sender)f(since)i(the)f
(last)h(rep)s(ort.)79 b(Eac)m(h)44 b(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(blo)s(c)m
(k)g(con)m(v)m(eys)0 2305 y(statistics)30 b(on)f(the)f(reception)h(of)g
(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)e(a)h(single)g(sync)m(hronization)
g(source.)41 b(Receiv)m(ers)30 b Fi(should)0 2418 y(not)81
b Fq(carry)41 b(o)m(v)m(er)h(statistics)h(when)c(a)j(source)f(c)m
(hanges)g(its)h(SSR)m(C)d(iden)m(ti\014er)i(due)g(to)g(a)g(collision.)
74 b(These)0 2530 y(statistics)32 b(are:)0 2721 y Fl(SSR)m(C)p
273 2721 32 4 v 38 w(n)j(\(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er\):)45
b Fq(32)32 b(bits)227 2834 y(The)39 b(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(of)g
(the)g(source)h(to)f(whic)m(h)g(the)g(information)h(in)e(this)h
(reception)h(rep)s(ort)e(blo)s(c)m(k)227 2947 y(p)s(ertains.)0
3127 y Fl(fraction)d(lost:)46 b Fq(8)31 b(bits)227 3240
y(The)22 b(fraction)h(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)22 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(from)e
(source)g(SSR)m(C)p 2265 3240 28 4 v 32 w(n)g(lost)h(since)g(the)f
(previous)g(SR)g(or)g(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(et)227 3353 y(w)m(as)27
b(sen)m(t,)h(expressed)e(as)g(a)h(\014xed)e(p)s(oin)m(t)i(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)e(with)g(the)i(binary)e(p)s(oin)m(t)i(at)g(the)f(left)h(edge)g(of)g
(the)f(\014eld.)227 3466 y(\(That)42 b(is)f(equiv)-5
b(alen)m(t)43 b(to)f(taking)g(the)f(in)m(teger)i(part)e(after)h(m)m
(ultiplying)g(the)f(loss)h(fraction)g(b)m(y)f(256.\))227
3579 y(This)35 b(fraction)g(is)h(de\014ned)e(to)h(b)s(e)g(the)g(n)m(um)
m(b)s(er)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(lost)f(divided)f(b)m(y)g(the)g(n)m(um)m
(b)s(er)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)227 3692 y(exp)s(ected,)h(as)e(de\014ned)f
(in)g(the)h(next)h(paragraph.)51 b(An)33 b(implemen)m(tation)j(is)e
(sho)m(wn)f(in)h(App)s(endix)e(A.3.)227 3805 y(If)g(the)g(loss)g(is)g
(negativ)m(e)i(due)e(to)g(duplicates,)h(the)f(fraction)h(lost)g(is)f
(set)g(to)h(zero.)46 b(Note)34 b(that)e(a)g(receiv)m(er)227
3917 y(cannot)i(tell)g(whether)e(an)m(y)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(w)m(ere)g
(lost)f(after)g(the)g(last)h(one)f(receiv)m(ed,)i(and)d(that)i(there)e
(will)i(b)s(e)227 4030 y(no)g(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(blo)s(c)m(k)h
(issued)e(for)i(a)f(source)h(if)f(all)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(from)e(that)h
(source)g(sen)m(t)g(during)e(the)227 4143 y(last)f(rep)s(orting)f(in)m
(terv)-5 b(al)32 b(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s(een)d(lost.)0 4324
y Fl(cum)m(ulativ)m(e)35 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(of)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)g
(lost:)46 b Fq(24)31 b(bits)227 4437 y(The)37 b(total)j(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)c(of)i(R)-8 b(TP)37 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)d(source)h(SSR)m
(C)p 2607 4437 V 31 w(n)g(that)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h(b)s(een)d(lost)j(since)f
(the)227 4549 y(b)s(eginning)f(of)h(reception.)63 b(This)37
b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(is)g(de\014ned)g(to)h(b)s(e)f(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(exp)s(ected)e(less)227 4662
y(the)33 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(actually)g(receiv)m
(ed,)h(where)d(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(receiv)m
(ed)g(includes)e(an)m(y)227 4775 y(whic)m(h)i(are)g(late)h(or)f
(duplicates.)51 b(Th)m(us)33 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(that)g(arriv)m(e)f(late)
h(are)f Fk(not)h Fq(coun)m(ted)f(as)g(lost,)i(and)d(the)227
4888 y(loss)28 b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(negativ)m(e)j(if)e(there)g(are)f
(duplicates.)41 b(The)27 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(exp)s
(ected)f(is)g(de\014ned)e(to)j(b)s(e)227 5001 y(the)e(extended)g(last)h
(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(receiv)m(ed,)j(as)f(de\014ned)d(next,)j
(less)g(the)f(initial)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)227
5114 y(receiv)m(ed.)42 b(This)30 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(calculated)i(as)f
(sho)m(wn)e(in)h(App)s(endix)f(A.3.)0 5294 y Fl(extended)35
b(highest)g(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(receiv)m(ed:)46
b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 5407 y(The)i(lo)m(w)i(16)f(bits)g(con)m(tain)h
(the)f(highest)g(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(receiv)m(ed)j(in)e(an)h
(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(from)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(30])p eop
%%Page: 31 31
31 30 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(source)h(SSR)m(C)p 744 399 28 4 v 32 w(n,)g(and)f(the)h(most)h
(signi\014can)m(t)g(16)f(bits)g(extend)g(that)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)f(with)g(the)h(cor-)227 511 y(resp)s(onding)g(coun)m(t)h(of)g
(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(cycles,)k(whic)m(h)e(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f
(main)m(tained)i(according)g(to)f(the)g(al-)227 624 y(gorithm)d(in)f
(App)s(endix)e(A.1.)41 b(Note)31 b(that)e(di\013eren)m(t)h(receiv)m
(ers)g(within)f(the)g(same)h(session)f(will)g(generate)227
737 y(di\013eren)m(t)i(extensions)g(to)g(the)g(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)f(if)i(their)f(start)h(times)g(di\013er)f(signi\014can)m(tly)-8
b(.)0 925 y Fl(in)m(terarriv)i(al)35 b(jitter:)45 b Fq(32)31
b(bits)227 1038 y(An)d(estimate)j(of)e(the)f(statistical)k(v)-5
b(ariance)29 b(of)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(in)m
(terarriv)-5 b(al)29 b(time,)h(measured)e(in)227 1151
y(timestamp)j(units)e(and)h(expressed)f(as)h(an)g(unsigned)f(in)m
(teger.)42 b(The)30 b(in)m(terarriv)-5 b(al)31 b(jitter)f
Fg(J)39 b Fq(is)30 b(de\014ned)f(to)227 1264 y(b)s(e)e(the)g(mean)g
(deviation)h(\(smo)s(othed)f(absolute)h(v)-5 b(alue\))28
b(of)f(the)g(di\013erence)g Fg(D)j Fq(in)d(pac)m(k)m(et)i(spacing)e(at)
h(the)227 1377 y(receiv)m(er)34 b(compared)f(to)g(the)f(sender)g(for)g
(a)h(pair)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets.)48 b(As)33 b(sho)m(wn)f(in)g(the)g
(equation)i(b)s(elo)m(w,)f(this)227 1489 y(is)g(equiv)-5
b(alen)m(t)34 b(to)f(the)g(di\013erence)g(in)f(the)h(\\relativ)m(e)i
(transit)e(time")g(for)g(the)f(t)m(w)m(o)i(pac)m(k)m(ets;)i(the)d
(relativ)m(e)227 1602 y(transit)h(time)f(is)h(the)f(di\013erence)g(b)s
(et)m(w)m(een)h(a)g(pac)m(k)m(et's)h(R)-8 b(TP)33 b(timestamp)g(and)g
(the)g(receiv)m(er's)i(clo)s(c)m(k)f(at)227 1715 y(the)d(time)g(of)f
(arriv)-5 b(al,)32 b(measured)d(in)h(the)h(same)g(units.)227
1866 y(If)j Fg(S)378 1880 y Fe(i)440 1866 y Fq(is)h(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)34 b(timestamp)h(from)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i Fg(i)p Fq(,)g(and)e
Fg(R)2222 1880 y Fe(i)2284 1866 y Fq(is)h(the)f(time)i(of)e(arriv)-5
b(al)35 b(in)f(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(timestamp)227 1978 y(units)c(for)g(pac)m
(k)m(et)j Fg(i)p Fq(,)d(then)g(for)h(t)m(w)m(o)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
Fg(i)d Fq(and)g Fg(j)5 b Fq(,)31 b Fg(D)i Fq(ma)m(y)e(b)s(e)f
(expressed)g(as)957 2228 y Fg(D)s Fq(\()p Fg(i;)15 b(j)5
b Fq(\))27 b(=)e(\()p Fg(R)1445 2242 y Fe(j)1502 2228
y Fj(\000)20 b Fg(R)1662 2242 y Fe(i)1691 2228 y Fq(\))g
Fj(\000)g Fq(\()p Fg(S)1928 2242 y Fe(j)1985 2228 y Fj(\000)g
Fg(S)2132 2242 y Fe(i)2160 2228 y Fq(\))25 b(=)g(\()p
Fg(R)2420 2242 y Fe(j)2477 2228 y Fj(\000)20 b Fg(S)2624
2242 y Fe(j)2661 2228 y Fq(\))g Fj(\000)g Fq(\()p Fg(R)2911
2242 y Fe(i)2960 2228 y Fj(\000)g Fg(S)3107 2242 y Fe(i)3135
2228 y Fq(\))227 2478 y(The)34 b(in)m(terarriv)-5 b(al)35
b(jitter)f Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)67 b(calculated)36 b(con)m(tin)m
(uously)f(as)f(eac)m(h)h(data)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h Fg(i)e
Fq(is)g(receiv)m(ed)227 2591 y(from)29 b(source)h(SSR)m(C)p
956 2591 V 32 w(n,)f(using)g(this)g(di\013erence)h Fg(D)j
Fq(for)c(that)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(and)e(the)h(previous)f(pac)m(k)m(et)i
Fg(i)19 b Fj(\000)f Fq(1)30 b(in)227 2704 y(order)g(of)h(arriv)-5
b(al)31 b(\(not)g(necessarily)g(in)f(sequence\),)h(according)h(to)f
(the)f(form)m(ula)1161 2954 y Fg(J)9 b Fq(\()p Fg(i)p
Fq(\))26 b(=)f Fg(J)9 b Fq(\()p Fg(i)21 b Fj(\000)f Fq(1\))h(+)f(\()p
Fj(j)p Fg(D)s Fq(\()p Fg(i)h Fj(\000)f Fq(1)p Fg(;)15
b(i)p Fq(\))p Fj(j)22 b(\000)e Fg(J)9 b Fq(\()p Fg(i)21
b Fj(\000)f Fq(1\)\))p Fg(=)p Fq(16)227 3204 y(Whenev)m(er)31
b(a)g(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(is)g(issued,)g(the)h(curren)m(t)f(v)-5
b(alue)31 b(of)f Fg(J)40 b Fq(is)30 b(sampled.)227 3354
y(The)i(jitter)h(calculation)i Fi(must)d Fq(conform)g(to)h(the)g(form)m
(ula)g(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(here)g(in)g(order)g(to)66 b(allo)m(w)34
b(pro\014le-)227 3467 y(indep)s(enden)m(t)g(monitors)g(to)i(mak)m(e)f
(v)-5 b(alid)35 b(in)m(terpretations)h(of)e(rep)s(orts)g(coming)h(from)
g(di\013eren)m(t)g(imple-)227 3580 y(men)m(tations.)42
b(This)29 b(algorithm)h(is)f(the)h(optimal)g(\014rst-order)f(estimator)
i(and)e(the)g(gain)h(parameter)g(1)p Fg(=)p Fq(16)227
3693 y(giv)m(es)40 b(a)f(go)s(o)s(d)g(noise)g(reduction)f(ratio)i
(while)e(main)m(taining)i(a)f(reasonable)h(rate)f(of)g(con)m(v)m
(ergence)i([22)q(,)227 3806 y(Section)g(11.5-11.12,)47
b(Fig.)70 b(11.6].)h(A)40 b(sample)h(implemen)m(tation)g(is)f(sho)m(wn)
f(in)h(App)s(endix)e(A.8.)71 b(See)227 3919 y(Section)29
b(6.4.4)g(for)f(a)g(discussion)f(of)h(the)f(e\013ects)i(of)f(v)-5
b(arying)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(duration)d(and)g(dela)m(y)i(b)s(efore)e
(trans-)227 4032 y(mission.)0 4219 y Fl(last)35 b(SR)g(timestamp)f
(\(LSR\):)46 b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 4332 y(The)i(middle)f(32)i(bits)f
(out)h(of)f(64)h(in)e(the)i(NTP)e(timestamp)i(\(as)g(explained)f(in)g
(Section)g(4\))h(receiv)m(ed)h(as)227 4445 y(part)c(of)g(the)g(most)g
(recen)m(t)g(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(sender)f(rep)s(ort)g(\(SR\))g(pac)m(k)m
(et)j(from)d(source)h(SSR)m(C)p 3258 4445 V 32 w(n.)41
b(If)31 b(no)f(SR)g(has)227 4558 y(b)s(een)g(receiv)m(ed)i(y)m(et,)f
(the)g(\014eld)f(is)g(set)h(to)g(zero.)0 4746 y Fl(dela)m(y)k(since)h
(last)e(SR)i(\(DLSR\):)45 b Fq(32)31 b(bits)227 4858
y(The)f(dela)m(y)-8 b(,)33 b(expressed)d(in)g(units)g(of)h(1)p
Fg(=)p Fq(65536)j(seconds,)c(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)i(receiving)g(the)e(last)
i(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et)i(from)227 4971 y(source)k(SSR)m(C)p
748 4971 V 31 w(n)f(and)f(sending)h(this)g(reception)h(rep)s(ort)e(blo)
s(c)m(k.)56 b(If)35 b(no)g(SR)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(has)e(b)s(een)g(receiv)m
(ed)227 5084 y(y)m(et)d(from)e(SSR)m(C)p 831 5084 V 31
w(n,)h(the)f(DLSR)g(\014eld)g(is)g(set)h(to)h(zero.)227
5235 y(Let)d(SSR)m(C)p 625 5235 V 32 w(r)f(denote)h(the)g(receiv)m(er)h
(issuing)e(this)g(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(ort.)39 b(Source)29
b(SSR)m(C)p 3137 5235 V 31 w(n)f(can)h(compute)g(the)227
5347 y(round-trip)56 b(propagation)30 b(dela)m(y)g(to)f(SSR)m(C)p
1780 5347 V 32 w(r)f(b)m(y)h(recording)f(the)h(time)h
Fg(A)f Fq(when)e(this)i(reception)h(rep)s(ort)0 5656
y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(31])p eop
%%Page: 32 32
32 31 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(blo)s(c)m(k)c(is)f(receiv)m(ed.)41 b(It)27 b(calculates)h(the)f
(total)h(round-trip)d(time)i Fg(A)p Fj(\000)p Fq(LSR)e(using)h(the)g
(last)i(SR)d(timestamp)227 511 y(\(LSR\))44 b(\014eld,)j(and)d(then)f
(subtracting)i(this)e(\014eld)h(to)h(lea)m(v)m(e)h(the)e(round-trip)f
(propagation)i(dela)m(y)g(as)227 624 y(\()p Fg(A)p Fj(\000)37
b Fq(LSR)e Fj(\000)h Fq(DLSR\).)h(This)e(is)h(illustrated)i(in)d(Fig.)j
(2.)59 b(Times)36 b(are)h(sho)m(wn)e(in)h(b)s(oth)g(a)h(hexadecimal)227
737 y(represen)m(tation)i(of)e(the)h(32-bit)g(\014elds)f(and)g(the)g
(equiv)-5 b(alen)m(t)39 b(\015oating-p)s(oin)m(t)f(decimal)h(represen)m
(tation.)227 850 y(Colons)31 b(indicate)g(a)g(32-bit)h(\014eld)e
(divided)f(in)m(to)j(a)e(16-bit)i(in)m(teger)g(part)e(and)g(16-bit)h
(fraction)g(part.)227 1000 y(This)e(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(used)h(as)h(an)f
(appro)m(ximate)h(measure)f(of)h(distance)g(to)g(cluster)g(receiv)m
(ers,)h(although)f(some)227 1113 y(links)g(ha)m(v)m(e)i(v)m(ery)f
(asymmetric)g(dela)m(ys.)0 3432 y
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 0.98114 0.98114 scale neg exch
neg exch translate
 0 3432 a @beginspecial
0 @llx 0 @lly 477 @urx 257 @ury 4770 @rwi @setspecial
%%BeginDocument: rtt.ps
%!PS-Adobe-2.0 EPSF-2.0
%%Title: rtt.fig
%%Creator: fig2dev Version 3.1 Patchlevel 1
%%CreationDate: Fri Nov 10 13:59:48 1995
%%For: hgs@lupus (Henning Schulzrinne)
%%Orientation: Portrait
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 477 257
%%Pages: 0
%%BeginSetup
%%IncludeFeature: *PageSize Letter
%%EndSetup
%%EndComments
/$F2psDict 200 dict def
$F2psDict begin
$F2psDict /mtrx matrix put
/col-1 {} def
/col0 {0.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col1 {0.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col2 {0.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col3 {0.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col4 {1.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col5 {1.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col6 {1.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col7 {1.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col8 {0.000 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col9 {0.000 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col10 {0.000 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col11 {0.530 0.810 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col12 {0.000 0.560 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col13 {0.000 0.690 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col14 {0.000 0.820 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col15 {0.000 0.560 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col16 {0.000 0.690 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col17 {0.000 0.820 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col18 {0.560 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col19 {0.690 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col20 {0.820 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col21 {0.560 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col22 {0.690 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col23 {0.820 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col24 {0.500 0.190 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col25 {0.630 0.250 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col26 {0.750 0.380 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col27 {1.000 0.500 0.500 srgb} bind def
/col28 {1.000 0.630 0.630 srgb} bind def
/col29 {1.000 0.750 0.750 srgb} bind def
/col30 {1.000 0.880 0.880 srgb} bind def
/col31 {1.000 0.840 0.000 srgb} bind def

end
save
-39.0 424.0 translate
1 -1 scale

/clp {closepath} bind def
/ef {eofill} bind def
/gr {grestore} bind def
/gs {gsave} bind def
/l {lineto} bind def
/m {moveto} bind def
/n {newpath} bind def
/s {stroke} bind def
/slc {setlinecap} bind def
/slj {setlinejoin} bind def
/slw {setlinewidth} bind def
/srgb {setrgbcolor} bind def
/rot {rotate} bind def
/sc {scale} bind def
/tr {translate} bind def
/tnt {dup dup currentrgbcolor
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add srgb}
  bind def
/shd {dup dup currentrgbcolor 4 -2 roll mul 4 -2 roll mul
  4 -2 roll mul srgb} bind def
/$F2psBegin {$F2psDict begin /$F2psEnteredState save def} def
/$F2psEnd {$F2psEnteredState restore end} def
%%EndProlog

$F2psBegin
10 setmiterlimit
 0.06299 0.06299 sc
7.500 slw
% Polyline
n 3150 5175 m 3600 5175 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 3270.00 5205.00 m 3150.00 5175.00 l 3270.00 5145.00 l gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 4050 5175 m 4500 5175 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 4380.00 5145.00 m 4500.00 5175.00 l 4380.00 5205.00 l gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 4500 5085 m 4500 5265 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3150 5085 m 3150 5265 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1350 4950 m 6750 4950 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 6630.00 4920.00 m 6750.00 4950.00 l 6630.00 4980.00 l  6630.50 4950.50 l 6630.00 4920.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 1350 3150 m 6750 3150 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 6630.00 3120.00 m 6750.00 3150.00 l 6630.00 3180.00 l  6630.50 3150.50 l 6630.00 3120.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 2250 3150 m 3150 4950 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 3123.17 4829.25 m 3150.00 4950.00 l 3069.50 4856.09 l  3096.83 4843.17 l 3123.17 4829.25 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 4500 4950 m 4950 3150 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 4891.79 3259.14 m 4950.00 3150.00 l 4950.00 3273.69 l  4921.40 3266.92 l 4891.79 3259.14 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 945 6435 m 4095 6435 l  gs col-1 s gr 
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 3105 m
gs 1 -1 sc (A=0xb710:8000 \(46864.500 s\)) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1350 4860 m
gs 1 -1 sc (r) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1350 3060 m
gs 1 -1 sc (n) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
2250 3060 m
gs 1 -1 sc (SR\(n\)) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4860 4815 m
gs 1 -1 sc (RR\(n\)) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1300 2790 m
gs 1 -1 sc ([10 Nov 1995 11:33:25.125 UTC]) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4750 2790 m
gs 1 -1 sc ([10 Nov 1995 11:33:36.5 UTC]) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 4275 m
gs 1 -1 sc (lsr =0xb705:2000 \(46853.125 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 4050 m
gs 1 -1 sc (dlsr=0x0005:4000 \(    5.250 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
630 4050 m
gs 1 -1 sc (ntp_sec =0xb44db705) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
630 4260 m
gs 1 -1 sc (ntp_frac=0x20000000) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
945 4455 m
gs 1 -1 sc (\(3024992005.125 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3825 5505 m
gs 1 -1 sc (\(5.25 s\)) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3825 5265 m
gs 1 -1 sc (DLSR) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
900 5850 m
gs 1 -1 sc (A     0xb710:8000 \(46864.500 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
900 6060 m
gs 1 -1 sc (DLSR -0x0005:4000 \(    5.250 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
900 6270 m
gs 1 -1 sc (LSR  -0xb705:2000 \(46853.125 s\)) col-1 show gr
/Courier findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
900 6690 m
gs 1 -1 sc (delay 0x0006:2000 \(    6.125 s\)) col-1 show gr
$F2psEnd
restore

%%EndDocument
 @endspecial 0 3432 a
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1 0.98114 div 1 0.98114 div scale
neg exch neg exch translate
 0 3432 a 919 3627 a Fq(Figure)g(2:)41
b(Example)31 b(for)f(round-trip)f(time)i(computation)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(32])p eop
%%Page: 33 33
33 32 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(6.4.2)105 b(RR:)36 b(Receiv)m(er)g(rep)s(ort)f(R)-9
b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)349 557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349
656 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)
g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)0
856 y(header)e(|V=2|P|)172 b(RC)129 b(|)i(PT=RR=201)c(|)566
b(length)521 b(|)305 955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1055 y(|)915 b(SSRC)42 b(of)h(packet)e(sender)913
b(|)305 1155 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o
(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0
1254 y(report)41 b(|)741 b(SSRC_1)41 b(\(SSRC)g(of)i(first)f(source\))
738 b(|)0 1354 y(block)85 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)87 1453 y(1)174 b(|)43 b(fraction)e(lost)g(|)305
b(cumulative)40 b(number)h(of)h(packets)f(lost)304 b(|)305
1553 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
1653 y(|)479 b(extended)40 b(highest)h(sequence)f(number)h(received)477
b(|)305 1752 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
305 1852 y(|)959 b(interarrival)38 b(jitter)957 b(|)305
1952 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
2051 y(|)1089 b(last)42 b(SR)h(\(LSR\))1088 b(|)305 2151
y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
2250 y(|)828 b(delay)41 b(since)h(last)g(SR)h(\(DLSR\))782
b(|)305 2350 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o
(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0
2450 y(report)41 b(|)741 b(SSRC_2)41 b(\(SSRC)g(of)i(second)e(source\))
695 b(|)0 2549 y(block)85 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)87 2649 y(2)174 b(:)1351 b(...)1263 b(:)305
2749 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)305
2848 y(|)784 b(profile-specific)37 b(extensions)781 b(|)305
2948 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
3144 y Fq(The)28 b(format)g(of)g(the)g(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(ort)d
(\(RR\))h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)e(the)h(same)f(as)g(that)h(of)f(the)g(SR)f
(pac)m(k)m(et)j(except)f(that)0 3257 y(the)c(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(e)
e(\014eld)f(con)m(tains)i(the)f(constan)m(t)h(201)g(and)e(the)h(\014v)m
(e)g(w)m(ords)f(of)h(sender)f(information)h(are)g(omitted)0
3370 y(\(these)35 b(are)g(the)g(NTP)f(and)g(R)-8 b(TP)34
b(timestamps)h(and)f(sender's)g(pac)m(k)m(et)j(and)d(o)s(ctet)i(coun)m
(ts\).)54 b(The)34 b(remaining)0 3483 y(\014elds)c(ha)m(v)m(e)h(the)g
(same)g(meaning)f(as)h(for)f(the)h(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et.)141
3595 y(An)i(empt)m(y)h(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(\(R)m(C)f(=)g(0\))g
Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)63 b(put)31 b(at)h(the)g(head)f(of)h(a)g(comp)s
(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(when)0 3708 y(there)d(is)f(no)g
(data)h(transmission)f(or)h(reception)g(to)g(rep)s(ort.)0
4130 y Fl(6.4.3)105 b(Extending)35 b(the)g(sender)g(and)g(receiv)m(er)g
(rep)s(orts)0 4302 y Fq(A)29 b(pro\014le)g Fi(should)f
Fq(de\014ne)h(pro\014le-sp)s(eci\014c)g(extensions)g(to)i(the)e(sender)
g(rep)s(ort)f(and)h(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(ort)d(if)i(there)0
4415 y(is)i(additional)i(information)e(that)h(needs)f(to)66
b(b)s(e)32 b(rep)s(orted)f(regularly)i(ab)s(out)f(the)h(sender)e(or)i
(receiv)m(ers.)48 b(This)0 4528 y(metho)s(d)34 b Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)i(used)g(in)g(preference)g(to)h(de\014ning)e(another)i(R)-8
b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(t)m(yp)s(e)d(b)s(ecause)h(it)f(requires)0
4641 y(less)d(o)m(v)m(erhead:)136 4853 y Fj(\017)46 b
Fq(few)m(er)31 b(o)s(ctets)h(in)e(the)g(pac)m(k)m(et)j(\(no)d(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(header)g(or)h(SSR)m(C)e(\014eld\);)136 5041
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(simpler)c(and)g(faster)h(parsing)e(b)s(ecause)i
(applications)g(running)e(under)g(that)h(pro\014le)g(w)m(ould)g(b)s(e)g
(pro-)227 5154 y(grammed)c(to)h(alw)m(a)m(ys)h(exp)s(ect)f(the)f
(extension)h(\014elds)e(in)h(the)h(directly)f(accessible)i(lo)s(cation)
g(after)f(the)227 5267 y(reception)31 b(rep)s(orts.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(33])p eop
%%Page: 34 34
34 33 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(The)i(extension)g(is)h(a)f(fourth)g(section)h(in)f(the)g(sender-)g
(or)g(receiv)m(er-rep)s(ort)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(whic)m(h)e(comes)h(at)g
(the)g(end)0 511 y(after)24 b(the)g(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(blo)s(c)m
(ks,)j(if)d(an)m(y)-8 b(.)40 b(If)23 b(additional)h(sender)f
(information)h(is)g(required,)g(then)f(for)h(sender)0
624 y(rep)s(orts)30 b(it)h(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(included)f(\014rst)h(in)g
(the)h(extension)g(section,)h(but)e(for)g(receiv)m(er)i(rep)s(orts)e
(it)h(w)m(ould)f(not)h(b)s(e)0 737 y(presen)m(t.)127
b(If)38 b(information)g(ab)s(out)g(receiv)m(ers)h(is)f(to)h(b)s(e)e
(included,)j(that)e(data)h Fi(should)74 b Fq(b)s(e)38
b(structured)f(as)0 850 y(an)c(arra)m(y)g(of)g(blo)s(c)m(ks)g(parallel)
h(to)f(the)g(existing)h(arra)m(y)f(of)g(reception)h(rep)s(ort)e(blo)s
(c)m(ks;)i(that)g(is,)f(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)0
963 y(blo)s(c)m(ks)f(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(indicated)h(b)m(y)f(the)g(R)m
(C)h(\014eld.)0 1203 y Fl(6.4.4)105 b(Analyzing)36 b(sender)f(and)g
(receiv)m(er)h(rep)s(orts)0 1375 y Fq(It)23 b(is)h(exp)s(ected)f(that)h
(reception)g(qualit)m(y)h(feedbac)m(k)f(will)f(b)s(e)g(useful)f(not)i
(only)f(for)g(the)h(sender)e(but)g(also)j(for)e(other)0
1488 y(receiv)m(ers)h(and)e(third-part)m(y)g(monitors.)39
b(The)22 b(sender)f(ma)m(y)j(mo)s(dify)d(its)i(transmissions)f(based)h
(on)f(the)h(feedbac)m(k;)0 1601 y(receiv)m(ers)31 b(can)e(determine)h
(whether)e(problems)h(are)g(lo)s(cal,)i(regional)g(or)e(global;)j(net)m
(w)m(ork)e(managers)f(ma)m(y)h(use)0 1714 y(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)m
(t)g(monitors)h(that)g(receiv)m(e)i(only)e(the)g(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(and)d(not)h(the)g(corresp)s(onding)f(R)-8
b(TP)0 1826 y(data)31 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(to)f(ev)-5 b(aluate)32
b(the)f(p)s(erformance)f(of)g(their)h(net)m(w)m(orks)g(for)f(m)m
(ulticast)i(distribution.)141 1939 y(Cum)m(ulativ)m(e)i(coun)m(ts)f
(are)g(used)f(in)g(b)s(oth)g(the)h(sender)f(information)h(and)f(receiv)
m(er)i(rep)s(ort)e(blo)s(c)m(ks)h(so)g(that)0 2052 y(di\013erences)c
(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(calculated)i(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f(an)m(y)g(t)m(w)m(o)h
(rep)s(orts)e(to)h(mak)m(e)h(measuremen)m(ts)f(o)m(v)m(er)g(b)s(oth)f
(short)h(and)0 2165 y(long)37 b(time)g(p)s(erio)s(ds,)g(and)e(to)i(pro)
m(vide)g(resilience)h(against)f(the)g(loss)f(of)h(a)g(rep)s(ort.)58
b(The)36 b(di\013erence)g(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)0 2278 y(the)f(last)h(t)m(w)
m(o)h(rep)s(orts)d(receiv)m(ed)j(can)e(b)s(e)g(used)f(to)i(estimate)h
(the)e(recen)m(t)h(qualit)m(y)g(of)g(the)f(distribution.)54
b(The)0 2391 y(NTP)27 b(timestamp)g(is)g(included)f(so)h(that)h(rates)f
(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(calculated)j(from)d(these)h(di\013erences)h(o)m(v)m
(er)g(the)f(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)0 2504 y(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)30
b(t)m(w)m(o)g(rep)s(orts.)40 b(Since)29 b(that)h(timestamp)g(is)f
(indep)s(enden)m(t)f(of)h(the)h(clo)s(c)m(k)g(rate)g(for)f(the)h(data)g
(enco)s(ding,)0 2617 y(it)h(is)f(p)s(ossible)g(to)h(implemen)m(t)g
(enco)s(ding-)g(and)f(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)m(t)f(qualit)m(y)i
(monitors.)141 2730 y(An)f(example)h(calculation)h(is)f(the)f(pac)m(k)m
(et)i(loss)f(rate)g(o)m(v)m(er)g(the)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)31
b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)g(t)m(w)m(o)g(reception)g(rep)s(orts.)0
2843 y(The)c(di\013erence)i(in)e(the)h(cum)m(ulativ)m(e)i(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)c(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(lost)f(giv)m(es)g(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f
(lost)h(during)f(that)i(in)m(terv)-5 b(al.)0 2956 y(The)23
b(di\013erence)i(in)e(the)h(extended)g(last)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s
(ers)f(receiv)m(ed)i(giv)m(es)g(the)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m
(ets)i(exp)s(ected)0 3068 y(during)41 b(the)i(in)m(terv)-5
b(al.)79 b(The)42 b(ratio)h(of)g(these)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(is)f(the)g(pac)m
(k)m(et)h(loss)f(fraction)g(o)m(v)m(er)h(the)f(in)m(terv)-5
b(al.)79 b(This)0 3181 y(ratio)37 b(should)d(equal)i(the)g(fraction)g
(lost)g(\014eld)f(if)h(the)f(t)m(w)m(o)i(rep)s(orts)e(are)h(consecutiv)
m(e,)j(but)34 b(otherwise)i(it)g(ma)m(y)0 3294 y(not.)62
b(The)36 b(loss)i(rate)g(p)s(er)e(second)i(can)f(b)s(e)g(obtained)h(b)m
(y)f(dividing)g(the)g(loss)h(fraction)g(b)m(y)f(the)h(di\013erence)f
(in)0 3407 y(NTP)31 b(timestamps,)i(expressed)e(in)g(seconds.)44
b(The)31 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(of)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(receiv)m(ed)f(is)e
(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 3520 y(exp)s(ected)h(min)
m(us)g(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(lost.)50 b(The)32 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g
(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(exp)s(ected)g(ma)m(y)f(also)h(b)s(e)e(used)h(to)g
(judge)g(the)0 3633 y(statistical)27 b(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)25
b(of)f(an)m(y)g(loss)h(estimates.)40 b(F)-8 b(or)24 b(example,)j(1)d
(out)g(of)g(5)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(lost)f(has)f(a)g(lo)m(w)m(er)h
(signi\014cance)0 3746 y(than)30 b(200)i(out)e(of)h(1000.)141
3859 y(F)-8 b(rom)26 b(the)h(sender)e(information,)i(a)f(third-part)m
(y)g(monitor)g(can)g(calculate)i(the)e(a)m(v)m(erage)j(pa)m(yload)e
(data)f(rate)0 3972 y(and)35 b(the)h(a)m(v)m(erage)i(pac)m(k)m(et)f
(rate)g(o)m(v)m(er)f(an)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)37 b(without)e(receiving)i
(the)f(data.)57 b(T)-8 b(aking)36 b(the)f(ratio)i(of)f(the)0
4085 y(t)m(w)m(o)d(giv)m(es)g(the)e(a)m(v)m(erage)j(pa)m(yload)f(size.)
44 b(If)31 b(it)h(can)g(b)s(e)f(assumed)f(that)j(pac)m(k)m(et)g(loss)f
(is)f(indep)s(enden)m(t)f(of)i(pac)m(k)m(et)0 4198 y(size,)37
b(then)e(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(receiv)m(ed)f(b)m
(y)f(a)h(particular)f(receiv)m(er)i(times)f(the)f(a)m(v)m(erage)j(pa)m
(yload)e(size)0 4310 y(\(or)31 b(the)f(corresp)s(onding)g(pac)m(k)m(et)
i(size\))g(giv)m(es)f(the)g(apparen)m(t)f(throughput)f(a)m(v)-5
b(ailable)33 b(to)e(that)g(receiv)m(er.)141 4423 y(In)39
b(addition)g(to)h(the)f(cum)m(ulativ)m(e)i(coun)m(ts)f(whic)m(h)f(allo)
m(w)i(long-term)f(pac)m(k)m(et)h(loss)f(measuremen)m(ts)f(using)0
4536 y(di\013erences)27 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)h(rep)s(orts,)f(the)g
(fraction)g(lost)h(\014eld)e(pro)m(vides)h(a)g(short-term)g(measuremen)
m(t)h(from)e(a)h(single)0 4649 y(rep)s(ort.)39 b(This)27
b(b)s(ecomes)i(more)f(imp)s(ortan)m(t)g(as)g(the)g(size)h(of)f(a)g
(session)g(scales)h(up)e(enough)g(that)i(reception)g(state)0
4762 y(information)d(migh)m(t)g(not)f(b)s(e)g(k)m(ept)h(for)f(all)h
(receiv)m(ers)h(or)e(the)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)26 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)g
(rep)s(orts)f(b)s(ecomes)g(long)h(enough)0 4875 y(that)31
b(only)f(one)h(rep)s(ort)f(migh)m(t)h(ha)m(v)m(e)h(b)s(een)d(receiv)m
(ed)j(from)e(a)h(particular)f(receiv)m(er.)141 4988 y(The)25
b(in)m(terarriv)-5 b(al)27 b(jitter)g(\014eld)e(pro)m(vides)h(a)g
(second)f(short-term)h(measure)g(of)g(net)m(w)m(ork)g(congestion.)41
b(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)0 5101 y(loss)d(trac)m(ks)h(p)s(ersisten)m(t)f
(congestion)h(while)f(the)g(jitter)g(measure)g(trac)m(ks)g(transien)m
(t)h(congestion.)64 b(The)37 b(jitter)0 5214 y(measure)31
b(ma)m(y)i(indicate)f(congestion)h(b)s(efore)e(it)h(leads)g(to)g(pac)m
(k)m(et)i(loss.)44 b(The)31 b(in)m(terarriv)-5 b(al)33
b(jitter)f(\014eld)f(is)h(only)0 5327 y(a)40 b(snapshot)f(of)h(the)h
(jitter)f(at)h(the)f(time)g(of)g(a)g(rep)s(ort)g(and)f(is)h(not)g(in)m
(tended)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(tak)m(en)i(quan)m(titativ)m(ely)-8
b(.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)g(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(34])p eop
%%Page: 35 35
35 34 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(Rather,)39 b(it)f(is)f(in)m(tended)g(for)f(comparison)i(across)f(a)g
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(rep)s(orts)g(from)f(one)h(receiv)m(er)i(o)m(v)m
(er)f(time)g(or)0 511 y(from)25 b(m)m(ultiple)h(receiv)m(ers,)i(e.g.,)g
(within)d(a)h(single)g(net)m(w)m(ork,)i(at)e(the)g(same)g(time.)40
b(T)-8 b(o)26 b(allo)m(w)h(comparison)e(across)0 624
y(receiv)m(ers,)k(it)e(is)g(imp)s(ortan)m(t)g(the)g(the)f(jitter)i(b)s
(e)e(calculated)i(according)g(to)f(the)g(same)g(form)m(ula)g(b)m(y)g
(all)g(receiv)m(ers.)141 737 y(Because)f(the)e(jitter)h(calculation)h
(is)e(based)g(on)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)24 b(timestamp)h(whic)m(h)f
(represen)m(ts)g(the)g(instan)m(t)h(when)0 850 y(the)30
b(\014rst)e(data)i(in)g(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(w)m(as)e(sampled,)f(an)m
(y)h(v)-5 b(ariation)30 b(in)g(the)f(dela)m(y)i(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f
(that)g(sampling)f(instan)m(t)0 963 y(and)37 b(the)h(time)h(the)f(pac)m
(k)m(et)i(is)e(transmitted)g(will)g(a\013ect)h(the)f(resulting)g
(jitter)h(that)f(is)g(calculated.)65 b(Suc)m(h)38 b(a)0
1076 y(v)-5 b(ariation)36 b(in)e(dela)m(y)i(w)m(ould)f(o)s(ccur)f(for)h
(audio)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(of)f(v)-5 b(arying)35 b(duration.)54
b(It)34 b(will)i(also)f(o)s(ccur)g(for)f(video)0 1189
y(enco)s(dings)i(b)s(ecause)h(the)g(timestamp)g(is)g(the)g(same)g(for)f
(all)i(the)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(of)e(one)f(frame)h(but)f(those)h(pac)m(k)m
(ets)0 1302 y(are)g(not)g(all)h(transmitted)f(at)h(the)f(same)g(time.)
61 b(The)37 b(v)-5 b(ariation)38 b(in)e(dela)m(y)i(un)m(til)f
(transmission)g(do)s(es)f(reduce)0 1415 y(the)i(accuracy)h(of)f(the)g
(jitter)h(calculation)h(as)e(a)g(measure)g(of)g(the)g(b)s(eha)m(vior)g
(of)g(the)g(net)m(w)m(ork)h(b)m(y)f(itself,)j(but)0 1528
y(it)35 b(is)f(appropriate)h(to)g(include)f(considering)g(that)h(the)g
(receiv)m(er)h(bu\013er)d(m)m(ust)h(accommo)s(date)i(it.)54
b(When)34 b(the)0 1641 y(jitter)f(calculation)i(is)d(used)g(as)h(a)g
(comparativ)m(e)h(measure,)g(the)e(\(constan)m(t\))j(comp)s(onen)m(t)d
(due)g(to)i(v)-5 b(ariation)33 b(in)0 1753 y(dela)m(y)26
b(un)m(til)f(transmission)f(subtracts)g(out)h(so)g(that)g(a)g(c)m
(hange)h(in)f(the)f(net)m(w)m(ork)i(jitter)f(comp)s(onen)m(t)g(can)g
(then)g(b)s(e)0 1866 y(observ)m(ed)30 b(unless)f(it)h(is)g(relativ)m
(ely)i(small.)42 b(If)29 b(the)h(c)m(hange)h(is)f(small)g(then)g(it)g
(is)g(lik)m(ely)h(to)g(b)s(e)e(inconsequen)m(tial.)0
2107 y Fo(6.5)112 b(SDES:)38 b(Source)f(description)h(R)-9
b(TCP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(et)349 2266 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349
2365 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g
(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
2465 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)0
2565 y(header)e(|V=2|P|)172 b(SC)129 b(|)87 b(PT=SDES=202)c(|)566
b(length)521 b(|)305 2664 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o
(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0 2764 y(chunk)85 b(|)1133 b(SSRC/CSRC_1)c(|)87
2864 y(1)174 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
305 2963 y(|)1177 b(SDES)41 b(items)1132 b(|)305 3063
y(|)1307 b(...)g(|)305 3162 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o
(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)0 3262 y(chunk)85 b(|)1133 b(SSRC/CSRC_2)c(|)87
3362 y(2)174 b(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
305 3461 y(|)1177 b(SDES)41 b(items)1132 b(|)305 3561
y(|)1307 b(...)g(|)305 3661 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o
(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)141 3856 y Fq(The)39 b(SDES)f(pac)m(k)m(et)k(is)d(a)h
(three-lev)m(el)h(structure)e(comp)s(osed)g(of)h(a)f(header)h(and)e
(zero)i(or)g(more)f(c)m(h)m(unks,)0 3969 y(eac)m(h)c(of)f(whic)m(h)f
(is)h(comp)s(osed)g(of)f(items)i(describing)e(the)h(source)g(iden)m
(ti\014ed)g(in)f(that)h(c)m(h)m(unk.)51 b(The)33 b(items)i(are)0
4082 y(describ)s(ed)29 b(individually)h(in)g(subsequen)m(t)g(sections.)
0 4280 y Fl(v)m(ersion)36 b(\(V\),)e(padding)h(\(P\),)g(length:)227
4393 y Fq(As)c(describ)s(ed)e(for)h(the)h(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(\(see)e
(Section)g(6.4.1\).)0 4575 y Fl(pac)m(k)m(et)k(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\(PT\):)45
b Fq(8)31 b(bits)227 4688 y(Con)m(tains)g(the)g(constan)m(t)g(202)h(to)
f(iden)m(tify)g(this)f(as)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(SDES)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)0
4871 y Fl(source)36 b(coun)m(t)f(\(SC\):)45 b Fq(5)31
b(bits)227 4984 y(The)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C)f(c)m(h)
m(unks)g(con)m(tained)j(in)d(this)h(SDES)f(pac)m(k)m(et.)44
b(A)31 b(v)-5 b(alue)32 b(of)f(zero)h(is)f(v)-5 b(alid)227
5097 y(but)30 b(useless.)141 5294 y(Eac)m(h)d(c)m(h)m(unk)f(consists)g
(of)g(an)g(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(follo)m(w)m(ed)i(b)m(y)d
(a)i(list)f(of)h(zero)f(or)g(more)h(items,)g(whic)m(h)0
5407 y(carry)37 b(information)h(ab)s(out)f(the)g(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C.)60
b(Eac)m(h)38 b(c)m(h)m(unk)f(starts)h(on)f(a)h(32-bit)g(b)s(oundary)-8
b(.)60 b(Eac)m(h)38 b(item)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(35])p eop
%%Page: 36 36
36 35 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(consists)40 b(of)g(an)f(8-bit)i(t)m(yp)s(e)f(\014eld,)i(an)d(8-bit)i
(o)s(ctet)g(coun)m(t)f(describing)f(the)h(length)g(of)g(the)g(text)g
(\(th)m(us,)j(not)0 511 y(including)30 b(this)g(t)m(w)m(o-o)s(ctet)j
(header\),)d(and)g(the)g(text)h(itself.)41 b(Note)32
b(that)e(the)h(text)g(can)f(b)s(e)f(no)h(longer)h(than)f(255)0
624 y(o)s(ctets,)i(but)e(this)g(is)g(consisten)m(t)i(with)e(the)h(need)
f(to)h(limit)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(bandwidth)e(consumption.)141
737 y(The)f(text)h(is)f(enco)s(ded)f(according)i(to)g(the)f(UTF-8)h
(enco)s(ding)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(in)h(RF)m(C)g(2279)i([5].)40
b(US-ASCI)s(I)26 b(is)h(a)0 850 y(subset)f(of)h(this)g(enco)s(ding)g
(and)f(requires)h(no)f(additional)i(enco)s(ding.)40 b(The)26
b(presence)h(of)g(m)m(ulti-o)s(ctet)i(enco)s(dings)0
963 y(is)h(indicated)h(b)m(y)g(setting)g(the)g(most)f(signi\014can)m(t)
i(bit)e(of)h(a)f(c)m(haracter)i(to)g(a)e(v)-5 b(alue)31
b(of)g(one.)141 1076 y(Items)g(are)h(con)m(tiguous,)g(i.e.,)h(items)e
(are)h(not)f(individually)g(padded)e(to)j(a)g(32-bit)g(b)s(oundary)-8
b(.)41 b(T)-8 b(ext)32 b(is)f(not)0 1189 y(n)m(ull)i(terminated)h(b)s
(ecause)f(some)h(m)m(ulti-o)s(ctet)h(enco)s(dings)e(include)g(n)m(ull)g
(o)s(ctets.)51 b(The)33 b(list)h(of)f(items)h(in)f(eac)m(h)0
1302 y(c)m(h)m(unk)c Fi(must)g Fq(b)s(e)58 b(terminated)30
b(b)m(y)f(one)h(or)f(more)h(n)m(ull)f(o)s(ctets,)j(the)d(\014rst)g(of)h
(whic)m(h)f(is)g(in)m(terpreted)h(as)g(an)f(item)0 1415
y(t)m(yp)s(e)37 b(of)f(zero)i(to)f(denote)g(the)g(end)f(of)g(the)h
(list.)60 b(No)37 b(length)g(o)s(ctet)h(follo)m(ws)g(the)e(n)m(ull)h
(item)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(o)s(ctet,)j(but)0 1528 y(additional)28
b(n)m(ull)f(o)s(ctets)i Fi(must)d Fq(b)s(e)h(included)g(if)g(needed)g
(to)h(pad)e(un)m(til)i(the)g(next)f(32-bit)i(b)s(oundary)-8
b(.)38 b(Note)28 b(that)0 1641 y(this)g(padding)f(is)g(separate)i(from)
e(that)i(indicated)f(b)m(y)g(the)g(P)f(bit)h(in)g(the)g(R)-8
b(TCP)27 b(header.)79 b(A)28 b(c)m(h)m(unk)g(with)f(zero)0
1753 y(items)k(\(four)f(n)m(ull)g(o)s(ctets\))i(is)f(v)-5
b(alid)30 b(but)g(useless.)141 1866 y(End)21 b(systems)h(send)g(one)g
(SDES)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(con)m(taining)g(their)e(o)m(wn)h(source)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(\(the)f(same)h(as)f(the)h(SSR)m(C)0 1979
y(in)h(the)h(\014xed)f(R)-8 b(TP)24 b(header\).)39 b(A)25
b(mixer)f(sends)g(one)h(SDES)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(con)m(taining)f(a)f(c)m
(h)m(unk)f(for)h(eac)m(h)g(con)m(tributing)0 2092 y(source)40
b(from)f(whic)m(h)h(it)g(is)g(receiving)h(SDES)e(information,)k(or)d(m)
m(ultiple)g(complete)i(SDES)d(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)f(the)0
2205 y(format)31 b(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)g(if)g(there)f(are)h(more)f(than)h
(31)g(suc)m(h)f(sources)g(\(see)i(Section)f(7\).)141
2318 y(The)h(SDES)g(items)h(curren)m(tly)f(de\014ned)f(are)i(describ)s
(ed)e(in)h(the)h(next)g(sections.)47 b(Only)32 b(the)h(CNAME)f(item)0
2431 y(is)27 b(mandatory)-8 b(.)39 b(Some)27 b(items)g(sho)m(wn)f(here)
g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(useful)g(only)g(for)g(particular)h(pro\014les,)g
(but)f(the)h(item)g(t)m(yp)s(es)0 2544 y(are)h(all)h(assigned)f(from)f
(one)h(common)g(space)h(to)f(promote)g(shared)g(use)f(and)g(to)i
(simplify)e(pro\014le-indep)s(enden)m(t)0 2657 y(applications.)60
b(Additional)36 b(items)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(de\014ned)f(in)h(a)g
(pro\014le)g(b)m(y)g(registering)i(the)e(t)m(yp)s(e)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)
f(with)0 2770 y(IANA)c(as)f(describ)s(ed)g(in)g(App)s(endix)e(D.)0
3009 y Fl(6.5.1)105 b(CNAME:)35 b(Canonical)g(end-p)s(oin)m(t)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(SDES)g(item)349 3167 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349
3267 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g
(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
3366 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
3466 y(|)174 b(CNAME=1)d(|)218 b(length)172 b(|)43 b(user)f(and)g
(domain)f(name)347 b(...)305 3566 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141 3761 y Fq(The)30 b(CNAME)h(iden)m(ti\014er)f
(has)g(the)h(follo)m(wing)h(prop)s(erties:)136 3967 y
Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Because)31 b(the)f(randomly)f(allo)s(cated)j(SSR)m(C)c
(iden)m(ti\014er)i(ma)m(y)g(c)m(hange)h(if)f(a)f(con\015ict)i(is)f
(disco)m(v)m(ered)g(or)g(if)g(a)227 4080 y(program)j(is)g(restarted,)h
(the)f(CNAME)g(item)h Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)g(included)65
b(to)33 b(pro)m(vide)g(the)h(binding)d(from)i(the)227
4193 y(SSR)m(C)d(iden)m(ti\014er)g(to)h(an)g(iden)m(ti\014er)f(for)g
(the)h(source)f(that)h(remains)f(constan)m(t.)136 4379
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Lik)m(e)23 b(the)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er,)j(the)f
(CNAME)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h Fi(should)d Fq(also)j(b)s(e)f(unique)f
(among)i(all)g(participan)m(ts)227 4492 y(within)30 b(one)h(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(session.)136 4677 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(o)33
b(pro)m(vide)f(a)h(binding)e(across)i(m)m(ultiple)g(media)g(to)s(ols)g
(used)e(b)m(y)h(one)h(participan)m(t)g(in)f(a)h(set)g(of)f(related)227
4790 y(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(sessions,)h(the)g(CNAME)f Fi(should)f
Fq(b)s(e)h(\014xed)f(for)h(that)h(participan)m(t.)136
4975 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(o)36 b(facilitate)h(third-part)m(y)e
(monitoring,)i(the)e(CNAME)g Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)h(suitable)h(for)g
(either)g(a)g(program)227 5088 y(or)c(a)f(p)s(erson)g(to)h(lo)s(cate)h
(the)e(source.)141 5294 y(Therefore,)41 b(the)e(CNAME)g
Fi(should)f Fq(b)s(e)g(deriv)m(ed)h(algorithmically)j(and)c(not)h(en)m
(tered)h(man)m(ually)-8 b(,)42 b(when)0 5407 y(p)s(ossible.)c(T)-8
b(o)24 b(meet)h(these)f(requiremen)m(ts,)h(the)f(follo)m(wing)h(format)
f Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)i(used)g(unless)g(a)h(pro\014le)f(sp)s
(eci\014es)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(36])p eop
%%Page: 37 37
37 36 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(an)39 b(alternate)i(syn)m(tax)f(or)f(seman)m(tics.)68
b(The)39 b(CNAME)g(item)h Fi(should)d Fq(ha)m(v)m(e)j(the)g(format)f
(\\user@host",)j(or)0 511 y(\\host")31 b(if)f(a)g(user)f(name)h(is)g
(not)g(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable)33 b(as)d(on)g(single-user)g(systems.)40
b(F)-8 b(or)31 b(b)s(oth)e(formats,)i(\\host")g(is)e(either)0
624 y(the)37 b(fully)g(quali\014ed)f(domain)h(name)g(of)g(the)g(host)g
(from)f(whic)m(h)h(the)g(real-time)i(data)e(originates,)j(formatted)0
737 y(according)c(to)h(the)e(rules)g(sp)s(eci\014ed)g(in)g(RF)m(C)h
(1034)h([6)q(],)g(RF)m(C)f(1035)h([7)q(])e(and)g(Section)i(2.1)f(of)g
(RF)m(C)g(1123)h([8];)0 850 y(or)d(the)h(standard)f(ASCI)s(I)f
(represen)m(tation)i(of)g(the)f(host's)h(n)m(umeric)f(address)g(on)g
(the)h(in)m(terface)h(used)e(for)g(the)0 963 y(R)-8 b(TP)31
b(comm)m(unication.)43 b(F)-8 b(or)32 b(example,)g(the)f(standard)f
(ASCI)s(I)f(represen)m(tation)j(of)f(an)g(IP)f(V)-8 b(ersion)32
b(4)f(address)0 1076 y(is)42 b(\\dotted)h(decimal",)j(also)d(kno)m(wn)e
(as)h(dotted)g(quad,)i(and)e(for)f(IP)g(V)-8 b(ersion)43
b(6,)i(addresses)c(are)h(textually)0 1189 y(represen)m(ted)f(as)h
(groups)e(of)i(hexadecimal)h(digits)e(separated)h(b)m(y)f(colons)i
(\(with)e(v)-5 b(ariations)42 b(as)g(detailed)g(in)0
1302 y(RF)m(C)23 b(2373)h([23)q(]\).)76 b(Other)22 b(address)g(t)m(yp)s
(es)g(are)h(exp)s(ected)g(to)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h(ASCI)s(I)c(represen)m
(tations)k(that)f(are)f(m)m(utually)0 1415 y(unique.)43
b(The)31 b(fully)g(quali\014ed)g(domain)g(name)g(is)h(more)f(con)m(v)m
(enien)m(t)j(for)d(a)h(h)m(uman)e(observ)m(er)i(and)e(ma)m(y)i(a)m(v)m
(oid)0 1528 y(the)d(need)g(to)g(send)f(a)h(NAME)h(item)f(in)g
(addition,)g(but)f(it)i(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)f(di\016cult)h(or)g(imp)s
(ossible)f(to)i(obtain)f(reliably)0 1641 y(in)i(some)g(op)s(erating)h
(en)m(vironmen)m(ts.)43 b(Applications)32 b(that)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e
(run)g(in)h(suc)m(h)f(en)m(vironmen)m(ts)i Fi(should)d
Fq(use)0 1753 y(the)i(ASCI)s(I)d(represen)m(tation)k(of)e(the)h
(address)e(instead.)141 1866 y(Examples)20 b(are)h(\\do)s(e@sleep)m(y)
-8 b(.example.com",)26 b(\\do)s(e@192.0.2.89")f(or)20
b(\\do)s(e@2201:056D::112E:1)q(44A)q(:1E2)q(4")0 1979
y(for)25 b(a)g(m)m(ulti-user)g(system.)39 b(On)24 b(a)h(system)g(with)g
(no)g(user)f(name,)i(examples)g(w)m(ould)e(b)s(e)h(\\sleep)m(y)-8
b(.example.com",)0 2092 y(\\192.0.2.89")35 b(or)c(\\2201:056D::112E:14)
q(4A:)q(1E24)q(".)141 2205 y(The)g(user)g(name)h Fi(should)e
Fq(b)s(e)g(in)i(a)g(form)f(that)h(a)g(program)f(suc)m(h)g(as)h
(\\\014nger")g(or)g(\\talk")h(could)f(use,)g(i.e.,)0
2318 y(it)39 b(t)m(ypically)h(is)e(the)g(login)h(name)g(rather)f(than)g
(the)g(p)s(ersonal)g(name.)64 b(The)38 b(host)g(name)g(is)h(not)f
(necessarily)0 2431 y(iden)m(tical)32 b(to)f(the)g(one)g(in)f(the)g
(participan)m(t's)i(electronic)g(mail)f(address.)141
2544 y(This)g(syn)m(tax)h(will)g(not)g(pro)m(vide)g(unique)f(iden)m
(ti\014ers)g(for)h(eac)m(h)h(source)f(if)f(an)h(application)h(p)s
(ermits)e(a)h(user)0 2657 y(to)i(generate)g(m)m(ultiple)g(sources)e
(from)h(one)g(host.)48 b(Suc)m(h)33 b(an)f(application)j(w)m(ould)d(ha)
m(v)m(e)i(to)g(rely)f(on)g(the)g(SSR)m(C)0 2770 y(to)i(further)d(iden)m
(tify)j(the)f(source,)h(or)f(the)g(pro\014le)g(for)f(that)i
(application)g(w)m(ould)f(ha)m(v)m(e)h(to)f(sp)s(ecify)g(additional)0
2883 y(syn)m(tax)d(for)f(the)h(CNAME)f(iden)m(ti\014er.)141
2995 y(If)45 b(eac)m(h)h(application)h(creates)g(its)f(CNAME)f(indep)s
(enden)m(tly)-8 b(,)49 b(the)c(resulting)h(CNAMEs)f(ma)m(y)h(not)g(b)s
(e)0 3108 y(iden)m(tical)37 b(as)e(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(required)g(to)i
(pro)m(vide)f(a)g(binding)f(across)h(m)m(ultiple)g(media)g(to)s(ols)h
(b)s(elonging)f(to)h(one)0 3221 y(participan)m(t)28 b(in)e(a)i(set)f
(of)g(related)h(R)-8 b(TP)26 b(sessions.)40 b(If)26 b(cross-media)i
(binding)e(is)h(required,)g(it)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(necessary)0
3334 y(for)37 b(the)g(CNAME)h(of)f(eac)m(h)h(to)s(ol)h(to)f(b)s(e)e
(externally)j(con\014gured)d(with)h(the)g(same)h(v)-5
b(alue)38 b(b)m(y)f(a)g(co)s(ordination)0 3447 y(to)s(ol.)141
3560 y(Application)29 b(writers)f(should)e(b)s(e)i(a)m(w)m(are)h(that)f
(priv)-5 b(ate)29 b(net)m(w)m(ork)g(address)e(assignmen)m(ts)h(suc)m(h)
g(as)g(the)g(Net-)0 3673 y(10)44 b(assignmen)m(t)g(prop)s(osed)e(in)h
(RF)m(C)h(1918)h([24)q(])f(ma)m(y)g(create)g(net)m(w)m(ork)h(addresses)
d(that)i(are)g(not)f(globally)0 3786 y(unique.)67 b(This)39
b(w)m(ould)g(lead)i(to)f(non-unique)e(CNAMEs)i(if)f(hosts)h(with)f
(priv)-5 b(ate)40 b(addresses)f(and)g(no)g(direct)0 3899
y(IP)g(connectivit)m(y)i(to)f(the)g(public)e(In)m(ternet)i(ha)m(v)m(e)g
(their)g(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(forw)m(arded)e(to)h(the)f
(public)g(In)m(ternet)0 4012 y(through)29 b(an)h(R)-8
b(TP-lev)m(el)32 b(translator.)42 b(\(See)30 b(also)h(RF)m(C)g(1627)h
([25)q(].\))41 b(T)-8 b(o)30 b(handle)g(this)g(case,)h(applications)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)0 4125 y Fq(pro)m(vide)34 b(a)h(means)f(to)h(con\014gure)f
(a)h(unique)e(CNAME,)i(but)e(the)i(burden)d(is)i(on)g(the)h(translator)
g(to)g(translate)0 4237 y(CNAMEs)i(from)f(priv)-5 b(ate)38
b(addresses)e(to)i(public)e(addresses)g(if)h(necessary)g(to)h(k)m(eep)g
(priv)-5 b(ate)37 b(addresses)f(from)0 4350 y(b)s(eing)30
b(exp)s(osed.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(37])p eop
%%Page: 38 38
38 37 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(6.5.2)105 b(NAME:)35 b(User)h(name)e(SDES)h(item)349
557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 656 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g
(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)
g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305 756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 856 y(|)218 b(NAME=2)171 b(|)218
b(length)172 b(|)43 b(common)e(name)h(of)h(source)302
b(...)305 955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)
o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
141 1151 y Fq(This)29 b(is)g(the)g(real)h(name)f(used)g(to)g(describ)s
(e)g(the)g(source,)h(e.g.,)h(\\John)e(Do)s(e,)h(Bit)h(Recycler".)42
b(It)29 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(in)0 1264 y(an)m(y)h(form)g(desired)f(b)m(y)
h(the)g(user.)39 b(F)-8 b(or)30 b(applications)g(suc)m(h)e(as)h
(conferencing,)h(this)f(form)f(of)h(name)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(the)0
1377 y(most)h(desirable)f(for)g(displa)m(y)g(in)g(participan)m(t)h
(lists,)h(and)d(therefore)i(migh)m(t)g(b)s(e)e(sen)m(t)i(most)g
(frequen)m(tly)f(of)g(those)0 1490 y(items)h(other)g(than)g(CNAME.)40
b(Pro\014les)29 b Fi(ma)-6 b(y)29 b Fq(establish)h(suc)m(h)e
(priorities.)41 b(The)28 b(NAME)h(v)-5 b(alue)29 b(is)g(exp)s(ected)g
(to)0 1603 y(remain)e(constan)m(t)i(at)f(least)h(for)e(the)g(duration)g
(of)h(a)g(session.)40 b(It)27 b Fi(should)f Fq(NOT)h(b)s(e)f(relied)i
(up)s(on)e(to)i(b)s(e)f(unique)0 1716 y(among)k(all)g(participan)m(ts)g
(in)g(the)f(session.)0 2138 y Fl(6.5.3)105 b(EMAIL:)35
b(Electronic)g(mail)g(address)g(SDES)g(item)349 2296
y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 2396 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)
g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g
(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305 2495 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 2595 y(|)174 b(EMAIL=3)d(|)218
b(length)172 b(|)43 b(email)f(address)e(of)j(source)215
b(...)305 2695 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)141 2891 y Fq(The)20 b(email)h(address)f(is)g(formatted)h
(according)g(to)g(RF)m(C)g(822)g([9)q(],)i(for)d(example,)j(\\John.Do)s
(e@example.com".)0 3003 y(The)30 b(EMAIL)g(v)-5 b(alue)31
b(is)f(exp)s(ected)h(to)g(remain)g(constan)m(t)g(for)f(the)h(duration)f
(of)g(a)h(session.)0 3425 y Fl(6.5.4)105 b(PHONE:)35
b(Phone)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)h(SDES)e(item)349 3584 y Ff(0)827
b(1)h(2)g(3)349 3683 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h
(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)
f(9)g(0)g(1)305 3783 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o
(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)305 3883 y(|)174 b(PHONE=4)d(|)218 b(length)172
b(|)43 b(phone)f(number)f(of)h(source)259 b(...)305 3982
y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
4178 y Fq(The)31 b(phone)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g Fi(should)f
Fq(b)s(e)h(formatted)h(with)f(the)h(plus)f(sign)h(replacing)g(the)g(in)
m(ternational)i(access)0 4291 y(co)s(de.)41 b(F)-8 b(or)31
b(example,)g(\\+1)g(908)h(555)g(1212")g(for)e(a)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(in)
h(the)h(United)f(States.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(38])p eop
%%Page: 39 39
39 38 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(6.5.5)105 b(LOC:)34 b(Geographic)i(user)f(lo)s(cation)h(SDES)f
(item)349 557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 656 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h
(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)
h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305 756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 856 y(|)218 b(LOC=5)d(|)j(length)
172 b(|)43 b(geographic)c(location)i(of)i(site)e(...)305
955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
1151 y Fq(Dep)s(ending)f(on)h(the)g(application,)k(di\013eren)m(t)c
(degrees)g(of)g(detail)h(are)f(appropriate)g(for)f(this)h(item.)72
b(F)-8 b(or)0 1264 y(conference)38 b(applications,)i(a)e(string)f(lik)m
(e)i(\\Murra)m(y)e(Hill,)j(New)d(Jersey")h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(su\016cien)
m(t,)k(while,)f(for)e(an)0 1377 y(activ)m(e)29 b(badge)d(system,)i
(strings)e(lik)m(e)i(\\Ro)s(om)f(2A244,)i(A)-8 b(T&T)26
b(BL)h(MH")g(migh)m(t)g(b)s(e)f(appropriate.)39 b(The)26
b(degree)0 1490 y(of)32 b(detail)i(is)e(left)h(to)g(the)f(implemen)m
(tation)i(and/or)e(user,)h(but)e(format)i(and)e(con)m(ten)m(t)j
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)34 b Fq(b)s(e)d(prescrib)s(ed)g(b)m(y)0
1603 y(a)i(pro\014le.)49 b(The)32 b(LOC)h(v)-5 b(alue)33
b(is)g(exp)s(ected)h(to)f(remain)g(constan)m(t)i(for)e(the)g(duration)f
(of)i(a)f(session,)h(except)g(for)0 1716 y(mobile)d(hosts.)0
2131 y Fl(6.5.6)105 b(TOOL:)34 b(Application)h(or)h(to)s(ol)f(name)f
(SDES)h(item)349 2290 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 2389
y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)
h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
2489 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
2588 y(|)218 b(TOOL=6)171 b(|)218 b(length)172 b(|name/version)38
b(of)43 b(source)e(appl.)g(...)305 2688 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141 2884 y Fq(A)36 b(string)g(giving)h(the)f
(name)h(and)e(p)s(ossibly)g(v)m(ersion)i(of)f(the)g(application)i
(generating)f(the)f(stream,)i(e.g.,)0 2997 y(\\videoto)s(ol)26
b(1.2".)40 b(This)24 b(information)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(useful)h(for)g
(debugging)g(purp)s(oses)e(and)i(is)g(similar)g(to)h(the)g(Mailer)0
3110 y(or)34 b(Mail-System-V)-8 b(ersion)36 b(SMTP)d(headers.)50
b(The)33 b(TOOL)g(v)-5 b(alue)34 b(is)g(exp)s(ected)g(to)h(remain)e
(constan)m(t)i(for)f(the)0 3223 y(duration)c(of)g(the)h(session.)0
3638 y Fl(6.5.7)105 b(NOTE:)34 b(Notice/status)h(SDES)g(item)349
3797 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 3896 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g
(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)
g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305 3996 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 4095 y(|)218 b(NOTE=7)171
b(|)218 b(length)172 b(|)43 b(note)f(about)f(the)i(source)302
b(...)305 4195 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)141 4391 y Fq(The)44 b(follo)m(wing)j(seman)m(tics)f(are)f
(suggested)g(for)g(this)f(item,)50 b(but)44 b(these)h(or)g(other)g
(seman)m(tics)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)46 b Fq(b)s(e)0 4504 y(explicitly)36
b(de\014ned)d(b)m(y)h(a)g(pro\014le.)52 b(The)34 b(NOTE)g(item)g(is)h
(in)m(tended)f(for)g(transien)m(t)h(messages)g(describing)f(the)0
4617 y(curren)m(t)29 b(state)i(of)f(the)g(source,)g(e.g.,)h(\\on)f(the)
g(phone,)f(can't)h(talk".)42 b(Or,)30 b(during)e(a)i(seminar,)g(this)f
(item)h(migh)m(t)0 4730 y(b)s(e)d(used)g(to)h(con)m(v)m(ey)h(the)f
(title)h(of)f(the)f(talk.)41 b(It)28 b(should)e(b)s(e)h(used)g(only)g
(to)i(carry)e(exceptional)j(information)e(and)0 4843
y Fi(should)k Fq(NOT)h(b)s(e)g(included)g(routinely)g(b)m(y)h(all)g
(participan)m(ts)h(b)s(ecause)e(this)h(w)m(ould)f(slo)m(w)h(do)m(wn)f
(the)h(rate)g(at)0 4956 y(whic)m(h)29 b(reception)i(rep)s(orts)e(and)g
(CNAME)h(are)g(sen)m(t,)h(th)m(us)e(impairing)h(the)f(p)s(erformance)g
(of)h(the)g(proto)s(col.)42 b(In)0 5068 y(particular,)32
b(it)g Fi(should)e Fq(NOT)g(b)s(e)h(included)g(as)g(an)h(item)g(in)f(a)
g(user's)g(con\014guration)h(\014le)f(nor)g(automatically)0
5181 y(generated)g(as)g(in)f(a)h(quote-of-the-da)m(y)-8
b(.)141 5294 y(Since)34 b(the)g(NOTE)f(item)i(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(imp)s
(ortan)m(t)h(to)h(displa)m(y)f(while)g(it)g(is)g(activ)m(e,)k(the)c
(rate)g(at)h(whic)m(h)f(other)0 5407 y(non-CNAME)c(items)h(suc)m(h)f
(as)h(NAME)f(are)h(transmitted)g(migh)m(t)g(b)s(e)e(reduced)h(so)h
(that)f(the)h(NOTE)f(item)h(can)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(39])p eop
%%Page: 40 40
40 39 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(tak)m(e)f(that)f(part)f(of)h(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(bandwidth.)39
b(When)28 b(the)h(transien)m(t)g(message)g(b)s(ecomes)g(inactiv)m(e,)i
(the)e(NOTE)0 511 y(item)i Fi(should)d Fq(con)m(tin)m(ue)j(to)g(b)s(e)f
(transmitted)g(a)g(few)g(times)h(at)f(the)h(same)f(rep)s(etition)h
(rate)f(but)g(with)g(a)g(string)0 624 y(of)38 b(length)g(zero)h(to)g
(signal)g(the)f(receiv)m(ers.)64 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)43
b(receiv)m(ers)c Fi(should)d Fq(also)j(consider)f(the)g(NOTE)f(item)0
737 y(inactiv)m(e)j(if)f(it)g(is)f(not)h(receiv)m(ed)h(for)e(a)h(small)
g(m)m(ultiple)g(of)g(the)f(rep)s(etition)h(rate,)j(or)c(p)s(erhaps)f
(20-30)j(R)-8 b(TCP)0 850 y(in)m(terv)j(als.)0 1454 y
Fl(6.5.8)105 b(PRIV:)36 b(Priv)-6 b(ate)35 b(extensions)h(SDES)e(item)
349 1612 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 1712 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f
(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)
f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305 1811 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)
o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)
o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1911 y(|)218 b(PRIV=8)171
b(|)218 b(length)172 b(|)43 b(prefix)e(length)g(|prefix)g(string...)305
2011 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
2110 y(...)565 b(|)785 b(value)41 b(string)651 b(...)305
2210 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
2406 y Fq(This)39 b(item)i(is)e(used)g(to)i(de\014ne)e(exp)s(erimen)m
(tal)h(or)g(application-sp)s(eci\014c)i(SDES)d(extensions.)69
b(The)39 b(item)0 2519 y(con)m(tains)27 b(a)f(pre\014x)e(consisting)j
(of)e(a)h(length-string)h(pair,)f(follo)m(w)m(ed)h(b)m(y)f(the)f(v)-5
b(alue)27 b(string)e(\014lling)h(the)g(remainder)0 2632
y(of)43 b(the)h(item)g(and)e(carrying)h(the)h(desired)e(information.)80
b(The)43 b(pre\014x)f(length)h(\014eld)g(is)g(8)h(bits)f(long.)79
b(The)0 2745 y(pre\014x)37 b(string)g(is)h(a)h(name)e(c)m(hosen)i(b)m
(y)e(the)h(p)s(erson)f(de\014ning)g(the)h(PRIV)f(item)i(to)f(b)s(e)g
(unique)e(with)i(resp)s(ect)0 2858 y(to)45 b(other)g(PRIV)f(items)i
(this)e(application)i(migh)m(t)f(receiv)m(e.)86 b(The)44
b(application)h(creator)h(migh)m(t)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)f(to)0
2970 y(use)36 b(the)h(application)h(name)f(plus)e(an)i(additional)g
(subt)m(yp)s(e)f(iden)m(ti\014cation)i(if)f(needed.)59
b(Alternativ)m(ely)-8 b(,)41 b(it)c(is)0 3083 y Fi(recommended)26
b Fq(that)i(others)h(c)m(ho)s(ose)g(a)g(name)f(based)g(on)g(the)g(en)m
(tit)m(y)i(they)f(represen)m(t,)g(then)f(co)s(ordinate)h(the)0
3196 y(use)h(of)h(the)f(name)h(within)e(that)i(en)m(tit)m(y)-8
b(.)141 3309 y(Note)46 b(that)e(the)h(pre\014x)e(consumes)g(some)i
(space)g(within)e(the)i(item's)f(total)i(length)f(of)f(255)i(o)s
(ctets,)j(so)0 3422 y(the)31 b(pre\014x)f(should)f(b)s(e)h(k)m(ept)i
(as)f(short)f(as)h(p)s(ossible.)42 b(This)30 b(facilit)m(y)j(and)d(the)
h(constrained)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(bandwidth)0 3535 y Fi(should)20
b Fq(NOT)g(b)s(e)h(o)m(v)m(erloaded;)26 b(it)c(is)f(not)h(in)m(tended)f
(to)h(satisfy)g(all)g(the)f(con)m(trol)i(comm)m(unication)g(requiremen)
m(ts)0 3648 y(of)31 b(all)g(applications.)141 3761 y(SDES)k(PRIV)g
(pre\014xes)g(will)g(not)h(b)s(e)f(registered)h(b)m(y)g(IANA.)56
b(If)35 b(some)h(form)f(of)g(the)h(PRIV)f(item)h(pro)m(v)m(es)0
3874 y(to)g(b)s(e)e(of)h(general)h(utilit)m(y)-8 b(,)38
b(it)e Fi(should)d Fq(instead)i(b)s(e)g(assigned)g(a)g(regular)g(SDES)g
(item)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(registered)h(with)0 3987 y(IANA)31
b(so)f(that)h(no)g(pre\014x)e(is)h(required.)40 b(This)30
b(simpli\014es)g(use)g(and)g(increases)h(transmission)f(e\016ciency)-8
b(.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)g(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(40])p eop
%%Page: 41 41
41 40 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fo(6.6)112 b(BYE:)37 b(Go)s(o)s(db)m(y)m(e)h(R)-9 b(TCP)36
b(pac)m(k)m(et)349 557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349 656
y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)g(6)
h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
856 y(|V=2|P|)172 b(SC)129 b(|)i(PT=BYE=203)83 b(|)566
b(length)521 b(|)305 955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1055 y(|)1177 b(SSRC/CSRC)c(|)305
1155 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
1254 y(:)1307 b(...)g(:)305 1354 y(+=+=+=+=+=+=+=+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o
(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o(=+)o(=+=)o(+=)o(+=+)o(=+)o
(=+=)o(+=)o(+=)o(+=+)44 1453 y(\(opt\))41 b(|)218 b(length)171
b(|)654 b(reason)41 b(for)h(leaving)520 b(...)305 1553
y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)141
1849 y Fq(The)30 b(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(indicates)f(that)g(one)g(or)f
(more)h(sources)f(are)h(no)f(longer)h(activ)m(e.)0 2061
y Fl(v)m(ersion)36 b(\(V\),)e(padding)h(\(P\),)g(length:)227
2174 y Fq(As)c(describ)s(ed)e(for)h(the)h(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(\(see)e
(Section)g(6.4.1\).)0 2362 y Fl(pac)m(k)m(et)k(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\(PT\):)45
b Fq(8)31 b(bits)227 2475 y(Con)m(tains)g(the)g(constan)m(t)g(203)h(to)
f(iden)m(tify)g(this)f(as)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)0
2662 y Fl(source)36 b(coun)m(t)f(\(SC\):)45 b Fq(5)31
b(bits)227 2775 y(The)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014ers)h(included)f(in)g(this)h(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)50
b(A)33 b(coun)m(t)h(v)-5 b(alue)33 b(of)g(zero)227 2888
y(is)e(v)-5 b(alid,)31 b(but)e(useless.)141 3101 y(The)h(rules)g(for)g
(when)f(a)i(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(should)e(b)s(e)f(sen)m(t)i(are)g(sp)s
(eci\014ed)f(in)g(Sections)h(6.3.7)h(and)e(8.2.)141 3214
y(If)i(a)h(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(is)f(receiv)m(ed)h(b)m(y)e(a)h(mixer,)g
(the)g(mixer)f Fi(should)64 b Fq(forw)m(ard)32 b(the)g(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m
(et)i(with)d(the)0 3326 y(SSR)m(C/CSR)m(C)27 b(iden)m(ti\014er\(s\))j
(unc)m(hanged.)39 b(If)28 b(a)h(mixer)g(sh)m(uts)f(do)m(wn,)h(it)g
Fi(should)e Fq(send)h(a)h(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(listing)0
3439 y(all)g(con)m(tributing)h(sources)e(it)h(handles,)g(as)f(w)m(ell)i
(as)f(its)g(o)m(wn)f(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er.)40 b(Optionally)-8
b(,)31 b(the)f(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et)0 3552 y Fi(ma)-6 b(y)38
b Fq(include)f(an)f(8-bit)i(o)s(ctet)h(coun)m(t)e(follo)m(w)m(ed)i(b)m
(y)d(that)i(man)m(y)f(o)s(ctets)h(of)f(text)h(indicating)g(the)f
(reason)g(for)0 3665 y(lea)m(ving,)32 b(e.g.,)g(\\camera)f
(malfunction")g(or)f(\\R)-8 b(TP)30 b(lo)s(op)g(detected".)43
b(The)29 b(string)h(has)g(the)g(same)h(enco)s(ding)f(as)0
3778 y(that)37 b(describ)s(ed)e(for)h(SDES.)57 b(If)36
b(the)g(string)g(\014lls)g(the)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(to)f(the)g(next)f
(32-bit)h(b)s(oundary)-8 b(,)36 b(the)h(string)f(is)0
3891 y(not)e(n)m(ull)g(terminated.)51 b(If)34 b(not,)h(the)f(BYE)g(pac)
m(k)m(et)i Fi(must)d Fq(b)s(e)g(padded)g(with)g(n)m(ull)h(o)s(ctets)h
(to)g(the)f(next)g(32-bit)0 4004 y(b)s(oundary)-8 b(.)39
b(This)30 b(padding)f(is)i(separate)g(from)f(that)h(indicated)g(b)m(y)f
(the)h(P)f(bit)g(in)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(header.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(41])p eop
%%Page: 42 42
42 41 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fo(6.7)112 b(APP:)37 b(Application-de\014ned)i(R)-9
b(TCP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et)349 557 y Ff(0)827 b(1)h(2)g(3)349
656 y(0)43 b(1)g(2)g(3)g(4)h(5)f(6)g(7)g(8)g(9)g(0)h(1)f(2)g(3)g(4)g(5)
g(6)h(7)f(8)g(9)g(0)g(1)g(2)h(3)f(4)g(5)g(6)g(7)h(8)f(9)g(0)g(1)305
756 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
856 y(|V=2|P|)e(subtype)f(|)131 b(PT=APP=204)83 b(|)566
b(length)521 b(|)305 955 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305 1055 y(|)1177 b(SSRC/CSRC)c(|)305
1155 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o
(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
1254 y(|)1133 b(name)42 b(\(ASCII\))1087 b(|)305 1354
y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o(+-+)305
1453 y(|)828 b(application-depe)o(nd)o(ent)37 b(data)695
b(...)305 1553 y(+-+-+-+-+-+-+-+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o
(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-+)o(-+)o(-+-)o(+-)o(+-)o
(+-+)141 1749 y Fq(The)39 b(APP)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)e(in)m(tended)f
(for)h(exp)s(erimen)m(tal)g(use)g(as)g(new)f(applications)i(and)e(new)g
(features)i(are)0 1862 y(dev)m(elop)s(ed,)26 b(without)e(requiring)g
(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(e)f(v)-5 b(alue)24 b(registration.)40
b(APP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(with)c(unrecognized)i(names)0
1975 y Fi(should)i Fq(b)s(e)i(ignored.)40 b(After)29
b(testing)h(and)f(if)g(wider)f(use)h(is)g(justi\014ed,)f(it)i(is)f
Fi(recommended)d Fq(that)k(eac)m(h)g(APP)0 2088 y(pac)m(k)m(et)c(b)s(e)
e(rede\014ned)e(without)j(the)f(subt)m(yp)s(e)f(and)h(name)g(\014elds)f
(and)h(registered)h(with)e(IANA)49 b(using)23 b(an)h(R)-8
b(TCP)0 2201 y(pac)m(k)m(et)32 b(t)m(yp)s(e.)0 2382 y
Fl(v)m(ersion)k(\(V\),)e(padding)h(\(P\),)g(length:)227
2495 y Fq(As)c(describ)s(ed)e(for)h(the)h(SR)e(pac)m(k)m(et)k(\(see)e
(Section)g(6.4.1\).)0 2672 y Fl(subt)m(yp)s(e:)46 b Fq(5)30
b(bits)227 2785 y(Ma)m(y)c(b)s(e)e(used)g(as)h(a)g(subt)m(yp)s(e)f(to)h
(allo)m(w)h(a)g(set)f(of)g(APP)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(to)e(b)s(e)f
(de\014ned)g(under)f(one)i(unique)f(name,)227 2898 y(or)31
b(for)f(an)m(y)g(application-dep)s(enden)m(t)i(data.)0
3076 y Fl(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\(PT\):)45 b Fq(8)31
b(bits)227 3188 y(Con)m(tains)g(the)g(constan)m(t)g(204)h(to)f(iden)m
(tify)g(this)f(as)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(APP)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)0
3366 y Fl(name:)45 b Fq(4)31 b(o)s(ctets)227 3479 y(A)j(name)f(c)m
(hosen)h(b)m(y)f(the)g(p)s(erson)f(de\014ning)g(the)i(set)g(of)f(APP)g
(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(to)f(b)s(e)f(unique)f(with)h(resp)s(ect)g(to)227
3592 y(other)i(APP)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(this)f(application)h(migh)m(t)f
(receiv)m(e.)54 b(The)34 b(application)i(creator)g(migh)m(t)f(c)m(ho)s
(ose)g(to)227 3705 y(use)27 b(the)g(application)i(name,)f(and)f(then)f
(co)s(ordinate)i(the)g(allo)s(cation)h(of)f(subt)m(yp)s(e)e(v)-5
b(alues)27 b(to)h(others)f(who)227 3817 y(w)m(an)m(t)k(to)f(de\014ne)f
(new)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(t)m(yp)s(es)f(for)g(the)f(application.)42
b(Alternativ)m(ely)-8 b(,)33 b(it)d(is)g Fi(recommended)d
Fq(that)227 3930 y(others)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)g(a)f(name)h(based)f(on)g(the)
g(en)m(tit)m(y)i(they)e(represen)m(t,)i(then)e(co)s(ordinate)h(the)f
(use)g(of)g(the)h(name)227 4043 y(within)39 b(that)h(en)m(tit)m(y)-8
b(.)69 b(The)38 b(name)h(is)g(in)m(terpreted)h(as)f(a)h(sequence)f(of)g
(four)g(ASCI)s(I)e(c)m(haracters,)43 b(with)227 4156
y(upp)s(ercase)30 b(and)g(lo)m(w)m(ercase)i(c)m(haracters)g(treated)f
(as)g(distinct.)0 4333 y Fl(application-dep)s(enden)m(t)k(data:)45
b Fq(v)-5 b(ariable)31 b(length)227 4446 y(Application-dep)s(enden)m(t)
i(data)h(ma)m(y)f(or)g(ma)m(y)g(not)g(app)s(ear)f(in)h(an)f(APP)h(pac)m
(k)m(et.)49 b(It)33 b(is)g(in)m(terpreted)g(b)m(y)227
4559 y(the)e(application)h(and)d(not)i(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(itself.)42
b(It)30 b Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)h(a)h(m)m(ultiple)g(of)g(32)g(bits)f
(long.)0 5091 y Fp(7)135 b(R)-11 b(TP)44 b(T)-11 b(ranslators)46
b(and)e(Mixers)0 5294 y Fq(In)33 b(addition)h(to)g(end)f(systems,)i(R)
-8 b(TP)33 b(supp)s(orts)f(the)h(notion)h(of)g(\\translators")h(and)e
(\\mixers",)j(whic)m(h)d(could)0 5407 y(b)s(e)44 b(considered)g(as)h
(\\in)m(termediate)h(systems")f(at)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)44
b(lev)m(el.)84 b(Although)45 b(this)f(supp)s(ort)f(adds)h(some)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(42])p eop
%%Page: 43 43
43 42 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(complexit)m(y)26 b(to)f(the)g(proto)s(col,)i(the)e(need)f(for)g
(these)h(functions)f(has)g(b)s(een)g(clearly)i(established)f(b)m(y)f
(exp)s(erimen)m(ts)0 511 y(with)f(m)m(ulticast)j(audio)e(and)f(video)h
(applications)h(in)f(the)f(In)m(ternet.)39 b(Example)24
b(uses)g(of)g(translators)g(and)f(mixers)0 624 y(giv)m(en)37
b(in)e(Section)i(2.3)g(stem)f(from)g(the)g(presence)g(of)g(\014rew)m
(alls)g(and)f(lo)m(w)i(bandwidth)d(connections,)39 b(b)s(oth)c(of)0
737 y(whic)m(h)30 b(are)h(lik)m(ely)h(to)f(remain.)0
980 y Fo(7.1)112 b(General)39 b(Description)0 1152 y
Fq(An)32 b(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(translator/mixer)i(connects)g(t)m(w)m(o)g(or)
f(more)g(transp)s(ort-lev)m(el)i(\\clouds".)46 b(T)m(ypically)-8
b(,)34 b(eac)m(h)f(cloud)f(is)0 1265 y(de\014ned)27 b(b)m(y)h(a)h
(common)f(net)m(w)m(ork)h(and)f(transp)s(ort)f(proto)s(col)j(\(e.g.,)g
(IP/UDP\))f(plus)f(a)g(m)m(ulticast)i(address)e(and)0
1378 y(transp)s(ort)i(lev)m(el)i(destination)g(p)s(ort)e(or)h(a)g(pair)
g(of)g(unicast)g(addresses)f(and)g(p)s(orts.)83 b(\(Net)m(w)m(ork-lev)m
(el)35 b(proto)s(col)0 1491 y(translators,)c(suc)m(h)e(as)h(IP)f(v)m
(ersion)i(4)f(to)g(IP)f(v)m(ersion)i(6,)f(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(presen)m(t)h
(within)f(a)h(cloud)g(in)m(visibly)g(to)h(R)-8 b(TP.\))0
1604 y(One)24 b(system)h(ma)m(y)h(serv)m(e)g(as)f(a)g(translator)h(or)f
(mixer)f(for)h(a)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(R)-8 b(TP)25
b(sessions,)h(but)e(eac)m(h)i(is)f(considered)0 1717
y(a)31 b(logically)i(separate)e(en)m(tit)m(y)-8 b(.)141
1829 y(In)37 b(order)h(to)h(a)m(v)m(oid)g(creating)g(a)g(lo)s(op)f
(when)f(a)h(translator)h(or)f(mixer)g(is)g(installed,)j(the)d(follo)m
(wing)h(rules)0 1942 y Fi(must)29 b Fq(b)s(e)h(observ)m(ed:)136
2153 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Eac)m(h)c(of)e(the)h(clouds)g(connected)g(b)m(y)
g(translators)g(and)g(mixers)f(participating)i(in)e(one)h(R)-8
b(TP)41 b(session)227 2266 y(either)g Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)f(distinct)i
(from)f(all)i(the)e(others)h(in)f(at)h(least)h(one)f(of)g(these)g
(parameters)f(\(proto)s(col,)227 2379 y(address,)30 b(p)s(ort\),)g(or)h
Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)h(isolated)i(at)f(the)f(net)m(w)m(ork)h(lev)m(el)i
(from)c(the)i(others.)136 2566 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(A)34
b(deriv)-5 b(ativ)m(e)35 b(of)f(the)f(\014rst)g(rule)g(is)h(that)g
(there)g Fi(must)i(not)d Fq(b)s(e)g(m)m(ultiple)h(translators)h(or)e
(mixers)g(con-)227 2679 y(nected)21 b(in)f(parallel)i(unless)d(b)m(y)i
(some)f(arrangemen)m(t)i(they)e(partition)h(the)g(set)g(of)f(sources)g
(to)i(b)s(e)d(forw)m(arded.)141 2889 y(Similarly)-8 b(,)30
b(all)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(end)g(systems)g(that)g(can)h(comm)m(unicate)g
(through)f(one)g(or)g(more)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(translators)h(or)0
3002 y(mixers)h(share)g(the)h(same)g(SSR)m(C)e(space,)j(that)f(is,)g
(the)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014ers)h Fi(must)g Fq(b)s(e)g(unique)f
(among)i(all)g(these)0 3115 y(end)c(systems.)40 b(Section)29
b(8.2)h(describ)s(es)e(the)g(collision)i(resolution)f(algorithm)h(b)m
(y)e(whic)m(h)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014ers)i(are)0 3228
y(k)m(ept)i(unique)e(and)h(lo)s(ops)h(are)f(detected.)141
3341 y(There)42 b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(man)m(y)g(v)-5 b(arieties)44
b(of)e(translators)h(and)e(mixers)h(designed)g(for)g(di\013eren)m(t)g
(purp)s(oses)f(and)0 3454 y(applications.)62 b(Some)37
b(examples)h(are)g(to)g(add)e(or)h(remo)m(v)m(e)i(encryption,)g(c)m
(hange)f(the)f(enco)s(ding)h(of)f(the)g(data)0 3566 y(or)42
b(the)h(underlying)e(proto)s(cols,)46 b(or)c(replicate)i(b)s(et)m(w)m
(een)f(a)f(m)m(ulticast)i(address)d(and)h(one)g(or)g(more)h(unicast)0
3679 y(addresses.)i(The)31 b(distinction)i(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f
(translators)h(and)e(mixers)h(is)g(that)h(a)f(translator)h(passes)e
(through)h(the)0 3792 y(data)k(streams)g(from)f(di\013eren)m(t)g
(sources)h(separately)-8 b(,)38 b(whereas)d(a)h(mixer)g(com)m(bines)f
(them)h(to)g(form)f(one)g(new)0 3905 y(stream:)0 4091
y Fl(T)-9 b(ranslator:)46 b Fq(F)-8 b(orw)m(ards)36 b(R)-8
b(TP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(with)d(their)g(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g
(in)m(tact;)42 b(this)36 b(mak)m(es)h(it)g(p)s(ossible)f(for)227
4204 y(receiv)m(ers)29 b(to)f(iden)m(tify)g(individual)e(sources)i(ev)m
(en)g(though)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)e(all)h(the)f(sources)h(pass)f
(through)227 4317 y(the)32 b(same)g(translator)g(and)e(carry)i(the)f
(translator's)h(net)m(w)m(ork)h(source)e(address.)43
b(Some)31 b(kinds)f(of)i(trans-)227 4430 y(lators)d(will)e(pass)h
(through)e(the)i(data)g(un)m(touc)m(hed,)g(but)f(others)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)28 b Fq(c)m(hange)h(the)f(enco)s(ding)f(of)h(the)f(data)
227 4543 y(and)g(th)m(us)f(the)i(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(data)g(pa)m(yload)h(t)m
(yp)s(e)g(and)e(timestamp.)40 b(If)27 b(m)m(ultiple)h(data)g(pac)m(k)m
(ets)h(are)e(re-enco)s(ded)227 4656 y(in)m(to)h(one,)g(or)e(vice)i(v)m
(ersa,)g(a)f(translator)g Fi(must)f Fq(assign)h(new)f(sequence)h(n)m
(um)m(b)s(ers)e(to)i(the)g(outgoing)h(pac)m(k-)227 4769
y(ets.)61 b(Losses)37 b(in)f(the)h(incoming)h(pac)m(k)m(et)g(stream)g
(ma)m(y)f(induce)f(corresp)s(onding)g(gaps)h(in)g(the)g(outgoing)227
4882 y(sequence)31 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers.)39 b(Receiv)m(ers)31
b(cannot)g(detect)g(the)f(presence)g(of)h(a)f(translator)h(unless)e
(they)h(kno)m(w)g(b)m(y)227 4994 y(some)h(other)g(means)f(what)g(pa)m
(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)e(or)h(transp)s(ort)e(address)h(w)m(as)g(used)g(b)m
(y)g(the)h(original)g(source.)0 5181 y Fl(Mixer:)46 b
Fq(Receiv)m(es)27 b(streams)e(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)24 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)
g(from)f(one)g(or)f(more)h(sources,)i(p)s(ossibly)c(c)m(hanges)j(the)f
(data)227 5294 y(format,)j(com)m(bines)f(the)f(streams)g(in)g(some)h
(manner)e(and)g(then)h(forw)m(ards)g(the)g(com)m(bined)g(stream.)40
b(Since)227 5407 y(the)35 b(timing)h(among)f(m)m(ultiple)h(input)d
(sources)i(will)g(not)h(generally)g(b)s(e)e(sync)m(hronized,)i(the)f
(mixer)g(will)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(43])p eop
%%Page: 44 44
44 43 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(mak)m(e)j(timing)g(adjustmen)m(ts)f(among)h(the)f(streams)g(and)g
(generate)h(its)g(o)m(wn)f(timing)h(for)e(the)i(com)m(bined)227
511 y(stream,)44 b(so)d(it)g(is)g(the)g(sync)m(hronization)h(source.)71
b(Th)m(us,)43 b(all)e(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(forw)m(arded)e(b)m(y)h(a)g
(mixer)227 624 y Fi(must)32 b Fq(b)s(e)h(mark)m(ed)g(with)g(the)g
(mixer's)g(o)m(wn)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er.)49 b(In)32
b(order)h(to)h(preserv)m(e)f(the)g(iden)m(tit)m(y)i(of)227
737 y(the)g(original)g(sources)f(con)m(tributing)g(to)h(the)f(mixed)g
(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(the)e(mixer)f Fi(should)e Fq(insert)i(their)g(SSR)m(C)
227 850 y(iden)m(ti\014ers)26 b(in)m(to)g(the)g(CSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(list)g(follo)m(wing)h(the)f(\014xed)f(R)-8
b(TP)25 b(header)g(of)h(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et.)41 b(A)26
b(mixer)227 963 y(that)40 b(is)f(also)h(itself)f(a)h(con)m(tributing)f
(source)g(for)g(some)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i Fi(should)c Fq(explicitly)k
(include)e(its)g(o)m(wn)227 1076 y(SSR)m(C)30 b(iden)m(ti\014er)g(in)g
(the)h(CSR)m(C)e(list)i(for)g(that)f(pac)m(k)m(et.)227
1226 y(F)-8 b(or)31 b(some)f(applications,)h(it)f Fi(ma)-6
b(y)31 b Fq(b)s(e)e(acceptable)j(for)d(a)i(mixer)e(not)h(to)h(iden)m
(tify)f(sources)f(in)h(the)g(CSR)m(C)227 1339 y(list.)71
b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)45 b(this)40 b(in)m(tro)s(duces)g(the)h(danger)f
(that)h(lo)s(ops)f(in)m(v)m(olving)i(those)f(sources)f(could)g(not)h(b)
s(e)227 1452 y(detected.)141 1640 y(The)29 b(adv)-5 b(an)m(tage)32
b(of)e(a)g(mixer)f(o)m(v)m(er)i(a)f(translator)h(for)e(applications)i
(lik)m(e)g(audio)f(is)f(that)i(the)e(output)h(band-)0
1753 y(width)c(is)h(limited)g(to)h(that)f(of)g(one)g(source)g(ev)m(en)g
(when)f(m)m(ultiple)h(sources)g(are)g(activ)m(e)i(on)e(the)g(input)e
(side.)40 b(This)0 1866 y(ma)m(y)32 b(b)s(e)g(imp)s(ortan)m(t)g(for)f
(lo)m(w-bandwidth)g(links.)45 b(The)31 b(disadv)-5 b(an)m(tage)34
b(is)d(that)i(receiv)m(ers)g(on)f(the)g(output)f(side)0
1978 y(don't)e(ha)m(v)m(e)h(an)m(y)g(con)m(trol)g(o)m(v)m(er)g(whic)m
(h)f(sources)g(are)h(passed)e(through)g(or)h(m)m(uted,)h(unless)e(some)
i(mec)m(hanism)f(is)0 2091 y(implemen)m(ted)j(for)f(remote)h(con)m
(trol)g(of)g(the)f(mixer.)43 b(The)31 b(regeneration)h(of)g(sync)m
(hronization)g(information)f(b)m(y)0 2204 y(mixers)k(also)g(means)g
(that)g(receiv)m(ers)i(can't)e(do)g(in)m(ter-media)h(sync)m
(hronization)g(of)f(the)g(original)h(streams.)54 b(A)0
2317 y(m)m(ulti-media)32 b(mixer)e(could)g(do)h(it.)0
4830 y
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1.1223 1.1223 scale neg exch neg
exch translate
 0 4830 a @beginspecial 0 @llx 0 @lly 417 @urx
258 @ury 4170 @rwi @setspecial
%%BeginDocument: map.ps
%!PS-Adobe-2.0 EPSF-2.0
%%Title: map.fig
%%Creator: fig2dev Version 3.1 Patchlevel 1
%%CreationDate: Fri Nov 10 13:36:20 1995
%%For: hgs@lupus (Henning Schulzrinne)
%%Orientation: Portrait
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 417 258
%%Pages: 0
%%BeginSetup
%%IncludeFeature: *PageSize Letter
%%EndSetup
%%EndComments
/$F2psDict 200 dict def
$F2psDict begin
$F2psDict /mtrx matrix put
/col-1 {} def
/col0 {0.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col1 {0.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col2 {0.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col3 {0.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col4 {1.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col5 {1.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col6 {1.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col7 {1.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col8 {0.000 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col9 {0.000 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col10 {0.000 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col11 {0.530 0.810 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col12 {0.000 0.560 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col13 {0.000 0.690 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col14 {0.000 0.820 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col15 {0.000 0.560 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col16 {0.000 0.690 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col17 {0.000 0.820 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col18 {0.560 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col19 {0.690 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col20 {0.820 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col21 {0.560 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col22 {0.690 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col23 {0.820 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col24 {0.500 0.190 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col25 {0.630 0.250 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col26 {0.750 0.380 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col27 {1.000 0.500 0.500 srgb} bind def
/col28 {1.000 0.630 0.630 srgb} bind def
/col29 {1.000 0.750 0.750 srgb} bind def
/col30 {1.000 0.880 0.880 srgb} bind def
/col31 {1.000 0.840 0.000 srgb} bind def

end
save
-83.0 314.0 translate
1 -1 scale

/clp {closepath} bind def
/ef {eofill} bind def
/gr {grestore} bind def
/gs {gsave} bind def
/l {lineto} bind def
/m {moveto} bind def
/n {newpath} bind def
/s {stroke} bind def
/slc {setlinecap} bind def
/slj {setlinejoin} bind def
/slw {setlinewidth} bind def
/srgb {setrgbcolor} bind def
/rot {rotate} bind def
/sc {scale} bind def
/tr {translate} bind def
/tnt {dup dup currentrgbcolor
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add srgb}
  bind def
/shd {dup dup currentrgbcolor 4 -2 roll mul 4 -2 roll mul
  4 -2 roll mul srgb} bind def
 /DrawEllipse {
	/endangle exch def
	/startangle exch def
	/yrad exch def
	/xrad exch def
	/y exch def
	/x exch def
	/savematrix mtrx currentmatrix def
	x y tr xrad yrad sc 0 0 1 startangle endangle arc
	closepath
	savematrix setmatrix
	} def

/$F2psBegin {$F2psDict begin /$F2psEnteredState save def} def
/$F2psEnd {$F2psEnteredState restore end} def
%%EndProlog

$F2psBegin
10 setmiterlimit
 0.06299 0.06299 sc
15.000 slw
% Ellipse
n 1800 2250 225 225 0 360 DrawEllipse gs col-1 s gr

% Ellipse
n 3375 3825 225 225 0 360 DrawEllipse gs col-1 s gr

% Ellipse
n 4950 3825 225 225 0 360 DrawEllipse gs col-1 s gr

% Polyline
n 1350 1125 m 2250 1125 l  2250 1575 l  1350 1575 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3375 2025 m 3150 2475 l  3600 2475 l  3375 2025 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1350 2925 m 2250 2925 l  2250 3375 l  1350 3375 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2925 2925 m 3825 2925 l  3825 3375 l  2925 3375 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 4950 2025 m 4725 2475 l  5175 2475 l  4950 2025 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 6300 2025 m 7200 2025 l  7200 2475 l  6300 2475 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 4500 1125 m 5400 1125 l  5400 1575 l  4500 1575 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1350 3600 m 2250 3600 l  2250 4050 l  1350 4050 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 4500 4500 m 5400 4500 l  5400 4950 l  4500 4950 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1800 2475 m 1800 2925 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 1770.00 2595.00 m 1800.00 2475.00 l 1830.00 2595.00 l  1800.50 2595.50 l 1770.00 2595.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 3375 2475 m 3375 2925 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2025 2250 m 3285 2250 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 3165.00 2220.00 m 3285.00 2250.00 l 3165.00 2280.00 l  3165.50 2250.50 l 3165.00 2220.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 3510 2250 m 4860 2250 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 4740.00 2220.00 m 4860.00 2250.00 l 4740.00 2280.00 l  4740.50 2250.50 l 4740.00 2220.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 5085 2250 m 6300 2250 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 6180.00 2220.00 m 6300.00 2250.00 l 6180.00 2280.00 l  6180.50 2250.50 l 6180.00 2220.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 4950 1575 m 4950 2025 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 4980.00 1905.00 m 4950.00 2025.00 l 4920.00 1905.00 l  4950.50 1905.50 l 4980.00 1905.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 4950 2475 m 4950 3600 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 4920.00 2595.00 m 4950.00 2475.00 l 4980.00 2595.00 l  4950.50 2595.50 l 4920.00 2595.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 2250 3825 m 3150 3825 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 3030.00 3795.00 m 3150.00 3825.00 l 3030.00 3855.00 l  3030.50 3825.50 l 3030.00 3795.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 3600 3825 m 4725 3825 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 4605.00 3795.00 m 4725.00 3825.00 l 4605.00 3855.00 l  4605.50 3825.50 l 4605.00 3795.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 4950 4050 m 4950 4500 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1800 1575 m 1800 2025 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 1830.00 1905.00 m 1800.00 2025.00 l 1770.00 1905.00 l  1800.50 1905.50 l 1830.00 1905.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
15.000 slw
% Polyline
n 5850 3825 m 7830 3825 l  gs col-1 s gr 
7.500 slw
n 7710.00 3795.00 m 7830.00 3825.00 l 7710.00 3855.00 l  7710.50 3825.50 l 7710.00 3795.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1800 3240 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E2) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3375 3240 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E4) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1800 3915 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E3) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3375 3870 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M2) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1800 2295 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M1) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3375 2385 m
gs 1 -1 sc (T1) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1800 1440 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E1) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 1440 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E6) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 2385 m
gs 1 -1 sc (T2) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 3915 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M3) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4950 4770 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E5) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
6750 2340 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E7) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5850 4050 m
gs 1 -1 sc (source: SSRC \(CSRC,...\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
6840 3735 m
gs 1 -1 sc (Legend:) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4995 3150 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M3: 89\(64,45\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5265 2430 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E4:47) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5265 2610 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M3:89\(64,45\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5265 2205 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M1:48\(1,17\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
5265 2025 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E6:15) col-1 show gr
/Times-Italic findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1800 1035 m
gs 1 -1 sc (end system) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Italic findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3375 1935 m
gs 1 -1 sc (translator) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Italic findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
2115 2475 m
gs 1 -1 sc (mixer) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4995 1755 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E6:15) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1845 1755 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E1:17) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3690 2430 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E4:47) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3690 2205 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M1: 48\(1,17\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
2115 2205 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M1:48\(1,17\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3690 4005 m
gs 1 -1 sc (M2:12\(64\)) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
1845 2880 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E2:1) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3420 2880 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E4:47) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
4995 4455 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E5:45) col-1 show gr
/Helvetica findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
2295 4005 m
gs 1 -1 sc (E3:64) col-1 show gr
$F2psEnd
restore

%%EndDocument
 @endspecial 0 4830 a
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1 1.1223 div 1 1.1223 div scale
neg exch neg exch translate
 0 4830 a 493 5026 a Fq(Figure)g(3:)41
b(Sample)30 b(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(net)m(w)m(ork)h(with)f(end)g(systems,)h
(mixers)f(and)g(translators)141 5256 y(A)h(collection)i(of)e(mixers)g
(and)f(translators)i(is)f(sho)m(wn)f(in)g(Fig.)i(3)f(to)h(illustrate)g
(their)f(e\013ect)h(on)f(SSR)m(C)f(and)0 5369 y(CSR)m(C)38
b(iden)m(ti\014ers.)64 b(In)38 b(the)h(\014gure,)h(end)e(systems)g(are)
h(sho)m(wn)f(as)g(rectangles)i(\(named)f(E\),)g(translators)g(as)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(44])p eop
%%Page: 45 45
45 44 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(triangles)38 b(\(named)f(T\))f(and)g(mixers)h(as)g(o)m(v)-5
b(als)38 b(\(named)f(M\).)g(The)g(notation)h(\\M1:)54
b(48\(1,17\)")41 b(designates)d(a)0 511 y(pac)m(k)m(et)h(originating)f
(a)f(mixer)f(M1,)k(iden)m(ti\014ed)c(with)h(M1's)g(\(random\))g(SSR)m
(C)e(v)-5 b(alue)37 b(of)g(48)h(and)e(t)m(w)m(o)i(CSR)m(C)0
624 y(iden)m(ti\014ers,)31 b(1)f(and)g(17,)i(copied)e(from)g(the)h(SSR)
m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014ers)i(of)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)e(E1)h(and)f(E2.)0
864 y Fo(7.2)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(Pro)s(cessing)i(in)g(T)-9
b(ranslators)0 1035 y Fq(In)24 b(addition)h(to)g(forw)m(arding)f(data)i
(pac)m(k)m(ets,)i(p)s(erhaps)23 b(mo)s(di\014ed,)h(translators)i(and)e
(mixers)g Fi(must)g Fq(also)h(pro)s(cess)0 1148 y(R)-8
b(TCP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)60 b(In)35 b(man)m(y)h(cases,)j(they)d(will)h
(tak)m(e)h(apart)e(the)h(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)36
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(receiv)m(ed)f(from)0 1261 y(end)28
b(systems)h(to)h(aggregate)i(SDES)c(information)h(and)g(to)h(mo)s(dify)
e(the)h(SR)f(or)h(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets.)42 b(Retransmission)0
1374 y(of)36 b(this)f(information)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(triggered)i(b)m(y)
f(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(arriv)-5 b(al)36 b(or)g(b)m(y)f(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)35 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)37 b(timer)f(of)g(the)0
1487 y(translator)31 b(or)g(mixer)f(itself.)141 1600
y(A)24 b(translator)g(that)g(do)s(es)f(not)h(mo)s(dify)e(the)i(data)g
(pac)m(k)m(ets,)j(for)c(example)h(one)g(that)g(just)e(replicates)j(b)s
(et)m(w)m(een)0 1713 y(a)30 b(m)m(ulticast)h(address)e(and)g(a)h
(unicast)g(address,)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(simply)e(forw)m(ard)g(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(unmo)s(di\014ed)d(as)i(w)m(ell.)0
1826 y(A)24 b(translator)g(that)h(transforms)e(the)h(pa)m(yload)g(in)g
(some)g(w)m(a)m(y)i Fi(must)d Fq(mak)m(e)i(corresp)s(onding)d
(transformations)i(in)0 1939 y(the)k(SR)g(and)f(RR)h(information)g(so)h
(that)f(it)h(still)g(re\015ects)f(the)h(c)m(haracteristics)h(of)e(the)h
(data)f(and)g(the)g(reception)0 2052 y(qualit)m(y)-8
b(.)82 b(These)43 b(translators)h Fi(must)j(not)c Fq(simply)g(forw)m
(ard)g(R)-8 b(TCP)43 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)82 b(In)43 b(general,)48
b(a)c(translator)0 2165 y Fi(should)30 b(not)c Fq(aggregate)31
b(SR)26 b(and)h(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(from)d(di\013eren)m(t)g(sources)h
(in)m(to)g(one)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(since)f(that)g(w)m(ould)0
2277 y(reduce)i(the)h(accuracy)g(of)g(the)f(propagation)i(dela)m(y)f
(measuremen)m(ts)g(based)f(on)g(the)g(LSR)g(and)g(DLSR)g(\014elds.)0
2465 y Fl(SR)35 b(sender)g(information:)46 b Fq(A)22
b(translator)h(do)s(es)f(not)g(generate)i(its)e(o)m(wn)g(sender)f
(information,)j(but)e(forw)m(ards)227 2578 y(the)29 b(SR)e(pac)m(k)m
(ets)j(receiv)m(ed)f(from)f(one)g(cloud)g(to)h(the)g(others.)40
b(The)27 b(SSR)m(C)g(is)h(left)h(in)m(tact)h(but)d(the)i(sender)227
2691 y(information)f Fi(must)e Fq(b)s(e)h(mo)s(di\014ed)f(if)i
(required)e(b)m(y)i(the)f(translation.)41 b(If)27 b(a)h(translator)g(c)
m(hanges)h(the)e(data)227 2804 y(enco)s(ding,)40 b(it)e
Fi(must)f Fq(c)m(hange)h(the)g(\\sender's)f(b)m(yte)i(coun)m(t")f
(\014eld.)62 b(If)37 b(it)i(also)f(com)m(bines)g(sev)m(eral)h(data)227
2917 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)26 b(in)m(to)e(one)g(output)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)k(it)d
Fi(must)f Fq(c)m(hange)i(the)e(\\sender's)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(coun)m(t")g
(\014eld.)38 b(If)23 b(it)h(c)m(hanges)227 3030 y(the)31
b(timestamp)g(frequency)-8 b(,)30 b(it)h Fi(must)f Fq(c)m(hange)h(the)g
(\\R)-8 b(TP)30 b(timestamp")i(\014eld)e(in)g(the)g(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)
0 3209 y Fl(SR/RR)36 b(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f(blo)s(c)m(ks:)46
b Fq(A)d(translator)h(forw)m(ards)e(reception)i(rep)s(orts)e(receiv)m
(ed)i(from)f(one)227 3322 y(cloud)30 b(to)h(the)f(others.)41
b(Note)31 b(that)f(these)h(\015o)m(w)e(in)h(the)g(direction)h(opp)s
(osite)f(to)g(the)g(data.)42 b(The)29 b(SSR)m(C)g(is)227
3435 y(left)d(in)m(tact.)40 b(If)24 b(a)h(translator)h(com)m(bines)f
(sev)m(eral)h(data)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)m(to)e(one)g(output)f(pac)m(k)m
(et,)k(and)c(therefore)227 3548 y(c)m(hanges)39 b(the)f(sequence)g(n)m
(um)m(b)s(ers,)g(it)g Fi(must)f Fq(mak)m(e)h(the)g(in)m(v)m(erse)h
(manipulation)f(for)f(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(loss)227 3660
y(\014elds)31 b(and)f(the)h(\\extended)h(last)g(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er")f(\014eld.)42 b(This)30 b(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)e(complex.)44
b(In)30 b(the)h(extreme)227 3773 y(case,)40 b(there)c(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f
(no)g(meaningful)g(w)m(a)m(y)i(to)f(translate)h(the)e(reception)h(rep)s
(orts,)h(so)e(the)h(translator)227 3886 y Fi(ma)-6 b(y)30
b Fq(pass)f(on)f(no)h(reception)h(rep)s(ort)e(at)i(all)g(or)e(a)i(syn)m
(thetic)g(rep)s(ort)e(based)g(on)h(its)g(o)m(wn)g(reception.)41
b(The)227 3999 y(general)32 b(rule)e(is)g(to)h(do)g(what)f(mak)m(es)h
(sense)f(for)g(a)h(particular)g(translation.)227 4145
y(A)h(translator)h(do)s(es)e(not)h(require)g(an)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(of)g(its)h(o)m(wn,)f(but)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)33
b Fq(c)m(ho)s(ose)g(to)f(allo)s(cate)j(one)227 4258 y(for)28
b(the)g(purp)s(ose)f(of)h(sending)f(rep)s(orts)g(ab)s(out)h(what)g(it)h
(has)e(receiv)m(ed.)42 b(These)27 b(w)m(ould)h(b)s(e)g(sen)m(t)g(to)h
(all)g(the)227 4371 y(connected)37 b(clouds,)h(eac)m(h)f(corresp)s
(onding)f(to)h(the)f(translation)h(of)f(the)h(data)g(stream)f(as)h(sen)
m(t)f(to)h(that)227 4484 y(cloud,)31 b(since)g(reception)g(rep)s(orts)e
(are)i(normally)g(m)m(ulticast)h(to)f(all)g(participan)m(ts.)0
4663 y Fl(SDES:)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(ranslators)28 b(t)m(ypically)h(forw)m
(ard)f(without)g(c)m(hange)g(the)g(SDES)g(information)g(they)g(receiv)m
(e)h(from)f(one)227 4776 y(cloud)35 b(to)h(the)f(others,)h(but)e
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)r Fq(,)35 b(for)g(example,)h(decide)g(to)f(\014lter)g
(non-CNAME)g(SDES)f(information)227 4889 y(if)c(bandwidth)e(is)i
(limited.)41 b(The)30 b(CNAMEs)g Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)g(forw)m(arded)g
(to)i(allo)m(w)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)h(collision)227
5002 y(detection)d(to)e(w)m(ork.)39 b(A)25 b(translator)h(that)f
(generates)i(its)e(o)m(wn)g(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j Fi(must)d
Fq(send)g(SDES)g(CNAME)227 5115 y(information)31 b(ab)s(out)f(itself)h
(to)g(the)g(same)g(clouds)f(that)h(it)g(sends)e(those)i(RR)f(pac)m(k)m
(ets.)0 5294 y Fl(BYE:)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(ranslators)31 b(forw)m(ard)g(BYE)
h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(unc)m(hanged.)43 b(A)31 b(translator)h(that)g(is)f
(ab)s(out)g(to)h(cease)h(forw)m(ard-)227 5407 y(ing)40
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h Fi(should)c Fq(send)i(a)g(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(to)f
(eac)m(h)g(connected)g(cloud)g(con)m(taining)g(all)h(the)e(SSR)m(C)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(45])p eop
%%Page: 46 46
46 45 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(iden)m(ti\014ers)e(that)g(w)m(ere)g(previously)f(b)s(eing)g(forw)m
(arded)g(to)h(that)g(cloud,)g(including)f(the)h(translator's)g(o)m(wn)
227 511 y(SSR)m(C)h(iden)m(ti\014er)g(if)h(it)f(sen)m(t)h(rep)s(orts)f
(of)g(its)h(o)m(wn.)0 699 y Fl(APP:)46 b Fq(T)-8 b(ranslators)31
b(forw)m(ard)f(APP)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(unc)m(hanged.)0
942 y Fo(7.3)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(Pro)s(cessing)i(in)g(Mixers)0
1114 y Fq(Since)31 b(a)g(mixer)f(generates)i(a)f(new)f(data)i(stream)f
(of)g(its)g(o)m(wn,)g(it)g(do)s(es)f(not)h(pass)f(through)g(SR)g(or)h
(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 1227 y(at)h(all)g(and)f(instead)h(generates)h
(new)d(information)i(for)f(b)s(oth)g(sides.)0 1440 y
Fl(SR)35 b(sender)g(information:)46 b Fq(A)31 b(mixer)g(do)s(es)g(not)g
(pass)f(through)h(sender)f(information)h(from)f(the)h(sources)g(it)227
1552 y(mixes)c(b)s(ecause)g(the)g(c)m(haracteristics)i(of)e(the)g
(source)g(streams)g(are)h(lost)f(in)g(the)g(mix.)39 b(As)27
b(a)g(sync)m(hroniza-)227 1665 y(tion)36 b(source,)h(the)e(mixer)g
Fi(should)f Fq(generate)i(its)g(o)m(wn)f(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(with)d
(sender)h(information)g(ab)s(out)227 1778 y(the)c(mixed)f(data)h
(stream)g(and)f(send)59 b(them)31 b(in)f(the)g(same)h(direction)g(as)g
(the)f(mixed)h(stream.)0 1966 y Fl(SR/RR)36 b(reception)g(rep)s(ort)f
(blo)s(c)m(ks:)46 b Fq(A)39 b(mixer)g(generates)h(its)g(o)m(wn)f
(reception)g(rep)s(orts)g(for)f(sources)h(in)227 2079
y(eac)m(h)c(cloud)e(and)g(sends)f(them)h(out)h(only)f(to)h(the)f(same)h
(cloud.)50 b(It)33 b Fi(must)j(not)66 b Fq(send)32 b(these)i(reception)
227 2192 y(rep)s(orts)d(to)h(the)g(other)g(clouds)f(and)g
Fi(must)k(not)62 b Fq(forw)m(ard)31 b(reception)h(rep)s(orts)f(from)g
(one)h(cloud)f(to)i(the)227 2305 y(others)e(b)s(ecause)f(the)h(sources)
f(w)m(ould)g(not)h(b)s(e)f(SSR)m(Cs)f(there)h(\(only)h(CSR)m(Cs\).)0
2492 y Fl(SDES:)46 b Fq(Mixers)e(t)m(ypically)i(forw)m(ard)e(without)g
(c)m(hange)h(the)g(SDES)e(information)i(they)f(receiv)m(e)i(from)e(one)
227 2605 y(cloud)35 b(to)h(the)f(others,)h(but)e Fi(ma)-6
b(y)r Fq(,)35 b(for)g(example,)h(decide)g(to)f(\014lter)g(non-CNAME)g
(SDES)f(information)227 2718 y(if)c(bandwidth)e(is)i(limited.)41
b(The)30 b(CNAMEs)g Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)g(forw)m(arded)g(to)i(allo)m(w)g
(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)h(collision)227 2831 y(detection)j(to)f(w)m
(ork.)44 b(\(An)31 b(iden)m(ti\014er)g(in)g(a)h(CSR)m(C)e(list)i
(generated)g(b)m(y)g(a)f(mixer)g(migh)m(t)h(collide)h(with)e(an)227
2944 y(SSR)m(C)22 b(iden)m(ti\014er)h(generated)h(b)m(y)e(an)h(end)f
(system.\))39 b(A)23 b(mixer)f Fi(must)g Fq(send)g(SDES)g(CNAME)h
(information)227 3057 y(ab)s(out)30 b(itself)i(to)f(the)f(same)h
(clouds)f(that)h(it)g(sends)f(SR)f(or)i(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(ets.)227
3207 y(Since)24 b(mixers)f(do)g(not)h(forw)m(ard)e(SR)h(or)g(RR)h(pac)m
(k)m(ets,)i(they)e(will)g(t)m(ypically)h(b)s(e)d(extracting)j(SDES)e
(pac)m(k)m(ets)227 3320 y(from)28 b(a)h(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8
b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)42 b(T)-8 b(o)29 b(minimize)g(o)m(v)m(erhead,)
i(c)m(h)m(unks)d(from)g(the)h(SDES)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)k
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)227 3433 y Fq(b)s(e)44 b(aggregated)i(in)m(to)f(a)f
(single)h(SDES)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j(whic)m(h)e(is)g(then)f(stac)m(k)m(ed)j
(on)e(an)g(SR)f(or)h(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(et)227 3546 y(originating)39
b(from)d(the)h(mixer.)61 b(A)37 b(mixer)g(whic)m(h)g(aggregates)i(SDES)
e(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(will)g(use)e(more)h(R)-8 b(TCP)227
3659 y(bandwidth)28 b(than)i(an)f(individual)g(source)h(b)s(ecause)g
(the)g(comp)s(ound)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)k(will)e(b)s(e)f(longer,)h(but)f
(that)227 3772 y(is)36 b(appropriate)h(since)f(the)h(mixer)f(represen)m
(ts)g(m)m(ultiple)h(sources.)58 b(Similarly)-8 b(,)38
b(a)f(mixer)f(whic)m(h)g(passes)227 3885 y(through)25
b(SDES)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(as)f(they)g(are)g(receiv)m(ed)h(will)e(b)s(e)g
(transmitting)h(R)-8 b(TCP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(at)e(higher)f(than)227
3997 y(the)j(single)g(source)g(rate,)h(but)e(again)h(that)h(is)e
(correct)i(since)f(the)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(come)e(from)f(m)m(ultiple)i
(sources.)227 4110 y(The)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(rate)f(ma)m
(y)g(b)s(e)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(on)f(eac)m(h)i(side)e(of)h(the)f(mixer.)
227 4261 y(A)48 b(mixer)g(that)g(do)s(es)g(not)g(insert)g(CSR)m(C)f
(iden)m(ti\014ers)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)49 b Fq(also)f(refrain)g(from)f(forw)m
(arding)h(SDES)227 4374 y(CNAMEs.)60 b(In)37 b(this)f(case,)k(the)d
(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(spaces)g(in)g(the)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(clouds)f
(are)g(indep)s(enden)m(t.)59 b(As)227 4486 y(men)m(tioned)31
b(earlier,)h(this)e(mo)s(de)g(of)g(op)s(eration)h(creates)h(a)f(danger)
f(that)h(lo)s(ops)f(can't)i(b)s(e)d(detected.)0 4674
y Fl(BYE:)46 b Fq(Mixers)40 b Fi(must)f Fq(forw)m(ard)h(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m
(ets.)72 b(A)40 b(mixer)g(that)h(is)g(ab)s(out)e(to)i(cease)h(forw)m
(arding)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)227 4787 y Fi(should)28 b Fq(send)g(a)h(BYE)h
(pac)m(k)m(et)h(to)f(eac)m(h)g(connected)g(cloud)f(con)m(taining)i(all)
f(the)f(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014ers)h(that)227 4900 y(w)m(ere)k
(previously)g(b)s(eing)f(forw)m(arded)g(to)h(that)h(cloud,)f(including)
f(the)h(mixer's)g(o)m(wn)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(if)227
5013 y(it)e(sen)m(t)g(rep)s(orts)f(of)g(its)h(o)m(wn.)0
5200 y Fl(APP:)46 b Fq(The)30 b(treatmen)m(t)i(of)f(APP)f(pac)m(k)m
(ets)i(b)m(y)f(mixers)f(is)g(application-sp)s(eci\014c.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(46])p eop
%%Page: 47 47
47 46 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fo(7.4)112 b(Cascaded)39 b(Mixers)0 570 y Fq(An)25
b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(session)g(ma)m(y)h(in)m(v)m(olv)m(e)h(a)f(collection)i
(of)d(mixers)g(and)g(translators)h(as)f(sho)m(wn)g(in)g(Fig.)h(3.)40
b(If)25 b(t)m(w)m(o)h(mixers)0 683 y(are)i(cascaded,)h(suc)m(h)f(as)g
(M2)g(and)f(M3)h(in)g(the)g(\014gure,)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(receiv)m(ed)g
(b)m(y)f(a)g(mixer)f(ma)m(y)i(already)f(ha)m(v)m(e)h(b)s(een)0
796 y(mixed)g(and)g(ma)m(y)h(include)f(a)g(CSR)m(C)g(list)g(with)g(m)m
(ultiple)h(iden)m(ti\014ers.)41 b(The)29 b(second)g(mixer)g
Fi(should)f Fq(build)g(the)0 909 y(CSR)m(C)23 b(list)i(for)f(the)g
(outgoing)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(using)d(the)i(CSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014ers)h
(from)g(already-mixed)g(input)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(and)0
1022 y(the)k(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014ers)h(from)g(unmixed)e(input)h(pac)
m(k)m(ets.)43 b(This)29 b(is)h(sho)m(wn)f(in)h(the)g(output)g(arc)g
(from)f(mixer)h(M3)0 1135 y(lab)s(eled)h(M3:89\(64,45\))k(in)30
b(the)h(\014gure.)40 b(As)31 b(in)f(the)h(case)g(of)g(mixers)f(that)h
(are)g(not)g(cascaded,)h(if)e(the)h(resulting)0 1248
y(CSR)m(C)f(list)h(has)f(more)g(than)g(15)i(iden)m(ti\014ers,)e(the)h
(remainder)f(cannot)h(b)s(e)e(included.)0 1534 y Fp(8)135
b(SSR)l(C)45 b(Iden)l(ti\014er)g(Allo)t(cation)h(and)f(Use)0
1737 y Fq(The)29 b(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er)h(carried)g(in)f(the)h(R)
-8 b(TP)29 b(header)h(and)f(in)g(v)-5 b(arious)30 b(\014elds)f(of)h(R)
-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(is)e(a)g(random)0 1850
y(32-bit)j(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(that)i(is)g(required)f(to)h(b)s(e)f
(globally)i(unique)e(within)g(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(session.)45
b(It)32 b(is)f(crucial)i(that)f(the)0 1963 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)25
b(b)s(e)i(c)m(hosen)g(with)f(care)i(in)e(order)h(that)g(participan)m
(ts)h(on)e(the)h(same)g(net)m(w)m(ork)h(or)f(starting)g(at)h(the)f
(same)0 2076 y(time)k(are)g(not)f(lik)m(ely)i(to)f(c)m(ho)s(ose)h(the)e
(same)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er.)141 2189 y(It)h(is)f Fk(not)h
Fq(su\016cien)m(t)g(to)g(use)f(the)g(lo)s(cal)i(net)m(w)m(ork)f
(address)e(\(suc)m(h)h(as)h(an)f(IPv4)g(address\))g(for)g(the)h(iden)m
(ti\014er)0 2302 y(b)s(ecause)h(the)h(address)f(ma)m(y)h(not)g(b)s(e)f
(unique.)49 b(Since)33 b(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(translators)g(and)f(mixers)g
(enable)h(in)m(terop)s(eration)0 2414 y(among)27 b(m)m(ultiple)f(net)m
(w)m(orks)h(with)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(address)e(spaces,)i(the)g(allo)s
(cation)h(patterns)e(for)g(addresses)f(within)0 2527
y(t)m(w)m(o)i(spaces)e(migh)m(t)i(result)e(in)g(a)g(m)m(uc)m(h)h
(higher)f(rate)h(of)f(collision)i(than)f(w)m(ould)f(o)s(ccur)g(with)g
(random)f(allo)s(cation.)0 2640 y(Multiple)31 b(sources)g(running)d(on)
i(one)h(host)g(w)m(ould)f(also)h(con\015ict.)141 2753
y(It)i(is)f(also)i(not)f(su\016cien)m(t)g(to)g(obtain)g(an)f(SSR)m(C)g
(iden)m(ti\014er)g(simply)h(b)m(y)f(calling)i Fh(random\(\))c
Fq(without)j(care-)0 2866 y(fully)41 b(initializing)j(the)e(state.)75
b(An)42 b(example)g(of)g(ho)m(w)f(to)i(generate)g(a)f(random)e(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(is)g(presen)m(ted)f(in)0 2979 y(App)s(endix)29
b(A.6.)0 3222 y Fo(8.1)112 b(Probabilit)m(y)38 b(of)g(Collision)0
3394 y Fq(Since)22 b(the)g(iden)m(ti\014ers)h(are)f(c)m(hosen)h
(randomly)-8 b(,)24 b(it)e(is)g(p)s(ossible)g(that)h(t)m(w)m(o)g(or)f
(more)h(sources)f(will)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)h(the)g(same)0
3507 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er.)39 b(Collision)31 b(o)s(ccurs)e(with)h(the)g
(highest)g(probabilit)m(y)g(when)f(all)h(sources)g(are)g(started)g(sim)
m(ultaneously)-8 b(,)0 3620 y(for)30 b(example)h(when)e(triggered)i
(automatically)h(b)m(y)e(some)h(session)f(managemen)m(t)h(ev)m(en)m(t.)
42 b(If)30 b Fg(N)40 b Fq(is)30 b(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)0
3733 y(of)45 b(sources)h(and)e Fg(L)h Fq(the)h(length)g(of)f(the)h
(iden)m(ti\014er)f(\(here,)50 b(32)c(bits\),)j(the)d(probabilit)m(y)f
(that)h(t)m(w)m(o)h(sources)0 3854 y(indep)s(enden)m(tly)32
b(pic)m(k)i(the)g(same)f(v)-5 b(alue)34 b(can)g(b)s(e)e(appro)m
(ximated)i(for)f(large)i Fg(N)43 b Fq([26)q(,)34 b(p.)f(33])i(as)e(1)23
b Fj(\000)f Fg(e)3524 3821 y Fd(\000)p Fe(N)3642 3798
y Fc(2)3677 3821 y Fe(=)p Fb(2)3747 3798 y Fa(L)p Fc(+1)3875
3854 y Fq(.)0 3967 y(F)-8 b(or)31 b Fg(N)k Fq(=)25 b(1000,)33
b(the)d(probabilit)m(y)h(is)g(roughly)f(10)1739 3934
y Fd(\000)p Fb(4)1834 3967 y Fq(.)141 4080 y(The)24 b(t)m(ypical)i
(collision)g(probabilit)m(y)f(is)g(m)m(uc)m(h)g(lo)m(w)m(er)g(than)g
(the)f(w)m(orst-case)j(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e.)40 b(When)24 b(one)h(new)f
(source)0 4193 y(joins)29 b(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(session)g(in)g(whic)m
(h)g(all)h(the)f(other)g(sources)g(already)h(ha)m(v)m(e)g(unique)e
(iden)m(ti\014ers,)i(the)f(probabilit)m(y)0 4306 y(of)38
b(collision)i(is)e(just)g(the)g(fraction)h(of)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)d
(used)i(out)g(of)h(the)f(space.)65 b(Again,)41 b(if)d
Fg(N)48 b Fq(is)38 b(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)0 4419
y(sources)32 b(and)f Fg(L)h Fq(the)g(length)h(of)f(the)g(iden)m
(ti\014er,)h(the)f(probabilit)m(y)g(of)h(collision)g(is)f
Fg(N)r(=)p Fq(2)3036 4386 y Fe(L)3090 4419 y Fq(.)45
b(F)-8 b(or)33 b Fg(N)38 b Fq(=)27 b(1000,)35 b(the)0
4532 y(probabilit)m(y)c(is)f(roughly)g(2)21 b Fj(\001)f
Fq(10)1088 4499 y Fd(\000)p Fb(7)1184 4532 y Fq(.)141
4645 y(The)35 b(probabilit)m(y)h(of)f(collision)i(is)e(further)f
(reduced)h(b)m(y)g(the)g(opp)s(ortunit)m(y)g(for)g(a)h(new)f(source)g
(to)h(receiv)m(e)0 4758 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)e(from)e(other)g(participan)m
(ts)h(b)s(efore)f(sending)f(its)i(\014rst)e(pac)m(k)m(et)j(\(either)f
(data)g(or)f(con)m(trol\).)48 b(If)31 b(the)h(new)0 4870
y(source)e(k)m(eeps)g(trac)m(k)h(of)f(the)f(other)h(participan)m(ts)h
(\(b)m(y)f(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er\),)j(then)e(b)s(efore)g
(transmitting)i(its)f(\014rst)0 4983 y(pac)m(k)m(et)46
b(the)e(new)f(source)h(can)g(v)m(erify)g(that)g(its)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g
(do)s(es)f(not)h(con\015ict)h(with)e(an)m(y)h(that)h(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s
(een)0 5096 y(receiv)m(ed,)32 b(or)e(else)i(c)m(ho)s(ose)f(again.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(47])p eop
%%Page: 48 48
48 47 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fo(8.2)112 b(Collision)39 b(Resolution)e(and)i(Lo)s(op)f(Detection)0
570 y Fq(Although)i(the)h(probabilit)m(y)f(of)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(collision)i(is)e(lo)m(w,)k(all)d(R)-8 b(TP)40
b(implemen)m(tations)h Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)0 683 y(prepared)26
b(to)h(detect)h(collisions)g(and)f(tak)m(e)h(the)f(appropriate)g
(actions)g(to)h(resolv)m(e)g(them.)39 b(If)27 b(a)g(source)g(disco)m(v)
m(ers)0 796 y(at)39 b(an)m(y)g(time)g(that)g(another)g(source)g(is)f
(using)g(the)h(same)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(as)f(its)h(o)m(wn,)i
(it)e Fi(must)e Fq(send)h(an)0 909 y(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m
(et)i(for)d(the)h(old)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(and)f(c)m(ho)s(ose)i(another)
e(random)g(one.)63 b(\(As)38 b(explained)f(b)s(elo)m(w,)0
1022 y(this)c(step)h(is)f(tak)m(en)h(only)g(once)g(in)f(case)h(of)g(a)g
(lo)s(op.\))99 b(If)33 b(a)h(receiv)m(er)g(disco)m(v)m(ers)h(that)f(t)m
(w)m(o)h(other)e(sources)h(are)0 1135 y(colliding,)f(it)f
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)33 b Fq(k)m(eep)f(the)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(from)e(one)h(and)f
(discard)g(the)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(from)e(the)h(other)g(when)e(this)i
(can)0 1248 y(b)s(e)e(detected)i(b)m(y)e(di\013eren)m(t)h(source)f
(transp)s(ort)g(addresses)g(or)g(CNAMEs.)41 b(The)30
b(t)m(w)m(o)i(sources)e(are)h(exp)s(ected)g(to)0 1360
y(resolv)m(e)h(the)e(collision)i(so)f(that)g(the)f(situation)i(do)s
(esn't)e(last.)141 1473 y(Because)46 b(the)f(random)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014ers)i(are)h(k)m(ept)f(globally)i(unique)d(for)g(eac)m(h)i(R)-8
b(TP)45 b(session,)k(they)0 1586 y(can)34 b(also)g(b)s(e)f(used)g(to)i
(detect)g(lo)s(ops)e(that)h(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)d(in)m(tro)s(duced)h(b)m(y)h
(mixers)f(or)h(translators.)51 b(A)34 b(lo)s(op)g(causes)0
1699 y(duplication)23 b(of)h(data)f(and)g(con)m(trol)h(information,)h
(either)f(unmo)s(di\014ed)d(or)i(p)s(ossibly)f(mixed,)i(as)g(in)e(the)h
(follo)m(wing)0 1812 y(examples:)136 2000 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(A)28 b(translator)h(ma)m(y)f(incorrectly)h(forw)m(ard)e(a)i(pac)m
(k)m(et)g(to)g(the)f(same)g(m)m(ulticast)i(group)d(from)g(whic)m(h)h
(it)g(has)227 2113 y(receiv)m(ed)33 b(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et,)i(either)e
(directly)g(or)g(through)e(a)i(c)m(hain)g(of)g(translators.)45
b(In)31 b(that)h(case,)h(the)f(same)227 2226 y(pac)m(k)m(et)h(app)s
(ears)c(sev)m(eral)j(times,)f(originating)h(from)e(di\013eren)m(t)h
(net)m(w)m(ork)g(sources.)136 2413 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Tw)m(o)35
b(translators)h(incorrectly)g(set)g(up)e(in)g(parallel,)k(i.e.,)g(with)
c(the)h(same)h(m)m(ulticast)g(groups)f(on)g(b)s(oth)227
2526 y(sides,)44 b(w)m(ould)d(b)s(oth)g(forw)m(ard)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j
(from)e(one)g(m)m(ulticast)i(group)e(to)h(the)f(other.)74
b(Unidirectional)227 2639 y(translators)31 b(w)m(ould)f(pro)s(duce)g(t)
m(w)m(o)h(copies;)h(bidirectional)f(translators)g(w)m(ould)g(form)e(a)i
(lo)s(op.)136 2827 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(A)28 b(mixer)f(can)h(close)g(a)g
(lo)s(op)f(b)m(y)h(sending)e(to)j(the)e(same)h(transp)s(ort)e
(destination)i(up)s(on)e(whic)m(h)h(it)h(receiv)m(es)227
2940 y(pac)m(k)m(ets,)37 b(either)e(directly)f(or)g(through)g(another)g
(mixer)g(or)g(translator.)52 b(In)34 b(this)g(case)h(a)f(source)g(migh)
m(t)227 3052 y(sho)m(w)d(up)e(b)s(oth)g(as)i(an)f(SSR)m(C)g(on)g(a)h
(data)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(and)e(a)h(CSR)m(C)e(in)h(a)h(mixed)f(data)h(pac)
m(k)m(et.)141 3240 y(A)40 b(source)g(ma)m(y)g(disco)m(v)m(er)h(that)f
(its)g(o)m(wn)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(are)f(b)s(eing)f(lo)s(op)s(ed,)j(or)e
(that)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)d(another)0 3353 y(source)31
b(are)f(b)s(eing)g(lo)s(op)s(ed)g(\(a)h(third-part)m(y)f(lo)s(op\).)141
3466 y(Both)d(lo)s(ops)f(and)g(collisions)i(in)e(the)h(random)e
(selection)j(of)f(a)f(source)h(iden)m(ti\014er)f(result)h(in)f(pac)m(k)
m(ets)i(arriving)0 3579 y(with)k(the)g(same)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(but)g(a)g(di\013eren)m(t)g(source)h(transp)s(ort)e
(address,)g(whic)m(h)h(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(that)i(of)f(the)0
3692 y(end)37 b(system)g(originating)i(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et)h(or)f(an)f
(in)m(termediate)i(system.)62 b(Therefore,)39 b(if)f(a)g(source)f(c)m
(hanges)i(its)0 3805 y(source)34 b(transp)s(ort)f(address,)h(it)g
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(also)g(c)m(ho)s(ose)f(a)h(new)e(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(to)g(a)m(v)m(oid)h(b)s(eing)f(in)m(terpreted)g(as)0
3918 y(a)c(lo)s(op)s(ed)g(source.)40 b(\(This)30 b(is)g(not)g
Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(ecause)g(in)h(some)g(applications)h(of)f(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(sources)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(exp)s(ected)0 4030
y(to)i(c)m(hange)f(addresses)g(during)e(a)i(session.\))43
b(Note)32 b(that)f(if)g(a)g(translator)h(restarts)f(and)f(consequen)m
(tly)i(c)m(hanges)0 4143 y(the)39 b(source)h(transp)s(ort)e(address)h
(\(e.g.,)k(c)m(hanges)d(the)g(UDP)f(source)h(p)s(ort)e(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er\))h(on)g(whic)m(h)g(it)h(forw)m(ards)0 4256 y(pac)m(k)m(ets,)c
(then)c(all)i(those)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(will)e(app)s(ear)g(to)g(receiv)m
(ers)i(to)e(b)s(e)g(lo)s(op)s(ed)f(b)s(ecause)h(the)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014ers)0 4369 y(are)27 b(applied)e(b)m(y)i(the)f(original)h(source)
f(and)g(will)g(not)h(c)m(hange.)40 b(This)26 b(problem)f(can)i(b)s(e)e
(a)m(v)m(oided)j(b)m(y)e(k)m(eeping)h(the)0 4482 y(source)i(transp)s
(ort)e(addressed)g(\014xed)h(across)h(restarts,)h(but)d(in)h(an)m(y)h
(case)g(will)g(b)s(e)f(resolv)m(ed)h(after)g(a)g(timeout)g(at)0
4595 y(the)i(receiv)m(ers.)141 4708 y(Lo)s(ops)h(or)g(collisions)i(o)s
(ccurring)e(on)g(the)g(far)h(side)f(of)g(a)h(translator)g(or)f(mixer)g
(cannot)h(b)s(e)f(detected)h(using)0 4821 y(the)26 b(source)g(transp)s
(ort)f(address)g(if)g(all)i(copies)f(of)g(the)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(go)e
(through)f(the)h(translator)h(or)f(mixer,)h(ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er)0
4934 y(collisions)g(ma)m(y)f(still)g(b)s(e)f(detected)i(when)d(c)m(h)m
(unks)h(from)g(t)m(w)m(o)i(R)-8 b(TCP)25 b(SDES)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)k(con)m
(tain)e(the)g(same)g(SSR)m(C)0 5047 y(iden)m(ti\014er)31
b(but)e(di\013eren)m(t)i(CNAMEs.)141 5160 y(T)-8 b(o)23
b(detect)h(and)e(resolv)m(e)i(these)f(con\015icts,)i(an)e(R)-8
b(TP)22 b(implemen)m(tation)j Fi(must)c Fq(include)h(an)h(algorithm)h
(similar)0 5272 y(to)38 b(the)g(one)g(describ)s(ed)e(b)s(elo)m(w,)k
(though)d(the)h(implemen)m(tation)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)39 b
Fq(c)m(ho)s(ose)f(a)g(di\013eren)m(t)g(p)s(olicy)g(for)f(whic)m(h)0
5385 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)27 b(from)e(colliding)h(third-part)m(y)f(sources)g
(are)h(k)m(ept.)39 b(The)25 b(algorithm)h(describ)s(ed)e(b)s(elo)m(w)50
b(ignores)26 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(48])p eop
%%Page: 49 49
49 48 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(from)k(a)h(new)e(source)i(or)f(lo)s(op)h(that)g(collide)g(with)f(an)h
(established)f(source.)56 b(It)35 b(resolv)m(es)i(collisions)g(with)e
(the)0 511 y(participan)m(t's)k(o)m(wn)f(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(b)
m(y)g(sending)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(BYE)i(for)e(the)i(old)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)g(and)f(c)m(ho)s(osing)0 624 y(a)f(new)f(one.)56
b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)39 b(when)34 b(the)i(collision)h(w)m(as)f(induced)e
(b)m(y)h(a)h(lo)s(op)g(of)f(the)h(participan)m(t's)g(o)m(wn)g(pac)m(k)m
(ets,)0 737 y(the)28 b(algorithm)i(will)e(c)m(ho)s(ose)i(a)e(new)g
(iden)m(ti\014er)g(only)h(once)g(and)e(thereafter)i(ignore)g(pac)m(k)m
(ets)h(from)e(the)h(lo)s(oping)0 850 y(source)i(transp)s(ort)e
(address.)40 b(This)29 b(is)i(required)e(to)j(a)m(v)m(oid)f(a)g(\015o)s
(o)s(d)f(of)g(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(ets.)141 963 y(This)40
b(algorithm)j(requires)d(k)m(eeping)i(a)g(table)g(indexed)f(b)m(y)g
(the)g(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er)h(and)e(con)m(taining)j(the)0
1076 y(source)38 b(transp)s(ort)f(addresses)g(from)g(the)h(\014rst)e(R)
-8 b(TP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(and)e(\014rst)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37
b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(receiv)m(ed)f(with)e(that)0 1189 y(iden)m(ti\014er,)26
b(along)f(with)f(other)h(state)h(for)e(that)h(source.)39
b(Tw)m(o)24 b(source)h(transp)s(ort)e(addresses)h(are)h(required)e
(since,)0 1302 y(for)j(example,)j(the)e(UDP)g(source)g(p)s(ort)f(n)m
(um)m(b)s(ers)f(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(on)g(R)-8
b(TP)26 b(and)g(R)-8 b(TCP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)42 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)0
1415 y(it)31 b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(assumed)f(that)i(the)g(net)m(w)m(ork)g
(address)f(is)g(the)g(same)h(in)f(b)s(oth)g(source)h(transp)s(ort)e
(addresses.)141 1528 y(Eac)m(h)i(SSR)m(C)f(or)h(CSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(receiv)m(ed)h(in)e(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(or)h(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)f(lo)s(ok)m(ed)h(up)e(in)g(the)h(source)0
1641 y(iden)m(ti\014er)g(table)h(in)e(order)h(to)g(pro)s(cess)g(that)g
(data)h(or)f(con)m(trol)h(information.)42 b(The)31 b(source)g(transp)s
(ort)f(address)0 1753 y(from)d(the)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(is)f(compared)g(to)
h(the)f(corresp)s(onding)f(source)h(transp)s(ort)f(address)g(in)h(the)g
(table)h(to)f(detect)i(a)0 1866 y(lo)s(op)23 b(or)g(collision)i(if)d
(they)i(don't)e(matc)m(h.)40 b(F)-8 b(or)23 b(con)m(trol)i(pac)m(k)m
(ets,)h(eac)m(h)e(elemen)m(t)h(with)d(its)i(o)m(wn)f(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er,)0 1979 y(for)k(example)h(an)f(SDES)g(c)m(h)m(unk,)h
(requires)f(a)h(separate)g(lo)s(okup.)39 b(\(The)25 b(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(in)f(a)g(reception)i(rep)s(ort)0 2092 y(blo)s(c)m(k)i(is)g
(an)g(exception)g(b)s(ecause)g(it)g(iden)m(ti\014es)g(a)h(source)e
(heard)h(b)m(y)f(the)h(rep)s(orter,)g(and)f(that)h(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)0 2205 y(is)e(unrelated)g(to)h(the)f(source)g(transp)s(ort)f
(address)h(of)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)25 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(sen)m(t)f(b)m(y)f
(the)g(rep)s(orter.\))39 b(If)26 b(the)g(SSR)m(C)0 2318
y(or)37 b(CSR)m(C)f(is)g(not)h(found,)h(a)f(new)f(en)m(try)h(is)g
(created.)61 b(These)36 b(table)i(en)m(tries)f(are)g(remo)m(v)m(ed)h
(when)e(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)0 2431 y(BYE)27 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(is)e(receiv)m
(ed)i(with)e(the)h(corresp)s(onding)e(SSR)m(C)h(iden)m(ti\014er)g(and)g
(v)-5 b(alidated)27 b(b)m(y)g(a)f(matc)m(hing)i(source)0
2544 y(transp)s(ort)i(address,)f(or)i(after)g(no)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(ha)m
(v)m(e)g(arriv)m(ed)e(for)g(a)h(relativ)m(ely)i(long)e(time)g(\(see)g
(Section)g(6.2.1\).)141 2657 y(Note)k(that)g(if)e(t)m(w)m(o)i(sources)f
(on)g(the)g(same)g(host)g(are)g(transmitting)h(with)e(the)h(same)g
(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g(at)0 2770 y(the)c(time)h(a)g(receiv)m(er)h
(b)s(egins)d(op)s(eration,)i(it)g(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(p)s(ossible)f
(that)i(the)g(\014rst)e(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(receiv)m(ed)g
(came)0 2883 y(from)37 b(one)h(of)f(the)h(sources)f(while)h(the)f
(\014rst)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(receiv)m(ed)g(came)f(from)f
(the)h(other.)62 b(This)36 b(w)m(ould)0 2995 y(cause)30
b(the)g(wrong)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(information)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(asso)s
(ciated)i(with)f(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(data,)h(but)e(this)g(situation)i
(should)0 3108 y(b)s(e)f(su\016cien)m(tly)h(rare)f(and)g(harmless)g
(that)h(it)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(disregarded.)141 3221 y(In)36
b(order)g(to)i(trac)m(k)g(lo)s(ops)e(of)h(the)g(participan)m(t's)h(o)m
(wn)e(data)i(pac)m(k)m(ets,)i(the)d(implemen)m(tation)h
Fi(must)e Fq(also)0 3334 y(k)m(eep)44 b(a)f(separate)h(list)g(of)f
(source)g(transp)s(ort)f(addresses)h(\(not)g(iden)m(ti\014ers\))h(that)
g(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s(een)e(found)g(to)i(b)s(e)0 3447 y(con\015icting.)80
b(As)43 b(in)g(the)g(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g(table,)48
b(t)m(w)m(o)c(source)f(transp)s(ort)g(addresses)f Fi(must)g
Fq(b)s(e)g(k)m(ept)i(to)0 3560 y(separately)33 b(trac)m(k)f
(con\015icting)h(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(and)f(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)46
b(Note)33 b(that)e(the)h(con\015icting)g(address)f(list)h(should)0
3673 y(b)s(e)g(short,)i(usually)e(empt)m(y)-8 b(.)50
b(Eac)m(h)33 b(elemen)m(t)h(in)f(this)g(list)g(stores)h(the)f(source)g
(addresses)f(plus)g(the)h(time)h(when)0 3786 y(the)25
b(most)g(recen)m(t)50 b(con\015icting)25 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(w)m(as)d
(receiv)m(ed.)41 b(An)24 b(elemen)m(t)i Fi(ma)-6 b(y)25
b Fq(b)s(e)f(remo)m(v)m(ed)i(from)e(the)g(list)i(when)d(no)0
3899 y(con\015icting)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)g(has)f(arriv)m(ed)g(from)f
(that)h(source)g(for)f(a)h(time)h(on)e(the)h(order)f(of)h(10)h(R)-8
b(TCP)27 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(als)0 4012 y(\(see)31
b(Section)h(6.2\).)141 4125 y(F)-8 b(or)29 b(the)f(algorithm)h(as)f
(sho)m(wn,)g(it)h(is)f(assumed)f(that)i(the)f(participan)m(t's)h(o)m
(wn)f(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g(and)g(state)0 4237 y(are)39
b(included)e(in)h(the)h(source)f(iden)m(ti\014er)g(table.)66
b(The)37 b(algorithm)j(could)e(b)s(e)g(restructured)f(to)i(\014rst)e
(mak)m(e)j(a)0 4350 y(separate)31 b(comparison)g(against)h(the)e
(participan)m(t's)i(o)m(wn)e(source)h(iden)m(ti\014er.)191
4588 y Fh(if)47 b(\(SSRC)f(or)i(CSRC)e(identifier)f(is)i(not)g(found)g
(in)g(the)g(source)382 4701 y(identifier)e(table\))h({)382
4814 y(create)g(a)h(new)g(entry)g(storing)e(the)i(data)g(or)g(control)f
(source)573 4927 y(transport)f(address,)h(the)g(SSRC)h(or)g(CSRC)g(and)
g(other)f(state;)191 5039 y(})191 5265 y(/*)h(Identifier)e(is)i(found)g
(in)g(the)g(table)f(*/)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(49])p eop
%%Page: 50 50
50 49 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)191 399
y Fh(else)47 b(if)g(\(table)f(entry)g(was)h(created)f(on)h(receipt)f
(of)h(a)h(control)d(packet)620 511 y(and)i(this)g(is)g(the)g(first)f
(data)h(packet)f(or)h(vice)g(versa\))f({)382 624 y(store)g(the)h
(source)f(transport)f(address)h(from)h(this)g(packet;)191
737 y(})191 850 y(else)g(if)g(\(source)f(transport)f(address)h(from)g
(the)h(packet)f(does)h(not)g(match)620 963 y(the)g(one)g(saved)g(in)g
(the)g(table)f(entry)g(for)h(this)g(identifier\))e({)382
1189 y(/*)i(An)g(identifier)e(collision)g(or)j(a)f(loop)g(is)g
(indicated)e(*/)382 1415 y(if)i(\(source)f(identifier)f(is)i(not)g(the)
g(participant's)d(own\))j({)573 1528 y(/*)g(OPTIONAL)e(error)i(counter)
f(step)g(*/)573 1641 y(if)h(\(source)f(identifier)f(is)i(from)g(an)g
(RTCP)f(SDES)h(chunk)764 1753 y(containing)e(a)i(CNAME)f(item)h(that)g
(differs)f(from)g(the)h(CNAME)764 1866 y(in)g(the)g(table)f(entry\))g
({)764 1979 y(count)g(a)h(third-party)e(collision;)573
2092 y(})i(else)g({)764 2205 y(count)f(a)h(third-party)e(loop;)573
2318 y(})573 2431 y(abort)h(processing)f(of)i(data)g(packet)f(or)h
(control)f(element;)573 2544 y(/*)h(MAY)g(choose)f(a)h(different)f
(policy)g(to)h(keep)g(new)f(source)h(*/)382 2657 y(})382
2883 y(/*)g(A)g(collision)f(or)h(loop)g(of)g(the)g(participant's)d(own)
j(packets)f(*/)382 3108 y(else)g(if)i(\(source)d(transport)h(address)g
(is)h(found)f(in)h(the)g(list)g(of)811 3221 y(conflicting)e(data)i(or)g
(control)f(source)g(transport)811 3334 y(addresses\))f({)573
3447 y(/*)i(OPTIONAL)e(error)i(counter)f(step)g(*/)573
3560 y(if)h(\(source)f(identifier)f(is)i(not)g(from)f(an)i(RTCP)e(SDES)
h(chunk)764 3673 y(containing)e(a)i(CNAME)f(item)h(or)g(CNAME)g(is)g
(the)764 3786 y(participant's)d(own\))i({)764 3899 y(count)g
(occurrence)f(of)i(own)g(traffic)f(looped;)573 4012 y(})573
4125 y(mark)g(current)g(time)h(in)g(conflicting)e(address)h(list)g
(entry;)573 4237 y(abort)g(processing)f(of)i(data)g(packet)f(or)h
(control)f(element;)382 4350 y(})382 4576 y(/*)h(New)g(collision,)e
(change)h(SSRC)h(identifier)e(*/)382 4802 y(else)h({)573
4915 y(log)h(occurrence)e(of)i(a)g(collision;)573 5028
y(create)f(a)h(new)g(entry)g(in)g(the)g(conflicting)d(data)j(or)g
(control)764 5141 y(source)f(transport)f(address)h(list)g(and)h(mark)g
(current)f(time;)573 5254 y(send)g(an)i(RTCP)e(BYE)h(packet)f(with)h
(the)g(old)g(SSRC)f(identifier;)573 5367 y(choose)g(a)h(new)g(SSRC)g
(identifier;)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(50])p eop
%%Page: 51 51
51 50 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)573 399
y Fh(create)46 b(a)h(new)g(entry)g(in)g(the)g(source)f(identifier)f
(table)h(with)764 511 y(the)h(old)f(SSRC)h(plus)g(the)g(source)f
(transport)f(address)h(from)764 624 y(the)h(data)f(or)h(control)f
(packet)g(being)h(processed;)382 737 y(})191 850 y(})141
1088 y Fq(In)32 b(this)g(algorithm,)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(from)e(a)h(newly)
f(con\015icting)h(source)f(address)g(will)g(b)s(e)g(ignored)g(and)g
(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 1200 y(from)h(the)g(original)i(source)e(address)f
(will)i(b)s(e)e(k)m(ept.)50 b(If)33 b(no)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(arriv)m(e)f
(from)f(the)g(original)i(source)e(for)g(an)0 1313 y(extended)i(p)s
(erio)s(d,)g(the)g(table)h(en)m(try)g(will)f(b)s(e)g(timed)g(out)g(and)
g(the)g(new)f(source)i(will)f(b)s(e)f(able)i(to)g(tak)m(e)g(o)m(v)m
(er.)0 1426 y(This)d(migh)m(t)h(o)s(ccur)f(if)h(the)f(original)i
(source)f(detects)g(the)g(collision)h(and)e(mo)m(v)m(es)i(to)f(a)g(new)
f(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er,)0 1539 y(but)d(in)g(the)g(usual)g(case)h
(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(will)f(b)s(e)e(receiv)m(ed)j
(from)e(the)g(original)i(source)e(to)h(delete)h(the)0
1652 y(state)g(without)e(ha)m(ving)h(to)g(w)m(ait)h(for)e(a)h(timeout.)
141 1765 y(If)42 b(the)g(original)h(source)f(address)g(w)m(as)g
(through)g(a)g(mixer)g(\(i.e.,)47 b(learned)42 b(as)g(a)h(CSR)m(C\))e
(and)h(later)h(the)0 1878 y(same)f(source)g(is)h(receiv)m(ed)g
(directly)-8 b(,)46 b(the)c(receiv)m(er)i(ma)m(y)e(b)s(e)g(w)m(ell)g
(advised)g(to)h(switc)m(h)f(to)h(the)f(new)g(source)0
1991 y(address)i(unless)g(other)h(sources)g(in)f(the)h(mix)f(w)m(ould)h
(b)s(e)f(lost.)85 b(F)-8 b(urthermore,)48 b(for)c(applications)i(suc)m
(h)f(as)0 2104 y(telephon)m(y)35 b(in)g(whic)m(h)f(some)h(sources)g
(suc)m(h)f(as)h(mobile)h(en)m(tities)g(ma)m(y)f(c)m(hange)h(addresses)e
(during)g(the)h(course)0 2217 y(of)g(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)35
b(session,)h(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(implemen)m(tation)i
Fi(should)c Fq(mo)s(dify)h(the)h(collision)i(detection)f(algorithm)g
(to)0 2330 y(accept)44 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(from)d(the)i(new)f(source)g
(transp)s(ort)f(address.)76 b(T)-8 b(o)42 b(guard)g(against)h
(\015ip-\015opping)e(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)0 2443 y(addresses)c(if)g(a)g
(gen)m(uine)h(collision)h(do)s(es)d(o)s(ccur,)j(the)f(algorithm)g
Fi(should)d Fq(include)i(some)h(means)f(to)h(detect)0
2555 y(this)30 b(case)i(and)d(a)m(v)m(oid)j(switc)m(hing.)141
2668 y(When)g(a)g(new)f(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)i(is)g(c)m(hosen)g
(due)f(to)h(a)g(collision,)i(the)e(candidate)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g
Fi(should)e Fq(\014rst)0 2781 y(b)s(e)i(lo)s(ok)m(ed)i(up)e(in)g(the)h
(source)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g(table)g(to)h(see)f(if)g(it)g(w)m(as)g
(already)h(in)e(use)h(b)m(y)f(some)h(other)g(source.)48
b(If)0 2894 y(so,)31 b(another)f(candidate)i Fi(must)59
b Fq(b)s(e)30 b(generated)h(and)f(the)h(pro)s(cess)f(rep)s(eated.)141
3007 y(A)e(lo)s(op)f(of)h(data)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(to)f(a)g(m)m(ulticast)
h(destination)f(can)g(cause)g(sev)m(ere)g(net)m(w)m(ork)g(\015o)s(o)s
(ding.)39 b(All)28 b(mixers)0 3120 y(and)37 b(translators)i
Fi(must)75 b Fq(implemen)m(t)38 b(a)g(lo)s(op)g(detection)i(algorithm)f
(lik)m(e)g(the)f(one)g(here)g(so)g(that)h(they)f(can)0
3233 y(break)28 b(lo)s(ops.)40 b(This)28 b(should)f(limit)i(the)g
(excess)g(tra\016c)g(to)g(no)f(more)h(than)f(one)h(duplicate)g(cop)m(y)
g(of)f(the)h(original)0 3346 y(tra\016c,)40 b(whic)m(h)d(ma)m(y)h(allo)
m(w)h(the)f(session)f(to)i(con)m(tin)m(ue)f(so)g(that)g(the)g(cause)g
(of)g(the)f(lo)s(op)h(can)g(b)s(e)e(found)h(and)0 3459
y(\014xed.)i(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)31 b(in)d(extreme)g(cases)h(where)f(a)g
(mixer)g(or)g(translator)h(do)s(es)e(not)i(prop)s(erly)d(break)i(the)g
(lo)s(op)h(and)0 3572 y(high)g(tra\016c)h(lev)m(els)h(result,)f(it)g
(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)d(necessary)i(for)g(end)f(systems)g(to)h(cease)h
(transmitting)g(data)f(or)f(con)m(trol)0 3685 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)36
b(en)m(tirely)-8 b(.)52 b(This)33 b(decision)h(ma)m(y)h(dep)s(end)d(up)
s(on)g(the)i(application.)52 b(An)34 b(error)f(condition)i
Fi(should)d Fq(b)s(e)0 3797 y(indicated)c(as)g(appropriate.)40
b(T)-8 b(ransmission)27 b Fi(ma)-6 b(y)57 b Fq(b)s(e)27
b(attempted)i(again)g(p)s(erio)s(dically)f(after)g(a)h(long,)g(random)0
3910 y(time)i(\(on)g(the)f(order)g(of)h(min)m(utes\).)0
4154 y Fo(8.3)112 b(Use)38 b(with)f(La)m(y)m(ered)i(Enco)s(dings)0
4325 y Fq(F)-8 b(or)30 b(la)m(y)m(ered)g(enco)s(dings)f(transmitted)g
(on)g(separate)h(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(sessions)g(\(see)g(Section)h(2.4\),)h
(a)e(single)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden-)0 4438 y(ti\014er)34 b(space)g
Fi(should)f Fq(b)s(e)g(used)g(across)i(the)f(sessions)g(of)g(all)h(la)m
(y)m(ers)g(and)e(the)h(core)h(\(base\))g(la)m(y)m(er)g
Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)0 4551 y(used)i(for)h(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h
(allo)s(cation)j(and)c(collision)j(resolution.)58 b(When)36
b(a)g(source)h(disco)m(v)m(ers)g(that)g(it)f(has)0 4664
y(collided,)29 b(it)f(transmits)f(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)26
b(BYE)i(pac)m(k)m(et)h(on)e(only)g(the)h(base)f(la)m(y)m(er)i(but)d(c)m
(hanges)i(the)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)0 4777 y(to)31
b(the)g(new)f(v)-5 b(alue)30 b(in)g(all)i(la)m(y)m(ers.)0
5063 y Fp(9)135 b(Securit)l(y)0 5266 y Fq(Lo)m(w)m(er)44
b(la)m(y)m(er)g(proto)s(cols)g(ma)m(y)f(ev)m(en)m(tually)i(pro)m(vide)e
(all)h(the)f(securit)m(y)g(services)h(that)f(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(desired)g
(for)0 5379 y(applications)c(of)e(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)37 b(including)f
(authen)m(tication,)41 b(in)m(tegrit)m(y)-8 b(,)41 b(and)36
b(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)-8 b(.)61 b(These)36 b(services)i(ha)m(v)m(e)
0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(51])p eop
%%Page: 52 52
52 51 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(b)s(een)41 b(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(for)i(IP)f(in)g([27)q(].)74
b(Since)41 b(the)h(initial)g(audio)g(and)f(video)h(applications)g
(using)f(R)-8 b(TP)41 b(needed)0 511 y(a)h(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)j
(service)e(b)s(efore)e(suc)m(h)h(services)h(w)m(ere)f(a)m(v)-5
b(ailable)45 b(for)d(the)g(IP)g(la)m(y)m(er,)47 b(the)42
b(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)0 624 y(service)35 b(describ)s(ed)e(in)h(the)
g(next)h(section)g(w)m(as)g(de\014ned)e(for)h(use)g(with)g(R)-8
b(TP)34 b(and)f(R)-8 b(TCP.)52 b(That)34 b(description)0
737 y(is)h(included)f(here)h(to)h(co)s(dify)f(existing)g(practice.)56
b(New)35 b(applications)i(of)e(R)-8 b(TP)34 b Fi(ma)-6
b(y)36 b Fq(implemen)m(t)g(this)f(R)-8 b(TP-)0 850 y(sp)s(eci\014c)29
b(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)i(service)f(for)f(bac)m(kw)m(ard)h
(compatibilit)m(y)-8 b(,)32 b(and/or)e(they)g Fi(ma)-6
b(y)31 b Fq(implemen)m(t)f(alternativ)m(e)0 963 y(securit)m(y)k
(services.)49 b(The)32 b(o)m(v)m(erhead)i(on)f(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)33 b(proto)s(col)h(for)e(this)h(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)i(service)
f(is)f(lo)m(w,)i(so)e(the)0 1076 y(p)s(enalt)m(y)e(will)f(b)s(e)g
(minimal)h(if)f(this)g(service)i(is)e(obsoleted)h(b)m(y)g(other)f
(services)h(in)f(the)h(future.)141 1189 y(Alternativ)m(ely)-8
b(,)43 b(other)37 b(services,)k(other)c(implemen)m(tations)i(of)f
(services)g(and)f(other)h(algorithms)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)0
1302 y(de\014ned)e(for)h(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(in)g(the)g(future.)63
b(In)37 b(particular,)k(an)d(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(pro\014le)g(called)h
(Secure)f(Real-time)i(T)-8 b(ransp)s(ort)0 1415 y(Proto)s(col)25
b(\(SR)-8 b(TP\))24 b([28)q(])f(is)h(b)s(eing)f(dev)m(elop)s(ed)h(to)h
(pro)m(vide)e(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)j(of)e(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)23 b(pa)m(yload)i(while)e(lea)m(ving)0 1528 y(the)32
b(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(header)g(in)g(the)g(clear)h(so)g(that)g(link-lev)m(el)
h(header)e(compression)g(algorithms)h(can)f(still)h(op)s(erate.)47
b(It)0 1641 y(is)39 b(exp)s(ected)g(that)g(SR)-8 b(TP)38
b(will)g(b)s(e)g(the)h(correct)h(c)m(hoice)g(for)f(man)m(y)f
(applications.)67 b(SR)-8 b(TP)37 b(is)i(based)f(on)h(the)0
1753 y(Adv)-5 b(anced)36 b(Encryption)g(Standard)f(\(AES\))h(and)g(pro)
m(vides)g(stronger)g(securit)m(y)h(than)f(the)h(service)g(describ)s(ed)
0 1866 y(here.)81 b(No)31 b(claim)g(is)f(made)g(that)h(the)f(metho)s
(ds)g(presen)m(ted)g(here)g(are)g(appropriate)g(for)g(a)h(particular)f
(securit)m(y)0 1979 y(need.)49 b(A)34 b(pro\014le)f(ma)m(y)g(sp)s
(ecify)g(whic)m(h)g(services)h(and)f(algorithms)h(should)f(b)s(e)f
(o\013ered)i(b)m(y)f(applications,)j(and)0 2092 y(ma)m(y)31
b(pro)m(vide)f(guidance)h(as)g(to)g(their)f(appropriate)h(use.)141
2205 y(Key)g(distribution)e(and)h(certi\014cates)i(are)f(outside)g(the)
f(scop)s(e)h(of)f(this)h(do)s(cumen)m(t.)0 2449 y Fo(9.1)112
b(Con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)0 2620 y Fq(Con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)25
b(means)e(that)h(only)g(the)f(in)m(tended)g(receiv)m(er\(s\))j(can)e
(deco)s(de)f(the)h(receiv)m(ed)h(pac)m(k)m(ets;)i(for)d(others,)0
2733 y(the)j(pac)m(k)m(et)h(con)m(tains)g(no)f(useful)f(information.)39
b(Con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)28 b(of)f(the)g(con)m(ten)m(t)h(is)f(ac)m
(hiev)m(ed)h(b)m(y)f(encryption.)141 2846 y(When)j(it)g(is)g(desired)g
(to)g(encrypt)g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(or)g(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(according)i(to)f
(the)h(metho)s(d)e(sp)s(eci\014ed)g(in)h(this)g(section,)0
2959 y(all)d(the)f(o)s(ctets)h(that)f(will)g(b)s(e)f(encapsulated)i
(for)e(transmission)g(in)h(a)g(single)g(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)j(pac)m
(k)m(et)f(are)e(encrypted)0 3072 y(as)e(a)g(unit.)38
b(F)-8 b(or)25 b(R)-8 b(TCP)g(,)24 b(a)g(32-bit)h(random)e(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)g(redra)m(wn)g(for)h(eac)m(h)h(unit)e Fi(must)g Fq(b)s(e)g(prep)s
(ended)f(to)i(the)g(unit)0 3185 y(b)s(efore)30 b(encryption.)41
b(F)-8 b(or)31 b(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)31 b(no)f(pre\014x)g(is)g(prep)s(ended;)
f(instead,)i(the)f(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(and)h(timestamp)0
3298 y(\014elds)f(are)h(initialized)h(with)e(random)g(o\013sets.)41
b(This)29 b(is)g(considered)h(to)g(b)s(e)f(a)g(w)m(eak)i
(initialization)h(v)m(ector)f(\(IV\))0 3410 y(b)s(ecause)40
b(of)g(p)s(o)s(or)f(randomness)g(prop)s(erties.)69 b(In)40
b(addition,)j(if)d(the)g(subsequen)m(t)f(\014eld,)k(the)d(SSR)m(C,)f
(can)i(b)s(e)0 3523 y(manipulated)30 b(b)m(y)h(an)f(enem)m(y)-8
b(,)31 b(there)g(is)f(further)f(w)m(eakness)i(of)g(the)f(encryption)h
(metho)s(d.)141 3636 y(F)-8 b(or)43 b(R)-8 b(TCP)g(,)42
b(an)g(implemen)m(tation)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)43 b Fq(segregate)i(the)d
(individual)f(R)-8 b(TCP)42 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(in)f(a)g(comp)s(ound)0
3749 y(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(in)m(to)e(t)m(w)m(o)h(separate)g
(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8 b(TCP)55 b(pac)m(k)m(ets,)30 b(one)e(to)g(b)s(e)f
(encrypted)g(and)g(one)h(to)g(b)s(e)f(sen)m(t)0 3862
y(in)h(the)g(clear.)40 b(F)-8 b(or)29 b(example,)g(SDES)e(information)h
(migh)m(t)h(b)s(e)e(encrypted)h(while)f(reception)i(rep)s(orts)e(w)m
(ere)h(sen)m(t)0 3975 y(in)38 b(the)h(clear)h(to)g(accommo)s(date)g
(third-part)m(y)f(monitors)g(that)g(are)g(not)g(privy)f(to)i(the)f
(encryption)g(k)m(ey)-8 b(.)67 b(In)0 4088 y(this)32
b(example,)h(depicted)f(in)g(Fig.)h(4,)g(the)f(SDES)f(information)h
Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)g(app)s(ended)f(to)j(an)f(RR)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(with)0
4201 y(no)c(rep)s(orts)g(\(and)f(the)i(random)e(n)m(um)m(b)s(er\))g(to)
i(satisfy)g(the)f(requiremen)m(t)h(that)g(all)g(comp)s(ound)d(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 4314 y(b)s(egin)k(with)g(an)g(SR)f(or)h(RR)g
(pac)m(k)m(et.)54 b(The)34 b(SDES)g(CNAME)g(item)h(is)f(required)f(in)h
(either)h(the)f(encrypted)g(or)0 4427 y(unencrypted)e(pac)m(k)m(et,)37
b(but)c(not)h(b)s(oth.)50 b(The)33 b(same)h(SDES)f(information)h
Fi(should)i(not)d Fq(b)s(e)g(carried)h(in)g(b)s(oth)0
4540 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)e(as)f(this)f(ma)m(y)h(compromise)g(the)f
(encryption.)141 4653 y(The)c(presence)g(of)g(encryption)g(and)g(the)g
(use)g(of)g(the)h(correct)g(k)m(ey)g(are)f(con\014rmed)g(b)m(y)g(the)g
(receiv)m(er)i(through)0 4765 y(header)35 b(or)g(pa)m(yload)g(v)-5
b(alidit)m(y)37 b(c)m(hec)m(ks.)55 b(Examples)35 b(of)g(suc)m(h)g(v)-5
b(alidit)m(y)36 b(c)m(hec)m(ks)g(for)f(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(and)f(R)-8
b(TCP)34 b(headers)0 4878 y(are)d(giv)m(en)g(in)f(App)s(endices)g(A.1)h
(and)f(A.2.)141 4991 y(T)-8 b(o)28 b(b)s(e)e(consisten)m(t)j(with)e
(existing)h(implemen)m(tations)h(of)e(the)h(initial)g(sp)s
(eci\014cation)g(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(in)g(RF)m(C)h(1889,)0
5104 y(the)e(default)g(encryption)g(algorithm)h(is)f(the)h(Data)g
(Encryption)f(Standard)f(\(DES\))h(algorithm)h(in)f(cipher)f(blo)s(c)m
(k)0 5217 y(c)m(haining)41 b(\(CBC\))g(mo)s(de,)i(as)e(describ)s(ed)e
(in)h(Section)i(1.1)f(of)g(RF)m(C)g(1423)h([29)q(],)i(except)d(that)h
(padding)d(to)j(a)0 5330 y(m)m(ultiple)26 b(of)g(8)f(o)s(ctets)i(is)e
(indicated)h(as)g(describ)s(ed)e(for)h(the)h(P)f(bit)g(in)g(Section)i
(5.1.)40 b(The)25 b(initialization)j(v)m(ector)f(is)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(52])p eop
%%Page: 53 53
53 52 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 1581
y
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1.32956 1.32956 scale neg exch
neg exch translate
 0 1581 a @beginspecial 0 @llx 0 @lly 352 @urx 115 @ury
3520 @rwi @setspecial
%%BeginDocument: rtcp_crypt.ps
%!PS-Adobe-2.0 EPSF-2.0
%%Title: rtcp_crypt.fig
%%Creator: fig2dev Version 3.1 Patchlevel 1
%%CreationDate: Fri Oct 13 18:06:02 1995
%%For: hgs@lupus (Henning Schulzrinne)
%%Orientation: Portrait
%%BoundingBox: 0 0 352 115
%%Pages: 0
%%BeginSetup
%%IncludeFeature: *PageSize Letter
%%EndSetup
%%EndComments
/$F2psDict 200 dict def
$F2psDict begin
$F2psDict /mtrx matrix put
/col-1 {} def
/col0 {0.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col1 {0.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col2 {0.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col3 {0.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col4 {1.000 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col5 {1.000 0.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col6 {1.000 1.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col7 {1.000 1.000 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col8 {0.000 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col9 {0.000 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col10 {0.000 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col11 {0.530 0.810 1.000 srgb} bind def
/col12 {0.000 0.560 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col13 {0.000 0.690 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col14 {0.000 0.820 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col15 {0.000 0.560 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col16 {0.000 0.690 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col17 {0.000 0.820 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col18 {0.560 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col19 {0.690 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col20 {0.820 0.000 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col21 {0.560 0.000 0.560 srgb} bind def
/col22 {0.690 0.000 0.690 srgb} bind def
/col23 {0.820 0.000 0.820 srgb} bind def
/col24 {0.500 0.190 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col25 {0.630 0.250 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col26 {0.750 0.380 0.000 srgb} bind def
/col27 {1.000 0.500 0.500 srgb} bind def
/col28 {1.000 0.630 0.630 srgb} bind def
/col29 {1.000 0.750 0.750 srgb} bind def
/col30 {1.000 0.880 0.880 srgb} bind def
/col31 {1.000 0.840 0.000 srgb} bind def

end
save
-32.0 186.0 translate
1 -1 scale

/clp {closepath} bind def
/ef {eofill} bind def
/gr {grestore} bind def
/gs {gsave} bind def
/l {lineto} bind def
/m {moveto} bind def
/n {newpath} bind def
/s {stroke} bind def
/slc {setlinecap} bind def
/slj {setlinejoin} bind def
/slw {setlinewidth} bind def
/srgb {setrgbcolor} bind def
/rot {rotate} bind def
/sc {scale} bind def
/tr {translate} bind def
/tnt {dup dup currentrgbcolor
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add
  4 -2 roll dup 1 exch sub 3 -1 roll mul add srgb}
  bind def
/shd {dup dup currentrgbcolor 4 -2 roll mul 4 -2 roll mul
  4 -2 roll mul srgb} bind def
/$F2psBegin {$F2psDict begin /$F2psEnteredState save def} def
/$F2psEnd {$F2psEnteredState restore end} def
%%EndProlog

$F2psBegin
10 setmiterlimit
 0.06299 0.06299 sc
7.500 slw
% Polyline
n 3030 1575 m 2925 1575 2925 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 2925 2025 3270 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3375 2025 3375 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 3375 1575 3030 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 3030 1575 m 2925 1575 2925 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 2925 2025 5970 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 6075 2025 6075 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 6075 1575 3030 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 4275 1575 m 4275 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 5130 1575 m 5130 2025 l gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
/Times-Roman findfont 180.00 scalefont setfont
3150 1890 m
gs 1 -1 sc (SR) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
3735 1800 m
gs 1 -1 sc (sender) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
3735 1935 m
gs 1 -1 sc (report) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
3555 2025 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
4455 2025 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
5310 2025 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
5490 1845 m
gs 1 -1 sc (site 2) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
4590 1845 m
gs 1 -1 sc (site 1) col-1 show gr
% Polyline
n 1455 1575 m 1350 1575 1350 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 2025 2595 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 2700 2025 2700 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 2700 1575 1455 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1455 1575 m 1350 1575 1350 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 2025 1695 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1800 2025 1800 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1800 1575 1455 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1005 1575 m 900 1575 900 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 900 2025 1245 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 2025 1350 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 1575 1005 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2925 1575 m 6075 1575 l  6075 2025 l  2925 2025 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2025 2160 m 2700 2160 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 2604.00 2130.00 m 2700.00 2160.00 l 2604.00 2190.00 l  2580.50 2160.50 l 2604.00 2130.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 2700 2115 m 2700 2205 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2925 2115 m 2925 2205 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 2925 2160 m 4050 2160 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 3021.00 2190.00 m 2925.00 2160.00 l 3021.00 2130.00 l  3045.50 2160.50 l 3021.00 2190.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 4950 2160 m 6075 2160 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 5979.00 2130.00 m 6075.00 2160.00 l 5979.00 2190.00 l  5955.50 2160.50 l 5979.00 2130.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 6075 2115 m 6075 2205 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 780 1575 m 675 1575 675 1920 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 675 2025 795 2025 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 900 2025 900 1680 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 900 1575 780 1575 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs 0.80 setgray ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 675 2160 m 1350 2160 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 771.00 2190.00 m 675.00 2160.00 l 771.00 2130.00 l  795.50 2160.50 l 771.00 2190.00 l clp gs 0.00 setgray ef gr gs col-1 s gr
% Polyline
n 675 2115 m 675 2205 l  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 1005 2475 m 900 2475 900 2820 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 900 2925 1245 2925 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 2925 1350 2580 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat 1350 2475 1005 2475 105 arcto 4 {pop} repeat clp gs col6 1.00 shd ef gr  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 675 1575 m 2700 1575 l  2700 2025 l  675 2025 l  clp  gs col-1 s gr 
% Polyline
n 765 1350 m 765 1800 l  gs col-1 s gr 
n 795.00 1680.00 m 765.00 1800.00 l 735.00 1680.00 l gs col-1 s gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
1125 1800 m
gs 1 -1 sc (RR) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 165.00 scalefont setfont
1980 2025 m
gs 1 -1 sc  90.0 rot (SSRC) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
2025 1845 m
gs 1 -1 sc (CNAME) col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 135.00 scalefont setfont
1125 1962 m
gs 1 -1 sc (\(empty\)) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
1575 1845 m
gs 1 -1 sc (SDES) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
4500 2205 m
gs 1 -1 sc (not encrypted) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
4455 1485 m
gs 1 -1 sc (UDP packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
1530 1485 m
gs 1 -1 sc (UDP packet) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
1665 2205 m
gs 1 -1 sc (encrypted) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 135.00 scalefont setfont
810 1215 m
gs 1 -1 sc (32-bit) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 135.00 scalefont setfont
810 1305 m
gs 1 -1 sc (random int.) dup stringwidth pop 2 div neg 0 rmoveto  col-1 show gr
/Times-Roman findfont 150.00 scalefont setfont
1485 2700 m
gs 1 -1 sc (fixed RTCP packet header) col-1 show gr
$F2psEnd
restore

%%EndDocument
 @endspecial 0 1581 a
 currentpoint currentpoint translate 1 1.32956 div 1 1.32956 div scale
neg exch neg exch translate
 0 1581 a 855 1777 a Fq(Figure)g(4:)41
b(Encrypted)29 b(and)h(non-encrypted)g(R)-8 b(TCP)29
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)0 2052 y(zero)f(b)s(ecause)f(random)g(v)-5
b(alues)27 b(are)h(supplied)e(in)h(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)27
b(header)g(or)g(b)m(y)g(the)h(random)e(pre\014x)g(for)h(comp)s(ound)0
2165 y(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)42 b(F)-8 b(or)32
b(details)f(on)f(the)h(use)f(of)g(CBC)g(initialization)k(v)m(ectors,)e
(see)f([30)q(].)141 2278 y(Implemen)m(tations)25 b(that)g(supp)s(ort)d
(the)j(encryption)f(metho)s(d)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)g(here)h
Fi(should)f Fq(alw)m(a)m(ys)i(supp)s(ort)e(the)0 2391
y(DES)32 b(algorithm)h(in)f(CBC)f(mo)s(de)h(as)g(the)g(default)h
(cipher)e(for)h(this)g(metho)s(d)64 b(to)32 b(maximize)i(in)m(terop)s
(erabilit)m(y)-8 b(.)0 2504 y(This)42 b(metho)s(d)f(w)m(as)i(c)m(hosen)
g(b)s(ecause)f(it)h(has)f(b)s(een)g(demonstrated)g(to)h(b)s(e)f(easy)h
(and)e(practical)j(to)f(use)f(in)0 2617 y(exp)s(erimen)m(tal)d(audio)e
(and)h(video)g(to)s(ols)g(in)g(op)s(eration)g(on)g(the)g(In)m(ternet.)
63 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)42 b(DES)37 b(has)h(since)g(b)s(een)0
2730 y(found)c(to)j(b)s(e)d(to)s(o)j(easily)f(brok)m(en.)57
b(It)35 b(is)h Fi(recommended)d Fq(that)j(stronger)g(encryption)f
(algorithms)h(suc)m(h)g(as)0 2843 y(T)-8 b(riple-DES)39
b(b)s(e)f(used)g(in)h(place)g(of)g(the)g(default)g(algorithm.)68
b(F)-8 b(urthermore,)41 b(secure)e(CBC)f(mo)s(de)g(requires)0
2956 y(that)i(the)g(\014rst)f(blo)s(c)m(k)h(of)g(eac)m(h)h(pac)m(k)m
(et)g(b)s(e)e(X)m(ORed)h(with)f(a)h(random,)i(indep)s(enden)m(t)c(IV)h
(of)h(the)g(same)g(size)0 3069 y(as)34 b(the)f(cipher's)g(blo)s(c)m(k)h
(size.)50 b(F)-8 b(or)34 b(R)-8 b(TCP)g(,)33 b(this)h(is)f
(\(partially\))i(ac)m(hiev)m(ed)g(b)m(y)e(prep)s(ending)f(eac)m(h)i
(pac)m(k)m(et)h(with)0 3181 y(a)42 b(32-bit)i(random)d(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er,)j(indep)s(enden)m(tly)d(c)m(hosen)h(for)g(eac)m(h)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)
78 b(F)-8 b(or)42 b(R)-8 b(TP)g(,)43 b(the)f(timestamp)h(and)0
3294 y(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(start)i(from)e(random)h(v)-5
b(alues,)46 b(but)c(consecutiv)m(e)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(will)f(not)f(b)s
(e)g(indep)s(enden)m(tly)0 3407 y(randomized.)53 b(It)35
b(should)e(b)s(e)h(noted)h(that)g(the)g(randomness)e(in)h(b)s(oth)g
(cases)h(\(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(and)f(R)-8 b(TCP\))34 b(is)h(limited.)0
3520 y(High-securit)m(y)i(applications)g Fi(should)c
Fq(consider)j(other,)h(more)f(con)m(v)m(en)m(tional,)k(protection)d
(means.)111 b(Other)0 3633 y(encryption)23 b(algorithms)i
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)24 b Fq(b)s(e)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)g(dynamically)h(for)f(a)h
(session)g(b)m(y)f(non-R)-8 b(TP)23 b(means.)39 b(In)22
b(particular,)0 3746 y(the)33 b(SR)-8 b(TP)31 b(pro\014le)h([28)q(])h
(based)f(on)g(AES)g(is)g(b)s(eing)g(dev)m(elop)s(ed)h(to)g(tak)m(e)h
(in)m(to)f(accoun)m(t)h(kno)m(wn)e(plain)m(text)i(and)0
3859 y(CBC)c(plain)m(text)i(manipulation)e(concerns,)h(and)f(will)h(b)s
(e)e(the)i(correct)g(c)m(hoice)i(in)d(the)g(future.)141
3972 y(As)f(an)f(alternativ)m(e)j(to)e(encryption)f(at)i(the)e(IP)h
(lev)m(el)h(or)e(at)h(the)58 b(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(lev)m(el)i(as)f(describ)s
(ed)e(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e,)j(pro\014les)0 4085 y Fi(ma)-6
b(y)33 b Fq(de\014ne)d(additional)j(pa)m(yload)f(t)m(yp)s(es)g(for)f
(encrypted)g(enco)s(dings.)44 b(Those)31 b(enco)s(dings)g
Fi(must)g Fq(sp)s(ecify)g(ho)m(w)0 4198 y(padding)23
b(and)h(other)g(asp)s(ects)h(of)f(the)h(encryption)f(are)h(to)g(b)s(e)e
(handled.)38 b(This)23 b(metho)s(d)h(allo)m(ws)i(encrypting)e(only)0
4311 y(the)36 b(data)g(while)f(lea)m(ving)i(the)f(headers)f(in)g(the)h
(clear)g(for)g(applications)g(where)f(that)h(is)g(desired.)55
b(It)36 b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)0 4423 y(particularly)d(useful)f(for)g(hardw)m
(are)g(devices)i(that)f(will)g(handle)f(b)s(oth)g(decryption)g(and)g
(deco)s(ding.)48 b(It)32 b(is)h(also)0 4536 y(v)-5 b(aluable)38
b(for)f(applications)i(where)e(link-lev)m(el)i(compression)f(of)f(R)-8
b(TP)37 b(and)g(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)k(headers)c(is)g(desired)0
4649 y(and)32 b(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)i(of)e(the)g(pa)m(yload)h
(\(but)f(not)h(addresses\))e(is)i(su\016cien)m(t)f(since)h(encryption)f
(of)g(the)g(headers)0 4762 y(precludes)e(compression.)0
5006 y Fo(9.2)112 b(Authen)m(tication)38 b(and)g(Message)h(In)m(tegrit)
m(y)0 5177 y Fq(Authen)m(tication)g(and)e(message)h(in)m(tegrit)m(y)h
(services)f(are)g(not)f(de\014ned)f(at)i(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)37
b(lev)m(el)76 b(since)37 b(these)h(ser-)0 5290 y(vices)32
b(w)m(ould)g(not)g(b)s(e)f(directly)h(feasible)h(without)e(a)h(k)m(ey)h
(managemen)m(t)g(infrastructure.)44 b(It)32 b(is)f(exp)s(ected)h(that)0
5403 y(authen)m(tication)h(and)c(in)m(tegrit)m(y)k(services)e(will)g(b)
s(e)e(pro)m(vided)h(b)m(y)g(lo)m(w)m(er)i(la)m(y)m(er)g(proto)s(cols.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(53])p eop
%%Page: 54 54
54 53 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fp(10)135 b(Congestion)46 b(Con)l(trol)0 601 y Fq(All)33
b(transp)s(ort)f(proto)s(cols)h(used)f(on)h(the)g(In)m(ternet)g(need)f
(to)h(address)f(congestion)i(con)m(trol)g(in)f(some)g(w)m(a)m(y)g([31)q
(].)0 714 y(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(is)f(not)h(an)g(exception,)h(but)e(b)s
(ecause)h(the)g(data)g(transp)s(orted)f(o)m(v)m(er)i(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(is)h(often)g(inelastic)i(\(generated)0 827
y(at)e(a)g(\014xed)e(or)i(con)m(trolled)g(rate\),)h(the)f(means)f(to)h
(con)m(trol)h(congestion)f(in)f(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(quite)h
(di\013eren)m(t)f(from)0 940 y(those)42 b(for)f(other)g(transp)s(ort)g
(proto)s(cols)h(suc)m(h)f(as)g(TCP.)72 b(In)41 b(one)g(sense,)k
(inelasticit)m(y)f(reduces)c(the)i(risk)f(of)0 1053 y(congestion)31
b(b)s(ecause)e(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(stream)h(will)f(not)h(expand)e(to)i
(consume)f(all)h(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable)32 b(bandwidth)27
b(as)i(a)h(TCP)0 1166 y(stream)37 b(can.)60 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)41
b(inelasticit)m(y)e(also)f(means)f(that)g(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)37 b(stream)g(cannot)g(arbitrarily)g(reduce)g(its)0
1279 y(load)31 b(on)f(the)h(net)m(w)m(ork)g(to)g(eliminate)h
(congestion)g(when)d(it)i(o)s(ccurs.)141 1392 y(Since)26
b(R)-8 b(TP)25 b(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)e(used)g(for)g(a)i(wide)e(v)-5
b(ariet)m(y)27 b(of)f(applications)h(in)f(man)m(y)f(di\013eren)m(t)i
(con)m(texts,)h(there)e(is)g(no)0 1505 y(single)33 b(congestion)i(con)m
(trol)f(mec)m(hanism)f(that)g(will)h(w)m(ork)e(for)h(all.)49
b(Therefore,)33 b(congestion)h(con)m(trol)h Fi(should)0
1618 y Fq(b)s(e)g(de\014ned)g(in)h(eac)m(h)h(R)-8 b(TP)36
b(pro\014le)f(as)i(appropriate.)57 b(F)-8 b(or)37 b(some)f(pro\014les,)
i(it)e(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(su\016cien)m(t)h(to)h(include)0
1731 y(an)e(applicabilit)m(y)i(statemen)m(t)h(restricting)e(the)g(use)f
(of)g(that)h(pro\014le)f(to)h(en)m(vironmen)m(ts)g(where)f(congestion)i
(is)0 1843 y(a)m(v)m(oided)31 b(b)m(y)e(engineering.)41
b(F)-8 b(or)30 b(other)f(pro\014les,)h(sp)s(eci\014c)f(metho)s(ds)f
(suc)m(h)h(as)h(data)g(rate)g(adaptation)g(based)f(on)0
1956 y(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(feedbac)m(k)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(required.)0
2243 y Fp(11)135 b(R)-11 b(TP)44 b(o)l(v)l(er)i(Net)l(w)l(ork)h(and)d
(T)-11 b(ransp)t(ort)45 b(Proto)t(cols)0 2446 y Fq(This)27
b(section)i(describ)s(es)e(issues)g(sp)s(eci\014c)h(to)h(carrying)f(R)
-8 b(TP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(within)d(particular)h(net)m(w)m(ork)h(and)
e(trans-)0 2559 y(p)s(ort)h(proto)s(cols.)41 b(The)28
b(follo)m(wing)i(rules)e(apply)g(unless)f(sup)s(erseded)g(b)m(y)h
(proto)s(col-sp)s(eci\014c)i(de\014nitions)e(outside)0
2672 y(this)i(sp)s(eci\014cation.)141 2784 y(R)-8 b(TP)38
b(relies)h(on)f(the)h(underlying)e(proto)s(col\(s\))j(to)f(pro)m(vide)f
(dem)m(ultiplexing)h(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(data)h(and)e(R)-8
b(TCP)0 2897 y(con)m(trol)25 b(streams.)39 b(F)-8 b(or)25
b(UDP)f(and)g(similar)g(proto)s(cols,)i(R)-8 b(TP)24
b Fi(should)e Fq(use)i(an)g(ev)m(en)g(destination)h(p)s(ort)e(n)m(um)m
(b)s(er)0 3010 y(and)31 b(the)g(corresp)s(onding)g(R)-8
b(TCP)31 b(stream)h Fi(should)d Fq(use)i(the)h(next)g(higher)f(\(o)s
(dd\))g(destination)h(p)s(ort)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er.)0 3123
y(F)-8 b(or)38 b(applications)g(that)g(tak)m(e)h(a)e(single)h(p)s(ort)e
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(as)h(a)h(parameter)g(and)e(deriv)m(e)i(the)f(R)-8
b(TP)37 b(and)f(R)-8 b(TCP)0 3236 y(p)s(ort)25 b(pair)g(from)g(that)h
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er,)f(if)h(an)f(o)s(dd)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(is)i(supplied)
e(then)h(the)h(application)g Fi(should)e Fq(replace)i(that)0
3349 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)i(with)i(the)g(next)g(lo)m(w)m(er)h(\(ev)m(en\))
g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(to)j(use)e(as)h(the)g(base)g(of)g(the)g(p)s(ort)f
(pair.)40 b(F)-8 b(or)30 b(applications)h(in)0 3462 y(whic)m(h)c(the)g
(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(and)f(R)-8 b(TCP)26 b(destination)i(p)s(ort)f(n)m(um)m
(b)s(ers)e(are)j(sp)s(eci\014ed)e(via)h(explicit,)j(separate)e
(parameters)0 3575 y(\(using)38 b(a)h(signaling)g(proto)s(col)h(or)e
(other)h(means\),)i(the)d(application)i Fi(ma)-6 b(y)40
b Fq(disregard)d(the)i(restrictions)g(that)0 3688 y(the)33
b(p)s(ort)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f(b)s(e)g(ev)m(en/o)s(dd)i(and)e
(consecutiv)m(e)j(although)f(the)f(use)g(of)h(an)f(ev)m(en/o)s(dd)g(p)s
(ort)g(pair)g(is)g(still)0 3801 y(encouraged.)54 b(The)34
b(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(and)g(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b(p)s(ort)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f
Fi(must)38 b(not)33 b Fq(b)s(e)h(the)h(same)g(since)g(R)-8
b(TP)34 b(relies)h(on)g(the)0 3914 y(p)s(ort)30 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)f
(to)i(dem)m(ultiplex)g(the)f(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(data)i(and)d(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(con)m(trol)i(streams.)141 4026 y(In)25 b(a)i(unicast)f
(session,)h(b)s(oth)e(participan)m(ts)i(need)f(to)g(iden)m(tify)h(a)f
(p)s(ort)f(pair)h(for)f(receiving)i(R)-8 b(TP)26 b(and)f(R)-8
b(TCP)0 4139 y(pac)m(k)m(ets.)67 b(Both)39 b(participan)m(ts)h
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)39 b Fq(use)g(the)f(same)h(p)s(ort)f(pair.)65
b(A)39 b(participan)m(t)g Fi(must)j(not)c Fq(assume)g(that)0
4252 y(the)j(source)g(p)s(ort)f(of)g(the)h(incoming)g(R)-8
b(TP)41 b(or)f(R)-8 b(TCP)41 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(can)f(b)s(e)f(used)g(as)h
(the)g(destination)g(p)s(ort)f(for)0 4365 y(outgoing)33
b(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(or)g(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)47
b(When)32 b(R)-8 b(TP)32 b(data)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(are)e(b)s(eing)g(sen)
m(t)g(in)g(b)s(oth)f(directions,)i(eac)m(h)0 4478 y(participan)m(t's)h
(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(SR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i Fi(must)d Fq(b)s(e)h(sen)m(t)h
(to)h(the)e(p)s(ort)g(that)h(the)g(other)g(participan)m(t)g(has)g(sp)s
(eci\014ed)0 4591 y(for)f(reception)h(of)f(R)-8 b(TCP.)45
b(The)32 b(R)-8 b(TCP)32 b(SR)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(com)m(bine)f(sender)e
(information)i(for)e(the)i(outgoing)g(data)0 4704 y(plus)c(reception)i
(rep)s(ort)e(information)h(for)g(the)g(incoming)g(data.)41
b(If)30 b(a)g(side)g(is)g(not)g(activ)m(ely)i(sending)d(data)i(\(see)0
4817 y(Section)g(6.4\),)h(an)f(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(RR)h(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)d
(sen)m(t)h(instead.)141 4930 y(It)26 b(is)g Fi(recommended)d
Fq(that)k(la)m(y)m(ered)g(enco)s(ding)f(applications)h(\(see)g(Section)
g(2.4\))g(use)f(a)g(set)h(of)f(con)m(tiguous)0 5043 y(p)s(ort)31
b(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers.)45 b(The)32 b(p)s(ort)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)g
Fi(must)g Fq(b)s(e)g(distinct)i(b)s(ecause)f(of)g(a)h(widespread)e
(de\014ciency)h(in)g(existing)0 5156 y(op)s(erating)k(systems)g(that)h
(prev)m(en)m(ts)g(use)e(of)i(the)f(same)g(p)s(ort)g(with)f(m)m(ultiple)
i(m)m(ulticast)h(addresses,)f(and)e(for)0 5268 y(unicast,)43
b(there)d(is)g(only)g(one)g(p)s(ermissible)f(address.)68
b(Th)m(us)39 b(for)g(la)m(y)m(er)j(n,)f(the)g(data)f(p)s(ort)f(is)h(P)g
(+)f(2n,)k(and)0 5381 y(the)35 b(con)m(trol)h(p)s(ort)e(is)h(P)f(+)h
(2n)f(+)h(1.)54 b(When)34 b(IP)h(m)m(ulticast)h(is)f(used,)g(the)g
(addresses)f Fi(must)g Fq(also)h(b)s(e)g(distinct)0 5656
y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(54])p eop
%%Page: 55 55
55 54 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(b)s(ecause)24 b(m)m(ulticast)j(routing)d(and)g(group)g(mem)m(b)s
(ership)f(are)i(managed)g(on)f(an)h(address)e(gran)m(ularit)m(y)-8
b(.)41 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)0 511 y(allo)s(cation)24 b(of)e(con)m
(tiguous)h(IP)e(m)m(ulticast)i(addresses)f(cannot)g(b)s(e)f(assumed)g
(b)s(ecause)h(some)g(groups)f(ma)m(y)h(require)0 624
y(di\013eren)m(t)31 b(scop)s(es)f(and)g(ma)m(y)h(therefore)g(b)s(e)e
(allo)s(cated)k(from)d(di\013eren)m(t)h(address)e(ranges.)141
737 y(The)34 b(previous)g(paragraph)g(con\015icts)h(with)f(the)g(SDP)g
(sp)s(eci\014cation,)j(RF)m(C)d(2327)i([15)r(],)f(whic)m(h)f(sa)m(ys)h
(that)0 850 y(it)44 b(is)g(illegal)i(for)e(b)s(oth)f(m)m(ultiple)h
(addresses)g(and)f(m)m(ultiple)h(p)s(orts)f(to)i(b)s(e)e(sp)s
(eci\014ed)g(in)h(the)g(same)g(session)0 963 y(description)27
b(b)s(ecause)f(the)h(asso)s(ciation)h(of)f(addresses)f(with)g(p)s(orts)
g(could)h(b)s(e)f(am)m(biguous.)40 b(It)26 b(is)h(in)m(tended)f(that)0
1076 y(this)g(restriction)i(will)e(b)s(e)g(relaxed)h(in)f(a)h(revision)
g(of)f(RF)m(C)h(2327)h(to)f(allo)m(w)h(an)e(equal)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e
(of)i(addresses)f(and)0 1189 y(p)s(orts)k(to)h(b)s(e)e(sp)s(eci\014ed)h
(with)g(a)h(one-to-one)h(mapping)e(implied.)141 1302
y(R)-8 b(TP)42 b(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(con)m(tain)g(no)e(length)g
(\014eld)g(or)g(other)h(delineation,)j(therefore)d(R)-8
b(TP)42 b(relies)h(on)f(the)0 1415 y(underlying)d(proto)s(col\(s\))j
(to)e(pro)m(vide)g(a)h(length)f(indication.)71 b(The)40
b(maxim)m(um)f(length)i(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)40 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(is)0
1528 y(limited)31 b(only)g(b)m(y)f(the)g(underlying)g(proto)s(cols.)141
1641 y(If)39 b(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(are)e(to)g(b)s(e)f
(carried)g(in)h(an)f(underlying)f(proto)s(col)j(that)f(pro)m(vides)f
(the)h(abstraction)h(of)0 1753 y(a)c(con)m(tin)m(uous)h(o)s(ctet)g
(stream)g(rather)e(than)h(messages)h(\(pac)m(k)m(ets\),)j(an)c
(encapsulation)h(of)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)37 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)0
1866 y Fi(must)23 b Fq(b)s(e)g(de\014ned)g(to)i(pro)m(vide)f(a)h
(framing)e(mec)m(hanism.)39 b(F)-8 b(raming)25 b(is)f(also)h(needed)f
(if)g(the)g(underlying)f(proto)s(col)0 1979 y(ma)m(y)34
b(con)m(tain)h(padding)d(so)i(that)g(the)f(exten)m(t)i(of)e(the)h(R)-8
b(TP)33 b(pa)m(yload)h(cannot)g(b)s(e)f(determined.)49
b(The)33 b(framing)0 2092 y(mec)m(hanism)e(is)f(not)h(de\014ned)e
(here.)141 2205 y(A)g(pro\014le)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)30 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)e(a)h
(framing)f(metho)s(d)g(to)h(b)s(e)f(used)g(ev)m(en)h(when)f(R)-8
b(TP)28 b(is)h(carried)g(in)f(proto)s(cols)h(that)0 2318
y(do)f(pro)m(vide)g(framing)g(in)g(order)g(to)h(allo)m(w)g(carrying)g
(sev)m(eral)g(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)e(one)h(lo)m(w)m(er-la)
m(y)m(er)i(proto)s(col)e(data)0 2431 y(unit,)40 b(suc)m(h)e(as)g(a)g
(UDP)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)66 b(Carrying)37 b(sev)m(eral)j(R)-8
b(TP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(in)d(one)i(net)m(w)m(ork)g(or)f(transp)s(ort)
f(pac)m(k)m(et)0 2544 y(reduces)30 b(header)g(o)m(v)m(erhead)i(and)e
(ma)m(y)g(simplify)g(sync)m(hronization)i(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)f
(di\013eren)m(t)g(streams.)0 2830 y Fp(12)135 b(Summary)45
b(of)g(Proto)t(col)g(Constan)l(ts)0 3033 y Fq(This)30
b(section)h(con)m(tains)h(a)e(summary)g(listing)h(of)f(the)h(constan)m
(ts)h(de\014ned)d(in)h(this)g(sp)s(eci\014cation.)141
3146 y(The)e(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\(PT\))f(constan)
m(ts)h(are)g(de\014ned)e(in)h(pro\014les)g(rather)g(than)g(this)g(do)s
(cumen)m(t.)40 b(Ho)m(w-)0 3259 y(ev)m(er,)33 b(the)e(o)s(ctet)i(of)f
(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(header)g(whic)m(h)g(con)m(tains)i(the)e(mark)m
(er)h(bit\(s\))g(and)f(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)g Fi(must)e
Fq(a)m(v)m(oid)0 3372 y(the)f(reserv)m(ed)h(v)-5 b(alues)29
b(200)i(and)d(201)j(\(decimal\))g(to)f(distinguish)e(R)-8
b(TP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)e(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)29
b(SR)g(and)f(RR)0 3485 y(pac)m(k)m(et)g(t)m(yp)s(es)e(for)g(the)g
(header)f(v)-5 b(alidation)28 b(pro)s(cedure)d(describ)s(ed)f(in)i(App)
s(endix)e(A.1.)40 b(F)-8 b(or)27 b(the)f(standard)f(de\014-)0
3598 y(nition)g(of)h(one)f(mark)m(er)g(bit)g(and)g(a)g(7-bit)h(pa)m
(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\014eld)e(as)i(sho)m(wn)e(in)h(this)g(sp)s
(eci\014cation,)i(this)e(restriction)0 3711 y(means)30
b(that)h(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(es)e(72)h(and)f(73)h(are)g(reserv)m(ed.)
0 3954 y Fo(12.1)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(es)50
4119 y Fq(abbrev.)99 b(name)640 b(v)-5 b(alue)50 4232
y(SR)277 b(sender)30 b(rep)s(ort)390 b(200)50 4345 y(RR)261
b(receiv)m(er)32 b(rep)s(ort)340 b(201)50 4458 y(SDES)162
b(source)31 b(description)206 b(202)50 4571 y(BYE)201
b(go)s(o)s(db)m(y)m(e)595 b(203)50 4684 y(APP)203 b
(application-de\014ned)168 b(204)141 4889 y(These)36
b(t)m(yp)s(e)h(v)-5 b(alues)36 b(w)m(ere)h(c)m(hosen)g(in)e(the)i
(range)f(200-204)k(for)c(impro)m(v)m(ed)g(header)g(v)-5
b(alidit)m(y)38 b(c)m(hec)m(king)g(of)0 5002 y(R)-8 b(TCP)27
b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(compared)e(to)h(R)-8 b(TP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(or)e
(other)h(unrelated)f(pac)m(k)m(ets.)41 b(When)27 b(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)27 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(e)0 5115 y(\014eld)40
b(is)h(compared)g(to)g(the)g(corresp)s(onding)f(o)s(ctet)i(of)f(the)g
(R)-8 b(TP)41 b(header,)i(this)e(range)g(corresp)s(onds)e(to)j(the)0
5228 y(mark)m(er)36 b(bit)h(b)s(eing)f(1)g(\(whic)m(h)h(it)f(usually)g
(is)h(not)f(in)g(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets\))i(and)c(to)i(the)g(high)f(bit)g
(of)g(the)h(standard)0 5341 y(pa)m(yload)25 b(t)m(yp)s(e)g(\014eld)f(b)
s(eing)g(1)g(\(since)h(the)g(static)h(pa)m(yload)f(t)m(yp)s(es)f(are)h
(t)m(ypically)h(de\014ned)d(in)h(the)h(lo)m(w)g(half)7
b(\).)39 b(This)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(55])p eop
%%Page: 56 56
56 55 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(range)g(w)m(as)h(also)g(c)m(hosen)f(to)h(b)s(e)f(some)g(distance)h(n)
m(umerically)g(from)e(0)i(and)e(255)j(since)e(all-zeros)i(and)e
(all-ones)0 511 y(are)g(common)f(data)h(patterns.)141
624 y(Since)g(all)h(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
Fi(must)d Fq(b)s(egin)h(with)f(SR)h(or)g(RR,)g(these)h(co)s(des)f(w)m
(ere)h(c)m(hosen)g(as)f(an)0 737 y(ev)m(en/o)s(dd)j(pair)g(to)h(allo)m
(w)h(the)f(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)36 b(c)m(hec)m(k)g(to)f
(test)g(the)f(maxim)m(um)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(bits)f(with)g(mask)0
850 y(and)c(v)-5 b(alue.)141 963 y(Additional)31 b(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(es)f(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(registered)j
(through)d(IANA)i(\(see)g(App)s(endix)e(D\).)0 1206 y
Fo(12.2)112 b(SDES)38 b(t)m(yp)s(es)50 1372 y Fq(abbrev.)151
b(name)1047 b(v)-5 b(alue)50 1485 y(END)248 b(end)29
b(of)i(SDES)f(list)759 b(0)50 1598 y(CNAME)100 b(canonical)32
b(name)807 b(1)50 1711 y(NAME)166 b(user)29 b(name)1014
b(2)50 1824 y(EMAIL)144 b(user's)29 b(electronic)k(mail)e(address)258
b(3)50 1936 y(PHONE)116 b(user's)29 b(phone)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)595
b(4)50 2049 y(LOC)253 b(geographic)31 b(user)f(lo)s(cation)457
b(5)50 2162 y(TOOL)182 b(name)30 b(of)h(application)g(or)g(to)s(ol)338
b(6)50 2275 y(NOTE)180 b(notice)31 b(ab)s(out)f(the)h(source)486
b(7)50 2388 y(PRIV)217 b(priv)-5 b(ate)30 b(extensions)706
b(8)141 2598 y(Additional)31 b(SDES)f(t)m(yp)s(es)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f
(registered)h(through)f(IANA)g(\(see)i(App)s(endix)c(D\).)0
2885 y Fp(13)135 b(R)-11 b(TP)44 b(Pro\014les)i(and)e(P)l(a)l(yload)j
(F)-11 b(ormat)45 b(Sp)t(eci\014cations)0 3087 y Fq(A)35
b(complete)h(sp)s(eci\014cation)g(of)f(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(for)h(a)g
(particular)g(application)h(will)f(require)g(one)g(or)g(more)g
(companion)0 3200 y(do)s(cumen)m(ts)30 b(of)h(t)m(w)m(o)g(t)m(yp)s(es)g
(describ)s(ed)e(here:)41 b(pro\014les,)30 b(and)f(pa)m(yload)j(format)f
(sp)s(eci\014cations.)141 3313 y(R)-8 b(TP)41 b(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)d(used)h
(for)g(a)h(v)-5 b(ariet)m(y)43 b(of)f(applications)h(with)e(somewhat)h
(di\013ering)f(requiremen)m(ts.)74 b(The)0 3426 y(\015exibilit)m(y)44
b(to)f(adapt)g(to)g(those)g(requiremen)m(ts)f(is)h(pro)m(vided)f(b)m(y)
h(allo)m(wing)h(m)m(ultiple)f(c)m(hoices)h(in)e(the)h(main)0
3539 y(proto)s(col)29 b(sp)s(eci\014cation,)h(then)e(selecting)i(the)e
(appropriate)g(c)m(hoices)i(or)e(de\014ning)f(extensions)i(for)f(a)h
(particular)0 3652 y(en)m(vironmen)m(t)g(and)e(class)i(of)f
(applications)h(in)f(a)g(separate)h Fk(pr)-5 b(o\014le)30
b Fq(do)s(cumen)m(t.)39 b(T)m(ypically)29 b(an)f(application)i(will)0
3765 y(op)s(erate)f(under)e(only)h(one)h(pro\014le)f(in)g(a)h
(particular)g(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(session,)h(so)g(there)g(is)f(no)g
(explicit)i(indication)f(within)0 3878 y(the)35 b(R)-8
b(TP)35 b(proto)s(col)h(itself)g(as)f(to)h(whic)m(h)f(pro\014le)g(is)g
(in)g(use.)109 b(A)35 b(pro\014le)g(for)f(audio)i(and)e(video)i
(applications)0 3991 y(ma)m(y)31 b(b)s(e)f(found)f(in)h(the)g
(companion)h(RF)m(C)g(XXXX.)41 b(Pro\014les)30 b(are)h(t)m(ypically)h
(titled)g(\\R)-8 b(TP)30 b(Pro\014le)h(for)f(.)15 b(.)h(.)f(".)141
4104 y(The)34 b(second)g(t)m(yp)s(e)g(of)g(companion)g(do)s(cumen)m(t)f
(is)h(a)h Fk(p)-5 b(aylo)g(ad)39 b(format)c Fq(sp)s(eci\014cation,)h
(whic)m(h)e(de\014nes)f(ho)m(w)0 4217 y(a)f(particular)g(kind)f(of)h
(pa)m(yload)h(data,)g(suc)m(h)e(as)h(H.261)i(enco)s(ded)d(video,)i
(should)e(b)s(e)g(carried)h(in)f(R)-8 b(TP.)45 b(These)0
4329 y(do)s(cumen)m(ts)33 b(are)h(t)m(ypically)i(titled)f(\\R)-8
b(TP)33 b(P)m(a)m(yload)j(F)-8 b(ormat)35 b(for)e(XYZ)h(Audio/Video)h
(Enco)s(ding".)50 b(P)m(a)m(yload)0 4442 y(formats)33
b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(useful)g(under)g(m)m(ultiple)h(pro\014les)f(and)h
(ma)m(y)g(therefore)g(b)s(e)f(de\014ned)g(indep)s(enden)m(tly)g(of)h
(an)m(y)0 4555 y(particular)i(pro\014le.)53 b(The)34
b(pro\014le)g(do)s(cumen)m(ts)g(are)h(then)f(resp)s(onsible)g(for)g
(assigning)h(a)g(default)g(mapping)f(of)0 4668 y(that)d(format)g(to)g
(a)g(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)f(v)-5 b(alue)31 b(if)g(needed.)141
4781 y(Within)f(this)f(sp)s(eci\014cation,)h(the)f(follo)m(wing)i
(items)f(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s(een)f(iden)m(ti\014ed)g(for)g(p)s(ossible)g
(de\014nition)f(within)0 4894 y(a)j(pro\014le,)f(but)g(this)g(list)h
(is)f(not)h(mean)m(t)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(exhaustiv)m(e:)0
5107 y Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(data)e(header:)45 b Fq(The)30
b(o)s(ctet)h(in)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(data)i(header)f(that)g(con)m
(tains)h(the)g(mark)m(er)f(bit)g(and)f(pa)m(yload)227
5219 y(t)m(yp)s(e)f(\014eld)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)29 b Fq(b)s(e)e(rede\014ned)
f(b)m(y)i(a)g(pro\014le)f(to)i(suit)e(di\013eren)m(t)h(requiremen)m
(ts,)h(for)e(example)h(with)g(more)227 5332 y(or)j(few)m(er)f(mark)m
(er)h(bits)f(\(Section)i(5.3,)f(p.)f(14\).)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(56])p eop
%%Page: 57 57
57 56 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fl(P)m(a)m(yload)36 b(t)m(yp)s(es:)45 b Fq(Assuming)34
b(that)g(a)h(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)f(\014eld)g(is)g(included,)h(the)f
(pro\014le)g(will)g(usually)g(de\014ne)g(a)227 511 y(set)c(of)g(pa)m
(yload)g(formats)g(\(e.g.,)i(media)d(enco)s(dings\))h(and)f(a)h
(default)f(static)i(mapping)e(of)h(those)g(formats)227
624 y(to)e(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(e)f(v)-5 b(alues.)40
b(Some)27 b(of)h(the)f(pa)m(yload)i(formats)e(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)d
(de\014ned)h(b)m(y)g(reference)h(to)g(separate)227 737
y(pa)m(yload)38 b(format)f(sp)s(eci\014cations.)60 b(F)-8
b(or)37 b(eac)m(h)h(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)f(de\014ned,)g(the)g
(pro\014le)f Fi(must)f Fq(sp)s(ecify)i(the)227 850 y(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(timestamp)h(clo)s(c)m(k)h(rate)f(to)g(b)s(e)f(used)g
(\(Section)h(5.1,)h(p.)e(12\).)0 1038 y Fl(R)-9 b(TP)36
b(data)e(header)h(additions:)45 b Fq(Additional)22 b(\014elds)f
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)23 b Fq(b)s(e)d(app)s(ended)g(to)i(the)f(\014xed)g(R)-8
b(TP)21 b(data)h(header)f(if)227 1151 y(some)28 b(additional)g
(functionalit)m(y)g(is)f(required)f(across)i(the)f(pro\014le's)g(class)
h(of)f(applications)h(indep)s(enden)m(t)227 1264 y(of)j(pa)m(yload)g(t)
m(yp)s(e)g(\(Section)g(5.3,)h(p.)e(14\).)0 1451 y Fl(R)-9
b(TP)36 b(data)e(header)h(extensions:)46 b Fq(The)20
b(con)m(ten)m(ts)j(of)e(the)g(\014rst)g(16)h(bits)f(of)g(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)21 b(data)g(header)g(extension)227 1564 y(structure)39
b Fi(must)f Fq(b)s(e)g(de\014ned)g(if)h(use)f(of)h(that)h(mec)m(hanism)
f(is)g(to)h(b)s(e)e(allo)m(w)m(ed)j(under)c(the)j(pro\014le)e(for)227
1677 y(implemen)m(tation-sp)s(eci\014c)32 b(extensions)f(\(Section)h
(5.3.1,)g(p.)e(15\).)0 1865 y Fl(R)-9 b(TCP)35 b(pac)m(k)m(et)g(t)m(yp)
s(es:)46 b Fq(New)25 b(application-class-sp)s(eci\014c)i(R)-8
b(TCP)24 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(es)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)25
b Fq(b)s(e)f(de\014ned)f(and)h(reg-)227 1978 y(istered)31
b(with)f(IANA.)0 2165 y Fl(R)-9 b(TCP)35 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-6
b(al:)46 b Fq(A)25 b(pro\014le)g Fi(should)f Fq(sp)s(ecify)h(that)h
(the)g(v)-5 b(alues)25 b(suggested)i(in)e(Section)h(6.2)h(for)e(the)227
2278 y(constan)m(ts)36 b(emplo)m(y)m(ed)g(in)f(the)g(calculation)i(of)e
(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)36
b(will)f(b)s(e)g(used.)53 b(Those)35 b(are)227 2391 y(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)35 b(fraction)h(of)g(session)f(bandwidth,)h(the)f(minim)m(um)g
(rep)s(ort)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al,)38 b(and)d(the)h(bandwidth)227
2504 y(split)31 b(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)g(senders)e(and)h(receiv)m(ers.)42
b(A)30 b(pro\014le)g Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)f(alternate)i(v)-5
b(alues)31 b(if)f(they)g(ha)m(v)m(e)i(b)s(een)227 2617
y(demonstrated)f(to)g(w)m(ork)f(in)g(a)h(scalable)h(manner.)0
2804 y Fl(SR/RR)k(extension:)46 b Fq(An)36 b(extension)h(section)g
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)38 b Fq(b)s(e)d(de\014ned)g(for)h(the)h(R)-8
b(TCP)36 b(SR)f(and)h(RR)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(if)227 2917
y(there)25 b(is)f(additional)h(information)f(that)h(should)e(b)s(e)g
(rep)s(orted)h(regularly)g(ab)s(out)g(the)g(sender)g(or)g(receiv)m(ers)
227 3030 y(\(Section)32 b(6.4.3,)g(p.)e(33\).)0 3218
y Fl(SDES)35 b(use:)46 b Fq(The)23 b(pro\014le)g Fi(ma)-6
b(y)25 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)f(the)g(relativ)m(e)h(priorities)g(for)e(R)-8
b(TCP)24 b(SDES)f(items)h(to)g(b)s(e)g(transmitted)227
3331 y(or)34 b(excluded)g(en)m(tirely)i(\(Section)f(6.3.9\);)j(an)c
(alternate)i(syn)m(tax)e(or)h(seman)m(tics)g(for)f(the)g(CNAME)g(item)
227 3444 y(\(Section)40 b(6.5.1\);)46 b(the)39 b(format)g(of)g(the)g
(LOC)e(item)j(\(Section)g(6.5.5\);)45 b(the)39 b(seman)m(tics)h(and)e
(use)h(of)g(the)227 3557 y(NOTE)30 b(item)h(\(Section)h(6.5.7\);)g(or)f
(new)f(SDES)f(item)i(t)m(yp)s(es)g(to)g(b)s(e)f(registered)h(with)f
(IANA.)0 3744 y Fl(Securit)m(y:)46 b Fq(A)34 b(pro\014le)g
Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)f(whic)m(h)g(securit)m(y)h(services)f
(and)g(algorithms)h(should)e(b)s(e)g(o\013ered)i(b)m(y)f(ap-)227
3857 y(plications,)e(and)e Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31 b Fq(pro)m(vide)g(guidance)g
(as)f(to)h(their)g(appropriate)f(use)g(\(Section)i(9,)f(p.)f(51\).)0
4045 y Fl(String-to-k)m(ey)35 b(mapping:)46 b Fq(A)33
b(pro\014le)g Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(sp)s(ecify)d(ho)m(w)i(a)f(user-pro)m
(vided)g(passw)m(ord)f(or)i(pass)e(phrase)h(is)227 4158
y(mapp)s(ed)c(in)m(to)j(an)e(encryption)g(k)m(ey)-8 b(.)0
4345 y Fl(Congestion:)46 b Fq(A)23 b(pro\014le)f Fi(should)g
Fq(sp)s(ecify)g(the)h(congestion)i(con)m(trol)f(b)s(eha)m(vior)f
(appropriate)g(for)g(that)g(pro\014le.)0 4533 y Fl(Underlying)36
b(proto)s(col:)47 b Fq(Use)23 b(of)h(a)g(particular)g(underlying)e(net)
m(w)m(ork)i(or)g(transp)s(ort)e(la)m(y)m(er)j(proto)s(col)g(to)f(carry)
227 4646 y(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j Fi(ma)-6 b(y)31
b Fq(b)s(e)f(required.)0 4834 y Fl(T)-9 b(ransp)s(ort)35
b(mapping:)46 b Fq(A)f(mapping)f(of)h(R)-8 b(TP)45 b(and)f(R)-8
b(TCP)45 b(to)g(transp)s(ort-lev)m(el)h(addresses,)i(e.g.,)j(UDP)227
4946 y(p)s(orts,)30 b(other)h(than)f(the)g(standard)g(mapping)g
(de\014ned)f(in)h(Section)h(11,)h(p.)e(54)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(sp)s
(eci\014ed.)0 5134 y Fl(Encapsulation:)46 b Fq(An)38
b(encapsulation)g(of)h(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e
(de\014ned)g(to)i(allo)m(w)h(m)m(ultiple)e(R)-8 b(TP)38
b(data)227 5247 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)26 b(to)e(b)s(e)f(carried)h(in)g(one)g
(lo)m(w)m(er-la)m(y)m(er)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(or)e(to)g(pro)m(vide)g
(framing)g(o)m(v)m(er)h(underlying)d(proto)s(cols)227
5360 y(that)31 b(do)g(not)f(already)h(do)f(so)h(\(Section)g(11,)h(p.)e
(54\).)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)
496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(57])p eop
%%Page: 58 58
58 57 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(It)d(is)g(not)h(exp)s(ected)f(that)h(a)f(new)g(pro\014le)f(will)i(b)s
(e)e(required)g(for)h(ev)m(ery)h(application.)41 b(Within)29
b(one)f(applica-)0 511 y(tion)j(class,)g(it)g(w)m(ould)f(b)s(e)g(b)s
(etter)h(to)g(extend)f(an)h(existing)g(pro\014le)f(rather)g(than)g(mak)
m(e)i(a)f(new)f(one)g(in)g(order)g(to)0 624 y(facilitate)f(in)m(terop)s
(eration)e(among)f(the)h(applications)g(since)f(eac)m(h)h(will)g(t)m
(ypically)h(run)c(under)h(only)h(one)g(pro\014le.)0 737
y(Simple)34 b(extensions)g(suc)m(h)g(as)g(the)g(de\014nition)g(of)g
(additional)h(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(e)f(v)-5 b(alues)34
b(or)g(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(t)m(yp)s(es)0 850
y(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(accomplished)g(b)m(y)g(registering)h(them)e(through)
g(IANA)i(and)e(publishing)f(their)i(descriptions)g(in)f(an)0
963 y(addendum)28 b(to)k(the)e(pro\014le)g(or)h(in)f(a)g(pa)m(yload)i
(format)e(sp)s(eci\014cation.)0 1249 y Fp(A)134 b(Algorithms)0
1452 y Fq(W)-8 b(e)32 b(pro)m(vide)f(examples)h(of)f(C)f(co)s(de)h(for)
g(asp)s(ects)g(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(sender)f(and)g(receiv)m(er)j
(algorithms.)43 b(There)30 b(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)0 1565 y(other)h(implemen)m
(tation)h(metho)s(ds)e(that)h(are)g(faster)h(in)e(particular)h(op)s
(erating)g(en)m(vironmen)m(ts)g(or)g(ha)m(v)m(e)h(other)0
1678 y(adv)-5 b(an)m(tages.)71 b(These)40 b(implemen)m(tation)h(notes)g
(are)f(for)g(informational)h(purp)s(oses)d(only)i(and)f(are)h(mean)m(t)
h(to)0 1791 y(clarify)31 b(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(sp)s(eci\014cation.)141
1904 y(The)f(follo)m(wing)i(de\014nitions)d(are)i(used)e(for)h(all)i
(examples;)f(for)f(clarit)m(y)i(and)e(brevit)m(y)-8 b(,)30
b(the)g(structure)f(de\014ni-)0 2017 y(tions)k(are)g(only)f(v)-5
b(alid)33 b(for)f(32-bit)i(big-endian)e(\(most)i(signi\014can)m(t)f(o)s
(ctet)h(\014rst\))e(arc)m(hitectures.)48 b(Bit)34 b(\014elds)e(are)0
2130 y(assumed)i(to)i(b)s(e)e(pac)m(k)m(ed)i(tigh)m(tly)h(in)d
(big-endian)h(bit)g(order,)h(with)f(no)g(additional)h(padding.)53
b(Mo)s(di\014cations)0 2243 y(w)m(ould)30 b(b)s(e)g(required)f(to)j
(construct)e(a)h(p)s(ortable)f(implemen)m(tation.)0 2455
y Fh(/*)48 2568 y(*)47 b(rtp.h)94 b(--)h(RTP)47 b(header)f(file)48
2681 y(*/)0 2794 y(#include)g(<sys/types.h>)0 3020 y(/*)48
3133 y(*)h(The)g(type)g(definitions)d(below)j(are)g(valid)f(for)h
(32-bit)f(architectures)e(and)48 3246 y(*)j(may)g(have)g(to)g(be)g
(adjusted)f(for)h(16-)f(or)i(64-bit)e(architectures.)48
3359 y(*/)0 3472 y(typedef)g(unsigned)f(char)95 b(u_int8;)0
3584 y(typedef)46 b(unsigned)f(short)i(u_int16;)0 3697
y(typedef)f(unsigned)f(int)143 b(u_int32;)0 3810 y(typedef)475
b(short)47 b(int16;)0 4036 y(/*)48 4149 y(*)g(Current)f(protocol)g
(version.)48 4262 y(*/)0 4375 y(#define)g(RTP_VERSION)188
b(2)0 4601 y(#define)46 b(RTP_SEQ_MOD)f(\(1<<16\))0 4714
y(#define)h(RTP_MAX_SDES)e(255)286 b(/*)47 b(maximum)f(text)g(length)h
(for)f(SDES)h(*/)0 4939 y(typedef)f(enum)g({)191 5052
y(RTCP_SR)141 b(=)48 b(200,)191 5165 y(RTCP_RR)141 b(=)48
b(201,)191 5278 y(RTCP_SDES)d(=)j(202,)191 5391 y(RTCP_BYE)93
b(=)48 b(203,)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(58])p eop
%%Page: 59 59
59 58 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)191 399
y Fh(RTCP_APP)93 b(=)48 b(204)0 511 y(})f(rtcp_type_t;)0
737 y(typedef)f(enum)g({)191 850 y(RTCP_SDES_END)140
b(=)47 b(0,)191 963 y(RTCP_SDES_CNAME)d(=)j(1,)191 1076
y(RTCP_SDES_NAME)92 b(=)47 b(2,)191 1189 y(RTCP_SDES_EMAIL)d(=)j(3,)191
1302 y(RTCP_SDES_PHONE)d(=)j(4,)191 1415 y(RTCP_SDES_LOC)140
b(=)47 b(5,)191 1528 y(RTCP_SDES_TOOL)92 b(=)47 b(6,)191
1641 y(RTCP_SDES_NOTE)92 b(=)47 b(7,)191 1753 y(RTCP_SDES_PRIV)92
b(=)47 b(8)0 1866 y(})g(rtcp_sdes_type_t;)0 2092 y(/*)48
2205 y(*)g(RTP)g(data)g(header)48 2318 y(*/)0 2431 y(typedef)f(struct)g
({)191 2544 y(unsigned)f(int)i(version:2;)141 b(/*)47
b(protocol)f(version)f(*/)191 2657 y(unsigned)g(int)i(p:1;)429
b(/*)47 b(padding)f(flag)g(*/)191 2770 y(unsigned)f(int)i(x:1;)429
b(/*)47 b(header)f(extension)f(flag)i(*/)191 2883 y(unsigned)e(int)i
(cc:4;)381 b(/*)47 b(CSRC)g(count)f(*/)191 2995 y(unsigned)f(int)i
(m:1;)429 b(/*)47 b(marker)f(bit)h(*/)191 3108 y(unsigned)e(int)i
(pt:7;)381 b(/*)47 b(payload)f(type)g(*/)191 3221 y(unsigned)f(int)i
(seq:16;)285 b(/*)47 b(sequence)f(number)g(*/)191 3334
y(u_int32)g(ts;)715 b(/*)47 b(timestamp)e(*/)191 3447
y(u_int32)h(ssrc;)619 b(/*)47 b(synchronization)d(source)i(*/)191
3560 y(u_int32)g(csrc[1];)475 b(/*)47 b(optional)f(CSRC)g(list)h(*/)0
3673 y(})g(rtp_hdr_t;)0 3899 y(/*)48 4012 y(*)g(RTCP)g(common)f(header)
g(word)48 4125 y(*/)0 4237 y(typedef)g(struct)g({)191
4350 y(unsigned)f(int)i(version:2;)141 b(/*)47 b(protocol)f(version)f
(*/)191 4463 y(unsigned)g(int)i(p:1;)429 b(/*)47 b(padding)f(flag)g(*/)
191 4576 y(unsigned)f(int)i(count:5;)237 b(/*)47 b(varies)f(by)h
(packet)f(type)h(*/)191 4689 y(unsigned)e(int)i(pt:8;)381
b(/*)47 b(RTCP)g(packet)f(type)g(*/)191 4802 y(u_int16)g(length;)523
b(/*)47 b(pkt)g(len)g(in)g(words,)f(w/o)h(this)g(word)f(*/)0
4915 y(})h(rtcp_common_t;)0 5141 y(/*)48 5254 y(*)g(Big-endian)e(mask)i
(for)g(version,)e(padding)h(bit)h(and)g(packet)f(type)h(pair)48
5367 y(*/)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(59])p eop
%%Page: 60 60
60 59 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fh(#define)46 b(RTCP_VALID_MASK)d(\(0xc000)j(|)i(0x2000)e(|)h(0xfe\))
0 511 y(#define)f(RTCP_VALID_VALUE)d(\(\(RTP_VERSION)h(<<)k(14\))e(|)i
(RTCP_SR\))0 737 y(/*)48 850 y(*)f(Reception)e(report)i(block)48
963 y(*/)0 1076 y(typedef)f(struct)g({)191 1189 y(u_int32)g(ssrc;)619
b(/*)47 b(data)g(source)f(being)g(reported)g(*/)191 1302
y(unsigned)f(int)i(fraction:8;)93 b(/*)47 b(fraction)f(lost)g(since)h
(last)f(SR/RR)h(*/)191 1415 y(int)g(lost:24;)666 b(/*)47
b(cumul.)f(no.)h(pkts)g(lost)f(\(signed!\))g(*/)191 1528
y(u_int32)g(last_seq;)427 b(/*)47 b(extended)f(last)g(seq.)h(no.)g
(received)e(*/)191 1641 y(u_int32)h(jitter;)523 b(/*)47
b(interarrival)d(jitter)j(*/)191 1753 y(u_int32)f(lsr;)667
b(/*)47 b(last)g(SR)g(packet)f(from)h(this)f(source)g(*/)191
1866 y(u_int32)g(dlsr;)619 b(/*)47 b(delay)f(since)h(last)f(SR)i
(packet)e(*/)0 1979 y(})h(rtcp_rr_t;)0 2205 y(/*)48 2318
y(*)g(SDES)g(item)48 2431 y(*/)0 2544 y(typedef)f(struct)g({)191
2657 y(u_int8)g(type;)667 b(/*)47 b(type)g(of)g(item)f
(\(rtcp_sdes_type_t\))d(*/)191 2770 y(u_int8)j(length;)571
b(/*)47 b(length)f(of)h(item)g(\(in)g(octets\))f(*/)191
2883 y(char)h(data[1];)618 b(/*)47 b(text,)f(not)h(null-terminated)d
(*/)0 2995 y(})j(rtcp_sdes_item_t;)0 3221 y(/*)48 3334
y(*)g(One)g(RTCP)g(packet)48 3447 y(*/)0 3560 y(typedef)f(struct)g({)
191 3673 y(rtcp_common_t)e(common;)237 b(/*)47 b(common)f(header)g(*/)
191 3786 y(union)g({)382 3899 y(/*)h(sender)f(report)g(\(SR\))h(*/)382
4012 y(struct)f({)573 4125 y(u_int32)g(ssrc;)237 b(/*)47
b(sender)f(generating)f(this)i(report)f(*/)573 4237 y(u_int32)g
(ntp_sec;)93 b(/*)47 b(NTP)g(timestamp)e(*/)573 4350
y(u_int32)h(ntp_frac;)573 4463 y(u_int32)g(rtp_ts;)141
b(/*)47 b(RTP)g(timestamp)e(*/)573 4576 y(u_int32)h(psent;)189
b(/*)47 b(packets)f(sent)g(*/)573 4689 y(u_int32)g(osent;)189
b(/*)47 b(octets)f(sent)h(*/)573 4802 y(rtcp_rr_t)e(rr[1];)94
b(/*)47 b(variable-length)d(list)i(*/)382 4915 y(})h(sr;)382
5141 y(/*)g(reception)e(report)h(\(RR\))h(*/)382 5254
y(struct)f({)573 5367 y(u_int32)g(ssrc;)237 b(/*)47 b(receiver)f
(generating)f(this)h(report)g(*/)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(60])p eop
%%Page: 61 61
61 60 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)573 399
y Fh(rtcp_rr_t)45 b(rr[1];)94 b(/*)47 b(variable-length)d(list)i(*/)382
511 y(})h(rr;)382 737 y(/*)g(source)f(description)f(\(SDES\))h(*/)382
850 y(struct)g(rtcp_sdes)f({)573 963 y(u_int32)h(src;)285
b(/*)47 b(first)f(SSRC/CSRC)g(*/)573 1076 y(rtcp_sdes_item_t)d
(item[1];)j(/*)h(list)f(of)i(SDES)e(items)h(*/)382 1189
y(})g(sdes;)382 1415 y(/*)g(BYE)g(*/)382 1528 y(struct)f({)573
1641 y(u_int32)g(src[1];)141 b(/*)47 b(list)g(of)g(sources)f(*/)573
1753 y(/*)h(can't)f(express)g(trailing)g(text)g(for)h(reason)f(*/)382
1866 y(})h(bye;)191 1979 y(})g(r;)0 2092 y(})g(rtcp_t;)0
2318 y(typedef)f(struct)g(rtcp_sdes)f(rtcp_sdes_t;)0
2621 y(/*)48 2734 y(*)i(Per-source)e(state)i(information)48
2847 y(*/)0 2960 y(typedef)f(struct)g({)191 3073 y(u_int16)g(max_seq;)
379 b(/*)48 b(highest)d(seq.)i(number)f(seen)h(*/)191
3186 y(u_int32)f(cycles;)427 b(/*)48 b(shifted)d(count)i(of)g(seq.)g
(number)f(cycles)g(*/)191 3299 y(u_int32)g(base_seq;)331
b(/*)48 b(base)e(seq)h(number)f(*/)191 3412 y(u_int32)g(bad_seq;)379
b(/*)48 b(last)e('bad')h(seq)f(number)h(+)g(1)g(*/)191
3525 y(u_int32)f(probation;)283 b(/*)48 b(sequ.)e(packets)g(till)g
(source)g(is)i(valid)e(*/)191 3638 y(u_int32)g(received;)331
b(/*)48 b(packets)d(received)h(*/)191 3751 y(u_int32)g(expected_prior;)
d(/*)48 b(packet)e(expected)f(at)i(last)g(interval)f(*/)191
3863 y(u_int32)g(received_prior;)d(/*)48 b(packet)e(received)f(at)i
(last)g(interval)f(*/)191 3976 y(u_int32)g(transit;)379
b(/*)48 b(relative)d(trans)h(time)h(for)g(prev)g(pkt)g(*/)191
4089 y(u_int32)f(jitter;)427 b(/*)48 b(estimated)d(jitter)h(*/)191
4202 y(/*)h(...)g(*/)0 4315 y(})g(source;)0 4649 y Fo(A.1)112
b(R)-9 b(TP)36 b(Data)i(Header)g(V)-9 b(alidit)m(y)37
b(Chec)m(ks)0 4821 y Fq(An)h(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(receiv)m(er)h
Fi(should)d Fq(c)m(hec)m(k)j(the)f(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)40
b(of)f(the)g(R)-8 b(TP)38 b(header)h(on)f(incoming)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(since)e(they)0 4934 y(migh)m(t)i(b)s(e)f(encrypted)h(or)f(migh)m(t)i
(b)s(e)e(from)g(a)h(di\013eren)m(t)g(application)h(that)f(happ)s(ens)e
(to)j(b)s(e)e(misaddressed.)0 5047 y(Similarly)-8 b(,)43
b(if)d(encryption)g(according)h(to)g(the)g(metho)s(d)e(describ)s(ed)g
(in)h(Section)h(9)80 b(is)40 b(enabled,)j(the)d(header)0
5160 y(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)37 b(c)m(hec)m(k)g(is)e(needed)g(to)i(v)m
(erify)e(that)h(incoming)g(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(ha)m(v)m(e)e(b)s(een)f
(correctly)i(decrypted,)g(although)0 5273 y(a)h(failure)f(of)h(the)g
(header)f(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)39 b(c)m(hec)m(k)g(\(e.g.,)i(unkno)m(wn)36
b(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e\))g(ma)m(y)g(not)g(necessarily)g(indicate)0
5386 y(decryption)30 b(failure.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(61])p eop
%%Page: 62 62
62 61 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(Only)d(w)m(eak)i(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)30 b(c)m(hec)m(ks)g(are)f(p)s
(ossible)f(on)g(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)28 b(data)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(from)e(a)h
(source)g(that)g(has)g(not)g(b)s(een)0 511 y(heard)h(b)s(efore:)136
699 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(v)m(ersion)h(\014eld)f(m)m(ust)h
(equal)f(2.)136 887 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)
e(m)m(ust)g(b)s(e)g(kno)m(wn,)g(and)g(in)g(particular)h(it)g(m)m(ust)f
(not)g(b)s(e)g(equal)h(to)g(SR)f(or)g(RR.)136 1074 y
Fj(\017)46 b Fq(If)40 b(the)h(P)g(bit)f(is)h(set,)j(then)c(the)h(last)h
(o)s(ctet)g(of)e(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(m)m(ust)d(con)m(tain)i(a)f(v)-5
b(alid)41 b(o)s(ctet)h(coun)m(t,)i(in)227 1187 y(particular,)31
b(less)g(than)f(the)h(total)h(pac)m(k)m(et)g(length)f(min)m(us)f(the)g
(header)g(size.)136 1375 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)32 b(X)h(bit)f(m)m(ust)h
(b)s(e)e(zero)j(if)e(the)h(pro\014le)f(do)s(es)g(not)h(sp)s(ecify)f
(that)h(the)f(header)h(extension)g(mec)m(hanism)227 1488
y(ma)m(y)j(b)s(e)f(used.)56 b(Otherwise,)37 b(the)f(extension)g(length)
g(\014eld)f(m)m(ust)h(b)s(e)f(less)h(than)f(the)h(total)h(pac)m(k)m(et)
h(size)227 1601 y(min)m(us)30 b(the)g(\014xed)g(header)g(length)h(and)f
(padding.)136 1788 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)34 b(length)g(of)g(the)g(pac)m
(k)m(et)h(m)m(ust)f(b)s(e)f(consisten)m(t)i(with)f(CC)f(and)g(pa)m
(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)f(\(if)g(pa)m(yloads)h(ha)m(v)m(e)g(a)227
1901 y(kno)m(wn)30 b(length\).)141 2089 y(The)40 b(last)g(three)g(c)m
(hec)m(ks)i(are)e(somewhat)g(complex)h(and)e(not)h(alw)m(a)m(ys)i(p)s
(ossible,)g(lea)m(ving)g(only)e(the)g(\014rst)0 2202
y(t)m(w)m(o)33 b(whic)m(h)f(total)h(just)f(a)g(few)f(bits.)45
b(If)32 b(the)g(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)i(in)g(the)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i
(is)d(one)i(that)f(has)f(b)s(een)h(receiv)m(ed)0 2315
y(b)s(efore,)j(then)g(the)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)d(probably)g(v)-5
b(alid)35 b(and)f(c)m(hec)m(king)i(if)e(the)h(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)e(is)i(in)f(the)h(exp)s(ected)0 2428 y(range)44 b(pro)m(vides)g
(further)f(v)-5 b(alidation.)83 b(If)44 b(the)g(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m
(ti\014er)h(has)g(not)g(b)s(een)f(seen)h(b)s(efore,)k(then)43
b(data)0 2540 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)29 b(carrying)f(that)g(iden)m(ti\014er)f
(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(considered)g(in)m(v)-5 b(alid)28 b(un)m(til)g(a)f
(small)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(them)f(arriv)m(e)h(with)0
2653 y(consecutiv)m(e)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers.)38
b(Those)27 b(in)m(v)-5 b(alid)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)h Fi(ma)-6
b(y)28 b Fq(b)s(e)f(discarded)f(or)i(they)g Fi(ma)-6
b(y)29 b Fq(b)s(e)d(stored)i(and)0 2766 y(deliv)m(ered)j(once)g(v)-5
b(alidation)32 b(has)e(b)s(een)g(ac)m(hiev)m(ed)i(if)e(the)h(resulting)
f(dela)m(y)i(is)e(acceptable.)141 2879 y(The)53 b(routine)f
Fh(update_seq)f Fq(sho)m(wn)h(b)s(elo)m(w)h(ensures)f(that)h(a)h
(source)f(is)g(declared)g(v)-5 b(alid)53 b(only)g(after)0
2992 y Fh(MIN_SEQUENTIAL)40 b Fq(pac)m(k)m(ets)46 b(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s
(een)d(receiv)m(ed)j(in)e(sequence.)82 b(It)45 b(also)g(v)-5
b(alidates)45 b(the)g(sequence)f(n)m(um-)0 3105 y(b)s(er)33
b Fh(seq)h Fq(of)g(a)h(newly)f(receiv)m(ed)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(and)c(up)s
(dates)h(the)g(sequence)h(state)g(for)f(the)h(pac)m(k)m(et's)h(source)f
(in)f(the)0 3218 y(structure)c(to)h(whic)m(h)f Fh(s)g
Fq(p)s(oin)m(ts.)141 3331 y(When)35 b(a)h(new)f(source)g(is)h(heard)e
(for)i(the)f(\014rst)g(time,)i(that)f(is,)h(its)f(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m
(ti\014er)i(is)f(not)g(in)h(the)f(table)0 3444 y(\(see)29
b(Section)f(8.2\),)i(and)e(the)f(p)s(er-source)h(state)h(is)f(allo)s
(cated)i(for)d(it,)i Fh(s->probation)c Fq(is)i(set)i(to)f(the)g(n)m(um)
m(b)s(er)f(of)0 3557 y(sequen)m(tial)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(required)d(b)s
(efore)h(declaring)g(a)h(source)f(v)-5 b(alid)28 b(\(parameter)h
Fh(MIN_SEQUENTIAL)p Fq(\))24 b(and)k(other)0 3670 y(v)-5
b(ariables)31 b(are)g(initialized:)191 3882 y Fh(init_seq\(s,)45
b(seq\);)191 3995 y(s->max_seq)g(=)i(seq)g(-)h(1;)191
4108 y(s->probation)c(=)k(MIN_SEQUENTIAL;)0 4320 y Fq(A)31
b(non-zero)g Fh(s->probation)c Fq(marks)j(the)h(source)f(as)h(not)g(y)m
(et)g(v)-5 b(alid)31 b(so)g(the)g(state)h(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)f(discarded)g
(after)h(a)0 4433 y(short)f(timeout)h(rather)g(than)f(a)h(long)g(one,)f
(as)h(discussed)f(in)g(Section)h(6.2.1.)141 4546 y(After)e(a)f(source)h
(is)f(considered)g(v)-5 b(alid,)29 b(the)f(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e
(is)h(considered)g(v)-5 b(alid)29 b(if)f(it)h(is)f(no)g(more)g(than)0
4659 y Fh(MAX_DROPOUT)38 b Fq(ahead)j(of)h Fh(s->max_seq)c
Fq(nor)i(more)i(than)e Fh(MAX_MISORDER)e Fq(b)s(ehind.)71
b(If)41 b(the)g(new)g(sequence)0 4772 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)25
b(is)i(ahead)g(of)g Fh(max_seq)e Fq(mo)s(dulo)h(the)h(R)-8
b(TP)27 b(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(range)h(\(16)h(bits\),)g(but)e
(is)h(smaller)g(than)0 4885 y Fh(max_seq)p Fq(,)f(it)i(has)f(wrapp)s
(ed)e(around)h(and)h(the)g(\(shifted\))h(coun)m(t)g(of)f(sequence)h(n)m
(um)m(b)s(er)d(cycles)k(is)e(incremen)m(ted.)0 4998 y(A)j(v)-5
b(alue)31 b(of)g(one)g(is)f(returned)f(to)i(indicate)h(a)e(v)-5
b(alid)31 b(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er.)141 5111 y(Otherwise,)25
b(the)f(v)-5 b(alue)24 b(zero)h(is)e(returned)g(to)h(indicate)h(that)g
(the)e(v)-5 b(alidation)26 b(failed,)f(and)f(the)f(bad)h(sequence)0
5224 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)32 b(plus)h(1)68 b(is)33 b(stored.)51
b(If)33 b(the)h(next)f(pac)m(k)m(et)j(receiv)m(ed)f(carries)f(the)g
(next)g(higher)f(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er,)f(it)0 5337
y(is)e(considered)f(the)h(v)-5 b(alid)31 b(start)g(of)g(a)g(new)f(pac)m
(k)m(et)j(sequence)e(presumably)f(caused)g(b)m(y)h(an)f(extended)h
(drop)s(out)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(62])p eop
%%Page: 63 63
63 62 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(or)36 b(a)h(source)f(restart.)58 b(Since)36 b(m)m(ultiple)h(complete)
h(sequence)e(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(cycles)i(ma)m(y)g(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s(een)e
(missed,)j(the)0 511 y(pac)m(k)m(et)32 b(loss)f(statistics)h(are)f
(reset.)141 624 y(T)m(ypical)23 b(v)-5 b(alues)23 b(for)f(the)g
(parameters)h(are)g(sho)m(wn,)g(based)f(on)g(a)h(maxim)m(um)f
(misordering)g(time)h(of)f(2)h(seconds)0 737 y(at)31
b(50)h(pac)m(k)m(ets/second)g(and)e(a)h(maxim)m(um)g(drop)s(out)e(of)i
(1)f(min)m(ute.)42 b(The)30 b(drop)s(out)f(parameter)i
Fh(MAX_DROPOUT)0 850 y Fi(should)h Fq(b)s(e)i(a)g(small)h(fraction)f
(of)h(the)f(16-bit)h(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(space)j(to)g(giv)m(e)
g(a)g(reasonable)f(probabilit)m(y)0 963 y(that)24 b(new)f(sequence)i(n)
m(um)m(b)s(ers)d(after)i(a)g(restart)g(will)g(not)g(fall)h(in)e(the)h
(acceptable)i(range)e(for)f(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)0
1076 y(from)30 b(b)s(efore)g(the)g(restart.)0 1289 y
Fh(void)47 b(init_seq\(source)c(*s,)k(u_int16)f(seq\))0
1401 y({)191 1514 y(s->base_seq)f(=)i(seq;)191 1627 y(s->max_seq)e(=)i
(seq;)191 1740 y(s->bad_seq)e(=)i(RTP_SEQ_MOD)e(+)j(1;)142
b(/*)47 b(so)h(seq)e(==)i(bad_seq)d(is)j(false)e(*/)191
1853 y(s->cycles)f(=)j(0;)191 1966 y(s->received)d(=)i(0;)191
2079 y(s->received_prior)c(=)k(0;)191 2192 y(s->expected_prior)c(=)k
(0;)191 2305 y(/*)g(other)f(initialization)e(*/)0 2418
y(})0 2643 y(int)j(update_seq\(source)c(*s,)k(u_int16)f(seq\))0
2756 y({)191 2869 y(u_int16)g(udelta)g(=)h(seq)g(-)h(s->max_seq;)191
2982 y(const)e(int)h(MAX_DROPOUT)e(=)i(3000;)191 3095
y(const)f(int)h(MAX_MISORDER)e(=)i(100;)191 3208 y(const)f(int)h
(MIN_SEQUENTIAL)d(=)k(2;)191 3434 y(/*)239 3547 y(*)f(Source)f(is)h
(not)g(valid)g(until)f(MIN_SEQUENTIAL)e(packets)i(with)239
3660 y(*)h(sequential)e(sequence)h(numbers)f(have)i(been)g(received.)
239 3773 y(*/)191 3885 y(if)g(\(s->probation\))d({)382
3998 y(/*)j(packet)f(is)h(in)g(sequence)f(*/)382 4111
y(if)h(\(seq)g(==)g(s->max_seq)e(+)i(1\))g({)573 4224
y(s->probation--;)573 4337 y(s->max_seq)e(=)i(seq;)573
4450 y(if)g(\(s->probation)d(==)j(0\))g({)764 4563 y(init_seq\(s,)d
(seq\);)764 4676 y(s->received++;)764 4789 y(return)i(1;)573
4902 y(})382 5015 y(})h(else)g({)573 5127 y(s->probation)d(=)k
(MIN_SEQUENTIAL)c(-)j(1;)573 5240 y(s->max_seq)e(=)i(seq;)382
5353 y(})0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(63])p eop
%%Page: 64 64
64 63 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)382 399
y Fh(return)46 b(0;)191 511 y(})h(else)g(if)g(\(udelta)f(<)h
(MAX_DROPOUT\))e({)382 624 y(/*)i(in)g(order,)f(with)h(permissible)e
(gap)i(*/)382 737 y(if)g(\(seq)g(<)g(s->max_seq\))e({)573
850 y(/*)620 963 y(*)j(Sequence)d(number)i(wrapped)e(-)j(count)e
(another)g(64K)h(cycle.)620 1076 y(*/)573 1189 y(s->cycles)e(+=)i
(RTP_SEQ_MOD;)382 1302 y(})382 1415 y(s->max_seq)e(=)i(seq;)191
1528 y(})g(else)g(if)g(\(udelta)f(<=)h(RTP_SEQ_MOD)e(-)i
(MAX_MISORDER\))e({)382 1641 y(/*)i(the)g(sequence)e(number)i(made)f(a)
i(very)e(large)h(jump)f(*/)382 1753 y(if)h(\(seq)g(==)g(s->bad_seq\))e
({)573 1866 y(/*)620 1979 y(*)j(Two)f(sequential)e(packets)h(--)h
(assume)f(that)h(the)f(other)h(side)620 2092 y(*)h(restarted)d(without)
h(telling)g(us)h(so)g(just)g(re-sync)620 2205 y(*)h(\(i.e.,)e(pretend)g
(this)g(was)h(the)g(first)g(packet\).)620 2318 y(*/)573
2431 y(init_seq\(s,)d(seq\);)382 2544 y(})382 2657 y(else)i({)573
2770 y(s->bad_seq)f(=)i(\(seq)g(+)g(1\))g(&)h(\(RTP_SEQ_MOD-1\);)573
2883 y(return)e(0;)382 2995 y(})191 3108 y(})h(else)g({)382
3221 y(/*)g(duplicate)e(or)i(reordered)f(packet)g(*/)191
3334 y(})191 3447 y(s->received++;)191 3560 y(return)g(1;)0
3673 y(})141 3877 y Fq(The)37 b(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)40
b(c)m(hec)m(k)f(can)f(b)s(e)g(made)f(stronger)h(requiring)g(more)g
(than)f(t)m(w)m(o)j(pac)m(k)m(ets)f(in)f(sequence.)63
b(The)0 3990 y(disadv)-5 b(an)m(tages)32 b(are)f(that)g(a)g(larger)g(n)
m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(initial)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)g(will)f(b)s(e)f
(discarded)g(\(or)h(dela)m(y)m(ed)h(in)e(a)h(queue\))0
4103 y(and)42 b(that)h(high)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(loss)f(rates)h(could)e
(prev)m(en)m(t)i(v)-5 b(alidation.)78 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)49
b(b)s(ecause)42 b(the)h(R)-8 b(TCP)42 b(header)0 4215
y(v)-5 b(alidation)28 b(is)f(relativ)m(ely)j(strong,)e(if)f(an)g(R)-8
b(TCP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(is)e(receiv)m(ed)h(from)f(a)g(source)g(b)s
(efore)g(the)g(data)h(pac)m(k)m(ets,)0 4328 y(the)k(coun)m(t)h(could)f
(b)s(e)f(adjusted)g(so)i(that)f(only)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(are)
f(required)e(in)g(sequence.)46 b(If)32 b(initial)h(data)g(loss)0
4441 y(for)h(a)g(few)g(seconds)g(can)g(b)s(e)f(tolerated,)k(an)d
(application)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)35 b Fq(c)m(ho)s(ose)g(to)g(discard)f(all)h
(data)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(from)e(a)0 4554 y(source)d(un)m(til)f(a)h(v)-5
b(alid)31 b(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(has)d(b)s(een)g(receiv)m(ed)
h(from)f(that)h(source.)141 4667 y(Dep)s(ending)23 b(on)g(the)g
(application)h(and)f(enco)s(ding,)h(algorithms)g(ma)m(y)g(exploit)g
(additional)g(kno)m(wledge)g(ab)s(out)0 4780 y(the)j(pa)m(yload)h
(format)g(for)f(further)e(v)-5 b(alidation.)41 b(F)-8
b(or)28 b(pa)m(yload)g(t)m(yp)s(es)f(where)g(the)g(timestamp)h
(incremen)m(t)g(is)f(the)0 4893 y(same)g(for)f(all)h(pac)m(k)m(ets,)j
(the)c(timestamp)h(v)-5 b(alues)27 b(can)g(b)s(e)e(predicted)i(from)f
(the)g(previous)g(pac)m(k)m(et)j(receiv)m(ed)e(from)0
5006 y(the)k(same)f(source)h(using)f(the)g(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e
(di\013erence)i(\(assuming)f(no)h(c)m(hange)g(in)f(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)
s(e\).)141 5119 y(A)37 b(strong)g(\\fast-path")h(c)m(hec)m(k)h(is)e(p)s
(ossible)f(since)h(with)g(high)f(probabilit)m(y)i(the)f(\014rst)f(four)
g(o)s(ctets)i(in)f(the)0 5232 y(header)d(of)g(a)g(newly)g(receiv)m(ed)h
(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(data)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(will)f(b)s(e)e(just)g(the)h(same)
h(as)f(that)g(of)g(the)h(previous)e(pac)m(k)m(et)0 5345
y(from)38 b(the)h(same)f(SSR)m(C)g(except)h(that)g(the)g(sequence)g(n)m
(um)m(b)s(er)e(will)h(ha)m(v)m(e)i(increased)f(b)m(y)f(one.)65
b(Similarly)-8 b(,)42 b(a)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(64])p eop
%%Page: 65 65
65 64 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(single-en)m(try)41 b(cac)m(he)h(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)e(used)h(for)g(faster)
g(SSR)m(C)g(lo)s(okups)f(in)h(applications)h(where)f(data)h(is)f(t)m
(ypically)0 511 y(receiv)m(ed)32 b(from)e(one)g(source)h(at)g(a)g
(time.)0 750 y Fo(A.2)112 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(Header)i(V)-9
b(alidit)m(y)37 b(Chec)m(ks)0 922 y Fq(The)30 b(follo)m(wing)i(c)m(hec)
m(ks)g Fi(should)58 b Fq(b)s(e)30 b(applied)g(to)h(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets.)136 1086 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(v)m(ersion)h(\014eld)f(m)m(ust)h(equal)f(2.)136
1265 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(pa)m(yload)i(t)m(yp)s(e)f(\014eld)f(of)
h(the)f(\014rst)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(in)d(a)h(comp)s(ound)e
(pac)m(k)m(et)k(m)m(ust)d(b)s(e)g(equal)h(to)h(SR)227
1378 y(or)f(RR.)136 1556 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)28 b(padding)f(bit)h
(\(P\))h(should)e(b)s(e)h(zero)h(for)f(the)g(\014rst)f(pac)m(k)m(et)k
(of)d(a)g(comp)s(ound)f(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(b)s(ecause)227
1669 y(padding)g(should)f(only)i(b)s(e)e(applied,)i(if)f(it)h(is)f
(needed,)h(to)g(the)f(last)i(pac)m(k)m(et.)136 1847 y
Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)c(length)g(\014elds)g(of)g(the)h(individual)e(R)-8
b(TCP)42 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(m)m(ust)e(total)h(to)g(the)g(o)m(v)m(erall)h
(length)e(of)h(the)227 1960 y(comp)s(ound)29 b(R)-8 b(TCP)30
b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(as)f(receiv)m(ed.)42 b(This)30 b(is)g(a)h(fairly)f
(strong)h(c)m(hec)m(k.)141 2124 y(The)41 b(co)s(de)h(fragmen)m(t)g(b)s
(elo)m(w)g(p)s(erforms)e(all)i(of)g(these)g(c)m(hec)m(ks.)76
b(The)41 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s(e)d(is)h(not)g(c)m(hec)m(k)m(ed)h
(for)0 2237 y(subsequen)m(t)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(since)f(unkno)m(wn)d
(pac)m(k)m(et)33 b(t)m(yp)s(es)d(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(presen)m(t)g(and)g
(should)g(b)s(e)f(ignored.)191 2422 y Fh(u_int32)46 b(len;)380
b(/*)48 b(length)e(of)h(compound)e(RTCP)i(packet)f(in)h(words)g(*/)191
2535 y(rtcp_t)f(*r;)476 b(/*)48 b(RTCP)e(header)g(*/)191
2647 y(rtcp_t)g(*end;)380 b(/*)48 b(end)f(of)g(compound)e(RTCP)i
(packet)f(*/)191 2873 y(if)h(\(\(*\(u_int16)e(*\)r)i(&)g
(RTCP_VALID_MASK\))d(!=)j(RTCP_VALID_VALUE\))c({)382
2986 y(/*)k(something)e(wrong)i(with)f(packet)g(format)g(*/)191
3099 y(})191 3212 y(end)h(=)g(\(rtcp_t)f(*\)\(\(u_int32)f(*\)r)i(+)g
(len\);)191 3438 y(do)g(r)h(=)f(\(rtcp_t)f(*\)\(\(u_int32)f(*\)r)h(+)i
(r->common.length)43 b(+)48 b(1\);)191 3551 y(while)e(\(r)h(<)h(end)f
(&&)g(r->common.version)c(==)k(2\);)191 3777 y(if)g(\(r)g(!=)g(end\))g
({)382 3889 y(/*)g(something)e(wrong)i(with)f(packet)g(format)g(*/)191
4002 y(})0 4332 y Fo(A.3)112 b(Determining)38 b(Num)m(b)s(er)g(of)g(P)m
(ac)m(k)m(ets)e(Exp)s(ected)i(and)g(Lost)0 4504 y Fq(In)30
b(order)h(to)h(compute)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(loss)e(rates,)i(the)e(n)m(um)m
(b)s(er)f(of)h(R)-8 b(TP)31 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)j(exp)s(ected)d(and)g
(actually)i(receiv)m(ed)0 4617 y(from)28 b(eac)m(h)i(source)e(needs)g
(to)h(b)s(e)f(kno)m(wn,)h(using)f(p)s(er-source)g(state)h(information)g
(de\014ned)e(in)i Fh(struct)46 b(source)0 4730 y Fq(referenced)31
b(via)g(p)s(oin)m(ter)g Fh(s)g Fq(in)f(the)h(co)s(de)g(b)s(elo)m(w.)42
b(The)31 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(receiv)m(ed)f(is)f
(simply)f(the)h(coun)m(t)h(of)0 4843 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)37
b(as)f(they)g(arriv)m(e,)i(including)d(an)m(y)h(late)h(or)e(duplicate)h
(pac)m(k)m(ets.)58 b(The)35 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(exp)s(ected)0 4956 y(can)c(b)s(e)g(computed)g(b)m(y)g(the)g(receiv)m
(er)h(as)g(the)f(di\013erence)g(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)h(the)f(highest)g
(sequence)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(receiv)m(ed)0 5068 y(\()p
Fh(s->max_seq)p Fq(\))c(and)i(the)g(\014rst)g(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)f(receiv)m(ed)j(\()p Fh(s->base_seq)p Fq(\).)41 b(Since)31
b(the)h(sequence)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)0 5181 y(is)j(only)f(16)i(bits)e
(and)g(will)h(wrap)f(around,)g(it)h(is)g(necessary)g(to)g(extend)g(the)
f(highest)h(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(with)0 5294
y(the)c(\(shifted\))g(coun)m(t)h(of)f(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f
(wraparounds)f(\()p Fh(s->cycles)p Fq(\).)38 b(Both)28
b(the)g(receiv)m(ed)h(pac)m(k)m(et)h(coun)m(t)0 5407
y(and)g(the)g(coun)m(t)h(of)g(cycles)g(are)g(main)m(tained)g(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)30 b(header)g(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)32 b(c)m(hec)m(k)g(routine)e(in)h
(App)s(endix)d(A.1.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(65])p eop
%%Page: 66 66
66 65 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)191 399
y Fh(extended_max)44 b(=)k(s->cycles)d(+)j(s->max_seq;)191
511 y(expected)d(=)j(extended_max)c(-)k(s->base_seq)d(+)i(1;)0
724 y Fq(The)37 b(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)g(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(lost)g(is)f
(de\014ned)e(to)j(b)s(e)e(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)i
(exp)s(ected)e(less)g(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)0 837
y(pac)m(k)m(ets)32 b(actually)g(receiv)m(ed:)191 1049
y Fh(lost)47 b(=)g(expected)f(-)h(s->received;)0 1262
y Fq(Since)30 b(this)f(signed)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(is)i(carried)g(in)f
(24)i(bits,)f(it)g Fi(should)e Fq(b)s(e)h(clamp)s(ed)g(at)i
(0x7\013\013f)f(for)f(p)s(ositiv)m(e)i(loss)f(or)0 1375
y(0x800000)j(for)e(negativ)m(e)h(loss)f(rather)f(than)g(wrapping)g
(around.)141 1488 y(The)38 b(fraction)i(of)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(lost)e
(during)f(the)h(last)h(rep)s(orting)e(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)40
b(\(since)g(the)f(previous)f(SR)g(or)h(RR)0 1601 y(pac)m(k)m(et)e(w)m
(as)e(sen)m(t\))g(is)g(calculated)h(from)f(di\013erences)f(in)h(the)g
(exp)s(ected)g(and)f(receiv)m(ed)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(coun)m(ts)f(across)0
1714 y(the)c(in)m(terv)-5 b(al,)32 b(where)e Fh(expected_prior)d
Fq(and)j Fh(received_prior)d Fq(are)k(the)f(v)-5 b(alues)31
b(sa)m(v)m(ed)h(when)e(the)g(previous)0 1826 y(reception)h(rep)s(ort)f
(w)m(as)h(generated:)191 2039 y Fh(expected_interval)43
b(=)k(expected)f(-)h(s->expected_prior;)191 2152 y(s->expected_prior)c
(=)k(expected;)191 2265 y(received_interval)c(=)k(s->received)e(-)j
(s->received_prior;)191 2378 y(s->received_prior)43 b(=)k(s->received;)
191 2491 y(lost_interval)d(=)k(expected_interval)43 b(-)k
(received_interval;)191 2604 y(if)g(\(expected_interval)c(==)k(0)h(||)f
(lost_interval)d(<=)j(0\))g(fraction)f(=)h(0;)191 2716
y(else)g(fraction)e(=)j(\(lost_interval)43 b(<<)48 b(8\))f(/)g
(expected_interval;)0 2929 y Fq(The)30 b(resulting)g
Fh(fraction)e Fq(is)j(an)f(8-bit)h(\014xed)f(p)s(oin)m(t)g(n)m(um)m(b)s
(er)f(with)i(the)f(binary)g(p)s(oin)m(t)g(at)h(the)g(left)g(edge.)0
3172 y Fo(A.4)112 b(Generating)38 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(SDES)i(P)m(ac)m(k)m
(ets)0 3344 y Fq(This)24 b(function)h(builds)e(one)i(SDES)f(c)m(h)m
(unk)h(in)m(to)h(bu\013er)e Fh(b)g Fq(comp)s(osed)h(of)g
Fh(argc)e Fq(items)j(supplied)d(in)i(arra)m(ys)g Fh(type)p
Fq(,)0 3457 y Fh(value)k Fq(and)h Fh(length)p Fq(.)39
b(It)30 b(returns)f(a)i(p)s(oin)m(ter)f(to)i(next)e(a)m(v)-5
b(ailable)33 b(lo)s(cation)f(within)e Fh(b)p Fq(.)0 3670
y Fh(char)47 b(*rtp_write_sdes\(char)42 b(*b,)47 b(u_int32)f(src,)g
(int)h(argc,)1002 3782 y(rtcp_sdes_type_t)d(type[],)h(char)i(*value[],)
1002 3895 y(int)g(length[]\))0 4008 y({)191 4121 y(rtcp_sdes_t)e(*s)i
(=)g(\(rtcp_sdes_t)e(*\)b;)191 4234 y(rtcp_sdes_item_t)e(*rsp;)191
4347 y(int)k(i;)191 4460 y(int)g(len;)191 4573 y(int)g(pad;)191
4799 y(/*)g(SSRC)g(header)f(*/)191 4912 y(s->src)g(=)h(src;)191
5024 y(rsp)g(=)g(&s->item[0];)191 5250 y(/*)g(SDES)g(items)f(*/)191
5363 y(for)h(\(i)g(=)g(0;)h(i)f(<)h(argc;)e(i++\))h({)0
5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(66])p eop
%%Page: 67 67
67 66 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)382 399
y Fh(rsp->type)45 b(=)j(type[i];)382 511 y(len)f(=)g(length[i];)382
624 y(if)g(\(len)g(>)g(RTP_MAX_SDES\))d({)573 737 y(/*)j(invalid)f
(length,)g(may)g(want)h(to)g(take)g(other)f(action)g(*/)573
850 y(len)h(=)g(RTP_MAX_SDES;)382 963 y(})382 1076 y(rsp->length)e(=)i
(len;)382 1189 y(memcpy\(rsp->data,)c(value[i],)i(len\);)382
1302 y(rsp)i(=)g(\(rtcp_sdes_item_t)c(*\)&rsp->data[len];)191
1415 y(})191 1641 y(/*)k(terminate)e(with)i(end)g(marker)f(and)h(pad)g
(to)g(next)g(4-octet)e(boundary)h(*/)191 1753 y(len)h(=)g(\(\(char)f
(*\))i(rsp\))e(-)i(b;)191 1866 y(pad)f(=)g(4)h(-)f(\(len)g(&)g(0x3\);)
191 1979 y(b)g(=)h(\(char)e(*\))h(rsp;)191 2092 y(while)f(\(pad--\))g
(*b++)h(=)g(RTCP_SDES_END;)191 2318 y(return)f(b;)0 2431
y(})0 2765 y Fo(A.5)112 b(P)m(arsing)38 b(R)-9 b(TCP)36
b(SDES)h(P)m(ac)m(k)m(ets)0 2937 y Fq(This)g(function)h(parses)g(an)h
(SDES)e(pac)m(k)m(et,)43 b(calling)c(functions)f Fh(find_member\(\))d
Fq(to)k(\014nd)e(a)h(p)s(oin)m(ter)h(to)g(the)0 3050
y(information)33 b(for)f(a)i(session)e(mem)m(b)s(er)g(giv)m(en)i(the)f
(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(and)f Fh(member_sdes\(\))d
Fq(to)k(store)h(the)e(new)0 3163 y(SDES)i(information)h(for)g(that)g
(mem)m(b)s(er.)53 b(This)34 b(function)h(exp)s(ects)g(a)g(p)s(oin)m
(ter)g(to)g(the)g(header)g(of)g(the)f(R)-8 b(TCP)0 3276
y(pac)m(k)m(et.)0 3488 y Fh(void)47 b(rtp_read_sdes\(rtcp_t)42
b(*r\))0 3601 y({)191 3714 y(int)47 b(count)f(=)i(r->common.count;)191
3826 y(rtcp_sdes_t)d(*sd)i(=)g(&r->r.sdes;)191 3939 y(rtcp_sdes_item_t)
c(*rsp,)k(*rspn;)191 4052 y(rtcp_sdes_item_t)c(*end)k(=)g
(\(rtcp_sdes_item_t)c(*\))1336 4165 y(\(\(u_int32)j(*\)r)h(+)g
(r->common.length)c(+)48 b(1\);)191 4278 y(source)e(*s;)191
4504 y(while)g(\(--count)g(>=)h(0\))g({)382 4617 y(rsp)g(=)g
(&sd->item[0];)382 4730 y(if)g(\(rsp)g(>=)g(end\))f(break;)382
4843 y(s)h(=)h(find_member\(sd->src\);)382 5068 y(for)f(\(;)g
(rsp->type;)e(rsp)i(=)g(rspn)g(\))g({)573 5181 y(rspn)f(=)i
(\(rtcp_sdes_item_t)43 b(*\)\(\(char*\)rsp+rsp->lengt)o(h+2\))o(;)573
5294 y(if)k(\(rspn)f(>=)h(end\))g({)764 5407 y(rsp)g(=)g(rspn;)0
5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(67])p eop
%%Page: 68 68
68 67 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)764 399
y Fh(break;)573 511 y(})573 624 y(member_sdes\(s,)44
b(rsp->type,)h(rsp->data,)g(rsp->length\);)382 737 y(})382
850 y(sd)i(=)g(\(rtcp_sdes_t)e(*\))620 963 y(\(\(u_int32)h(*\)sd)g(+)i
(\(\(\(char)e(*\)rsp)g(-)h(\(char)g(*\)sd\))f(>>)h(2\)+1\);)191
1076 y(})191 1189 y(if)g(\(count)f(>=)h(0\))h({)382 1302
y(/*)f(invalid)f(packet)g(format)g(*/)191 1415 y(})0
1528 y(})0 1862 y Fo(A.6)112 b(Generating)38 b(a)g(Random)g(32-bit)g
(Iden)m(ti\014er)0 2034 y Fq(The)e(follo)m(wing)i(subroutine)e
(generates)h(a)g(random)f(32-bit)i(iden)m(ti\014er)f(using)f(the)h(MD5)
g(routines)g(published)0 2146 y(in)i(RF)m(C)g(1321)h([32)r(].)66
b(The)39 b(system)g(routines)f(ma)m(y)i(not)f(b)s(e)f(presen)m(t)h(on)g
(all)h(op)s(erating)f(systems,)j(but)c(they)0 2259 y(should)33
b(serv)m(e)h(as)g(hin)m(ts)g(as)g(to)h(what)f(kinds)e(of)i(information)
h(ma)m(y)f(b)s(e)f(used.)51 b(Other)33 b(system)h(calls)h(that)f(ma)m
(y)0 2372 y(b)s(e)c(appropriate)g(include)136 2560 y
Fj(\017)46 b Fh(getdomainname\(\))p Fq(,)136 2748 y Fj(\017)g
Fh(getwd\(\))p Fq(,)29 b(or)136 2935 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(getrusage\(\))p
Fq(.)0 3123 y(\\Liv)m(e")33 b(video)e(or)g(audio)g(samples)g(are)g
(also)h(a)f(go)s(o)s(d)f(source)h(of)g(random)f(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers,)g
(but)g(care)i(m)m(ust)f(b)s(e)f(tak)m(en)0 3236 y(to)h(a)m(v)m(oid)h
(using)e(a)h(turned-o\013)f(microphone)g(or)g(blinded)f(camera)j(as)e
(a)h(source)g([17)q(].)141 3349 y(Use)38 b(of)g(this)f(or)g(similar)h
(routine)g(is)f Fi(recommended)73 b Fq(to)38 b(generate)h(the)e
(initial)i(seed)f(for)f(the)h(random)0 3462 y(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)27
b(generator)j(pro)s(ducing)d(the)i(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(p)s(erio)s(d)g(\(as)
h(sho)m(wn)f(in)g(App)s(endix)f(A.7\),)j(to)g(generate)g(the)f(initial)
0 3574 y(v)-5 b(alues)34 b(for)g(the)g(sequence)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f
(and)g(timestamp,)j(and)d(to)h(generate)i(SSR)m(C)d(v)-5
b(alues.)51 b(Since)34 b(this)g(routine)0 3687 y(is)39
b(lik)m(ely)i(to)e(b)s(e)g(CPU-in)m(tensiv)m(e,)k(its)c(direct)h(use)f
(to)g(generate)i(R)-8 b(TCP)38 b(p)s(erio)s(ds)g(is)h(inappropriate)g
(b)s(ecause)0 3800 y(predictabilit)m(y)25 b(is)f(not)f(an)h(issue.)38
b(Note)25 b(that)f(this)f(routine)h(pro)s(duces)e(the)i(same)g(result)f
(on)g(rep)s(eated)h(calls)h(un)m(til)0 3913 y(the)31
b(v)-5 b(alue)30 b(of)h(the)g(system)f(clo)s(c)m(k)i(c)m(hanges)f
(unless)f(di\013eren)m(t)h(v)-5 b(alues)30 b(are)h(supplied)e(for)h
(the)h Fh(type)e Fq(argumen)m(t.)0 4126 y Fh(/*)48 4239
y(*)47 b(Generate)f(a)h(random)f(32-bit)g(quantity.)48
4352 y(*/)0 4464 y(#include)g(<sys/types.h>)139 b(/*)47
b(u_long)f(*/)0 4577 y(#include)g(<sys/time.h>)187 b(/*)47
b(gettimeofday\(\))d(*/)0 4690 y(#include)i(<unistd.h>)283
b(/*)47 b(get..\(\))f(*/)0 4803 y(#include)g(<stdio.h>)331
b(/*)47 b(printf\(\))f(*/)0 4916 y(#include)g(<time.h>)379
b(/*)47 b(clock\(\))f(*/)0 5029 y(#include)g(<sys/utsname.h>)d(/*)k
(uname\(\))f(*/)0 5142 y(#include)g("global.h")283 b(/*)47
b(from)g(RFC)g(1321)g(*/)0 5255 y(#include)f("md5.h")427
b(/*)47 b(from)g(RFC)g(1321)g(*/)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(68])p eop
%%Page: 69 69
69 68 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fh(#define)46 b(MD_CTX)g(MD5_CTX)0 511 y(#define)g(MDInit)g(MD5Init)0
624 y(#define)g(MDUpdate)f(MD5Update)0 737 y(#define)h(MDFinal)g
(MD5Final)0 963 y(static)g(u_long)g(md_32\(char)f(*string,)h(int)h
(length\))0 1076 y({)191 1189 y(MD_CTX)f(context;)191
1302 y(union)g({)382 1415 y(char)142 b(c[16];)382 1528
y(u_long)46 b(x[4];)191 1641 y(})h(digest;)191 1753 y(u_long)f(r;)191
1866 y(int)h(i;)191 2092 y(MDInit)f(\(&context\);)191
2205 y(MDUpdate)f(\(&context,)g(string,)h(length\);)191
2318 y(MDFinal)g(\(\(unsigned)f(char)h(*\)&digest,)f(&context\);)191
2431 y(r)i(=)h(0;)191 2544 y(for)f(\(i)g(=)g(0;)h(i)f(<)h(3;)f(i++\))f
({)382 2657 y(r)h(^=)g(digest.x[i];)191 2770 y(})191
2883 y(return)f(r;)0 2995 y(})1479 b(/*)47 b(md_32)g(*/)0
3334 y(/*)48 3447 y(*)g(Return)f(random)g(unsigned)g(32-bit)g
(quantity.)93 b(Use)47 b('type')f(argument)g(if)48 3560
y(*)h(you)g(need)g(to)g(generate)e(several)h(different)g(values)g(in)h
(close)f(succession.)48 3673 y(*/)0 3786 y(u_int32)g(random32\(int)e
(type\))0 3899 y({)191 4012 y(struct)i({)382 4125 y(int)238
b(type;)382 4237 y(struct)94 b(timeval)45 b(tv;)382 4350
y(clock_t)h(cpu;)382 4463 y(pid_t)142 b(pid;)382 4576
y(u_long)94 b(hid;)382 4689 y(uid_t)142 b(uid;)382 4802
y(gid_t)g(gid;)382 4915 y(struct)94 b(utsname)45 b(name;)191
5028 y(})i(s;)191 5254 y(gettimeofday\(&s.tv,)42 b(0\);)191
5367 y(uname\(&s.name\);)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(69])p eop
%%Page: 70 70
70 69 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)191 399
y Fh(s.type)46 b(=)h(type;)191 511 y(s.cpu)94 b(=)47
b(clock\(\);)191 624 y(s.pid)94 b(=)47 b(getpid\(\);)191
737 y(s.hid)94 b(=)47 b(gethostid\(\);)191 850 y(s.uid)94
b(=)47 b(getuid\(\);)191 963 y(s.gid)94 b(=)47 b(getgid\(\);)191
1076 y(/*)g(also:)f(system)h(uptime)f(*/)191 1302 y(return)g
(md_32\(\(char)f(*\)&s,)h(sizeof\(s\)\);)0 1415 y(})1479
b(/*)47 b(random32)f(*/)0 1748 y Fo(A.7)112 b(Computing)38
b(the)g(R)-9 b(TCP)36 b(T)-9 b(ransmission)39 b(In)m(terv)-6
b(al)0 1919 y Fq(The)35 b(follo)m(wing)j(functions)d(implemen)m(t)h
(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)36 b(transmission)f(and)g(reception)i(rules)e
(describ)s(ed)g(in)g(Sec-)0 2032 y(tion)c(6.2.)42 b(These)30
b(rules)g(are)h(co)s(ded)f(in)g(sev)m(eral)h(functions:)136
2235 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(rtcp)p 425 2235 29 4 v 34 w(interval\(\))29
b Fq(computes)j(the)g(deterministic)h(calculated)g(in)m(terv)-5
b(al,)34 b(measured)e(in)f(seconds.)45 b(The)227 2348
y(parameters)31 b(are)g(de\014ned)e(in)h(Section)h(6.3.)136
2533 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(OnExpire\(\))28 b Fq(is)i(called)i(when)d(the)i
(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(transmission)g(timer)g(expires.)136
2717 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(OnReceive\(\))28 b Fq(is)i(called)i(whenev)m(er)
e(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(is)f(receiv)m(ed.)141
2920 y(Both)g Fh(OnExpire\(\))c Fq(and)j Fh(OnReceive\(\))d
Fq(ha)m(v)m(e)k Fh(event)47 b(e)29 b Fq(as)i(an)f(argumen)m(t.)41
b(This)29 b(is)i(the)f(next)g(sc)m(heduled)0 3033 y(ev)m(en)m(t)25
b(for)f(that)g(participan)m(t,)j(either)d(an)g(R)-8 b(TCP)23
b(rep)s(ort)g(or)h(a)g(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(et.)40 b(It)24
b(is)g(assumed)f(that)h(the)g(follo)m(wing)0 3146 y(functions)30
b(are)h(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable:)136 3326 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(Schedule\(time)e
(t,)k(event)e(e\))31 b Fq(sc)m(hedules)g(an)g(ev)m(en)m(t)i(e)e(to)h(o)
s(ccur)f(at)h(time)g(t.)44 b(When)31 b(time)h(t)f(arriv)m(es,)227
3438 y(the)g(function)f(OnExpire)f(is)h(called)i(with)e(e)h(as)f(an)h
(argumen)m(t.)136 3623 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(Reschedule\(time)e(t,)j(event)
f(e\))30 b Fq(resc)m(hedules)h(a)f(previously)h(sc)m(heduled)f(ev)m(en)
m(t)i(e)e(for)g(time)h(t.)136 3807 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh
(SendRTCPReport\(event)d(e\))29 b Fq(sends)h(an)g(R)-8
b(TCP)30 b(rep)s(ort.)136 3992 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(SendBYEPacket\(event)d
(e\))30 b Fq(sends)f(a)i(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m(et.)136 4176
y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(TypeOfEvent\(event)d(e\))h Fq(returns)g(EVENT)p
1886 4176 28 4 v 32 w(BYE)h(if)g(the)g(ev)m(en)m(t)h(b)s(eing)e(pro)s
(cessed)g(is)h(for)g(a)g(BYE)227 4289 y(pac)m(k)m(et)33
b(to)e(b)s(e)e(sen)m(t,)j(else)f(it)g(returns)e(EVENT)p
1871 4289 V 32 w(REPOR)-8 b(T.)136 4474 y Fj(\017)46
b Fh(PacketType\(p\))19 b Fq(returns)i(P)-8 b(A)m(CKET)p
1565 4474 V 33 w(R)g(TCP)p 1851 4474 V 32 w(REPOR)g(T)22
b(if)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(p)e(is)g(an)h(R)-8 b(TCP)21 b(rep)s(ort)h(\(not)h
(BYE\),)227 4587 y(P)-8 b(A)m(CKET)p 616 4587 V 33 w(BYE)40
b(if)f(its)h(a)g(BYE)f(R)-8 b(TCP)39 b(pac)m(k)m(et,)44
b(and)39 b(P)-8 b(A)m(CKET)p 2613 4587 V 32 w(R)g(TP)40
b(if)f(its)h(a)f(regular)h(R)-8 b(TP)39 b(data)227 4700
y(pac)m(k)m(et.)136 4884 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(ReceivedPacketSize\(\))31
b Fq(and)k Fh(SentPacketSize\(\))d Fq(return)j(the)h(size)h(of)f(the)g
(referenced)g(pac)m(k)m(et)i(in)227 4997 y(o)s(ctets.)136
5181 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(NewMember\(p\))23 b Fq(returns)h(a)i(1)g(if)g
(the)g(participan)m(t)h(who)e(sen)m(t)h(pac)m(k)m(et)i(p)d(is)h(not)g
(curren)m(tly)f(in)h(the)g(mem)m(b)s(er)227 5294 y(list,)35
b(0)e(otherwise.)48 b(Note)35 b(this)d(function)h(is)g(not)g
(su\016cien)m(t)g(for)g(a)g(complete)h(implemen)m(tation)h(b)s(ecause)
227 5407 y(eac)m(h)27 b(CSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)h(in)f(an)h(R)-8
b(TP)26 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(and)e(eac)m(h)i(SSR)m(C)e(in)g(a)i(BYE)f(pac)m
(k)m(et)h(should)e(b)s(e)g(pro)s(cessed.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(70])p eop
%%Page: 71 71
71 70 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)136 399
y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(NewSender\(p\))27 b Fq(returns)h(a)i(1)h(if)e(the)h
(participan)m(t)h(who)e(sen)m(t)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(p)f(is)f(not)h(curren)
m(tly)g(in)g(the)g(sender)227 511 y(sublist)g(of)h(the)f(mem)m(b)s(er)g
(list,)h(0)g(otherwise.)136 699 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(AddMember\(\))28
b Fq(and)h Fh(RemoveMember\(\))e Fq(to)k(add)f(and)f(remo)m(v)m(e)j
(participan)m(ts)g(from)e(the)g(mem)m(b)s(er)g(list.)136
887 y Fj(\017)46 b Fh(AddSender\(\))32 b Fq(and)i Fh(RemoveSender\(\))d
Fq(to)36 b(add)e(and)h(remo)m(v)m(e)h(participan)m(ts)g(from)e(the)h
(sender)f(sublist)227 1000 y(of)d(the)f(mem)m(b)s(er)g(list.)0
1212 y Fh(double)46 b(rtcp_interval\(int)d(members,)1002
1325 y(int)k(senders,)1002 1438 y(double)f(rtcp_bw,)1002
1551 y(int)h(we_sent,)1002 1664 y(double)f(avg_rtcp_size,)1002
1777 y(int)h(initial\))0 1890 y({)191 2002 y(/*)239 2115
y(*)g(Minimum)f(average)g(time)g(between)g(RTCP)h(packets)f(from)g
(this)h(site)g(\(in)239 2228 y(*)g(seconds\).)93 b(This)47
b(time)f(prevents)g(the)h(reports)f(from)g(`clumping')f(when)239
2341 y(*)i(sessions)f(are)h(small)f(and)h(the)g(law)g(of)g(large)f
(numbers)g(isn't)g(helping)239 2454 y(*)h(to)g(smooth)f(out)h(the)g
(traffic.)93 b(It)48 b(also)e(keeps)h(the)g(report)f(interval)239
2567 y(*)h(from)g(becoming)e(ridiculously)g(small)h(during)g(transient)
f(outages)h(like)239 2680 y(*)h(a)h(network)d(partition.)239
2793 y(*/)191 2906 y(double)h(const)g(RTCP_MIN_TIME)f(=)i(5.;)191
3019 y(/*)239 3132 y(*)g(Fraction)f(of)h(the)g(RTCP)f(bandwidth)g(to)h
(be)g(shared)f(among)g(active)239 3245 y(*)h(senders.)93
b(\(This)47 b(fraction)e(was)i(chosen)f(so)h(that)g(in)g(a)h(typical)
239 3357 y(*)f(session)f(with)h(one)f(or)i(two)f(active)f(senders,)f
(the)i(computed)f(report)239 3470 y(*)h(time)g(would)f(be)h(roughly)f
(equal)g(to)i(the)f(minimum)e(report)h(time)h(so)g(that)239
3583 y(*)g(we)g(don't)g(unnecessarily)d(slow)i(down)h(receiver)f
(reports.\))93 b(The)239 3696 y(*)47 b(receiver)f(fraction)f(must)i(be)
g(1)g(-)h(the)f(sender)f(fraction.)239 3809 y(*/)191
3922 y(double)g(const)g(RTCP_SENDER_BW_FRACTION)c(=)47
b(0.25;)191 4035 y(double)f(const)g(RTCP_RCVR_BW_FRACTION)c(=)48
b(\(1-RTCP_SENDER_BW_FRACTI)o(ON\))o(;)191 4148 y(/*)191
4261 y(/*)f(To)g(compensate)e(for)i("timer)f(reconsideration")e
(converging)h(to)i(a)239 4374 y(*)g(value)f(below)h(the)g(intended)e
(average.)239 4487 y(*/)191 4599 y(double)h(const)g(COMPENSATION)f(=)i
(2.71828)f(-)i(1.5;)191 4825 y(double)e(t;)906 b(/*)47
b(interval)f(*/)191 4938 y(double)g(rtcp_min_time)e(=)k(RTCP_MIN_TIME;)
191 5051 y(int)f(n;)1049 b(/*)47 b(no.)g(of)h(members)d(for)i
(computation)e(*/)191 5277 y(/*)239 5390 y(*)i(Very)g(first)f(call)h
(at)g(application)e(start-up)g(uses)i(half)f(the)h(min)0
5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(71])p eop
%%Page: 72 72
72 71 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)239 399
y Fh(*)47 b(delay)f(for)h(quicker)f(notification)f(while)h(still)g
(allowing)g(some)h(time)239 511 y(*)g(before)f(reporting)f(for)i
(randomization)e(and)h(to)i(learn)e(about)g(other)239
624 y(*)h(sources)f(so)h(the)g(report)f(interval)g(will)g(converge)g
(to)h(the)g(correct)239 737 y(*)g(interval)f(more)g(quickly.)239
850 y(*/)191 963 y(if)h(\(initial\))e({)382 1076 y(rtcp_min_time)f(/=)j
(2;)191 1189 y(})191 1415 y(/*)239 1528 y(*)g(If)g(there)g(were)f
(active)g(senders,)g(give)h(them)f(at)h(least)g(a)g(minimum)239
1641 y(*)g(share)f(of)i(the)f(RTCP)f(bandwidth.)93 b(Otherwise)45
b(all)i(participants)e(share)239 1753 y(*)i(the)g(RTCP)g(bandwidth)e
(equally.)239 1866 y(*/)191 1979 y(n)i(=)h(members;)191
2092 y(if)f(\(senders)f(>)h(0)h(&&)f(senders)f(<)h(members)f(*)h
(RTCP_SENDER_BW_FRACTION\))41 b({)382 2205 y(if)47 b(\(we_sent\))e({)
573 2318 y(rtcp_bw)h(*=)h(RTCP_SENDER_BW_FRACTION)o(;)573
2431 y(n)g(=)h(senders;)382 2544 y(})f(else)g({)573 2657
y(rtcp_bw)f(*=)h(RTCP_RCVR_BW_FRACTION;)573 2770 y(n)g(-=)g(senders;)
382 2883 y(})191 2995 y(})191 3221 y(/*)239 3334 y(*)g(The)g(effective)
e(number)h(of)i(sites)e(times)g(the)h(average)f(packet)g(size)h(is)239
3447 y(*)g(the)g(total)f(number)g(of)i(octets)e(sent)g(when)h(each)g
(site)f(sends)h(a)g(report.)239 3560 y(*)g(Dividing)f(this)g(by)h(the)g
(effective)f(bandwidth)f(gives)h(the)h(time)239 3673
y(*)g(interval)f(over)g(which)h(those)f(packets)g(must)g(be)i(sent)e
(in)h(order)g(to)239 3786 y(*)g(meet)g(the)g(bandwidth)e(target,)h
(with)g(a)i(minimum)e(enforced.)93 b(In)47 b(that)239
3899 y(*)g(time)g(interval)e(we)i(send)g(one)g(report)f(so)h(this)g
(time)g(is)g(also)f(our)239 4012 y(*)h(average)f(time)h(between)e
(reports.)239 4125 y(*/)191 4237 y(t)i(=)h(avg_rtcp_size)c(*)j(n)h(/)f
(rtcp_bw;)191 4350 y(if)g(\(t)g(<)h(rtcp_min_time\))c(t)j(=)h
(rtcp_min_time;)191 4576 y(/*)239 4689 y(*)f(To)g(avoid)g(traffic)e
(bursts)i(from)f(unintended)f(synchronization)f(with)239
4802 y(*)j(other)f(sites,)h(we)g(then)f(pick)h(our)g(actual)f(next)h
(report)f(interval)f(as)i(a)239 4915 y(*)g(random)f(number)g(uniformly)
g(distributed)e(between)i(0.5*t)g(and)h(1.5*t.)239 5028
y(*/)191 5141 y(t)g(=)h(t)f(*)h(\(drand48\(\))d(+)i(0.5\);)191
5254 y(t)g(=)h(t)f(/)h(COMPENSATION;)191 5367 y(return)e(t;)0
5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(72])p eop
%%Page: 73 73
73 72 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y Fh(})0 665 y(void)47 b(OnExpire\(event)d(e,)668 778
y(int)190 b(members,)668 891 y(int)g(senders,)668 1004
y(double)46 b(rtcp_bw,)668 1117 y(int)190 b(we_sent,)668
1230 y(double)46 b(*avg_rtcp_size,)668 1342 y(int)190
b(*initial,)668 1455 y(time_tp)141 b(tc,)668 1568 y(time_tp)g(*tp,)668
1681 y(int)190 b(*pmembers\))0 1794 y({)191 1907 y(/*)47
b(This)g(function)e(is)i(responsible)e(for)i(deciding)f(whether)f(to)j
(send)e(an)239 2020 y(*)h(RTCP)g(report)f(or)h(BYE)g(packet)f(now,)h
(or)g(to)g(reschedule)e(transmission.)239 2133 y(*)i(It)g(is)g(also)g
(responsible)e(for)i(updating)e(the)i(pmembers,)e(initial,)h(tp,)239
2246 y(*)h(and)g(avg_rtcp_size)d(state)j(variables.)92
b(This)47 b(function)e(should)i(be)239 2359 y(*)g(called)f(upon)h
(expiration)e(of)i(the)g(event)f(timer)h(used)f(by)h(Schedule\(\).)239
2472 y(*/)191 2697 y(double)f(t;)238 b(/*)47 b(Interval)f(*/)191
2810 y(double)g(tn;)190 b(/*)47 b(Next)g(transmit)e(time)i(*/)191
3036 y(/*)g(In)g(the)g(case)g(of)g(a)g(BYE,)g(we)g(use)g("timer)f
(reconsideration")e(to)239 3149 y(*)j(reschedule)e(the)i(transmission)d
(of)k(the)f(BYE)f(if)i(necessary)d(*/)191 3375 y(if)i
(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_BYE\))e({)382 3488 y(t)i(=)h
(rtcp_interval\(members,)1241 3601 y(senders,)1241 3714
y(rtcp_bw,)1241 3826 y(we_sent,)1241 3939 y(*avg_rtcp_size,)1241
4052 y(*initial\);)382 4165 y(tn)f(=)g(*tp)g(+)h(t;)382
4278 y(if)f(\(tn)g(<=)g(tc\))g({)573 4391 y(SendBYEPacket\(e\);)573
4504 y(exit\(1\);)382 4617 y(})g(else)g({)573 4730 y(Schedule\(tn,)d
(e\);)382 4843 y(})191 5068 y(})j(else)g(if)g(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j
(EVENT_REPORT\))d({)382 5181 y(t)j(=)h(rtcp_interval\(members,)1241
5294 y(senders,)1241 5407 y(rtcp_bw,)0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(73])p eop
%%Page: 74 74
74 73 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)1241
399 y Fh(we_sent,)1241 511 y(*avg_rtcp_size,)1241 624
y(*initial\);)382 737 y(tn)47 b(=)g(*tp)g(+)h(t;)382
963 y(if)f(\(tn)g(<=)g(tc\))g({)573 1076 y(SendRTCPReport\(e\);)573
1189 y(*avg_rtcp_size)d(=)j(\(1./16.\)*SentPacketSize\(e)o(\))42
b(+)764 1302 y(\(15./16.\)*\(*avg_rtcp_si)o(ze\);)573
1415 y(*tp)47 b(=)g(tc;)573 1641 y(/*)g(We)g(must)g(redraw)f(the)h
(interval.)93 b(Don't)46 b(reuse)g(the)716 1753 y(one)h(computed)e
(above,)h(since)h(its)g(not)g(actually)716 1866 y(distributed)e(the)i
(same,)f(as)h(we)g(are)g(conditioned)716 1979 y(on)g(it)g(being)g
(small)f(enough)g(to)h(cause)g(a)g(packet)f(to)716 2092
y(be)h(sent)g(*/)573 2318 y(t)g(=)h(rtcp_interval\(members,)1432
2431 y(senders,)1432 2544 y(rtcp_bw,)1432 2657 y(we_sent,)1432
2770 y(*avg_rtcp_size,)1432 2883 y(*initial\);)573 3108
y(Schedule\(t+tc,e\);)573 3221 y(*initial)d(=)j(0;)382
3334 y(})f(else)g({)573 3447 y(Schedule\(tn,)d(e\);)382
3560 y(})382 3673 y(*pmembers)h(=)j(members;)191 3786
y(})0 3899 y(})0 4165 y(void)f(OnReceive\(packet)c(p,)716
4278 y(event)j(e,)716 4391 y(int)h(*members,)716 4504
y(int)g(*pmembers,)716 4617 y(int)g(*senders,)716 4730
y(double)f(*avg_rtcp_size,)716 4843 y(double)g(*tp,)716
4956 y(double)g(tc,)716 5068 y(double)g(tn\))0 5181 y({)191
5294 y(/*)h(What)g(we)g(do)g(depends)f(on)h(whether)f(we)h(have)g(left)
f(the)h(group,)f(and)h(are)239 5407 y(*)g(waiting)f(to)h(send)g(a)g
(BYE)g(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_BYE\))e(or)i(an)g(RTCP)0
5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(74])p eop
%%Page: 75 75
75 74 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)239 399
y Fh(*)47 b(report.)94 b(p)47 b(represents)e(the)i(packet)f(that)h(was)
g(just)f(received.)93 b(*/)191 624 y(if)47 b(\(PacketType\(p\))d(==)j
(PACKET_RTCP_REPORT\))c({)382 737 y(if)k(\(NewMember\(p\))d(&&)j
(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_REPORT\)\))d({)573 850
y(AddMember\(p\);)573 963 y(*members)h(+=)i(1;)382 1076
y(})382 1189 y(*avg_rtcp_size)d(=)j(\(1./16.\)*ReceivedPacketSi)o
(ze\(p)o(\))42 b(+)573 1302 y(\(15./16.\)*\(*avg_rtcp_si)o(ze\);)191
1415 y(})47 b(else)g(if)g(\(PacketType\(p\))d(==)j(PACKET_RTP\))e({)382
1528 y(if)i(\(NewMember\(p\))d(&&)j(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j
(EVENT_REPORT\)\))d({)573 1641 y(AddMember\(p\);)573
1753 y(*members)h(+=)i(1;)382 1866 y(})382 1979 y(if)g
(\(NewSender\(p\))d(&&)j(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_REPORT\)\))d
({)573 2092 y(AddSender\(p\);)573 2205 y(*senders)h(+=)i(1;)382
2318 y(})191 2431 y(})g(else)g(if)g(\(PacketType\(p\))d(==)j
(PACKET_BYE\))e({)382 2544 y(*avg_rtcp_size)f(=)j
(\(1./16.\)*ReceivedPacketSi)o(ze\(p)o(\))42 b(+)573
2657 y(\(15./16.\)*\(*avg_rtcp_si)o(ze\);)382 2883 y(if)47
b(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_REPORT\))d({)573 2995
y(if)j(\(NewSender\(p\))d(==)j(FALSE\))f({)764 3108 y
(RemoveSender\(p\);)764 3221 y(*senders)f(-=)i(1;)573
3334 y(})573 3560 y(if)g(\(NewMember\(p\))d(==)j(FALSE\))f({)764
3673 y(RemoveMember\(p\);)764 3786 y(*members)f(-=)i(1;)573
3899 y(})573 4125 y(if)g(\(*members)e(<)j(*pmembers\))d({)764
4237 y(tn)i(=)g(tc)g(+)955 4350 y(\(\(\(double\))e
(*members\)/\(*pmembers\)\)*)o(\(tn)c(-)48 b(tc\);)764
4463 y(*tp)f(=)g(tc)g(-)955 4576 y(\(\(\(double\))e
(*members\)/\(*pmembers\)\)*)o(\(tc)c(-)48 b(*tp\);)764
4802 y(/*)f(Reschedule)e(the)i(next)f(report)g(for)h(time)g(tn)g(*/)764
5028 y(Reschedule\(tn,)d(e\);)764 5141 y(*pmembers)h(=)i(*members;)573
5254 y(})0 5656 y Fq(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m
(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(75])p eop
%%Page: 76 76
76 75 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)382 399
y Fh(})47 b(else)g(if)g(\(TypeOfEvent\(e\))d(==)j(EVENT_BYE\))e({)573
511 y(*members)g(+=)i(1;)382 624 y(})191 737 y(})0 850
y(})0 1180 y Fo(A.8)112 b(Estimating)38 b(the)f(In)m(terarriv)-6
b(al)37 b(Jitter)0 1352 y Fq(The)21 b(co)s(de)g(fragmen)m(ts)h(b)s(elo)
m(w)f(implemen)m(t)h(the)f(algorithm)h(giv)m(en)g(in)f(Section)h(6.4.1)
h(for)e(calculating)i(an)e(estimate)0 1464 y(of)30 b(the)g(statistical)
j(v)-5 b(ariance)31 b(of)f(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(data)g(in)m(terarriv)-5
b(al)31 b(time)g(to)g(b)s(e)e(inserted)h(in)g(the)g(in)m(terarriv)-5
b(al)31 b(jitter)0 1577 y(\014eld)37 b(of)h(reception)h(rep)s(orts.)62
b(The)38 b(inputs)f(are)h Fh(r->ts)p Fq(,)g(the)g(timestamp)h(from)e
(the)h(incoming)h(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(and)0 1690 y Fh(arrival)p
Fq(,)35 b(the)h(curren)m(t)g(time)g(in)g(the)f(same)i(units.)56
b(Here)36 b Fh(s)f Fq(p)s(oin)m(ts)h(to)g(state)i(for)d(the)h(source;)j
Fh(s->transit)0 1803 y Fq(holds)33 b(the)g(relativ)m(e)j(transit)e
(time)g(for)f(the)g(previous)g(pac)m(k)m(et,)j(and)d
Fh(s->jitter)e Fq(holds)i(the)g(estimated)i(jitter.)0
1916 y(The)24 b(jitter)h(\014eld)f(of)h(the)f(reception)h(rep)s(ort)f
(is)h(measured)e(in)i(timestamp)g(units)e(and)h(expressed)g(as)h(an)f
(unsigned)0 2029 y(in)m(teger,)37 b(but)c(the)h(jitter)h(estimate)h(is)
e(k)m(ept)h(in)f(a)h(\015oating)g(p)s(oin)m(t.)52 b(As)34
b(eac)m(h)h(data)g(pac)m(k)m(et)h(arriv)m(es,)g(the)e(jitter)0
2142 y(estimate)e(is)f(up)s(dated:)191 2354 y Fh(int)47
b(transit)f(=)h(arrival)f(-)h(r->ts;)191 2467 y(int)g(d)g(=)h(transit)e
(-)h(s->transit;)191 2580 y(s->transit)e(=)i(transit;)191
2693 y(if)g(\(d)g(<)h(0\))f(d)g(=)h(-d;)191 2806 y(s->jitter)d(+=)i
(\(1./16.\))f(*)h(\(\(double\)d)e(-)j(s->jitter\);)0
3019 y Fq(When)26 b(a)h(reception)h(rep)s(ort)e(blo)s(c)m(k)h(\(to)g
(whic)m(h)g Fh(rr)f Fq(p)s(oin)m(ts\))g(is)h(generated)g(for)g(this)f
(mem)m(b)s(er,)h(the)g(curren)m(t)f(jitter)0 3132 y(estimate)32
b(is)f(returned:)191 3344 y Fh(rr->jitter)45 b(=)i(\(u_int32\))f
(s->jitter;)0 3557 y Fq(Alternativ)m(ely)-8 b(,)40 b(the)c(jitter)g
(estimate)h(can)f(b)s(e)f(k)m(ept)h(as)g(an)g(in)m(teger,)i(but)d
(scaled)i(to)f(reduce)f(round-o\013)g(error.)0 3670 y(The)30
b(calculation)i(is)f(the)f(same)h(except)h(for)e(the)g(last)i(line:)191
3882 y Fh(s->jitter)45 b(+=)i(d)h(-)f(\(\(s->jitter)e(+)i(8\))h(>>)f
(4\);)0 4095 y Fq(In)30 b(this)g(case,)i(the)e(estimate)i(is)f(sampled)
f(for)g(the)g(reception)i(rep)s(ort)d(as:)191 4307 y
Fh(rr->jitter)45 b(=)i(s->jitter)f(>>)h(4;)0 4589 y Fp(B)134
b(Changes)46 b(from)f(RF)l(C)g(1889)0 4792 y Fq(Most)26
b(of)f(this)g(RF)m(C)g(is)g(iden)m(tical)i(to)f(RF)m(C)f(1889.)41
b(There)24 b(are)i(no)f(c)m(hanges)h(in)e(the)i(pac)m(k)m(et)h(formats)
e(on)g(the)g(wire,)0 4905 y(only)33 b(c)m(hanges)g(to)h(the)e(rules)g
(and)g(algorithms)i(go)m(v)m(erning)g(ho)m(w)f(the)f(proto)s(col)i(is)e
(used.)47 b(The)32 b(biggest)i(c)m(hange)0 5018 y(is)c(an)h(enhancemen)
m(t)g(to)g(the)f(scalable)i(timer)f(algorithm)g(for)f(calculating)j
(when)c(to)j(send)d(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(ets:)136
5181 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)23 b(algorithm)i(for)e(calculating)j(the)e
(R)-8 b(TCP)23 b(transmission)g(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)25
b(sp)s(eci\014ed)e(in)g(Sections)h(6.2)h(and)e(6.3)227
5294 y(and)i(illustrated)g(in)g(App)s(endix)e(A.7)j(is)f(augmen)m(ted)h
(to)f(include)g(\\reconsideration")i(to)e(minimize)h(trans-)227
5407 y(mission)31 b(in)f(excess)i(of)f(the)g(in)m(tended)g(rate)g(when)
f(man)m(y)h(participan)m(ts)h(join)e(a)i(session)e(sim)m(ultaneously)-8
b(,)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)g(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(76])p eop
%%Page: 77 77
77 76 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)227 399
y(and)e(\\rev)m(erse)i(reconsideration")g(to)f(reduce)f(the)h
(incidence)g(and)f(duration)g(of)h(false)g(participan)m(t)h(time-)227
511 y(outs)i(when)e(the)h(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(participan)m(ts)h
(drops)e(rapidly)-8 b(.)46 b(Rev)m(erse)33 b(reconsideration)h(is)e
(also)h(used)e(to)227 624 y(p)s(ossibly)c(shorten)h(the)g(dela)m(y)h(b)
s(efore)f(sending)f(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(SR)f(when)g(transitioning)i(from)f
(passiv)m(e)g(receiv)m(er)227 737 y(to)j(activ)m(e)i(sender)d(mo)s(de.)
136 925 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Section)38 b(6.3.7)h(sp)s(eci\014es)e(new)f
(rules)h(con)m(trolling)i(when)d(an)h(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(BYE)g(pac)m(k)m
(et)i(should)d(b)s(e)h(sen)m(t)g(in)227 1038 y(order)30
b(to)h(a)m(v)m(oid)h(a)f(\015o)s(o)s(d)e(of)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(when)d
(man)m(y)i(participan)m(ts)g(lea)m(v)m(e)i(a)e(session)f(sim)m
(ultaneously)-8 b(.)136 1225 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)37
b(requiremen)m(t)h(to)h(retain)f(state)h(for)e(inactiv)m(e)j
(participan)m(ts)e(for)f(a)h(p)s(erio)s(d)f(long)h(enough)f(to)i(span)
227 1338 y(t)m(ypical)34 b(net)m(w)m(ork)f(partitions)g(w)m(as)g(remo)m
(v)m(ed)g(from)f(Section)h(6.2.1.)49 b(In)32 b(a)g(session)h(where)f
(man)m(y)g(partic-)227 1451 y(ipan)m(ts)g(join)g(for)g(a)g(brief)f
(time)i(and)e(fail)h(to)h(send)e(BYE,)h(this)g(requiremen)m(t)g(w)m
(ould)f(cause)i(a)f(signi\014can)m(t)227 1564 y(o)m(v)m(erestimate)j
(of)d(the)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(participan)m(ts.)46
b(The)31 b(reconsideration)i(algorithm)f(added)g(in)f(this)h(re-)227
1677 y(vision)i(comp)s(ensates)g(for)g(the)g(large)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f
(of)h(new)f(participan)m(ts)i(joining)e(sim)m(ultaneously)i(when)e(a)
227 1790 y(partition)e(heals.)0 1978 y(It)f(should)f(b)s(e)h(noted)g
(that)h(these)f(enhancemen)m(ts)h(only)f(ha)m(v)m(e)h(a)g(signi\014can)
m(t)g(e\013ect)g(when)e(the)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)d(of)j(ses-)0
2090 y(sion)h(participan)m(ts)g(is)g(large)g(\(thousands\))f(and)g
(most)h(of)g(the)g(participan)m(ts)g(join)g(or)f(lea)m(v)m(e)j(at)e
(the)g(same)g(time.)0 2203 y(This)27 b(mak)m(es)i(testing)g(in)f(a)g
(liv)m(e)i(net)m(w)m(ork)f(di\016cult.)40 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)30
b(the)f(algorithm)g(w)m(as)f(sub)5 b(jected)28 b(to)h(a)f(thorough)0
2316 y(analysis)36 b(and)f(sim)m(ulation)i(to)f(v)m(erify)g(its)g(p)s
(erformance.)55 b(F)-8 b(urthermore,)37 b(the)f(enhanced)f(algorithm)i
(w)m(as)f(de-)0 2429 y(signed)30 b(to)g(in)m(terop)s(erate)h(with)e
(the)h(algorithm)g(in)g(RF)m(C)g(1889)h(suc)m(h)e(that)h(the)g(degree)h
(of)e(reduction)h(in)f(excess)0 2542 y(R)-8 b(TCP)29
b(bandwidth)f(during)g(a)i(step)f(join)h(is)f(prop)s(ortional)h(to)g
(the)g(fraction)g(of)g(participan)m(ts)g(that)g(implemen)m(t)0
2655 y(the)h(enhanced)f(algorithm.)43 b(In)m(terop)s(eration)32
b(of)f(the)g(t)m(w)m(o)h(algorithms)g(has)e(b)s(een)g(v)m(eri\014ed)h
(exp)s(erimen)m(tally)h(on)0 2768 y(liv)m(e)g(net)m(w)m(orks.)141
2881 y(Other)e(functional)h(c)m(hanges)g(w)m(ere:)136
3068 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Section)37 b(6.2.1)h(sp)s(eci\014es)d(that)i
(implemen)m(tations)g(ma)m(y)f(store)h(only)f(a)g(sampling)g(of)g(the)g
(participan)m(ts')227 3181 y(SSR)m(C)20 b(iden)m(ti\014ers)g(to)h(allo)
m(w)h(scaling)f(to)g(v)m(ery)g(large)g(sessions.)37 b(Algorithms)21
b(are)g(sp)s(eci\014ed)e(in)h(RF)m(C)h(2762)h([21)q(].)136
3369 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(In)28 b(Section)h(6.2)g(it)f(is)h(sp)s
(eci\014ed)e(that)i(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(sender)g(and)h(receiv)m(er)i
(bandwidths)c(to)j(b)s(e)e(set)i(as)f(separate)227 3482
y(parameters)j(of)g(the)g(session)g(rather)g(than)f(a)h(strict)h(p)s
(ercen)m(tage)g(of)f(the)g(session)g(bandwidth,)e(and)h(ma)m(y)227
3595 y(b)s(e)45 b(set)g(to)h(zero.)86 b(The)44 b(requiremen)m(t)h(that)
h(R)-8 b(TCP)45 b(w)m(as)g(mandatory)g(for)g(R)-8 b(TP)45
b(sessions)g(using)f(IP)227 3708 y(m)m(ulticast)30 b(w)m(as)f(relaxed.)
40 b(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)31 b(a)e(clari\014cation)h(w)m(as)e(also)i
(added)d(that)i(turning)e(o\013)i(R)-8 b(TCP)27 b(is)i
Fi(not)227 3821 y(recommended)p Fq(.)136 4008 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(Also)31 b(in)f(Section)g(6.2)h(it)g(is)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(that)h
(the)h(minim)m(um)e(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)31
b(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(scaled)i(to)f(smaller)227 4121 y(v)-5
b(alues)35 b(for)e(high)h(bandwidth)e(sessions,)j(and)e(that)i(the)f
(initial)h(R)-8 b(TCP)34 b(dela)m(y)g(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)e(set)i(to)f(zero)
h(for)227 4234 y(unicast)c(sessions.)136 4422 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(Timing)30 b(out)h(a)f(participan)m(t)h(is)f(to)h(b)s(e)f(based)f
(on)h(inactivit)m(y)j(for)c(a)i(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)e(of)h(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(rep)s(ort)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(als)227 4535 y(calculated)33
b(using)c(the)i(receiv)m(er)h(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(bandwidth)e(fraction)j
(ev)m(en)g(for)g(activ)m(e)h(senders.)136 4722 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(Sections)40 b(7.2)g(and)e(7.3)i(sp)s(ecify)f(that)g(translators)h
(and)e(mixers)h(should)f(send)g(BYE)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(for)e(the)227
4835 y(sources)31 b(they)f(are)h(no)f(longer)h(forw)m(arding.)136
5023 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(Rule)c(c)m(hanges)h(for)e(la)m(y)m(ered)i(enco)s
(dings)e(are)h(de\014ned)f(in)g(Sections)h(2.4,)k(6.3.9,)h(8.3)42
b(and)g(11.)75 b(In)41 b(the)227 5136 y(last)d(of)e(these,)j(it)e(is)g
(noted)f(that)h(the)g(address)f(and)g(p)s(ort)g(assignmen)m(t)h(rule)f
(con\015icts)h(with)f(the)h(SDP)227 5249 y(sp)s(eci\014cation,)25
b(RF)m(C)e(2327)g([15)r(],)h(but)d(it)i(is)f(in)m(tended)g(that)h(this)
f(restriction)h(will)f(b)s(e)g(relaxed)g(in)g(a)h(revision)227
5362 y(of)31 b(RF)m(C)g(2327.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(77])p eop
%%Page: 78 78
78 77 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)136 399
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)29 b(con)m(v)m(en)m(tion)i(for)e(using)g(ev)m
(en/o)s(dd)g(p)s(ort)f(pairs)h(for)g(R)-8 b(TP)29 b(and)f(R)-8
b(TCP)29 b(in)f(Section)i(11)g(w)m(as)g(clari\014ed)227
511 y(to)j(refer)g(to)g(destination)g(p)s(orts.)46 b(The)32
b(requiremen)m(t)h(to)g(use)f(an)g(ev)m(en/o)s(dd)h(p)s(ort)f(pair)g(w)
m(as)h(remo)m(v)m(ed)g(if)227 624 y(the)i(t)m(w)m(o)h(p)s(orts)e(are)i
(sp)s(eci\014ed)e(explicitly)-8 b(.)56 b(F)-8 b(or)35
b(unicast)h(R)-8 b(TP)34 b(sessions,)i(distinct)g(p)s(ort)e(pairs)g(ma)
m(y)i(b)s(e)227 737 y(used)30 b(for)g(the)h(t)m(w)m(o)g(ends)f
(\(Sections)h(3,)g(7.1)h(and)d(11\).)136 913 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(A)27 b(new)f(Section)h(10)g(w)m(as)g(added)f(to)h(explain)g(the)g
(requiremen)m(t)f(for)h(congestion)h(con)m(trol)g(in)e(applications)227
1026 y(using)k(R)-8 b(TP)g(.)136 1202 y Fj(\017)46 b
Fq(In)38 b(Section)h(8.2,)j(the)d(requiremen)m(t)f(that)h(a)g(new)f
(SSR)m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er)g Fi(must)g Fq(b)s(e)f(c)m(hosen)i(whenev)m
(er)g(the)227 1315 y(source)30 b(transp)s(ort)f(address)f(is)i(c)m
(hanged)g(has)g(b)s(een)e(relaxed)j(to)f(sa)m(y)g(that)g(a)g(new)f(SSR)
m(C)g(iden)m(ti\014er)h Fi(ma)-6 b(y)227 1427 y Fq(b)s(e)41
b(c)m(hosen.)75 b(Corresp)s(ondingly)-8 b(,)43 b(it)f(w)m(as)g
(clari\014ed)g(that)g(an)g(implemen)m(tation)h Fi(ma)-6
b(y)42 b Fq(c)m(ho)s(ose)h(to)f(k)m(eep)227 1540 y(pac)m(k)m(ets)33
b(from)e(the)h(new)f(source)g(address)g(rather)g(than)g(the)h(existing)
g(source)g(address)e(when)h(an)g(SSR)m(C)227 1653 y(collision)37
b(o)s(ccurs)e(b)s(et)m(w)m(een)h(t)m(w)m(o)g(other)g(participan)m(ts,)h
(and)e Fi(should)e Fq(do)i(so)h(for)f(applications)h(suc)m(h)f(as)227
1766 y(telephon)m(y)40 b(in)f(whic)m(h)f(some)i(sources)f(suc)m(h)f(as)
i(mobile)f(en)m(tities)i(ma)m(y)f(c)m(hange)g(addresses)e(during)g(the)
227 1879 y(course)31 b(of)f(an)h(R)-8 b(TP)30 b(session.)136
2055 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(An)33 b(inden)m(tation)i(bug)d(in)i(the)f(RF)m
(C)h(1889)h(prin)m(ting)e(of)h(the)f(pseudo-co)s(de)h(for)f(the)g
(collision)i(detection)227 2168 y(and)23 b(resolution)h(algorithm)g(in)
f(Section)h(8.2)h(has)e(b)s(een)f(corrected)j(b)m(y)e(translating)h
(the)g(syn)m(tax)g(to)g(pseudo)227 2281 y(C)35 b(language,)i(and)e(the)
g(algorithm)h(has)e(b)s(een)h(mo)s(di\014ed)e(to)j(remo)m(v)m(e)g(the)g
(restriction)f(that)h(b)s(oth)e(R)-8 b(TP)227 2394 y(and)30
b(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(m)m(ust)g(b)s(e)g(sen)m(t)h(from)f(the)g(same)h
(source)g(p)s(ort)e(n)m(um)m(b)s(er.)136 2569 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(The)29 b(description)h(of)f(the)h(padding)f(mec)m(hanism)g(for)h
(R)-8 b(TCP)28 b(pac)m(k)m(ets)k(w)m(as)e(clari\014ed)f(and)g(it)h(is)g
(sp)s(eci\014ed)227 2682 y(that)h(padding)g Fi(must)e
Fq(only)i(b)s(e)f(applied)g(to)h(the)f(last)i(pac)m(k)m(et)g(of)e(a)h
(comp)s(ound)e(R)-8 b(TCP)30 b(pac)m(k)m(et.)136 2858
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(In)29 b(Section)i(A.1,)g(initialization)i(of)c(base)p
1661 2858 28 4 v 33 w(seq)h(w)m(as)h(corrected)f(to)h(b)s(e)e(seq)h
(rather)g(than)f(seq)h(-)g(1,)h(and)e(the)227 2971 y(text)40
b(w)m(as)g(corrected)g(to)f(sa)m(y)h(the)f(bad)f(sequence)i(n)m(um)m(b)
s(er)d(plus)h(1)i(is)f(stored.)66 b(The)39 b(initialization)j(of)227
3084 y(max)p 401 3084 V 33 w(seq)27 b(and)e(other)h(v)-5
b(ariables)27 b(for)f(the)h(algorithm)g(w)m(as)f(separated)h(from)f
(the)g(text)h(to)g(mak)m(e)g(clear)g(that)227 3197 y(this)g
(initialization)j(m)m(ust)c(b)s(e)g(done)h(in)f(addition)h(to)h
(calling)g(the)f(init)p 2626 3197 V 33 w(seq\(\))h(function)e(\(and)h
(a)g(few)f(w)m(ords)227 3310 y(lost)31 b(in)g(RF)m(C)f(1889)i(when)e
(pro)s(cessing)g(the)g(do)s(cumen)m(t)h(from)f(source)g(to)h(output)f
(form)g(w)m(ere)h(restored\).)136 3485 y Fj(\017)46 b
Fq(Clamping)37 b(of)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(of)h(pac)m(k)m(ets)i(lost)e(in)
g(Section)h(A.3)g(w)m(as)f(corrected)h(to)g(use)e(b)s(oth)h(p)s(ositiv)
m(e)h(and)227 3598 y(negativ)m(e)33 b(limits.)136 3774
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)37 b(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(of)f(\\relativ)m(e")j
(NTP)d(timestamp)g(in)g(the)g(R)-8 b(TCP)37 b(SR)f(section)i(no)m(w)f
(de\014nes)f(these)227 3887 y(timestamps)e(to)g(b)s(e)e(based)h(on)g
(the)g(most)h(common)f(system-sp)s(eci\014c)g(clo)s(c)m(k,)j(suc)m(h)c
(as)i(system)f(uptime,)227 4000 y(rather)j(than)f(on)g(session)h
(elapsed)f(time)h(whic)m(h)f(w)m(ould)h(not)f(b)s(e)g(the)h(same)f(for)
h(m)m(ultiple)g(applications)227 4113 y(started)31 b(on)f(the)h(same)g
(mac)m(hine)g(at)g(di\013eren)m(t)g(times.)141 4270 y(Non-functional)g
(c)m(hanges:)136 4428 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(It)28 b(is)f(sp)s(eci\014ed)f
(that)i(a)g(receiv)m(er)g Fi(must)e Fq(ignore)i(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(with)e
(pa)m(yload)h(t)m(yp)s(es)g(it)f(do)s(es)g(not)h(understand.)136
4604 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(In)29 b(Fig.)h(2,)g(the)f(\015oating)h(p)s(oin)m
(t)f(NTP)g(timestamp)g(v)-5 b(alue)30 b(w)m(as)f(corrected,)i(some)f
(missing)e(leading)i(zeros)227 4717 y(w)m(ere)h(added)f(in)g(a)h(hex)f
(n)m(um)m(b)s(er,)f(and)h(the)g(UTC)g(timezone)i(w)m(as)f(sp)s
(eci\014ed.)136 4893 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30 b(inconsequence)h(of)g
(NTP)f(timestamps)g(wrapping)g(around)f(in)h(the)h(y)m(ear)g(2036)h(is)
e(explained.)136 5068 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)40 b(p)s(olicy)g(for)g
(registration)h(of)g(R)-8 b(TCP)39 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(t)m(yp)s(es)e(and)f
(SDES)h(t)m(yp)s(es)g(w)m(as)g(clari\014ed)g(in)g(a)g(new)227
5181 y(App)s(endix)27 b(D,)j(IANA)f(Considerations.)40
b(The)28 b(suggestion)i(that)f(exp)s(erimen)m(ters)g(register)h(the)e
(n)m(um)m(b)s(ers)227 5294 y(they)k(need)g(and)f(then)h(unregister)g
(those)g(whic)m(h)g(pro)m(v)m(e)h(to)f(b)s(e)g(unneeded)e(has)i(b)s
(een)f(remo)m(v)m(ed)i(in)f(fa)m(v)m(or)227 5407 y(of)f(using)f(APP)g
(and)g(PRIV.)40 b(Registration)32 b(of)f(pro\014le)f(names)g(w)m(as)h
(also)g(sp)s(eci\014ed.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(78])p eop
%%Page: 79 79
79 78 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)136 399
y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)31 b(reference)g(for)f(the)h(UTF-8)h(c)m
(haracter)g(set)g(w)m(as)f(c)m(hanged)g(from)g(an)f(X/Op)s(en)g
(Preliminary)h(Sp)s(eci-)227 511 y(\014cation)h(to)f(b)s(e)e(RF)m(C)i
(2279.)136 699 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)32 b(reference)h(for)e(RF)m(C)i
(1597)h(w)m(as)e(up)s(dated)f(to)i(RF)m(C)g(1918)h(and)d(the)i
(reference)f(for)g(RF)m(C)h(2543)h(w)m(as)227 812 y(up)s(dated)29
b(to)i(RF)m(C)g(3261.)136 1000 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)30
b(last)i(paragraph)e(of)h(the)g(in)m(tro)s(duction)g(in)f(RF)m(C)h
(1889,)i(whic)m(h)d(cautioned)i(implemen)m(ters)f(to)g(limit)227
1112 y(deplo)m(ymen)m(t)h(in)e(the)g(In)m(ternet,)h(w)m(as)g(remo)m(v)m
(ed)g(b)s(ecause)g(it)g(w)m(as)f(deemed)h(no)f(longer)h(relev)-5
b(an)m(t.)136 1300 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(A)36 b(non-normativ)m(e)g(note)g
(regarding)f(the)h(use)f(of)g(R)-8 b(TP)35 b(with)g(Source-Sp)s
(eci\014c)g(Multicast)i(\(SSM\))f(w)m(as)227 1413 y(added)30
b(in)g(Section)h(6.)136 1601 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)21
b(de\014nition)g(of)g(\\R)-8 b(TP)21 b(session")h(in)f(Section)g(3)h(w)
m(as)f(expanded)g(to)g(ac)m(kno)m(wledge)j(that)e(a)f(single)h(session)
227 1714 y(ma)m(y)41 b(use)e(m)m(ultiple)i(destination)f(transp)s(ort)f
(addresses)h(\(as)g(w)m(as)g(alw)m(a)m(ys)h(the)f(case)h(for)f(a)g
(translator)227 1826 y(or)45 b(mixer\))g(and)f(to)i(explain)f(that)h
(the)f(distinguishing)f(feature)h(of)g(an)g(R)-8 b(TP)44
b(session)h(is)g(that)h(eac)m(h)227 1939 y(corresp)s(onds)35
b(to)h(a)g(separate)h(SSR)m(C)e(iden)m(ti\014er)h(space.)58
b(A)35 b(new)h(de\014nition)f(of)h(\\m)m(ultimedia)h(session")227
2052 y(w)m(as)31 b(added)f(to)h(reduce)f(confusion)g(ab)s(out)g(the)h
(w)m(ord)f(\\session".)136 2240 y Fj(\017)46 b Fq(The)32
b(meaning)g(of)g(\\sampling)g(instan)m(t")i(w)m(as)e(explained)g(in)g
(more)g(detail)h(as)f(part)g(of)g(the)g(de\014nition)g(of)227
2353 y(the)f(timestamp)g(\014eld)f(of)g(the)h(R)-8 b(TP)30
b(header)g(in)g(Section)i(5.1.)136 2540 y Fj(\017)46
b Fq(Small)24 b(clari\014cations)h(of)e(the)h(text)g(ha)m(v)m(e)g(b)s
(een)f(made)g(in)g(sev)m(eral)i(places,)h(some)d(in)g(resp)s(onse)g(to)
h(questions)227 2653 y(from)30 b(readers.)41 b(In)29
b(particular:)330 2804 y Fl({)45 b Fq(In)d(RF)m(C)g(1889,)47
b(the)42 b(\014rst)f(\014v)m(e)i(w)m(ords)e(of)h(the)g(second)h(sen)m
(tence)g(of)f(Section)h(2.2)g(w)m(ere)f(lost)h(in)427
2917 y(pro)s(cessing)30 b(the)h(do)s(cumen)m(t)f(from)g(source)h(to)g
(output)f(form,)g(but)g(are)g(no)m(w)h(restored.)330
3063 y Fl({)45 b Fq(A)33 b(de\014nition)g(for)g(\\R)-8
b(TP)33 b(media)h(t)m(yp)s(e")f(w)m(as)h(added)e(in)h(Section)h(3)f(to)
h(allo)m(w)g(the)g(explanation)g(of)427 3176 y(m)m(ultiplexing)c(R)-8
b(TP)29 b(sessions)h(in)e(Section)i(5.2)h(to)f(b)s(e)e(more)i(clear)g
(regarding)f(the)h(m)m(ultiplexing)g(of)427 3288 y(m)m(ultiple)39
b(media.)62 b(That)38 b(section)g(also)h(no)m(w)f(explains)f(that)h(m)m
(ultiplexing)h(m)m(ultiple)f(sources)g(of)427 3401 y(the)g(same)g
(medium)e(based)i(on)f(SSR)m(C)f(iden)m(ti\014ers)i(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f
(appropriate)g(and)g(is)h(the)f(norm)g(for)427 3514 y(m)m(ulticast)32
b(sessions.)330 3660 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)20 b(de\014nition)g(for)g
(\\non-R)-8 b(TP)20 b(means")h(w)m(as)g(expanded)e(to)i(include)f
(examples)h(of)g(other)f(proto)s(cols)427 3773 y(constituting)32
b(non-R)-8 b(TP)30 b(means.)330 3919 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)23
b(description)g(of)g(the)g(session)h(bandwidth)d(parameter)i(is)h
(expanded)e(in)h(Section)g(6.2,)j(including)427 4032
y(a)j(clari\014cation)i(that)e(the)g(con)m(trol)h(tra\016c)f(bandwidth)
e(is)i(in)f(addition)h(to)g(the)g(session)g(bandwidth)427
4145 y(for)h(the)h(data)g(tra\016c.)330 4291 y Fl({)45
b Fq(The)c(e\013ect)i(of)f(v)-5 b(arying)41 b(pac)m(k)m(et)i(duration)e
(on)h(the)f(jitter)h(calculation)i(w)m(as)e(explained)f(in)g(Sec-)427
4404 y(tion)31 b(6.4.4.)330 4550 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)c(metho)s(d)f(for)h
(terminating)h(and)f(padding)f(a)i(sequence)f(of)g(SDES)g(items)g(w)m
(as)h(clari\014ed)f(in)427 4663 y(Section)31 b(6.5.)330
4809 y Fl({)45 b Fq(IPv6)27 b(address)f(examples)h(w)m(ere)g(added)f
(in)h(the)g(description)f(of)h(SDES)f(CNAME)h(in)f(Section)i(6.5.1,)427
4922 y(and)i(\\example.com")j(w)m(as)e(used)e(in)h(place)i(of)e(other)h
(example)g(domain)f(names.)330 5068 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)23
b(Securit)m(y)h(section)g(added)f(a)h(formal)g(reference)f(to)h(IPSEC)f
(no)m(w)g(that)h(it)g(is)f(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable,)28 b(and)22
b(sa)m(ys)427 5181 y(that)h(the)g(con\014den)m(tialit)m(y)h(metho)s(d)e
(de\014ned)f(in)i(this)f(sp)s(eci\014cation)h(is)g(primarily)f(to)h(co)
s(dify)f(existing)427 5294 y(practice.)50 b(It)34 b(is)f
Fi(recommended)d Fq(that)k(stronger)f(encryption)g(algorithms)h(suc)m
(h)e(as)i(T)-8 b(riple-DES)427 5407 y(b)s(e)24 b(used)g(in)g(place)i
(of)f(the)g(default)f(algorithm,)k(and)c(noted)g(that)i(the)e(SR)-8
b(TP)24 b(pro\014le)h(based)f(on)g(AES)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30
b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32 b(79])p eop
%%Page: 80 80
80 79 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)427 399
y(will)25 b(b)s(e)f(the)h(correct)g(c)m(hoice)i(in)d(the)h(future.)37
b(A)25 b(caution)g(ab)s(out)g(the)f(w)m(eakness)h(of)g(the)g(R)-8
b(TP)24 b(header)427 511 y(as)31 b(an)f(initialization)j(v)m(ector)f(w)
m(as)e(added.)40 b(It)30 b(w)m(as)h(also)g(noted)f(that)h(pa)m
(yload-only)h(encryption)e(is)427 624 y(necessary)h(to)g(allo)m(w)h
(for)e(header)g(compression.)330 765 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)28
b(metho)s(d)g(for)h(partial)g(encryption)g(of)f(R)-8
b(TCP)28 b(w)m(as)h(clari\014ed;)h(in)e(particular,)i(SDES)e(CNAME)427
878 y(is)j(carried)f(in)g(only)h(one)f(part)h(when)e(the)i(comp)s(ound)
e(R)-8 b(TCP)29 b(pac)m(k)m(et)k(is)d(split.)330 1019
y Fl({)45 b Fq(It)24 b(is)g(clari\014ed)g(that)h(only)f(one)g(comp)s
(ound)f(R)-8 b(TCP)23 b(pac)m(k)m(et)j(should)d(b)s(e)g(sen)m(t)h(p)s
(er)f(rep)s(orting)h(in)m(terv)-5 b(al)427 1132 y(and)31
b(that)i(if)f(there)g(are)g(to)s(o)g(man)m(y)g(activ)m(e)i(sources)e
(for)f(the)h(rep)s(orts)f(to)i(\014t)f(in)f(the)h(MTU,)g(then)g(a)427
1245 y(subset)e(of)h(the)f(sources)h(should)e(b)s(e)h(selected)i
(round-robin)c(o)m(v)m(er)k(m)m(ultiple)f(in)m(terv)-5
b(als.)330 1386 y Fl({)45 b Fq(A)f(note)g(w)m(as)g(added)f(in)g(App)s
(endix)f(A.1)j(that)f(pac)m(k)m(ets)h(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)e(sa)m(v)m(ed)h
(during)f(R)-8 b(TP)43 b(header)427 1499 y(v)-5 b(alidation)32
b(and)e(deliv)m(ered)h(up)s(on)e(success.)330 1640 y
Fl({)45 b Fq(Section)26 b(7.3)h(no)m(w)e(explains)h(that)g(a)f(mixer)h
(aggregating)i(SDES)c(pac)m(k)m(ets)k(uses)c(more)i(R)-8
b(TCP)25 b(band-)427 1752 y(width)g(due)f(to)i(longer)g(pac)m(k)m(ets,)
i(and)d(a)g(mixer)g(passing)g(through)g(R)-8 b(TCP)24
b(naturally)i(sends)e(pac)m(k)m(ets)427 1865 y(at)31
b(higher)f(than)h(the)f(single)h(source)g(rate,)g(but)f(b)s(oth)f(b)s
(eha)m(viors)i(are)f(v)-5 b(alid.)330 2006 y Fl({)45
b Fq(Section)29 b(13)f(clari\014es)g(that)g(an)g(R)-8
b(TP)27 b(application)i(ma)m(y)f(use)f(m)m(ultiple)i(pro\014les)e(but)f
(t)m(ypically)k(only)427 2119 y(one)h(in)f(a)h(giv)m(en)g(session.)330
2260 y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)30 b(terms)g Fi(must)p Fq(,)g
Fi(should)p Fq(,)f Fi(ma)-6 b(y)r Fq(,)30 b(etc.)41 b(are)31
b(used)f(as)g(de\014ned)f(in)i(RF)m(C)f(2119.)330 2401
y Fl({)45 b Fq(The)30 b(bibliograph)m(y)h(w)m(as)f(divided)g(in)m(to)h
(normativ)m(e)h(and)e(informativ)m(e)h(references.)0
2685 y Fp(C)135 b(Securit)l(y)45 b(Considerations)0 2888
y Fq(R)-8 b(TP)23 b(su\013ers)f(from)g(the)i(same)f(securit)m(y)h
(liabilities)h(as)e(the)g(underlying)f(proto)s(cols.)39
b(F)-8 b(or)24 b(example,)h(an)e(imp)s(ostor)0 3001 y(can)29
b(fak)m(e)i(source)e(or)g(destination)h(net)m(w)m(ork)g(addresses,)f
(or)g(c)m(hange)i(the)e(header)g(or)g(pa)m(yload.)41
b(Within)30 b(R)-8 b(TCP)g(,)0 3114 y(the)25 b(CNAME)f(and)g(NAME)h
(information)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(used)g(to)h(imp)s(ersonate)g(another)g
(participan)m(t.)40 b(In)23 b(addition,)0 3227 y(R)-8
b(TP)35 b(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)d(sen)m(t)j(via)f(IP)f(m)m(ulticast,)k(whic)m
(h)c(pro)m(vides)g(no)h(direct)g(means)f(for)h(a)g(sender)e(to)j(kno)m
(w)e(all)i(the)0 3340 y(receiv)m(ers)32 b(of)g(the)f(data)h(sen)m(t)g
(and)e(therefore)i(no)f(measure)g(of)g(priv)-5 b(acy)d(.)44
b(Righ)m(tly)32 b(or)f(not,)h(users)e(ma)m(y)i(b)s(e)f(more)0
3452 y(sensitiv)m(e)g(to)f(priv)-5 b(acy)29 b(concerns)h(with)f(audio)g
(and)g(video)h(comm)m(unication)h(than)e(they)g(ha)m(v)m(e)i(b)s(een)e
(with)g(more)0 3565 y(traditional)34 b(forms)e(of)h(net)m(w)m(ork)h
(comm)m(unication)g([33)q(].)49 b(Therefore,)33 b(the)g(use)g(of)g
(securit)m(y)g(mec)m(hanisms)g(with)0 3678 y(R)-8 b(TP)30
b(is)h(imp)s(ortan)m(t.)40 b(These)31 b(mec)m(hanisms)f(are)h
(discussed)e(in)h(Section)i(9.)141 3791 y(R)-8 b(TP-lev)m(el)25
b(translators)f(or)f(mixers)g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)g(used)f(to)i(allo)m(w)g
(R)-8 b(TP)23 b(tra\016c)h(to)f(reac)m(h)h(hosts)f(b)s(ehind)e(\014rew)
m(alls.)0 3904 y(Appropriate)j(\014rew)m(all)g(securit)m(y)g
(principles)g(and)f(practices,)j(whic)m(h)e(are)g(b)s(ey)m(ond)f(the)h
(scop)s(e)g(of)g(this)g(do)s(cumen)m(t,)0 4017 y(should)39
b(b)s(e)f(follo)m(w)m(ed)k(in)d(the)h(design)f(and)g(installation)i(of)
f(these)g(devices)g(and)f(in)g(the)h(admission)f(of)h(R)-8
b(TP)0 4130 y(applications)32 b(for)e(use)g(b)s(ehind)e(the)j(\014rew)m
(all.)0 4414 y Fp(D)135 b(IANA)44 b(Considerations)0
4617 y Fq(Additional)33 b(R)-8 b(TCP)33 b(pac)m(k)m(et)h(t)m(yp)s(es)f
(and)f(SDES)g(item)i(t)m(yp)s(es)f(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(registered)i
(through)e(the)h(In)m(ternet)g(As-)0 4730 y(signed)h(Num)m(b)s(ers)f
(Authorit)m(y)h(\(IANA\).)i(Since)e(these)g(n)m(um)m(b)s(er)f(spaces)i
(are)f(small,)i(allo)m(wing)g(unconstrained)0 4843 y(registration)f(of)
f(new)g(v)-5 b(alues)34 b(w)m(ould)f(not)h(b)s(e)f(pruden)m(t.)50
b(T)-8 b(o)34 b(facilitate)j(review)d(of)g(requests)g(and)f(to)h
(promote)0 4956 y(shared)c(use)h(of)g(new)g(t)m(yp)s(es)g(among)h(m)m
(ultiple)g(applications,)g(requests)f(for)g(registration)i(of)e(new)g
(v)-5 b(alues)31 b(m)m(ust)0 5068 y(b)s(e)e(do)s(cumen)m(ted)h(in)g(an)
f(RF)m(C)i(or)e(other)i(p)s(ermanen)m(t)e(and)g(readily)i(a)m(v)-5
b(ailable)32 b(reference)e(suc)m(h)g(as)g(the)g(pro)s(duct)0
5181 y(of)h(another)g(co)s(op)s(erativ)m(e)i(standards)d(b)s(o)s(dy)f
(\(e.g.,)k(ITU-T\).)e(Other)f(requests)h(ma)m(y)h(also)g(b)s(e)e
(accepted,)i(under)0 5294 y(the)c(advice)h(of)f(a)g(\\designated)h(exp)
s(ert.")40 b(\(Con)m(tact)30 b(the)e(IANA)g(for)g(the)g(con)m(tact)i
(information)e(of)g(the)g(curren)m(t)0 5407 y(exp)s(ert.\))0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(80])p eop
%%Page: 81 81
81 80 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)141 399
y(R)-8 b(TP)46 b(pro\014le)h(sp)s(eci\014cations)g Fi(should)e
Fq(register)i(with)g(IANA)f(a)h(name)g(for)f(the)h(pro\014le)f(in)h
(the)f(form)0 511 y(\\R)-8 b(TP/xxx",)43 b(where)38 b(xxx)i(is)f(a)g
(short)g(abbreviation)h(of)f(the)h(pro\014le)f(title.)69
b(These)38 b(names)i(are)f(for)g(use)g(b)m(y)0 624 y(higher-lev)m(el)c
(con)m(trol)f(proto)s(cols,)h(suc)m(h)d(as)h(the)h(Session)e
(Description)i(Proto)s(col)g(\(SDP\),)g(RF)m(C)f(2327)i([15)q(],)f(to)0
737 y(refer)c(to)h(transp)s(ort)f(metho)s(ds.)0 1024
y Fp(E)135 b(References)187 1267 y Fo(Normativ)m(e)37
b(References)45 1439 y Fq([1])47 b(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne,)33
b(H.)g(and)e(S.)i(Casner,)f(\\R)-8 b(TP)33 b(Pro\014le)f(for)g(Audio)h
(and)f(Video)h(Conferences)f(with)g(Minimal)187 1552
y(Con)m(trol,")g(RF)m(C)e(XXXX,)i(In)m(ternet)e(Engineering)h(T)-8
b(ask)31 b(F)-8 b(orce.)42 b(W)-8 b(ork)31 b(in)f(progress.)45
1739 y([2])47 b(Bradner,)23 b(S.,)g(\\Key)e(W)-8 b(ords)22
b(for)f(Use)g(in)g(RF)m(Cs)h(to)g(Indicate)g(Requiremen)m(t)f(Lev)m
(els,")k(BCP)c(14,)j(RF)m(C)e(2119,)187 1852 y(Marc)m(h)31
b(1997.)45 2040 y([3])47 b(P)m(ostel,)32 b(J.,)f(\\In)m(ternet)g(Proto)
s(col,")h(STD)e(5,)h(RF)m(C)g(791,)h(Septem)m(b)s(er)d(1981.)45
2228 y([4])47 b(Mills,)35 b(D.,)g(\\Net)m(w)m(ork)g(Time)e(Proto)s(col)
i(\(V)-8 b(ersion)34 b(3\))g(Sp)s(eci\014cation,)h(Implemen)m(tation)f
(and)f(Analysis,")187 2341 y(RF)m(C)e(1305,)h(Marc)m(h)f(1992.)45
2528 y([5])47 b(Y)-8 b(ergeau,)32 b(F.,)f(\\UTF-8,)h(a)f(T)-8
b(ransformation)30 b(F)-8 b(ormat)32 b(of)e(ISO)g(10646,")j(RF)m(C)e
(2279,)h(Jan)m(uary)e(1998.)45 2716 y([6])47 b(Mo)s(c)m(k)-5
b(ap)s(etris,)37 b(P)-8 b(.,)36 b(\\Domain)g(Names)f(-)f(Concepts)h
(and)f(F)-8 b(acilities,")39 b(STD)34 b(13,)j(RF)m(C)d(1034,)k(No)m(v)m
(em)m(b)s(er)187 2829 y(1987.)45 3016 y([7])47 b(Mo)s(c)m(k)-5
b(ap)s(etris,)39 b(P)-8 b(.,)38 b(\\Domain)f(Names)g(-)g(Implemen)m
(tation)g(and)e(Sp)s(eci\014cation,")k(STD)d(13,)i(RF)m(C)f(1035,)187
3129 y(No)m(v)m(em)m(b)s(er)31 b(1987.)45 3317 y([8])47
b(Braden,)28 b(R.,)h(\\Requiremen)m(ts)g(for)f(In)m(ternet)g(Hosts)h(-)
f(Application)h(and)e(Supp)s(ort,")g(STD)h(3,)h(RF)m(C)f(1123,)187
3430 y(Octob)s(er)i(1989.)45 3617 y([9])47 b(Cro)s(c)m(k)m(er,)30
b(D.,)g(\\Standard)f(for)g(the)g(F)-8 b(ormat)31 b(of)e(ARP)-8
b(A)30 b(In)m(ternet)f(T)-8 b(ext)30 b(Messages,")i(STD)c(11,)j(RF)m(C)
e(822,)187 3730 y(August)h(1982.)187 4011 y Fo(Informativ)m(e)38
b(References)0 4220 y Fq([10])47 b(Clark,)29 b(D.)g(and)e(D.)i(T)-8
b(ennenhouse,)28 b(\\Arc)m(hitectural)j(Considerations)d(for)g(a)h(New)
f(Generation)i(of)e(Proto-)187 4333 y(cols,")37 b(in)d
Fk(SIGCOMM)i(Symp)-5 b(osium)39 b(on)e(Communic)-5 b(ations)38
b(A)n(r)-5 b(chite)g(ctur)g(es)38 b(and)f(Pr)-5 b(oto)g(c)g(ols)p
Fq(,)39 b(\(Philadel-)187 4446 y(phia,)56 b(P)m(ennsylv)-5
b(ania\),)58 b(pp.)51 b(200{208,)60 b(IEEE)51 b(Computer)f(Comm)m
(unications)i(Review,)58 b(V)-8 b(ol.)53 b(20\(4\),)187
4559 y(Septem)m(b)s(er)30 b(1990.)0 4746 y([11])47 b(Sc)m(h)m
(ulzrinne,)29 b(H.,)h(\\Issues)e(in)g(designing)h(a)g(transp)s(ort)f
(proto)s(col)i(for)e(audio)h(and)f(video)h(conferences)h(and)187
4859 y(other)g(m)m(ultiparticipan)m(t)j(real-time)f(applications.")g
(expired)e(In)m(ternet)h(Draft,)g(Octob)s(er)f(1993.)0
5047 y([12])47 b(Comer,)25 b(D.,)h Fk(Internetworking)i(with)g(TCP/IP)p
Fq(,)23 b(v)m(ol.)j(1.)k(Englew)m(o)s(o)s(d)24 b(Cli\013s,)h(New)f
(Jersey:)38 b(Pren)m(tice)25 b(Hall,)187 5160 y(1991.)0
5348 y([13])47 b(Rosen)m(b)s(erg,)31 b(J.)f(et)h(al.,)g(\\SIP:)g
(Session)f(Initiation)h(Proto)s(col,")i(RF)m(C)d(3261,)j(June)c(2002.)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(81])p eop
%%Page: 82 82
82 81 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y([14])47 b(In)m(ternational)38 b(T)-8 b(elecomm)m(unication)39
b(Union,)f(\\Visual)f(telephone)g(systems)g(and)f(equipmen)m(t)g(for)h
(lo)s(cal)187 511 y(area)i(net)m(w)m(orks)g(whic)m(h)f(pro)m(vide)g(a)h
(non-guaran)m(teed)g(qualit)m(y)g(of)g(service,")j(Recommendation)d
(H.323,)187 624 y(T)-8 b(elecomm)m(unication)33 b(Standardization)e
(Sector)g(of)f(ITU,)h(Genev)-5 b(a,)31 b(Switzerland,)g(Ma)m(y)g(1996.)
0 810 y([15])47 b(Handley)-8 b(,)31 b(M.)g(and)f(V.)h(Jacobson,)f
(\\SDP:)h(Session)f(Description)i(Proto)s(col,")g(RF)m(C)f(2327,)h
(April)e(1998.)0 996 y([16])47 b(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne,)22
b(H.,)h(A.)e(Rao,)i(and)d(R.)g(Lanphier,)i(\\Real)g(Time)e(Streaming)h
(Proto)s(col)g(\(R)-8 b(TSP\),")21 b(RF)m(C)g(2326,)187
1109 y(April)30 b(1998.)0 1295 y([17])47 b(Eastlak)m(e,)38
b(D.)e(3rd,)f(S.)g(Cro)s(c)m(k)m(er,)i(and)d(J.)h(Sc)m(hiller,)i
(\\Randomness)d(Recommendations)i(for)f(Securit)m(y,")187
1408 y(RF)m(C)c(1750,)h(Decem)m(b)s(er)f(1994.)0 1594
y([18])47 b(Bolot,)42 b(J.-C.,)e(T.)e(T)-8 b(urletti,)41
b(and)c(I.)h(W)-8 b(ak)m(eman,)42 b(\\Scalable)e(F)-8
b(eedbac)m(k)40 b(Con)m(trol)f(for)e(Multicast)j(Video)187
1707 y(Distribution)i(in)f(the)h(In)m(ternet,")k(in)c
Fk(SIGCOMM)g(Symp)-5 b(osium)45 b(on)f(Communic)-5 b(ations)45
b(A)n(r)-5 b(chite)g(ctur)g(es)187 1820 y(and)33 b(Pr)-5
b(oto)g(c)g(ols)p Fq(,)34 b(\(London,)c(England\),)g(pp.)g(58{67,)j(A)m
(CM,)e(August)f(1994.)0 2006 y([19])47 b(Busse,)30 b(I.,)g(B.)h
(De\013ner,)f(and)f(H.)h(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne,)g(\\Dynamic)h(QoS)f(Con)m
(trol)g(of)g(Multimedia)h(Applications)187 2119 y(Based)g(on)f(R)-8
b(TP,")31 b Fk(Computer)j(Communic)-5 b(ations)p Fq(,)33
b(v)m(ol.)f(19,)f(pp.)f(49{58,)i(Jan)m(uary)e(1996.)0
2305 y([20])47 b(Flo)m(yd,)e(S.)d(and)f(V.)h(Jacobson,)j(\\The)c(Sync)m
(hronization)h(of)g(P)m(erio)s(dic)g(Routing)g(Messages,")47
b(in)41 b Fk(SIG-)187 2418 y(COMM)33 b(Symp)-5 b(osium)37
b(on)e(Communic)-5 b(ations)37 b(A)n(r)-5 b(chite)g(ctur)g(es)36
b(and)f(Pr)-5 b(oto)g(c)g(ols)36 b Fq(\(D.)d(P)-8 b(.)33
b(Sidh)m(u,)f(ed.\),)i(\(San)187 2531 y(F)-8 b(rancisco,)32
b(California\),)g(pp.)d(33{44,)k(A)m(CM,)e(Septem)m(b)s(er)f(1993.)42
b(Also)31 b(in)g([34)q(].)0 2717 y([21])47 b(Rosen)m(b)s(erg,)31
b(J.)g(and)f(H.)h(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne,)g(\\Sampling)g(of)g(the)g(Group)f
(Mem)m(b)s(ership)g(in)g(R)-8 b(TP,")32 b(RF)m(C)f(2762,)187
2830 y(Ma)m(y)g(1999.)0 3016 y([22])47 b(Cadzo)m(w,)25
b(J.,)g Fk(F)-7 b(oundations)29 b(of)d(Digital)g(Signal)g(Pr)-5
b(o)g(c)g(essing)28 b(and)f(Data)f(A)n(nalysis)p Fq(.)k(New)23
b(Y)-8 b(ork,)26 b(New)d(Y)-8 b(ork:)187 3129 y(Macmillan,)32
b(1987.)0 3315 y([23])47 b(Hinden,)30 b(R.)g(and)g(S.)g(Deering,)i
(\\IP)e(V)-8 b(ersion)31 b(6)g(Addressing)e(Arc)m(hitecture)j(,")f(RF)m
(C)g(2373,)h(July)e(1998.)0 3501 y([24])47 b(Rekh)m(ter,)31
b(Y.,)f(B.)h(Mosk)m(o)m(witz,)h(D.)f(Karren)m(b)s(erg,)e(and)h(G.)g(de)
g(Gro)s(ot,)g(\\Address)g(Allo)s(cation)i(for)d(Priv)-5
b(ate)187 3614 y(In)m(ternets,")31 b(RF)m(C)g(1918,)h(F)-8
b(ebruary)30 b(1996.)0 3800 y([25])47 b(Lear,)23 b(E.,)h(E.)d(F)-8
b(air,)24 b(D.)e(Cro)s(c)m(k)m(er,)i(and)c(T.)h(Kessler,)j(\\Net)m(w)m
(ork)f(10)f(Considered)e(Harmful)h(\(Some)g(Practices)187
3913 y(Shouldn't)29 b(b)s(e)h(Co)s(di\014ed\),")g(RF)m(C)h(1627,)h
(June)d(1994.)0 4099 y([26])47 b(F)-8 b(eller,)30 b(W.,)g
Fk(A)n(n)g(Intr)-5 b(o)g(duction)33 b(to)e(Pr)-5 b(ob)g(ability)32
b(The)-5 b(ory)33 b(and)e(its)g(Applic)-5 b(ations)p
Fq(,)31 b(v)m(ol.)e(1.)38 b(New)28 b(Y)-8 b(ork,)30 b(New)187
4211 y(Y)-8 b(ork:)41 b(John)30 b(Wiley)h(and)f(Sons,)g(third)f(ed.,)i
(1968.)0 4397 y([27])47 b(Ken)m(t,)23 b(S.)d(and)g(R.)g(A)m(tkinson,)j
(\\Securit)m(y)e(Arc)m(hitecture)h(for)e(the)h(In)m(ternet)g(Proto)s
(col,")j(RF)m(C)d(2401,)j(No)m(v)m(em-)187 4510 y(b)s(er)29
b(1998.)0 4696 y([28])47 b(Baugher,)33 b(M.,)g(R.)f(Blom,)i(E.)e
(Carrara,)h(D.)g(McGrew,)g(M.)g(Naslund,)f(K.)g(Norrman,)g(D.)h(Oran,)f
(\\Secure)187 4809 y(Real-time)g(T)-8 b(ransp)s(ort)30
b(Proto)s(col,")i(In)m(ternet)f(Engineering)f(T)-8 b(ask)31
b(F)-8 b(orce.)42 b(W)-8 b(ork)31 b(in)f(progress.)0
4995 y([29])47 b(Balenson,)54 b(D.,)g(\\Priv)-5 b(acy)49
b(Enhancemen)m(t)g(for)f(In)m(ternet)h(Electronic)h(Mail:)78
b(P)m(art)49 b(I)s(I)s(I:)e(Algorithms,)187 5108 y(Mo)s(des,)31
b(and)e(Iden)m(ti\014ers,")i(RF)m(C)g(1423,)h(F)-8 b(ebruary)30
b(1993.)0 5294 y([30])47 b(V)-8 b(o)m(ydo)s(c)m(k,)47
b(V.)c(and)f(S.)g(Ken)m(t,)k(\\Securit)m(y)d(Mec)m(hanisms)g(in)f
(High-Lev)m(el)i(Net)m(w)m(ork)g(Proto)s(cols,")j Fk(A)n(CM)187
5407 y(Computing)34 b(Surveys)p Fq(,)c(v)m(ol.)i(15,)f(pp.)f(135{171,)k
(June)29 b(1983.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(82])p eop
%%Page: 83 83
83 82 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y([31])47 b(Flo)m(yd,)31 b(S.,)g(\\Congestion)g(Con)m(trol)g
(Principles,")g(BCP)g(41,)g(RF)m(C)g(2914,)h(Septem)m(b)s(er)e(2000.)0
586 y([32])47 b(Riv)m(est,)32 b(R.,)e(\\The)h(MD5)g(Message-Digest)j
(Algorithm,")e(RF)m(C)f(1321,)h(April)e(1992.)0 774 y([33])47
b(Stubblebine,)29 b(S.,)g(\\Securit)m(y)i(Services)f(for)f(Multimedia)i
(Conferencing,")f(in)g Fk(16th)j(National)h(Computer)187
887 y(Se)-5 b(curity)33 b(Confer)-5 b(enc)g(e)p Fq(,)31
b(\(Baltimore,)i(Maryland\),)e(pp.)f(391{395,)j(Septem)m(b)s(er)d
(1993.)0 1074 y([34])47 b(Flo)m(yd,)28 b(S.)e(and)g(V.)h(Jacobson,)h
(\\The)e(Sync)m(hronization)h(of)g(P)m(erio)s(dic)g(Routing)g
(Messages,")j Fk(IEEE/A)n(CM)187 1187 y(T)-7 b(r)i(ansactions)35
b(on)e(Networking)p Fq(,)e(v)m(ol.)h(2,)f(pp.)e(122{136,)34
b(April)c(1994.)0 1474 y Fp(F)134 b(Ac)l(kno)l(wledgmen)l(ts)0
1677 y Fq(This)26 b(memorandum)f(is)h(based)g(on)h(discussions)e
(within)h(the)h(IETF)f(Audio/Video)h(T)-8 b(ransp)s(ort)26
b(w)m(orking)g(group)0 1789 y(c)m(haired)k(b)m(y)f(Stephen)g(Casner)g
(and)g(Colin)g(P)m(erkins.)41 b(The)29 b(curren)m(t)g(proto)s(col)i
(has)e(its)h(origins)g(in)f(the)g(Net)m(w)m(ork)0 1902
y(V)-8 b(oice)36 b(Proto)s(col)g(and)e(the)g(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)j(Video)e
(Proto)s(col)h(\(Dann)m(y)f(Cohen)e(and)h(Randy)g(Cole\))h(and)f(the)g
(proto)s(col)0 2015 y(implemen)m(ted)e(b)m(y)f(the)h(v)-5
b(at)32 b(application)g(\(V)-8 b(an)32 b(Jacobson)g(and)f(Stev)m(e)h
(McCanne\).)44 b(Christian)31 b(Huitema)h(pro-)0 2128
y(vided)39 b(ideas)g(for)g(the)g(random)f(iden)m(ti\014er)h(generator.)
68 b(Extensiv)m(e)40 b(analysis)g(and)e(sim)m(ulation)i(of)f(the)h
(timer)0 2241 y(reconsideration)34 b(algorithm)h(w)m(as)f(done)f(b)m(y)
g(Jonathan)h(Rosen)m(b)s(erg.)50 b(The)32 b(additions)i(for)f(la)m(y)m
(ered)i(enco)s(dings)0 2354 y(w)m(ere)c(sp)s(eci\014ed)f(b)m(y)g(Mic)m
(hael)i(Sp)s(eer)d(and)h(Stev)m(e)i(McCanne.)0 2640 y
Fp(G)134 b(Addresses)45 b(of)g(Authors)0 2843 y Fq(Henning)30
b(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne)0 2956 y(Departmen)m(t)i(of)e(Computer)g(Science)0
3069 y(Colum)m(bia)h(Univ)m(ersit)m(y)0 3182 y(1214)h(Amsterdam)e(Av)m
(en)m(ue)0 3295 y(New)h(Y)-8 b(ork,)31 b(NY)f(10027)0
3408 y(USA)0 3521 y(electronic)i(mail:)42 b Fh(schulzrinne@cs.columbia)
o(.edu)0 3733 y Fq(Stephen)29 b(L.)i(Casner)0 3846 y(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)i
(Design)0 3959 y(3400)f(Hillview)g(Av)m(en)m(ue,)f(Building)g(3)0
4072 y(P)m(alo)h(Alto,)g(CA)e(94304)0 4185 y(United)h(States)0
4298 y(electronic)h(mail:)42 b Fh(casner@acm.org)0 4510
y Fq(Ron)30 b(F)-8 b(rederic)m(k)0 4623 y(Blue)31 b(Coat)g(Systems)f
(Inc.)0 4736 y(650)i(Almanor)e(Av)m(en)m(ue)0 4849 y(Sunn)m(yv)-5
b(ale,)30 b(CA)g(94085)0 4962 y(United)h(States)0 5075
y(electronic)h(mail:)42 b Fh(ronf@bluecoat.com)0 5288
y Fq(V)-8 b(an)31 b(Jacobson)0 5400 y(P)m(ac)m(k)m(et)i(Design)0
5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8 b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496
b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496 b([P)m(age)32
b(83])p eop
%%Page: 84 84
84 83 bop 0 100 a Fq(INTERNET-DRAFT)716 b(draft-ietf-a)m
(vt-rtp-new-12.ps)688 b(Marc)m(h)31 b(2,)g(2003)0 399
y(3400)h(Hillview)g(Av)m(en)m(ue,)f(Building)g(3)0 511
y(P)m(alo)h(Alto,)g(CA)e(94304)0 624 y(United)h(States)0
737 y(electronic)h(mail:)42 b Fh(van@packetdesign.com)0
1024 y Fp(H)135 b(In)l(tellectual)47 b(Prop)t(ert)l(y)e(Righ)l(ts)h
(Statemen)l(t)0 1227 y Fq(The)35 b(IETF)h(tak)m(es)h(no)f(p)s(osition)f
(regarding)h(the)g(v)-5 b(alidit)m(y)38 b(or)d(scop)s(e)h(of)g(an)m(y)g
(in)m(tellectual)j(prop)s(ert)m(y)c(or)h(other)0 1340
y(righ)m(ts)26 b(that)g(migh)m(t)h(b)s(e)e(claimed)i(to)f(p)s(ertain)f
(to)i(the)f(implemen)m(tation)h(or)f(use)f(of)h(the)g(tec)m(hnology)i
(describ)s(ed)c(in)0 1452 y(this)i(do)s(cumen)m(t)f(or)h(the)g(exten)m
(t)h(to)g(whic)m(h)e(an)m(y)h(license)h(under)e(suc)m(h)g(righ)m(ts)h
(migh)m(t)h(or)f(migh)m(t)g(not)g(b)s(e)f(a)m(v)-5 b(ailable;)0
1565 y(neither)26 b(do)s(es)h(it)g(represen)m(t)f(that)h(it)g(has)f
(made)h(an)m(y)g(e\013ort)g(to)g(iden)m(tify)g(an)m(y)g(suc)m(h)f(righ)
m(ts.)40 b(Information)26 b(on)h(the)0 1678 y(IETF's)k(pro)s(cedures)e
(with)i(resp)s(ect)g(to)g(righ)m(ts)h(in)e(standards-trac)m(k)i(and)e
(standards-related)h(do)s(cumen)m(tation)0 1791 y(can)h(b)s(e)f(found)f
(in)i(BCP-11.)45 b(Copies)32 b(of)g(claims)g(of)g(righ)m(ts)g(made)g(a)
m(v)-5 b(ailable)34 b(for)d(publication)h(and)f(an)m(y)h(assur-)0
1904 y(ances)d(of)g(licenses)h(to)f(b)s(e)f(made)h(a)m(v)-5
b(ailable,)31 b(or)e(the)g(result)g(of)f(an)h(attempt)h(made)f(to)g
(obtain)g(a)g(general)h(license)0 2017 y(or)j(p)s(ermission)f(for)h
(the)g(use)g(of)h(suc)m(h)e(proprietary)h(righ)m(ts)h(b)m(y)f(implemen)
m(tors)g(or)g(users)g(of)g(this)g(sp)s(eci\014cation)0
2130 y(can)e(b)s(e)e(obtained)i(from)f(the)h(IETF)f(Secretariat.)141
2243 y(The)43 b(IETF)g(in)m(vites)i(an)m(y)f(in)m(terested)g(part)m(y)g
(to)g(bring)f(to)h(its)g(atten)m(tion)i(an)m(y)d(cop)m(yrigh)m(ts,)49
b(paten)m(ts)44 b(or)0 2356 y(paten)m(t)32 b(applications,)h(or)e
(other)g(proprietary)g(righ)m(ts)h(whic)m(h)f(ma)m(y)h(co)m(v)m(er)g
(tec)m(hnology)i(that)d(ma)m(y)h(b)s(e)f(required)0 2469
y(to)g(practice)h(this)e(standard.)40 b(Please)32 b(address)d(the)i
(information)f(to)h(the)g(IETF)f(Executiv)m(e)i(Director.)0
2755 y Fp(I)135 b(F)-11 b(ull)44 b(Cop)l(yrigh)l(t)i(Statemen)l(t)0
2958 y Fq(Cop)m(yrigh)m(t)31 b(\(C\))g(The)f(In)m(ternet)g(So)s(ciet)m
(y)i(\(2003\).)43 b(All)31 b(Righ)m(ts)g(Reserv)m(ed.)141
3071 y(This)38 b(do)s(cumen)m(t)g(and)g(translations)h(of)f(it)h(ma)m
(y)g(b)s(e)f(copied)h(and)f(furnished)e(to)j(others,)i(and)c(deriv)-5
b(ativ)m(e)0 3184 y(w)m(orks)35 b(that)h(commen)m(t)g(on)f(or)g
(otherwise)h(explain)g(it)f(or)g(assist)h(in)f(its)h(implemen)m(tation)
g(ma)m(y)g(b)s(e)f(prepared,)0 3297 y(copied,)25 b(published)c(and)h
(distributed,)i(in)e(whole)h(or)g(in)f(part,)j(without)d(restriction)i
(of)f(an)m(y)g(kind,)h(pro)m(vided)e(that)0 3410 y(the)27
b(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)g(cop)m(yrigh)m(t)h(notice)f(and)f(this)g(paragraph)g
(are)h(included)f(on)g(all)h(suc)m(h)f(copies)h(and)f(deriv)-5
b(ativ)m(e)28 b(w)m(orks.)0 3523 y(Ho)m(w)m(ev)m(er,)k(this)e(do)s
(cumen)m(t)g(itself)h(ma)m(y)f(not)g(b)s(e)g(mo)s(di\014ed)e(in)i(an)m
(y)g(w)m(a)m(y)-8 b(,)32 b(suc)m(h)e(as)g(b)m(y)g(remo)m(ving)g(the)h
(cop)m(yrigh)m(t)0 3635 y(notice)38 b(or)e(references)g(to)h(the)g(In)m
(ternet)f(So)s(ciet)m(y)i(or)e(other)g(In)m(ternet)h(organizations,)j
(except)d(as)f(needed)g(for)0 3748 y(the)f(purp)s(ose)d(of)j(dev)m
(eloping)g(In)m(ternet)g(standards)e(in)h(whic)m(h)g(case)i(the)e(pro)s
(cedures)f(for)i(cop)m(yrigh)m(ts)g(de\014ned)0 3861
y(in)h(the)g(In)m(ternet)g(Standards)f(pro)s(cess)h(m)m(ust)g(b)s(e)f
(follo)m(w)m(ed,)k(or)d(as)h(required)e(to)i(translate)g(it)g(in)m(to)g
(languages)0 3974 y(other)31 b(than)f(English.)141 4087
y(The)k(limited)h(p)s(ermissions)e(gran)m(ted)i(ab)s(o)m(v)m(e)h(are)f
(p)s(erp)s(etual)e(and)h(will)h(not)f(b)s(e)g(rev)m(ok)m(ed)i(b)m(y)e
(the)h(In)m(ternet)0 4200 y(So)s(ciet)m(y)d(or)e(its)h(successors)f(or)
h(assigns.)141 4313 y(This)c(do)s(cumen)m(t)g(and)g(the)g(information)h
(con)m(tained)g(herein)f(is)h(pro)m(vided)f(on)g(an)g(\\AS)g(IS")g
(basis)h(and)e(THE)0 4426 y(INTERNET)44 b(SOCIETY)f(AND)j(THE)e
(INTERNET)g(ENGINEERING)h(T)-8 b(ASK)45 b(F)m(OR)m(CE)g(DISCLAIMS)0
4539 y(ALL)40 b(W)-10 b(ARRANTIES,)39 b(EXPRESS)f(OR)i(IMPLIED,)g
(INCLUDING)g(BUT)g(NOT)f(LIMITED)g(TO)g(ANY)0 4652 y(W)-10
b(ARRANTY)45 b(THA)-8 b(T)44 b(THE)f(USE)h(OF)g(THE)g(INF)m(ORMA)-8
b(TION)44 b(HEREIN)g(WILL)g(NOT)g(INFRINGE)0 4765 y(ANY)f(RIGHTS)f(OR)g
(ANY)h(IMPLIED)g(W)-10 b(ARRANTIES)42 b(OF)h(MER)m(CHANT)-8
b(ABILITY)43 b(OR)f(FITNESS)0 4877 y(F)m(OR)31 b(A)f(P)-8
b(AR)g(TICULAR)31 b(PURPOSE.)0 5656 y(Sc)m(h)m(ulzrinne/Casner/F)-8
b(rederic)m(k/Jacobson)496 b(Expires)30 b(Septem)m(b)s(er)g(2003)496
b([P)m(age)32 b(84])p eop
%%Trailer
end
userdict /end-hook known{end-hook}if
%%EOF
PAFTECH AB 2003-2026
2026-04-24 01:55:06